Markuson, I just saw someone commented on your post over at Naturescapes. This is getting really embarrassing, please tell people you were kidding before I lose all faith in the human race. (Now I see why Orson Wells was able to create such a stir so easily.)
One of the wonderful things that Larry Flynt brought us (besides the obvious) was the Supreme Court ruling on parody being protected by the First Amendment.
Hrow wrote:
There are a couple of folks that aren't getting it. The first post was a obviously joke, and so is the second one. The world ends on December 21, 2012 so it is time to lighten up a bit and enjoy a good laugh. Thanks Markuson!
It is you that don't understand. Just because it was a joke, does not make it legal.
Let's try this...suppose you are a professional...you make your life by selling your images. You post an image to FM for comments and I took it...did some PP and reposted it as below....with the following title...
cavis wrote:
One of the wonderful things that Larry Flynt brought us (besides the obvious) was the Supreme Court ruling on parody being protected by the First Amendment.
That is right...a very famous case.....and even though Larry Flynt was not found guilty of libel, he did have to pay damages to Jerry Falwell. Don't forget that part of it.
nathanlake wrote: Hrow wroteThere are a couple of folks that aren't getting it. The first post was a obviously joke, and so is the second one. The world ends on December 21, 2012 so it is time to lighten up a bit and enjoy a good laugh. Thanks Markuson!It is you that don't understand. Just because it was a joke, does not make it legal.
Let's try this...suppose you are a professional...you make your life by selling your images. You post an image to FM for comments and I took it...did some PP and reposted it as below....with the following title...
Hrow's best work...
Is this funny?
Unfortunately, that's about how well my 1DMkIII performs some of the time.
At this point, Canon should just be happy that a whole bunch of folks aren't suing them. If a little light hearted fun is going to get their undies in a bunch then I say let's all have a go at it because I have to tell you, I don't find one thing funny about spending $4500 on a camera that misses focus on a regular basis.
nathanlake and others may be confused. Canon's logo is not copyrighted as far as I can tell. It is a trademark, but that is an entirely different set of intellectual property issues, reflecting a quite different balancing of interests. The Lanham Act protects against the use of a trademark in commerce -- it does not prohibit the artistic or parodying alteration of a mark by a non-competitor, as far as I know.
I don't know whether the OP was kidding or not about the email supposedly sent by Canon, but let's be careful about the legal principles involved, if you're going to take any of it seriously. (Rolls eyes)
While we're off-topic (sigh), it may be worth pointing out that the key case concerning copyright and parody is not Flynt but Campbell v. Acuff-Rose, a Supreme Court case from 1994 that affirmed the right to fair use of a copyrighted work via parody even in an overtly commercial context. The Flynt case(s) was/were not about copyright at all, but about libel and the First Amendment. I don't know where you got the idea that Flynt was compelled to pay damages to Falwell; the Supreme Court said exactly the opposite.
Thanks, Etadam. Yes, I am a lawyer (although not an IP lawyer), and yes, I do wear a bow tie when I go to court. We all have burdens to bear, and mine are self-inflicted.
The avatar was custom made by another FM'er whose name I have forgotten as a fund-raising effort for a member whose daughter was ill. I rather like it, though it's far more garish than your nicely subtle taijitu (very nice color matching, BTW).
Goodness...
Let me put a few of you who seem in such a serious mood to rest...and just let you know that the entire post (both of them) were entirely parody. Canon has received FAR worse posts than my goofy one... Frankly, they are now catching a break from my fairly "unhappy" posts regarding 7 months of frustration...denial (by Canon)...delay...and what I frankly see as abuse of the fundamental warranty concept, "repair...or REPLACE." If you can sell good units for two months, but can't repair them for 7..."replace" has to come in there at some point.
Anyway... I took a lighthearted diversion with some humor not so different from a sketch you might see on Saturday Night Live or late-night talk TV... As a result, a lot of frustrated photographers had a much needed laugh. I know I needed it. Heck, I think even Canon should laugh a bit...but then wake up. Maybe a bit a laughing will do just that.
So laugh along with me...relax...and lets hope Canon makes a BOLD move to restore the image they've so thoroughly damaged...by actually replacing units, rather than plunking an ever-to-be-doubted blue sticker on the box.
Opinions may differ on that...but let there be no more difference of opinion regarding whether my posts were both examples of complete parody.... They were...INCLUDING the supposed "letter from Canon..." where they supposedly send me a dotted version of my blurry mess one.
Have a great evening.
-Markuson
Edited by Markuson on Dec 04, 2007 at 09:51 PM GMT
Your first logo post was really funny. Then you had me going with the "Canon is not happy with me" post. That's some ripe humor! We all should laugh a lot more. Some of the posts on FM are just depressing, rude and mean spirited.
"The most wasted day is that in which we have not laughed." -Chamfort
nathanlake wrote:
Either you misunderstood their intent or they did not make themselves clear. You have used a likeness of a copyrighted logo to convey a negative image of the company. They are not concerned with your posting being confused with theirs, they are concerned that you are illegally using something very similar to a copyrighted logo to slander them. If you had any money, they would not have warned you, they just would have sued... and probably won.
nathanlake wrote:
Either you misunderstood their intent or they did not make themselves clear. You have used a likeness of a copyrighted logo to convey a negative image of the company. They are not concerned with your posting being confused with theirs, they are concerned that you are illegally using something very similar to a copyrighted logo to slander them. If you had any money, they would not have warned you, they just would have sued... and probably won.
Talk about not looking at the link........... Bet you never hit the target when shooting or playing darts either........
You are as funny as the OP's link.....
Hello, I am Canon, and I never sent you that blue dot logo so you had better shut up. Didn't you read the letter I sent with it? I order you all to desist forthwith or I will sue you and force you to use very bad cameras for an unknown period.