fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2004 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2004Long Lens - front element

  
 
smaug
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Long Lens - front element
If anyone cares, the front element of my - non IS - 300mm F4L was badly scratched when I bought it used (and abused) so I just took it out. I then added the thinnest UV filter I could find to protect the internal elements of the lens in the absence of the front glass and the lens is still RAZOR sharp. This should at least confirm the theory that some of the older L guns had a flat piece of glass in front that wasn't a very active part of the optics.

YMMV

-Steve


Mar 05, 2004 at 04:17 PM
jray
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Long Lens - front element
Ok, let's see if I have this straight...

The type of meniscus lens Canon is using is one of equal thickness throughout the surface area. The reason I say 'type of meniscus lens' is because although I thought I understood the term, it seems the term 'meniscus' is not always be used to describe a singular lens/element type, but instead may loosely describe a family of element types? I'm going throw around a few definitions here. It's not to nitpick, but instead to gain a better understanding of what is, and what isn't. Here's the definition of meniscus (good old Google):

American Heritage Dictionary:

1)A crescent-shaped body
2)A concavo-convex lens

Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary:

1) A crescent.
2) A lens convex on on side and concave on the other.


Additional definitions from the American Heritage Dictionary:

concavo-convex:
1) Concave on one side and convex on the other (duh)
2) Having greater curvature on the concave side than on the convex side. Used of a lens.

convexo-concave:
1) Concave on one side and convex on the other (once again, duh)
2) Having greater curvature on the convex side than on the concave side. Used of a lens.

crescent:
1) The figure of the moon as it appears in its first or last quarter, with concave and convex edges terminating in points. (This would indicate a concavo-convex lens shape IMO)

Further definitions for 'converging meniscus' and 'diverging meniscus' from Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary yield the same results as meniscus.

They do offer a definition for both but I would imagine a diverging meniscus element would not be crescent shaped, so I must assume Webster's second definition is more accurate for our discussion since it loosely describes a meniscus lens/element as a lens with a shape that is "convex on on side and concave on the other". Unfortunately, this brings up another question.

What exactly qualifies a lens element as 'meniscus' verses a concavo-convex, convexo-concave, or any other lens element that might be concave on one side and convex on the other? I originally thought perhaps meniscus might relate to minuscule or miniscule, where it would describe a lens element that had negligible effects on the final optical design, but did offer some benefit to the overall performance in real world use. ie, the reduction of internal reflections and flare without affecting sharpness, contrast, distortion, etc. Perhaps it's a stretch, but it's obvious this is the intent of the element, so why exactly is it called a meniscus element. Anybody know?

Here's a diagram I put together to better illustrate my question:

http://www.d30.info/temp/meniscus/lens_elements.gif

I would assume from Canon's block diagrams that the radius of the meniscus lens element must be huge, which is why it appears flat. This brings up yet another question. What exactly is the purpose of the apparently flat element closest to the lens mount? Could it be a UV filter? Would there need to be another meniscus element to counteract any effects of the front element? If so, I would question the intelligence in using them in the first place. BTW, speaking of UV filters.

Since the benefits of a meniscus element seem to outweigh any negative aspects of placing it ahead of the front element, wouldn't designing UV filters as screw-on meniscus elements make sense? Due to the radius of the meniscus element I would imagine there is a relatively large latitude in design that would still offer benefits without affecting optical performance in any critical areas. I don't know how much, if any, Canon modifies their lens design parameters to accommodate the meniscus element, but if it's negligible then it would make sense to offer such after-market screw-on elements. In fact, if the effect of the meniscus element is negligible for the most part, then such screw-on elements might remove some, or most, of the reservations some have about UV filters. They might even be advantageous to overall lens performance in some cases. Canon seems to think so. The viability of such am after-market device might lie in the function of the element closest to the lens mount.
Mar 05, 2004 at 07:37 PM
CyberDyne
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Long Lens - front element
I think the only question that is really pertinant here is,...

"How much will it cost me to replace this front element if damaged??"

All the other info aside,. this is the "meat of the matter"
Mar 05, 2004 at 08:58 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister