Gravitytoy wrote:
This 1D3 drama is getting old...
I don't know what those of you who are *so* dissatisfied with this camera do for a living, but with the time spent lambasting on frivolous forums, one could have been schlepping Slurpees at 7-11 and made enough cash to buy a brand new Nikon kit!
I own a 1D3... and I have sympathy for those who may have received a less that perfect body.. But I have a difficult time understanding why if this is the case, one would not just sell the darn camera and get on with life.
Yakim Peled wrote:
Well, I guess you can kiss the 1D MK III N goodbye. I thought they will introduced a new version before the Olympics.
Happy shooting,
Yakim.
I would be surprised if a select few don't have a 1DMkIIIN (or even a 1DMkIV prototype) at the Olympics (along with a hefty NDA!). It will be interesting to see how many long black lenses there are in Bejing.
Yakim Peled wrote:
Well, I guess you can kiss the 1D MK III N goodbye. I thought they will introduced a new version before the Olympics.
Happy shooting,
Yakim.
I don't think this makes you wrong, Yakim, I think this points to you being right.
My thinking is that they will be introducing an N model very soon and this is part of the plan. Basically what I think their ploy will be is to say that this camera is fine but look at this new baby that has even more features that keep it competitive with the competition. I think they will change the LCD, add the features to Live View that are present in the 40D, maybe even add in MLU and claim that they didn't make any changes to the AF. Wink, wink, nod, nod.
"After the AF mirror Adjustment, including the updated firmware version 1.1.3, the EOS-1D Mark III AF function performed better in our tests than all previous EOS camera models."
Considering their testing methods allowed the MkIII to be designed, built, and hit the streets in the condition it was in, this statement has no meaning for me. It's their testing methods that allowed the camera to become the debacle that it has.
That may be the last straw for me then. I was planning on buying a 300/3.8L IS, but it ain't gonna happen if this is the end of the story. If 'not quite as good as the MkIIn' is as good as it gets, that's not good enough for me, given how the camera was marketed.
icandyimages wrote:
Someone go buy the Mark III today and report back by weeks end your findings,
I received mine last Wednesday (2/27/2008) and have already put almost 1500 shots through it for a grade school variety show on 3/1 and 3/2.
Apples to apples comparison with my 20D which I used to shoot the first weekend of the show puts the 1D3 head and shoulders above the 20D for focus, high ISO noise and image quality in general. And the post processing time spent is much lower too, which is a fantastic bonus/side effect.
I don't doubt those having problems (there are still too many reputable FMer's in this category), but the general trend with newer bodies seems very positive.
There will always be a debate and people on both sides but if there are people who still have legitimate issues and this as the end all for Canon the sweeping under the rug at this point will be very disappointing! Cmon summer!!
That's what Canon told me at the Focus show in Birmingham last week, that there is no additional hardware fix coming as Rob Galbraith mentioned, though there will be another firmware coming out soon.
On a general update note, I am becoming more and more pleased with my 1D3. Under low light it is fabulous, I shot a Division 1 rugby match yesterday evening, close to freezing temperature, a little mist, floodlight giving me barely 1/640s at ISO 6400 and f2.8 on my 400mm. Out of 780 shots fired, not one out of focus because of the camera, the <20 there were were me losing my track of the subject. Last Sunday I shot a rally motorsport event, again, really very good performance. Saturday was rugby again, 3pm kick off so better light, it did an excellent job. I have to have left/right expand configured as I am now 100% certain that the tracking/lock ability of the central sensor alone (no expand) is no way near as good as the 1D2N. Accepting this, I have adapted the way I shoot a bit and the results are great.
In many ways the 1D2N was the perfect camera, in very low light it's focussing ability did degrade, but in good light nothing else could touch it. The 1D3 seems the opposite, fantastic in very low light but not quite as good as the 1D2N in good light. That's my opinion anyway, but as a package, for the events I shoot, it does what I need and my results get published. Just my 2p worth.
I am considering buying 2 this year for my business. CPS is sending me one on March 14 to test.
I know Rob Galbraith personally and when I read his original preview of the 1D Mark III I believed him when he said there were AI-Servo issues with the camera. So, I've held off while this has sorted itself out. But it's time to give the camera a chance. Canon seems to have made progress with AF working well for most people.
Film used to be the great equalizer. But I think with digital we will continue to see one manufacturer gaining temporary leads in one feature area or another, then being leapfrogged by their competition. Switching systems every time this happens is not practical for most of us. Switching is not an option for me in any case, as I prefer Canon IQ, lens selection, and system ergonomics.
Jeff wrote:
That may be the last straw for me then.
-Jeff
I'm heading that way as well. While I've been using Canon only for 10 years, after my first Nikon SLR just didn't fit well with me, this is really something.
I view Canon's communications in light of their business interest in the sales of their products.
IMO, much more weight should be given to the product operating feedback, and ultimately one's own experience with the product. All else tends to be fluff.
Two very well put post guys. I agree with Alistair 100% about the Mark3, I'm on my 5th one and it seems to be slightly under the Mark2 in brighter conditions using AI servo, is this good enough? I would like to see some more improvement.
Alistair Watson wrote:
That's what Canon told me at the Focus show in Birmingham last week, that there is no additional hardware fix coming as Rob Galbraith mentioned, though there will be another firmware coming out soon.
On a general update note, I am becoming more and more pleased with my 1D3. Under low light it is fabulous, I shot a Division 1 rugby match yesterday evening, close to freezing temperature, a little mist, floodlight giving me barely 1/640s at ISO 6400 and f2.8 on my 400mm. Out of 780 shots fired, not one out of focus because of the camera, the <20 there were were me losing my track of the subject. Last Sunday I shot a rally motorsport event, again, really very good performance. Saturday was rugby again, 3pm kick off so better light, it did an excellent job. I have to have left/right expand configured as I am now 100% certain that the tracking/lock ability of the central sensor alone (no expand) is no way near as good as the 1D2N. Accepting this, I have adapted the way I shoot a bit and the results are great.
In many ways the 1D2N was the perfect camera, in very low light it's focussing ability did degrade, but in good light nothing else could touch it. The 1D3 seems the opposite, fantastic in very low light but not quite as good as the 1D2N in good light. That's my opinion anyway, but as a package, for the events I shoot, it does what I need and my results get published. Just my 2p worth. ...Show more →
For the time being, I an doing the same.....IIN in the day, III at night. Canon isn't through with the MKIII.
I do not believe you will ever see a MKIIIN. Think about the uproar it would cause if it were released. The silent fix / grassy knoll people (many who don't even own the camera) would be burning up the forums and chat rooms. Even if Canon wanted to......they wouldn't.
I'm guessing the MKIV will debut some time next year, with so many major improvements, it will calm the silent fix crowd and be looked at as a completely different animal.
Gravitytoy wrote:
This 1D3 drama is getting old...
I don't know what those of you who are *so* dissatisfied with this camera do for a living, but with the time spent lambasting on frivolous forums, one could have been schlepping Slurpees at 7-11 and made enough cash to buy a brand new Nikon kit!
I own a 1D3... and I have sympathy for those who may have received a less that perfect body.. But I have a difficult time understanding why if this is the case, one would not just sell the darn camera and get on with life.
Flame suit on...
Man you arent kidding. People give these forums too much credit sometimes, i am guilty myself.
I dont post much here but read it all the time. I had been patiently holding off buying a MK III 1D for mos because of the awful reviews given by these users. Some have a valid point, others.. not so much.
So my old rig is a MK II 1D but i have been curious of the high ISO capabilities of the MK III and D3. After reading the reviews here i thought no way i'll ever buy a MK III. About 2 mos ago I shot an indoor event for a magazine i work for. A good buddy of mine has just purchased his MK III and brought it with him. At the same time my boss/other buddy brought his freshly purchased D3. Both offered them up for some demo shots to me, my poor MK II was neglected. Both cameras rock! I think they both have strong points but NEITHER had the problems i've read on here. The canon was air tight, focus was not an issue. The end result.. i bought a MK III 1D two weeks ago fron B/H. Have about 2500 shots through it and it SMOKES the MK II. Took it on a photoshoot Saturday morning for a cover shot and didnt second guess it for a second. The camera is good, solid and our cover goes to print in a few days. Enough said... get over the focal crap.. geez.
Ruckus, I am glad you got a good camera and maybe people will "get over the focal crap...geez" when they get a good camera as well. I'm sorry but your logic that you got a new 1DMkIII that is good because someone you know has one that is good so all 1DMkIII's must now be good really falls a bit short.
I worked with a brand spanking new 1DMkIII over the weekend that was marginal but no better than that. Does that mean that all cameras purchased after yours are now marginal? Of course not. The simple reality is that this is a complex problem and "getting over it" isn't the answer. Getting it right, is.
Canon is just saying Screw you guys if you can't take a joke. We said it's not broken it's you. We say it's fixed so it's fixed. We say it's fixed again so it's fixed. The Audacity of Canon is simply beyond belief. I feel for all the people that got bad copies of the M3. I'm with Hrow and Jeff this thing needs fixing not empty statements. Those that got good copies good for you count yourself Blessed, you won the Canon lotto......
Hrow wrote:
Ruckus, I am glad you got a good camera and maybe people will "get over the focal crap...geez" when they get a good camera as well. I'm sorry but your logic that you got a new 1DMkIII that is good because someone you know has one that is good so all 1DMkIII's must now be good really falls a bit short.
I worked with a brand spanking new 1DMkIII over the weekend that was marginal but no better than that. Does that mean that all cameras purchased after yours are now marginal? Of course not. The simple reality is that this is a complex problem and "getting over it" isn't the answer. Getting it right, is. ...Show more →
I agree. Professionals are not going to just "get over it" if they have a camera that costs them money. I have never done the math, but I am sure you could figure out the cost associated with a 1% drop in keeper rate. I think my drop is about 10-15% compared to my IIN in bright conditions.
As for selling it, as was suggested, who is going to buy a camera from me when I tell them it does not shoot as well as my older version? And if they did want to buy it, what they would be willing to pay could be painful to me.
I will keep my MIII, and I will not be going to Nikon any time soon, but that does not mean I am as happy as I was pre-MIII.
Canon can't win. The truth is they fumbled the 1dm3 badly, and the time to react - slow.
A 1d3n would put them in worse light. The 1d2n was a minor improvement over a camera with a good track record and reputation.
The 1dm3 may indeed, be fixed and be the finest reduced-sized sensor camera Canon has ever built, but owners and potential buyers will always have nagging doubts. Canon will survive this embarassment, but good or bad, the 1dm3 reputation will always be tainted.
Hrow wrote:
Ruckus, I am glad you got a good camera and maybe people will "get over the focal crap...geez" when they get a good camera as well. I'm sorry but your logic that you got a new 1DMkIII that is good because someone you know has one that is good so all 1DMkIII's must now be good really falls a bit short.
I worked with a brand spanking new 1DMkIII over the weekend that was marginal but no better than that. Does that mean that all cameras purchased after yours are now marginal? Of course not. The simple reality is that this is a complex problem and "getting over it" isn't the answer. Getting it right, is. ...Show more →
Really? how do we know it's not user error? I know of at least 4 MK III's, all functional. Those are pretty good standards. So i'd say this is more "hype" than fact. Just my opinion and letting those that care that it's not a bad camera. In fact I WAS going with the D3 until i figured out this was more hype than anything else. hope everyone else has equal luck. and btw.. i am a professional.
ruckus wrote:
Really? how do we know it's not user error? I know of at least 4 MK III's, all functional. Those are pretty good standards. So i'd say this is more "hype" than fact. Just my opinion and letting those that care that it's not a bad camera. In fact I WAS going with the D3 until i figured out this was more hype than anything else. hope everyone else has equal luck. and btw.. i am a professional.