What a fun comparison!!!
The noct looks great - especially for its age. I am amazed at how sharp and contrasty it is.
The 58g is pretty magical too. I've been looking for a deal on one for a while...but there aren't too many to be had. What a dreamy, ethereal rendering for a modern lens. It seems like Nikon completely bungled the marketing on this.
Thanks to you and your model for making this comparison!