fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2009 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20095DII failures on LL Antarctic trip

  
 
maverick666
Offline
Details
p.6 #15DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I think they might have several vendors for the dang door, some vendor did some half a** job some didn't . Not sure if the grip is also weather sealed since I don't have one.

rsg_1 wrote:
With the creaks in CF door & battery compartment and this report from Antarctica, it appears Canon is cheapening the manufacturing process on the 5DMkII.

Hopefully, they've taken a page from Toyota who's quality suffered for the 2007 models, but quickly brought it back up for 2008 & 2009.

Feb 07, 2009 at 12:17 PM
rhorta
Offline
Details
p.6 #25DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
rsg_1 wrote:
With the creaks in CF door & battery compartment and this report from Antarctica, it appears Canon is cheapening the manufacturing process on the 5DMkII.

Hopefully, they've taken a page from Toyota who's quality suffered for the 2007 models, but quickly brought it back up for 2008 & 2009.


They did that with the 40D, few complained about that. Ever compare battery doors of the 40D to the ol' 20D?

Ruy
Feb 07, 2009 at 12:17 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.6 #35DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
mark1958 wrote:
As a scientist, I agree with Jame's post that 6/26 is statistically significant.


Sorry, but as a scientist you should know better. What comparison are you suggesting is statistically significant? And what statistical test would you use to determine this significance? Unless you define a specific test you are making and you can point to a statistical test you used and the parameters from that test, then you should not be saying that it is statistically significant. IMO, it is bad science to suggest that something is statistically significant without doing the actual test of that significance.

As a scientist who teaches statistics to PhD students, I can say I know of no test that would let one make an inference about statistical significance in this case. If there is such a test I would be happy to have Mark correct me. Part of the problem here is that it is not even clear what is being tested. Is the test whether there are more failures than zero? If that is the test then it is not a matter of statistics, but simply a matter of observation. Yes there were more failures than zero--obviously. Is the test, however, whether there were significantly more failures among the Canons (or specifically among the 5DMKIIs) than among the Nikons or Hasselblads or whatever? Now this question could possibly be addressed with statistics and one wouldn't even need to know confidence intervals. It could be tested with a simply chi-square test, if there were enough observations of Nikon cameras failing. With the current data there just isn't a big enough sample of Nikon cameras to do the comparison. A chi-square test would require more observations of other cameras failing. I don't see a way to test for statistical significance here, and that makes the report here an anecdote. A compelling one, but unless someone makes it clear what comparison they are testing and how they carried out the test, then they should not claim that the reported incidence of failures is statistically significant.

Best wishes,

Steve

Feb 07, 2009 at 12:48 PM
Photo by Jim
Offline
Details
p.6 #45DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I don't know.... I just got the 5dII this week, but also own 5D, and 1DMarkII and have taken them all out on outings,the most extreme Michigan Winters with no problems. However if its raining or snowing or risk them getting wet..... I just would rather not. Water and expensive equipment NOT!
Feb 07, 2009 at 01:04 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.6 #55DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Perhaps this is all part of Canon marketing's cunning plan to sell more bodies. This has serious implications for me as a wedding photographer. I have bought 2 5D2's, but I can't afford to take a 1% chance that I will have to stop working altogether at a wedding. As a result, I will almost certainly have to buy a 450D and possibly a third 5D2, although at that rate of expenditure just to get some security that you can complete the job, the D700 is looking all the more attractive.

What Canon wants you to do, you professional you, is to buy a 1-Series camera.

It does sound like the mkII has been built too fast and too cheaply. Canon realised that serious shooters aside, what the regular potential client wanted in a mkII was Megapixels!


Is anybody thinking that large sensors are cheap? That free lunches exist? Every benefit has a cost that must be paid somewhere, somehow, by someone sooner or later. So you see where the cost is paid. That's a good thing...now intelligent buying decisions can be made.

They were right, for all the rather over optimistic promises re noise, AF and now weather sealing, this camera seems to be nothing more than a 5D with too many megapixels of which a fraction of the buyers actually need.

Actually, I don't recall any "promises" about "weathersealing," but I am finding improved noise and autofocusing over my 5D, and enough resolution to enable me to retire my Mamiya RZ67 cameras.

Inasumch as in my studio the competition has always been between Mamiya the champion and Canon the challenger, Canon has finally won on points.

I agree - keep the bag closed until the camera is warmed up, and don't forget you need to leave time for the internals to warm up, not just the exterior of the camera.

Actually, that's about the extent to which Canon's "weathersealing" is intended to be effective.

The light condensation with rapid evaporation that one normally sees is not entering the camera--the reason it evaporates is because the outer surfaces of the camera warm that quickly.

A camera body is not air-tight, but it's also not a "heat convection engine" like a house. Air moves when it's moved. There is no heat convection in a camera body, and when a camera filled with cold, dense air, there is no physical mechanism to cause less-dense warm air to rapidly infiltrate it. It will warm by conduction far faster than the air inside mixes with the air outside.
Feb 07, 2009 at 01:05 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.6 #65DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I agree with some that there simply weren't enough A900's on the trip (2) to have any real indication as to their weather performance, however, this is an interesting statement from Michael's review:

"I should note that the 5D MKII's are not rated as weather resistant, but then neither are the Sony A900's. I deliberately allowed both of my A900 bodies be exposed to the rain for two days ashore to see how they would stand up. There were no operational difficulties. I also have used the Sonys back here in Toronto in snow storms, (unprotected), both before and after the Antarctic trip, with no ill effects. Though also not claimed as weather sealed, they appear to be as well protected as any other camera I've ever used."

Feb 07, 2009 at 01:09 PM
EyeBrock
Offline
Details
p.6 #75DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Deezie wrote:
The lack of common sense among camera users (note that I don't refer to them as photographers) is so rampant that I'm beginning to think that camera users are responsible for the phrase, "Stupid people are dumb."

Can you imagine if I wore a $3000 Armani suit to go snowboarding and complained that it that it failed to keep the water out, soaked my skin, resulted in hypothermia and shut my body down. Damn that Armani brand! They just don't know how to make a frickin' suit!

I've carried my old 5d through a typoon in China. I knew it wasn't
...Show more →

The most sensible post out of the whole thread. The 5D2 is basically a 'prosumer' model and it is brand new. I have had minor issues with mine but as a so called 'early adopter' I rolled the dice and bought one regardless.

I would think that a pro would go a different route than taking a camera that has just been introduced to the market on an expedition.
The said camera is not weather sealed and has a very short service life and therefore little history of field usage.

Really, I would have expected that any organised expedition would take tried and tested equipment that has been designed to withstand the rigours of the expected environments it is to face.

On the cold issue, my 5D2 has been fine outside in the recent very cold weather we have had in southern Ontario, (I was shooting in -20C with wind chills of -32C) but again I used some common sense in making sure my equipment had a good 30 minutes in my freezing car prior to actually using it.

To me this whole expedition thing is getting way too much attention and it looks to me like this was a case of piss poor planning.
Remember the law of "P's".

Prior Planning Prevents Piss-Poor Performance.

Feb 07, 2009 at 01:13 PM
mmurph
Offline
Details
p.6 #85DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
brainiac wrote:
BTW, the odds are quite interesting if you plan to take 5D2's to the antarctic. The important question is how many 5D's do you need to take to get a certain likelihood of at least one camera continuing to work. It goes like this:

2 cameras: 93.75%
3 cameras: 98.4%
4 cameras: 99.6%
5 cameras: 99.9%



OK, I get your calculation, that is the confidence level. To put it a little differently, the odds of all your cameras failing are the reverse of that:

2 cameras: 1/4 x 1/4 = 1/16 = 6.25%

3 cameras: 1/4 x 1/4 x14 = 1/64 = 1.6%

4 cameras: 1/4 x 1/4 x14 x 1/4 = 1/256 = .4%

etc.


But, 1/2 the failures were intermittent. Which means the camera started working again, so only a shorter down time.


Edited on Feb 07, 2009 at 01:34 PM · View previous versions
Feb 07, 2009 at 01:21 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.6 #95DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Deezie wrote:
The lack of common sense among camera users (note that I don't refer to them as photographers) is so rampant that I'm beginning to think that camera users are responsible for the phrase, "Stupid people are dumb."

Can you imagine if I wore a $3000 Armani suit to go snowboarding and complained that it that it failed to keep the water out, soaked my skin, resulted in hypothermia and shut my body down. Damn that Armani brand! They just don't know how to make a frickin' suit!

I've carried my old 5d through a typoon in China. I knew it wasn't
...Show more →

I guess that leaves the only thing a 5DII can do is take photos of brick walls on not too hot, not too cold, not too rainly and not too dry days. And I thought it was a good landscape camera. Silly of me to think so.
Feb 07, 2009 at 01:33 PM
Beni
Offline
Details
p.6 #105DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Anyone know where to find the quote from Canon that the 5D mkII is rated for 10mm of rain in 3 mins? Canon have specifically said that the camera is weather proof to a specific (quite high) degree, all those saying that the camera isn't weather proof and were taken into extreme conditions are too much fanboys to have a long memory or actually read what MR said about the conditions there.

BTW it's in the DPReview announce of the camera. No doubt also in official Canon literature.
http://www.dpreview.com/previews/canoneos5dmarkII/
Feb 07, 2009 at 01:39 PM
Shuko
Offline
Details
p.6 #115DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
To the stats guys, no need to over do it. 23% fail rate is simple enough, and that doesn't build confidence or trust. If it's your camera that fails, it will suck, no matter how small or large the chance is.

Let's wait a year, maybe then there will be more D700 (700x, 800, whatever) than Canons. This time there was 30% and they couldn't get single one to break.

Positive side is that only 1x1D3 and 1x1Ds3 failed, making 1-series 2/26.
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:17 PM
15Bit
Offline
Details
p.6 #125DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
chez wrote:
I guess that leaves the only thing a 5DII can do is take photos of brick walls on not too hot, not too cold, not too rainly and not too dry days. And I thought it was a good landscape camera. Silly of me to think so.

I'm afraid i agree. For £2000+ i think its reasonable to expect a camera which is rated for use in more than dry air conditioned studios and still sunny days. I can get this from a £100 P&S, why should i expect less from a £2000 SLR ?

As for the sample size/statistics etc, as a fellow scientist i can tell you that they are irrelevant - the report that 25% of the 5Ds died and non of the D700's did is a marketing coup for Nikon, whether its statistically valid or not.

Edited on Feb 07, 2009 at 02:31 PM · View previous versions
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:23 PM
jamesf99
Offline
Details
p.6 #135DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Steve Spencer wrote:
mark1958 wroteAs a scientist, I agree with Jame's post that 6/26 is statistically significant.
Sorry, but as a scientist you should know better. What comparison are you suggesting is statistically significant? And what statistical test would you use to determine this significance? Unless you define a specific test you are making and you can point to a statistical test you used and the parameters from that test, then you should not be saying that it is statistically significant. IMO, it is bad science to suggest that something is statistically significant without doing the actual test of that significance.

As a scientist who teaches statistics to PhD students,


Uh oh....Now here is a point that I say is conclusively, unequivocally, and absolutely insignificant.

Sorry, but I spent enough years in graduate school with fellow PhD students and masters degree candidates, and some of the worst instructors an Ivy league school could provide to know that your point is easily "challengable"........

I can say I know of no test that would let one make an inference about statistical significance in this case. If there is such a test I would be happy to have Mark correct me. Part of the problem here is that it is not even clear what is being tested. Is the test whether there are more failures than zero? If that is the test then it is not a matter of statistics, but simply a matter of observation. Yes there were more failures than zero--obviously. Is the test, however, whether there were significantly more failures among the Canons...Show more →


Of course we don't have all the information and what we do have is mostly - but not all - anecdotal, but 6 out of 26 is bad news. You can spin it anyway you want, and spend 6 weeks designing your test/population/confidence levels, but it's bad news. If you take 26 cameras at random, use them in an ordinary way, and 23% of them fail, you are talking about a serious issue and you don't need to design a complete statistical analysis to know that. No Nikon died under the same circumstances.

EX: 26 new, randomly selected, undamaged Toyota's drive from Boston to NY. 6 die along the way for one reason or another, but in no case were they subjected to improper or even deliberate misuse. Surly you must ask why, but in this case if you want the most basic analysis you could start with "what is the chance your new 5d will go belly up if you look at it wrong"? You may or may not want a larger sample size, but I think we're on to something here.

We don't need a chi-square test, any more regression testing, we need common sense. This shouldn't happen. Period.

Unfortunately, common sense isn't all that common.... M. Twain

Feb 07, 2009 at 02:25 PM
stiksandstones
Offline
Details
p.6 #145DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
all this bad news and you still can't find one at a store.
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:27 PM
rhorta
Offline
Details
p.6 #155DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Beni wrote:
Anyone know where to find the quote from Canon that the 5D mkII is rated for 10mm of rain in 3 mins? Canon have specifically said that the camera is weather proof to a specific (quite high) degree, all those saying that the camera isn't weather proof and were taken into extreme conditions are too much fanboys to have a long memory or actually read what MR said about the conditions there.

BTW it's in the DPReview announce of the camera. No doubt also in official Canon literature.
http://www.dpreview.com/previews/canoneos5dmarkII/


Why the name calling?

The figures are disturbing, but it far too early to draw any final conclusions.

Too many people here enjoying another "sensation".

Whhhhhooooooo another "failed" Canon, whooooo...

Ruy
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:28 PM
brainiac
Offline
[X]
Details
p.6 #165DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
RDKirk wrote:
Earlier quotePerhaps this is all part of Canon marketing's cunning plan to sell more bodies. This has serious implications for me as a wedding photographer. I have bought 2 5D2's, but I can't afford to take a 1% chance that I will have to stop working altogether at a wedding. As a result, I will almost certainly have to buy a 450D and possibly a third 5D2, although at that rate of expenditure just to get some security that you can complete the job, the D700 is looking all the more attractive.
What Canon wants you to do, you professional you, is to buy a 1-Series camera.


Well, in that case Canon is going to have to make them smaller and lighter (like Nikon does in the D700) because I didn't like having a 1Ds3 and a 5D around my neck for 14 hours, let alone 2 1Ds3's. It's not unprofessional to consider the weight of your gear. I am the kind of photographer who is happier wearing 3 lightweight bodies and three primes or short light zooms, instead of smashing furniture with a 28-300 and a 100-400.

Edited on Feb 07, 2009 at 02:31 PM · View previous versions
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:28 PM
SHVv
Offline
Details
p.6 #175DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Did Canon move the production facility for the 5D series Just saw this service notice:
Service Notice: EOS 5D: Main Mirror Detachment

http://www.usa.canon.com/consumer/controller?act=PgComSmModDisplayAct&fcategoryid=215&modelid=11933&keycode=2112&id=55659
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:30 PM
jamesf99
Offline
Details
p.6 #185DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Beni wrote:
Anyone know where to find the quote from Canon that the 5D mkII is rated for 10mm of rain in 3 mins? Canon have specifically said that the camera is weather proof to a specific (quite high) degree, all those saying that the camera isn't weather proof and were taken into extreme conditions are too much fanboys to have a long memory or actually read what MR said about the conditions there.

BTW it's in the DPReview announce of the camera. No doubt also in official Canon literature.
http://www.dpreview.com/previews/canoneos5dmarkII/



Hey Beni,

I think we need to understand that Canon misspoke here. What they meant to say was that the 5d2 could withstand "a 10mm strip of dense fog with a moisture content of .03%" coming at it repeatedly once a second for 5 seconds. I think that about nails it down...
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:32 PM
Daan B
Offline
Details
p.6 #195DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
SHVv wrote:
Did Canon move the production facility for the 5D series Just saw this service notice:
Service Notice: EOS 5D: Main Mirror Detachment

http://www.usa.canon.com/consumer/controller?act=PgComSmModDisplayAct&fcategoryid=215&modelid=11933&keycode=2112&id=55659


I hope Canon used better glue in the 5D2...
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:35 PM
Rampai65
Offline
Details
p.6 #205DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
stiksandstones wrote:
all this bad news and you still can't find one at a store.


All the more reason why improving quality is not a priority
Feb 07, 2009 at 02:38 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister