This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.
Archive 200810-stop ND photos
p.3 #110-stop ND photos
Now that I stumbled across THIS thread, I've just GOT to buy another filter.
This website costs me a fortune.
This website costs me a fortune.
Jun 25, 2008 at 09:33 PM
p.3 #310-stop ND photos
Btw, there's a huge difference between a 6 and 10 stop filter. If you can get a 30 second exposure with a 10 stop, then the 6 stop will only give you a 1.9 second exposure...
Jun 26, 2008 at 01:10 AM
p.3 #410-stop ND photos
congratulations to all who post images here.
I will have to by such a filter to... Maybe we all end up makeing long exposures :-)
I will have to by such a filter to... Maybe we all end up makeing long exposures :-)
Jun 26, 2008 at 01:34 AM
p.3 #510-stop ND photos
Just processed another photo from last weekend, same location. The long exposure effect isn't quite as pronounced but still looks ok I think...
Jan
Jan
Jun 28, 2008 at 02:55 PM
p.3 #610-stop ND photos
Jan Kristensen wrote:
Btw, there's a huge difference between a 6 and 10 stop filter. If you can get a 30 second exposure with a 10 stop, then the 6 stop will only give you a 1.9 second exposure...
Correct. I'm not after super long exposures in the middle of the day. I'm after the ability to get longer exposures in twilight hours, which is why I went with the 6-stop rather than the 10-stop. But you're right, there is a marked difference between the two.
-Jeremy
Btw, there's a huge difference between a 6 and 10 stop filter. If you can get a 30 second exposure with a 10 stop, then the 6 stop will only give you a 1.9 second exposure...
Correct. I'm not after super long exposures in the middle of the day. I'm after the ability to get longer exposures in twilight hours, which is why I went with the 6-stop rather than the 10-stop. But you're right, there is a marked difference between the two.
-Jeremy
Jun 28, 2008 at 04:07 PM
p.3 #710-stop ND photos
Amercko wrote:
congratulations to all who post images here.
I will have to by such a filter to... Maybe we all end up makeing long exposures :-)
And that is the issue with these filters. They are in my opinion being overused. Although there are some very good shots here there are also some average ones where the shot is heavily reliant on what I personally consider to be a bit of a gimmick. Long exposures are great, but using a 10 stop filter alone does not make good photos. I think in some cases the long exposure effect is used at the expense of image content.
I have one of these filters, I think it's great, but I seldom find it useful.
Alex
congratulations to all who post images here.
I will have to by such a filter to... Maybe we all end up makeing long exposures :-)
And that is the issue with these filters. They are in my opinion being overused. Although there are some very good shots here there are also some average ones where the shot is heavily reliant on what I personally consider to be a bit of a gimmick. Long exposures are great, but using a 10 stop filter alone does not make good photos. I think in some cases the long exposure effect is used at the expense of image content.
I have one of these filters, I think it's great, but I seldom find it useful.
Alex
Jun 28, 2008 at 04:15 PM
p.3 #810-stop ND photos
Alex,
How many of the landscape images here on FM do you reckon are produced with 6-10 stop ND filters? 1%? 2%? Not exactly what I'd call overused
.
Of course it can be bit of a gimmick and I agree that using a 10 stop filter alone does not make good photos. I do, however, find them a great tool (one of many) in landscape photography and whether they are useful or not really comes down to one's creativity.
Happy shooting, filters or not
Jan
How many of the landscape images here on FM do you reckon are produced with 6-10 stop ND filters? 1%? 2%? Not exactly what I'd call overused
.Of course it can be bit of a gimmick and I agree that using a 10 stop filter alone does not make good photos. I do, however, find them a great tool (one of many) in landscape photography and whether they are useful or not really comes down to one's creativity.
Happy shooting, filters or not
Jan
Jun 29, 2008 at 02:38 AM
p.3 #910-stop ND photos
akclimber wrote:
I figure I can add another ND or two once I get an idea how/if I'll use 'em.
Just so you know... all the Vari-ND is is two polarizers. So, if you can't actually use it with your polarizer as well. Also, it does produce some weird effects at or beyond the 8 stop mark.
Edited on Jul 02, 2008 at 03:26 PM
I figure I can add another ND or two once I get an idea how/if I'll use 'em.
Just so you know... all the Vari-ND is is two polarizers. So, if you can't actually use it with your polarizer as well. Also, it does produce some weird effects at or beyond the 8 stop mark.
Edited on Jul 02, 2008 at 03:26 PM
Jul 02, 2008 at 03:26 PM
p.3 #1010-stop ND photos
ajkessler wrote:
Just so you know... all the Vari-ND is is two polarizers. So, if you can't actually use it with your polarizer as well. Also, it does produce some weird effects at or beyond the 8 stop mark.
Thanks for the heads up! There is a warning in the literature that comes with the gizmo that warns of the potential for weird effects when going beyond 8 stops. I guess some experimentation lies ahead. Odd tho, that they sell the add-on 5 stop ND for the vari ND. Specially matched to the vari ND perhaps? I dunno....
CHeers!
akclimber wrote
I figure I can add another ND or two once I get an idea how/if I'll use 'em.Thanks for the heads up! There is a warning in the literature that comes with the gizmo that warns of the potential for weird effects when going beyond 8 stops. I guess some experimentation lies ahead. Odd tho, that they sell the add-on 5 stop ND for the vari ND. Specially matched to the vari ND perhaps? I dunno....
CHeers!
Jul 02, 2008 at 04:04 PM
p.3 #1110-stop ND photos
Hi there, this post is pretty old so I hope i'll get a response
I've got a question about the ND110 filtre from B+W (= 10 stop), i'm considering to buy it. I want to use it on a canon 10-22mm, but is it a problem to use the filtre at 10mm, or are the edges of the filter then in sight. (I hope my english is correct). So I mean if there is vignetting @ 10mm?(I use it on a canon 400D).
I'll be waiting for a response
Greetings,
Andreas
I've got a question about the ND110 filtre from B+W (= 10 stop), i'm considering to buy it. I want to use it on a canon 10-22mm, but is it a problem to use the filtre at 10mm, or are the edges of the filter then in sight. (I hope my english is correct). So I mean if there is vignetting @ 10mm?(I use it on a canon 400D).
I'll be waiting for a response
Greetings,
Andreas
Jun 07, 2009 at 03:36 AM
p.3 #1210-stop ND photos
Well I've got one but having owned it for almost 9 months I've virtually not used it. Being inland and away from any suitable water I just haven't really needed it. Can't wait till I get a chance to use it properly though my new lens is a 77mm thread and the filter is 67mm 
Just curious but do you guys find the filters have a warm cast to them? And they do seem to vignette quite a lot.
I've got the 10 stop in 67mm and the 6 stop in 77mm and both have very similar vignetting and casts to them.
Just curious but do you guys find the filters have a warm cast to them? And they do seem to vignette quite a lot.
I've got the 10 stop in 67mm and the 6 stop in 77mm and both have very similar vignetting and casts to them.
Jun 07, 2009 at 09:23 AM
p.3 #1310-stop ND photos
Very nice examples of a great nd filter to have in your arsenal.
Jun 07, 2009 at 03:04 PM
p.3 #1410-stop ND photos
but does anyone know if there is any vignetting @ 10mm with the ND110 filter (on 10-22)
Jun 08, 2009 at 04:01 AM
p.3 #1510-stop ND photos
andreas612 wrote:
but does anyone know if there is any vignetting @ 10mm with the ND110 filter (on 10-22)
I'm pretty certain there will be. I get vignetting @ 10mm with a 6 stop B+W ND and I get vignetting @ 18mm with a 10 stop B+W ND so I guess you will get some. Should be fixable in post but I think you'll be hard pushed to avoid it altogether when shooting.
but does anyone know if there is any vignetting @ 10mm with the ND110 filter (on 10-22)
I'm pretty certain there will be. I get vignetting @ 10mm with a 6 stop B+W ND and I get vignetting @ 18mm with a 10 stop B+W ND so I guess you will get some. Should be fixable in post but I think you'll be hard pushed to avoid it altogether when shooting.
Jun 10, 2009 at 09:10 AM
p.3 #1710-stop ND photos
For those of us on a budget:
http://dmcphoto.com/Articles/VariableND/index.html
http://dmcphoto.com/Articles/VariableND/index.html
Jun 10, 2009 at 01:09 PM
p.3 #1810-stop ND photos
Langran wrote:
I'm pretty certain there will be. I get vignetting @ 10mm with a 6 stop B+W ND and I get vignetting @ 18mm with a 10 stop B+W ND so I guess you will get some. Should be fixable in post but I think you'll be hard pushed to avoid it altogether when shooting.
ok, thank you for your reply. Maybe I'll change then to the cokin Z-pro system
andreas612 wrote
but does anyone know if there is any vignetting @ 10mm with the ND110 filter (on 10-22)ok, thank you for your reply. Maybe I'll change then to the cokin Z-pro system
Jun 10, 2009 at 02:34 PM
p.3 #1910-stop ND photos
http://www.22ndexposure.com/photos/534363664_dyhEK-L.jpg
40D 10-22 10 stop ND, 2 stop Grad-ND
40D 10-22 10 stop ND, 2 stop Grad-ND
Jun 10, 2009 at 03:28 PM
p.3 #2010-stop ND photos
A few recent shots, I love this filter
1
http://thomasmalinskiphotography.com/FM%20Images/20090530_5D_9233%20Footer.jpg
2
http://thomasmalinskiphotography.com/FM%20Images/20090530_5D_9239%20Footer.jpg
3
http://thomasmalinskiphotography.com/FM%20Images/20090524_5D_9115_Blended.jpg
Thanks for looking
Tom
1
http://thomasmalinskiphotography.com/FM%20Images/20090530_5D_9233%20Footer.jpg
2
http://thomasmalinskiphotography.com/FM%20Images/20090530_5D_9239%20Footer.jpg
3
http://thomasmalinskiphotography.com/FM%20Images/20090524_5D_9115_Blended.jpg
Thanks for looking
Tom
Jun 10, 2009 at 06:58 PM