Canon has informed me that if I post their logo at all, that it needs to be the correct version, as it could lead to confusion (I also detected a hint of "legal issues" in their comments)... As a "favor" to me, they sent a replacement and "requested" that I post it...or not post at all.
Surely they don't think anyone would REALLY mistake mine for theirs...but in any event, so as not to ruffle more feathers, You'll find their logo after the link below.
Interestingly...it IS somewhat changed from its familiar format. Have a look:
Either you misunderstood their intent or they did not make themselves clear. You have used a likeness of a copyrighted logo to convey a negative image of the company. They are not concerned with your posting being confused with theirs, they are concerned that you are illegally using something very similar to a copyrighted logo to slander them. If you had any money, they would not have warned you, they just would have sued... and probably won.
nathanlake wrote:
Either you misunderstood their intent or they did not make themselves clear. You have used a likeness of a copyrighted logo to convey a negative image of the company. They are not concerned with your posting being confused with theirs, they are concerned that you are illegally using something very similar to a copyrighted logo to slander them. If you had any money, they would not have warned you, they just would have sued... and probably won.
No worries...
It's parody, and is protected speech.
nathanlake wrote:
Either you misunderstood their intent or they did not make themselves clear. You have used a likeness of a copyrighted logo to convey a negative image of the company. They are not concerned with your posting being confused with theirs, they are concerned that you are illegally using something very similar to a copyrighted logo to slander them. If you had any money, they would not have warned you, they just would have sued... and probably won.
So if I drive a Chevy, and next to the name badge on the back of the car I write "is a terrible company, no one should buy from them!" is Chevy going to sue me? Me thinks not.
Plus it's blurred out a lot and has a blue dot on it. To me it's now a unique image no longer under copyright law.
Hmm, I'm thinking that the image would likely be viewed as a derived work rather than an original work and still subject to Canon's copyright. I also think that the image is probably more ridicule than parody and not protected speech.
I expect that Canon lawyers will likely be quite sensitive about copyright issues and lean on you until it feels more expensive than funny to continue to publish the image.
jeffmock wrote:
Hmm, I'm thinking that the image would likely be viewed as a derived work rather than an original work and still subject to Canon's copyright. I also think that the image is probably more ridicule than parody and not protected speech.
I expect that Canon lawyers will likely be quite sensitive about copyright issues and lean on you until it feels more expensive than funny to continue to publish the image.
jeff
I expect that Canon lawyers will likely be quite sensitive about copyright issues and lean on you until it feels more expensive than funny to continue to publish the image.
What a sad state of affairs - doesn't anyone at Canon have a sense of fun?
Edited by Peter Kelly on Dec 04, 2007 at 07:51 PM GMT
nathanlake wrote:
Either you misunderstood their intent or they did not make themselves clear. You have used a likeness of a copyrighted logo to convey a negative image of the company. They are not concerned with your posting being confused with theirs, they are concerned that you are illegally using something very similar to a copyrighted logo to slander them. If you had any money, they would not have warned you, they just would have sued... and probably won.
There are other examples of censure that have proven to be very negative for the trademark.
Canon should have let it go [btw are you sure it is an official Canon mail you received?].
As censoring the image will probably push many people to copy the blurred image on their website, in my opinion.
There are a couple of folks that aren't getting it. The first post was a obviously joke, and so is the second one. The world ends on December 21, 2012 so it is time to lighten up a bit and enjoy a good laugh. Thanks Markuson!