fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2009 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20095DII failures on LL Antarctic trip

  
 
burningheart
Offline
Details
p.7 #15DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I was in Antarctica 2 years ago, took a 5D no grip, 4 lens (50 F1.0, 17-40L, 70-200F4 Non IS, 400 F5.6), and an EOS 1V. Shot 4500 digital shots, 1500 film shots, exposed the cameras and lens to freezing rain,snow, sleet, salt at times was so thich it coated the cameras and lens so I would have to clean off, cold temperatures sometimes in the -20s with wind chill, warm days +5C. Riding in the zodiacs with the only protection for the cameras was my rain poncho. I also went in and out of cold air to warm and back with no fogging. Oh and they also spent a night in the sleeping bag when we camped out on an ice flow.

Result - not one failure on the 5D, 2 failures on the 1V - shutter stayed open had to power off, twice then it was fine after that. Though the 5D is not the same as the 5D MKII in weatherproofing and build (MKII is stated to be better) it worked perefectly fine there. I now have the MKII and it has worked flawlessly in -30 weather for the couple of hours I was out. The the barrel of the lens was iced and was hard to turn for focusing(it was a manual focus lens)

I would be interested to find out what the 6 who's MKII's failed were used.

If I was to go to Antarctica again I would take both a 5D and 5D MKII.
Feb 07, 2009 at 03:08 PM
CharlesC
Offline
Details
p.7 #25DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Some quick facts.
- I was on this trip. Other than arranging the trip so that only photographers and "spice" were aboard, and sending the usual "what to bring" tourist information, there was no special preparation for this trip by any participant. People brought what they thought they should based on comments by others that had been before. Most had multiple bodies.
- With the exception of MR's, so far as I could tell all 5DMII's were purchased by "normal" people at the usual camera stores - they were not loaners. Mine was brand new purchased from a local camera store.
- The day the cameras failed (mine was one of them) was raining lightly with low clouds (e.g. above freezing and humid - I've had worst days in New England and the Pacific Northwest).
- I was using full rain covers on both my 5D and 5DMII, keeping any drops that hit them (you have to look at the histogram somehow) mopped up using a rag.
- I was not using grips on either camera, but I did have to break the cameras down to get them back in my pack for travel from the shore to the ship.
- My mistake was letting the cool camera get exposed to the air once I got back on the boat (so that I could charge batteries and download my card). Didn't make the mistake again on the trip.
- Both my 5D and 5DMII had condensation inside and out, only the 5DMII had problems (and they happened immediately).
- It came back to life after air-drying all night with everything open plus a stint with a hair-drier in a pillow case.
- Lots of other people came back on-board and had their cameras out pretty much at once. Only the Canons seemed to have problems with the resulting condensation (odd)
- Canon 5DMKII manual page 216: Operating conditions 32F-104F (0C-40C), humidity 80% or less. Page 9 - what to do coming in from the cold. 5D manual says same thing. We were within the operating temperature, above operating humidity. Coming inside some of us violated the "put it in a sealed bag and let it warm up" rule.

So, mistakes and lack of common sense/exhaustion/impatience on my part were behind my problems, but of two cameras exposed to identical situations, only one had problems. Probably I was lucky...or unlucky. Of probably 150 cameras used during that day in those conditions, pretty much only the 5DMIIs had problems. Best I can recall, all of the failures happened after that one landing.

I'm not sure we can come to any useful conclusions about this other than you should take proper care of your camera when you move into areas of different temperatures and humidity. Always bring a garbage bag or something like that with you so that the camera can warm up without being in contact with warmer, more humid air. This is physics, not a Canon, Nikon, or Sony-specific issue.

Cheers,
Charles
Feb 07, 2009 at 03:12 PM
burningheart
Offline
Details
p.7 #35DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Thanks for the feedback Charles. Have any picts you would like to share.
Feb 07, 2009 at 03:23 PM
BenV
Offline
Details
p.7 #45DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I've came to the conclusion after reading multiple threads on this, God is working with Nikon to ruin all Canons.
Feb 07, 2009 at 03:26 PM
orangefirefish
Offline
Details
p.7 #55DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Hah- or the Nikon users just never made the mistake of changing lenses without letting the camera warm up first...?
Feb 07, 2009 at 03:39 PM
maverick666
Offline
Details
p.7 #65DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Yeah I'm actually amazed at Nikon...never had any problems in their equipments...no complaints from their customers...at all.....zero defects. Mind boggling.
Feb 07, 2009 at 04:12 PM
OzPic
Offline
Details
p.7 #75DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I could comment but I dont want to get shot as I like living .......I just feel sorry for the people who had their cameras fail on such a woderfull trip.

Dean.
Feb 07, 2009 at 04:15 PM
maverick666
Offline
Details
p.7 #85DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Absolutely...what I've heard if you drop any Nikon camera, God will catch it and hand it to you...amazing...Now if you do that I will not be responsible of any damage.

BenV wrote:
I've came to the conclusion after reading multiple threads on this, God is working with Nikon to ruin all Canons.

Feb 07, 2009 at 04:23 PM
Lawrence Lee
Offline
Details
p.7 #95DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
From what I read, condensation could be a problem here. So I'm wondering, how would you guys protect your camera from condensation problems? Any specific tips? Should I worry about condensation being a problem if a camera is weather sealed?
Feb 07, 2009 at 04:51 PM
Deezie
Offline
Details
p.7 #105DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
RDKirk wrote: What Canon wants you to do, you professional you, is to buy a 1-Series camera.

It does sound like the mkII has been built too fast and too cheaply. Canon realised that serious shooters aside, what the regular potential client wanted in a mkII was Megapixels!

Is anybody thinking that large sensors are cheap? That free lunches exist? Every benefit has a cost that must be paid somewhere, somehow, by someone sooner or later. So you see where the cost is paid. That's a good thing...now intelligent buying decisions can be made.

They were right, for all the rather over optimistic promises
...Show more →

Superb post RD. Is anyone listening?
Feb 07, 2009 at 05:07 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #115DII failures on LL Antarctic trip

I wrote:
As a scientist who teaches statistics to PhD students,


jamesf99 responded:
Uh oh....Now here is a point that I say is conclusively, unequivocally, and absolutely insignificant.

Sorry, but I spent enough years in graduate school with fellow PhD students and masters degree candidates, and some of the worst instructors an Ivy league school could provide to know that your point is easily "challengable"........


My response to James:
It is fine with me if you think my teaching of statistics is irrelevant to this question, but then you should also agree that Mark's claim that he is a scientist is also irrelevant to the question at hand. It was his statement "as a scientist" that led me to respond as I did.

By the way, what point of mine is challengable; that I teach statistics?--probably not; that the statistical significance of the failures can't really be tested?--sure this is challengable and by all means feel free to do so. The way to challenge my point is to actually do a statistical test of significance. I would be happy to learn from you, just as I said I would be happy to learn from Mark. I never said my point that the results here can't really be tested isn't challengable, but I would say that it would take someone actually doing a test of statistical significance to challenge my point. So far no one has done that, but I would genuinely be interested if someone has a way to do so.

I wrote:
I can say I know of no test that would let one make an inference about statistical significance in this case. If there is such a test I would be happy to have Mark correct me. Part of the problem here is that it is not even clear what is being tested. Is the test whether there are more failures than zero? If that is the test then it is not a matter of statistics, but simply a matter of observation. Yes there were more failures than zero--obviously. Is the test, however, whether there were significantly more failures among the
...Show more →

jamesf99 responded:
Of course we don't have all the information and what we do have is mostly - but not all - anecdotal, but 6 out of 26 is bad news. You can spin it anyway you want, and spend 6 weeks designing your test/population/confidence levels, but it's bad news. If you take 26 cameras at random, use them in an ordinary way, and 23% of them fail, you are talking about a serious issue and you don't need to design a complete statistical analysis to know that. No Nikon died under the same circumstances.

EX: 26 new, randomly selected, undamaged Toyota's
...Show more →

My response to James:

It is fine by me if you think and say that 6 out of 26 cameras failing is important, meaningful, and a significant number of failures. I think it is noteworthy too. Just don't say it is "statistically significant," unless you test the significance statistically. I am all for measuring significance in other ways than with statistics. I genuinely believe that is a good thing, but it bugs me when people make a "scientific" claim to statistical significance without backing up such a claim. So, I am not saying that it isn't meaningful because you can't test it statistically. I am just saying it isn't statistically significant unless you can test it statistically.

By the way, I was not troubled at all by your original post as you were straightforward about not knowing whether it was indeed a statistically significant finding and were simply speculating about the statistical significance. In contrast, Mark claimed that he knew it was statistically significant, and that did bug me because he seemed to be saying he knew this without actually conducting a statistical test. Maybe I am wrong and he has done such a statistical test and he can show me I am wrong. I am perfectly fine with being wrong here, but if he hasn't done such a test, then he shouldn't be saying that, "as a scientist" he knows it is statistically significant.


jamesf99 also responded:
Unfortunately, common sense isn't all that common.... M. Twain


My response: I definitely agree. This is one of my favorite quotes. And to me it is just common sense that for people to claim something is 'statistically' significant they might have to examine the issue statistically.

Best wishes,

Steve
Feb 07, 2009 at 05:22 PM
jaclarkaus
Offline
Details
p.7 #125DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Steve Spencer wrote:
I wroteAs a scientist who teaches statistics to PhD students,



As an accountant (with a Masters) I can say it is not statistically significant because I don't own one yet, but if I did (which I expect to in the next week of so) and mine failed, it would be statistically significant to me
Feb 07, 2009 at 06:07 PM
thehawkins
Offline
Details
p.7 #135DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
OzPic wrote:
I could comment but I dont want to get shot as I like living .......I just feel sorry for the people who had their cameras fail on such a woderfull trip.


My friend and I bought 5D Mark II's recently, and he did Antarctica a few years back with a 20D as the primary camera and it worked fine, but he did say that he was pretty anal about keeping his clean, including putting the camera inside a gallon-sized ziploc bag.

My worst fear is having my camera die on a trip like this. Seriously, I'd probably start to cry. And I want to do this trip, and I know that the camera isn't weathersealed, but still, I'd like to think it held up to my XT and my 40D's experience in inclement weather.

But - I heard on the internet from that one photography site, that if you're in Antarctica and a CPS Platinum Plus member, they'll helicopter new ones to you same business day. That's what I read on the internet, so you know it must be true!
Feb 07, 2009 at 06:18 PM
jerrykur
Offline
Details
p.7 #145DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
One interesting thing is this trip seems to year after year kill Canon cameras. Here is the report from 2007. http://www.luminous-landscape.com/essays/aa-07-worked.shtml. Scroll on down to the section subtitle "Canon".

Summary:
6 - 1DsMK2's died, 3 recovered
3 - 5D died, 1 recovered
2 - XT lost rear LCD

So this year's 5DMK2s did as well as the 2007 1DsMK2s.

I brings up a question though. How many people have had a 1DsMK2 die due to water? I don't know of any unless someone submerged the camera. Has anyone lost one due to rain?

Outside of this trip has anyone killed a 5D or 5DMK2 due to rain? I shot with my 5D in the pouring rain with no issues. I usually threw a trash bag over the top but not protection much beyond that.

What is it about this trip that kills Canon cameras?

Feb 07, 2009 at 07:21 PM
Marvincheong
Offline
Details
p.7 #155DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
sad to heard this news.
Canon will improve their Quality time to time.
We all need to give them a chance.
Feb 07, 2009 at 07:39 PM
Tim Ashton
Offline
Details
p.7 #165DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
mfoto wrote:
I will probably never go to the Antartic


without the missing C (Antar_tic)you are probably right
Feb 07, 2009 at 07:51 PM
Tim Ashton
Offline
Details
p.7 #175DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Daan B wrote:
.. Canon is just screwing this one up... sadly, because in potential the 5D2 is a fine camera



As Daan says, potentially the 5D2 is a fine camera, in fact the 5D is a fine camera.

Canon has to bite the bullet and admit that many of the features of the D700 are what their customers want and should produce a 5D2/5D to match instead of assuming that everyone can afford a 1D series.
Next move is for Canon to produce that camera
fingers crossed
Tim


Feb 07, 2009 at 08:00 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.7 #185DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Canon has to bite the bullet and admit that many of the features of the D700 are what their customers want and should produce a 5D2/5D to match instead of assuming that everyone can afford a 1D series.

In the 5D2 White Paper, Canon compares the 5D2 to the D300, not the D700.
Feb 07, 2009 at 08:14 PM
thw2
Offline
Details
p.7 #195DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Marvincheong wrote:
sad to heard this news.
Canon will improve their Quality time to time.
We all need to give them a chance.


True. But their poor QC has been going on for quite a while now... at least in the last couple of years.

I strongly suspect most Canon parts are made elsewhere (where labor costs are low and QC p*ss poor) and assembled in Japan. Either that, or QC is poor in Canon Japan. How else does Canon keep their manufacturing costs low, in comparison to Nikon and Sony? Except for their D3/3x/D700 bodies, most Nikon DSLRs are assembled in Thailand. I think Canon management is too patriotic and try too hard to keep their manufacturing facilities within Japan. That is poor judgment on their part.
Feb 07, 2009 at 08:24 PM
maverick666
Offline
Details
p.7 #205DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Maybe if they ask you to do the QC things will be better...

thw2 wrote:
Marvincheong wrotesad to heard this news.
Canon will improve their Quality time to time.
We all need to give them a chance.
True. But their poor QC has been going on for quite a while now... at least in the last couple of years.

I strongly suspect most Canon parts are made elsewhere (where labor costs are low and QC p*ss poor) and assembled in Japan. Either that, or QC is poor in Canon Japan. How else does Canon keep their manufacturing costs low, in comparison to Nikon and Sony? Except for their D3/3x/D700 bodies, most Nikon DSLRs are assembled in Thailand. I think Canon management is too patriotic and try too hard to keep their manufacturing facilities within Japan. That is
...Show more →
Feb 07, 2009 at 09:00 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister