If it uses the actual photographic sensor and look great, I'm for it.
A viewfinder has one disadvantage for critcal focus tasks: The focus
screen has to be calibrated so that what's in focus in the viewfinder is
also in focus on the sensor. Live View and variations on it would eliminate
that source of possible miscalibration. If the viewfinder was clean and
crisp, why not ditch the mirror and go digital.
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Well if the VF had say a 120 fps refresh, was 100% and say had 1MP resolution it could be very nice. The Minolta EVF with 60fps weren't too bad at all.
Although one would naturally assume this to be inferior to a real OVF, I'm sure a time will come when an EVF's performance will be very good, and there's thing you can do with them you can't on a OVF.
It'll be interesting to see what Sony can offer.
I agree. The EVF on the ancient Minolta D7 was actually pretty darned good. It was grainy but still worked ok. The cool thing was it could damned near see in the dark. That would be a real boon for low light auto focus.
Regards,
Jon
Mike V wrote:
The technology exists for an electronic viewfinder to have the same resolution as an optical one.
High end digital cinema cameras already have them.
It's just a matter of time for the technology to be small enough, power efficient enough and cheap enough to make it into a stills camera.
"High end digital cinema cameras" are also $30,000+ and ten times bigger than a dSLR. Even then, most of them don't even use a viewfinder, they use a 7" or so LCD monitor. Sure, its possible to make a nice micro-LCD display, but its still prohibitively expensive to put one in a consumer dSLR.
I like the idea of a reasonably compact sized camera with SLR sized sensor (preferably FF), but no reflex mirror. Lens mount to sensor distance should be the same as SLRs so existing SLR lenses can be used and the sensor doesn't have to be redesigned for high angle of incidence in the corners (like M8). Such a camera would be brilliant for tripod-mounted Landscape work. If it had pro build quality I'd buy one for sure.
No-one has made the point yet that even if the camera has no mirror - and isn't therefore an SLR by definition anyway - the lens registration (lens mount to sensor distance) has to be the same as the other Sony bodies and thus can't be any thinner in this area.
This has probably been written but if sony wants to come out with a pure bomb then theyll use an evf. No real photographer will but it, hands down. evfs are terrible
The mirror is certainly a limiting aspect right now.... think of flash sync speed WAY above 200/250/300 without cheating with HS flash (multi flash by another name)..... the queue would be long just with the wedding types.
If it took great pictures and operated like an SLR [have to call it a SL without the R I guess] that is fine with me; they could stuff a pixie or two in the box for all I care
JDSA wrote:
An EVF just has too many advantages to be overlooked as a future possibility.
Just about everything you mention sure sounds nice but frankly a bit useless for anything other than studio environments. Out in the field I ain't gonna sit and stare at an EVF to make sure everything from DoF to WB is to my liking, I'm just gonna put the camera to my eye, aim, focus, shoot.
And it's digital so almost everything else can be tweaked either in RAW or by using the rear screen review features to pick the best of the 20 shots I rattled off in a few seconds.
I guess I fail to see the attraction of an EVF outside a studio, but I might be missing something.
The part that I object to most is that no matter how high resolution the viewfinder is, it will still separate the photographer from the subject. It will be like watching your subject on television rather than photographing them. I see how this could be a problem in particular with portraits. If you do not feel like you have established a connection with the subject, the photos will likely suffer. I don't care how good they get, I don't want anything to do with them.
Ben Horne wrote:
The part that I object to most is that no matter how high resolution the viewfinder is, it will still separate the photographer from the subject. It will be like watching your subject on television rather than photographing them. I see how this could be a problem in particular with portraits. If you do not feel like you have established a connection with the subject, the photos will likely suffer. I don't care how good they get, I don't want anything to do with them.
Ah that's like when CD's came out and the vinyl audiophiles said it's lacks the warmth of vinyl - meaning the SN was so good that CD's didn't have any crap hiss, snap crackle or pop.
Wow! Everyone pisses and moans about the optical viewfinders anyway - too dim , hard for critical focus except in bright light, DoF preview sucks, don't get the whole image, not enough info in VF, blah blah blah. I am frankly a little surprised at some of the apparently Luddite responses here. E.g., OLEDs are making progress in resolution and would be bright enough - anyone seen HDTV lately? Coupla MP (6 million dots) with zoom VF, real bright DoF preview at f/11, see what you're shooting at dusk - where's the imagination here folks OK, so it's not likely there yet, but what ever is when it's introduced as a first iteration? Recall many folks saying "What would I ever do with Live View, what a stupid idea!@#$%" Then people started using it and said "Hey, it is kind of useful after all"
Ah that's like when CD's came out and the vinyl audiophiles said it's lacks the warmth of vinyl - meaning the SN was so good that CD's didn't have any crap hiss, snap crackle or pop.
Still true about digital audio lacking warmth. In the studio I waste much of my time and signal chain and plugins trying to get digital to sound sweet like analog!
Incidentally I still have thousands of LPs without any snap crackle or pop. You merely have to use a good table/needle, handle and store properly and use a record vac. I also use air ionizers to reduce static.
I have liveview on my 40D and, while it was fun to play with, it isn't very useful for me.
Gochugogi wrote: Earlier quoteAh that's like when CD's came out and the vinyl audiophiles said it's lacks the warmth of vinyl - meaning the SN was so good that CD's didn't have any crap hiss, snap crackle or pop.Still true about digital audio lacking warmth. In the studio I waste much of my time and signal chain and plugins trying to get digital to sound sweet like analog!
Incidentally I still have thousands of LPs without any snap crackle or pop. You merely have to use a good table/needle, handle and store properly and use a record vac. I also use air ionizers to reduce static.
I have liveview on my 40D and, while it was fun to play with, it isn't very useful for me.
Why would I want to spend thousands on finding a good table and needle for what IMO sounds inferior. To me if you get the right speakers that's the most important thing for sound quality. We have people telling us that solid state amps suck too and we need to get good old valve amps to get back that sparkle and warmth. I have zero issues with CD/DVD's. If it can be demonstrated that an EVF can be made superior to an OVF then I'm all for it. New technology isn't always better, but in the digital world that's rarely true. Liveview is in it's infancy, don't judge it by what it offers now, think of what it'll offer in a few years. The features have to be offered at some stage even if nowhere near perfect.
Still I'm sure it'll be another 3-5 years before we need to worry about EVF being a threat to OVF.
I don't know why you would either. I didn't suggest spending any of your hard earned cash on it. You must be daydreaming or trying hard to find something to fill the empty hours with debate. I've been collecting records for over 40 years, so I feel impelled to preserve and maintain it as well as learn new technologies wholeheartedly. If I was a young upstart like you, I'd be kissing digital's arse left 'n right and not give rat's tail about the past--no investment or memories. However, as a pro classical musician, I spend great resources trying to impart an analog sweetness to my recordings: tube mics, tube mic preamps, tube simulation plugins, etc. Nobody wants to hear cold digital. Most consumers don't realize all the toil behind the scenes to make digital sound great is analog processing and simulation. It just strikes me extremely ironic in an age of techno-digi-worship...