Tina Kino wrote:
old-gregg wrote
I also loved the results you posted. But generally I agree: NLP is bad news when it comes to colors. Nate shared his approach in great detail on dpreview in "science" forum. Long story short: it is a wrong approach. It is based on guessing and sometimes it produces nice results, but it will never work **consistently**. Which means that if you shoot Portra and use NLP, you're not getting Portra colors. You're getting NLP colors, also known as "bubble gum colors". There's nothing to figure out. To be fair I have seen great results from folks using NLP, including great "Portra colors".
Can't say though whether these people are getting those great colors consistently, or how exactly they are using NLP, maybe with custom profiles..
I never dived deep into it (just using it for a short while).. I got the hunch it could be really good if you manage to dial it in, but for me the whole workflow was just a pain. I mean I guess scanning color film is a pain no matter how you do it 💁♂️
I think the main issue with NLP (for color) is consistency. Sometimes it does absolutely great. But then the next frame of the same scene is shockingly different.
Sometimes it 'benefits' the user by over-riding the stock (making 800T look daylight balanced, for example). Obviously, the flip side is that it imposes its mercurial character on the stock making everything look more like NLP than the film itself. I don't have the skill to fiddle with it and make it do my bidding.
I absolutely respect and applaud Nate for creating the program, but I wonder what Adobe could make with their army of engineers (I feel bad writing that, realizing that Adobe has become the evil empire...though, the monthly subscription is probably my penance for never paying for a copy in my youth).