PESCADOMAN wrote:
BTW, you should be talking to the multibillion dollar corp, not photographers. Why should the customer have to "bite the bullet" anyway
But if plenty unhappy 1D Mark III owners do that and change camp, the mass exodus will hit hard on Canon's bottom line and it will get their attention. Another available option is to file a class action lawsuit against Canon. Join forces and try that route; guaranteed it will get Canon's attention as well. All these "discussions" will not help the AF issues no matter how heated. You think Canon is listening to this? More power to you if you think so.
Sorry - I already bought my used 1D3 (non-blue dot) from a fellow FMer for a good deal.
Good thing I put the flame suit on.. it's getting hot in here.
At the end of the day, if it really is keeping you up at night, then perhaps the proposition of selling the camera for a $1500 loss might be money well spent. With as fired up as many of you appear over this issue, it begs the question of what is the price of your sanity. This battle with Canon will not be won.
This is sometimes just the way things play out in life.
I'm done with this, so flame on all you want. I have no desire to get into what clearly has the strong potential to degrade to frivolous battle of wit and ego.
Peace...
PESCADOMAN wrote: Gravitytoy wroteThis 1D3 drama is getting old...
I don't know what those of you who are *so* dissatisfied with this camera do for a living, but with the time spent lambasting on frivolous forums, one could have been schlepping Slurpees at 7-11 and made enough cash to buy a brand new Nikon kit!
I own a 1D3... and I have sympathy for those who may have received a less that perfect body.. But I have a difficult time understanding why if this is the case, one would not just sell the darn camera and get on with life.
Flame suit on... I'll sell it to you right now for 4500, which is what I paid for the damn thing. I'll even take Paypal. Heck, I'll even trade you for mine...less than 400 actuations, 90 percent blurry. Some of us feel the 1000 plus loss is substantial, as the used price simply sucks(could have something to do with the problems?).
I love how some people spend just as much time bitching about those of us unfortunate enough to have purchased a paperweight. Let us not forget that if it wasn't for the internet, Canon may have gotten away with this completely. Has that slipped your mind, or do you feel that this and other forums are really as useless and a waste of energy as you portray them?
Am I being kinda optimistic, or does this mean its the end of the road for the 1D3
"We are aware that some customers have raised questions about the performance of the EOS-1D Mark III AF system under certain conditions. We will continue to investigate, and look for opportunities to improve, the performance of the AF system to ensure the satisfaction of all of our customers"
I don't think Canon is done working on this problem yet.
I got a new Mark III. would not focus had to do it manually to get it started. and all though it showed it was in focus out of 547 shots 95%were out of focus! the store was nice enough to overnight me a new one yesterday and I sent mine back.
I don't think the main argument was ever that all 1D3s are faulty or that all of them were not faulty. The argument was that the number of faulty 1D3s was far in excess of an acceptable low random failure rate. There were polls that indicated about 1 in 3 were faulty. Sure the polls were taken amongst a biased group but the key point was that those cameras were not being fixed by Canon in a reasonable time. I've had a bundle of faulty Canon cameras and all but one (the 40D) were fixed by Canon after Canon Service recognised the problems were real. With the 1D3s that users are complaining about they could not - at least until recently - fix the faulty cameras and instead blamed the photographers Now without offering any apologies they expect those same photographers to buy the next Canon model.
If the cameras were so easily fixed or else so easily replaced with working units then think how much better off Canon would have been to replace Rob Galbraith's unit with a working one ! Instead he had 4 defective cameras that Canon could not fix despite Canon reps and engineers being with him to witness the tests that he was doing - on several occasions. Obviously that reinforces the suggestion that the problems were real and unfixable at the time. Now here we are a year after the model was announced and some people still have problems - sometimes after the fix was applied.
I can't afford the financial loss to abandon all of my Canon gear but I'm surely not going to rush into another Canon DSLR purchase with any currect model or any new model within three months of release. I've also put the brakes on my Canon lens purchases. I'm not a pro - just a cashed up amateur who probably spends more than most pros because my gear does not have to earn its keep. Canon has come close to losing me. They'll survive but worse yet for them is that they have already lost and continue to lose a considerable number of new high-end DSLR customers. Evidence of that is their falling market share relative to Nikon.
I'm very glad that Nikon presently have viable alternatives to the Canon high-end gear as it allows Canon to receive some financial punishment for their disgraceful behaviour towards owners of defective Canon cameras. In that regard Canon's timing was as bad as their behaviour. What a shame. Having said that, however, I'd be very glad to have a working 3D or even a 1Ds4 but I won't be anywhere near the front of the queue to buy one in case they too are duds.
People who suggest the victims should forget it and move on are not being entirely reasonable. Sure, it's excellent advice from a psychological viewpoint but it hardly does anything to recover the financial loss, and for a long time there was a good chance that a new purchase would be just as defective as the one being replaced.
I also noticed that a lot of FMers and others tended to blame the victims rather than accept that Canon could possibly be at fault. Only the sheer number of 1D3 victims tended to quiet that criticism but it took a long time. Now they are coming out of the woodwork again because Canon has decreed that all is well.
Moving on to the 1D3N, that is still a viable option for Canon as far as I can see. It would cause the value of 1D3 to plummet further and faster than previous replaced models but it would let them start afresh. Some argue that they did just that when they introduced the 1D2N - that it was mostly becasue some pros in particular were having unfixable (at the time) and intermittent AF problems with the 1D2. The 1D2N was probably not a worthy upgrade for any other reason than to put the 1D2 off the market. The new features were minor at best - No new processor, no new sensor, no new viewfinder, etc. - and many 1D2 owners did not see the upgrade as good value. I think that with the 1D3 reputation rightly stained there will be a better upgrade market for a 1D3N and a larger number of fence-sitters willing to buy after a suitable precautionary delay.
Self-promotion is overated. I trust Canon on this issue as much as I trusted Bush on WMD's. Still wouldn't touch a 1D III unless it was being sold by someone I knew had achieved stunning results in the most testing of AF and climatic conditions.
kazman442 wrote:
ruckus is just pushing our buttons. Please ignore the man behind the curtain
Did the "man behind the curtain" really join FM only today (March 5, 2008) as indicated by his registration? If so, maybe he should do some more reading....
Paul B wrote: kazman442 wroteruckus is just pushing our buttons. Please ignore the man behind the curtain Did the "man behind the curtain" really join FM only today (March 5, 2008) as indicated by his registration? If so, maybe he should do some more reading....
As a lawyer, Canon's Mar 5, 2008 Press Release strikes me as nothing more than their legal counsel bracing for a lawsuit.
All the MKIII owners who have neither encountered nor discovered the inherent defect with their cameras (regardless if they've not used the AF in the problematic mode(s), under defect revealing conditions, or with lenses capable of revealing the defect) could easily be portrayed as the satisfied and fulfilled majority user base of the product. Thereby contrasting the very few who have found the defect, and giving Canon an opportunity to allege the defect is either an electro mechanical and software tolerance issue not existent in all the units. The net effect is essentially posturing to reduce their exposure to eventual damages. In the meanwhile, they're attempting to create a diversion to the underlying defect, and give many of the unknowing owners something to feel good about. After all, satisfied owners are not likely to join ranks in a lawsuit.
Any FM'ers switching to Nikon, if you've got excellent condition L-Series lenses, I'd be more than happy to give them a home for use with my low frame count MKIIn!
Alan321 wrote:
...
I can't afford the financial loss to abandon all of my Canon gear but I'm surely not going to rush into another Canon DSLR purchase with any currect model or any new model within three months of release. I've also put the brakes on my Canon lens purchases....
- Alan
Alan, just curious about what you mean when you say you're putting the brakes on any lens purchases. For how long? I guess I've been assuming they'll get this fixed eventually or come out with a redesigned "MkIV" or whatever within some period (12-24 months.) I ask because I'm pretty close to buying a 600 and, like you, have a lot already invested in Canon equipment. I've got no problem putting down another $7,000 for a lense and waiting two or even three years for the next great body (I've got a MkIIn and 20D, and just got a 5D--bought this partly because of the price and partly because I knew I wouldn't be buying a "5DII" that might have issues which Canon could take its time fixing. ) I can see Canon having to do some major redesigning (and perhaps also personnel shakeups internally to fix this situation.) Is there any evidence you know of (from Canon or Nikon history) that it's going to take more than a couple years to turn around a major screw-up with camera design?
Edited by Paul B on Mar 05, 2008 at 07:09 PM GMT (Reason: typo)
I ordered a new MK 3 on Sat. from onecall.com and I got it today. I have spent a few hours testing it out this evening, taking different focus test shots with my 500 f/4 X 1.4 tc ..I shoot birds and wildlife...and I have to say that I'am 100% happy with the results I got....I feel very confident that this camera is going to work very well for my needs.
Alan321 wrote:
I've also put the brakes on my Canon lens purchases.
- Alan
So there was a lens you wanted or needed, but you decided not to buy it now because of the Mark III issue? Yeah, I guess that'll show them...fight the power!
Rob Greenstein wrote:
As a lawyer, Canon's Mar 5, 2008 Press Release strikes me as nothing more than their legal counsel bracing for a lawsuit.
As an old corporate guerilla thug, in that Press Release I just see a habitually (for Canon USA) anemic way of trying to communicate "we've got the problem licked".
Their MkIII sales are probably sagging below projections, their PR analysts have perhaps detected some erosion in the corporate image amongst the high end SLR customers, the camera design band-aiding costs are higher than expected and so are the warranty/recall costs. That's the bigger picture reality that Canon sees, and rightfully so.
I don't think lawsuits are entering that picture (yet). In effect, I think Canon could claim very successfully that they have been dutyfully ameliorating the MkIII teething problems, consistent with their warranty and beyond.
Donald Blue wrote:
I ordered a new MK 3 on Sat. from onecall.com and I got it today. I have spent a few hours testing it out this evening, taking different focus test shots with my 500 f/4 X 1.4 tc ..I shoot birds and wildlife...and I have to say that I'am 100% happy with the results I got....I feel very confident that this camera is going to work very well for my needs.
Don enjoy your new camera. I do find it strange that you can say your 100% happy with the results you got. Do you mean on your focus test shots? Or did you go out and shoot some birds in flight and your happy?
ruckus
PM me with who has the new 1D 3 and is not having problems with it out doors in bright sunlight and in 75 + deg temps..
I don't doubt that the newest versions are working properly now.
I can almost guarantee that they are fixed.. How You ask??
Because after a year of waiting for this camera I gave up yesterday and bought a 1Ds 2 instead.
So now I am sure that they will be fine now that I decided I was never getting one...
Alan321 wrote:
...
I can't afford the financial loss to abandon all of my Canon gear but I'm surely not going to rush into another Canon DSLR purchase with any currect model or any new model within three months of release. I've also put the brakes on my Canon lens purchases....
- Alan
Alan, my sentiments exactly. As the saying goes, "fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me"...
kazman442 wrote: Donald Blue wroteI ordered a new MK 3 on Sat. from onecall.com and I got it today. I have spent a few hours testing it out this evening, taking different focus test shots with my 500 f/4 X 1.4 tc ..I shoot birds and wildlife...and I have to say that I'am 100% happy with the results I got....I feel very confident that this camera is going to work very well for my needs.Don enjoy your new camera. I do find it strange that you can say your 100% happy with the results you got. Do you mean on your focus test shots? Or did you go out and shoot some birds in flight and your happy?
Yes...I meant that I'm happy with the focus test shots I took. I didn't have time enough to get any BIF shots with it today. I'm going to give it a good test run this weekend as I've got a private lake where there are alot of bufflehead ducks that I've been trying to get some sharp flight shots of....I was using a 40D and I just could not get a sharp flight shot on those buffleheads with it no matter what I tried...I'll see how it goes this weekend.