fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2007 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2007My MK3 servo ramp

  
 
gbee
Offline

p.1 #1My MK3 servo ramp
Did a fashion show [last night Sat 5Oct] a charity event but run with professional models and good lighting.

I took some 500 shots to select about a dozen from, from that end the assignment was successful.

I post a link to my PBase first sequence, nearly all the rest was very similar. The AF just seems to leave for no reason and these girls are not running athletes, I use M so all the camera had to do was track.

Centre point, circle expansion ON.

http://www.pbase.com/ger_bee/a1_servo

I also think these images are soft, too soft or about normal?
Oct 06, 2007 at 04:08 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.1 #2My MK3 servo ramp
Gbee,

They are far too soft. The MKIII is razor sharp in good lighting using RAW without any sharpening - not to say that I don't apply light capture sharpening and higher output sharpening to combat the ink spreading on the page.

How steady are you at hand holding?-Could 1/250th coupled with any camere/lens movement have caused any problems - the more the Af system has to detect different contrast between frames, either subject or operator movement, the greater the AF calculations have to be. I would seriously check to see that your camera does not have a rear/front focus error in one shot on a static subject using only the central Af sensor - camera parallel to target. Any slight front/rear AF error will manifest itself during predictive tracking.

See attached AI servo test image of someone running at camera taken with a MKIII 400mm F2.8 at F2.8 1/4000 sec - RAW ACR V4.1 No sharpening, contrast set to 50, clean low light is the key to the sharpness - although the angle of the light is too head-on for my liking, however it was only an AF test. Even on this image the eyes are not quite pin sharp but with light capture sharpening the image displays good sharpness for a moving target.

Both of my MKIII's have been accurate in one shot AF and AI servo on a static target (much better than MKII's) however overall consistency of my MKIII's AI servo isn't very good (worse than MKII's on less taxing subject to distances but superior closer to camera). My first camera went back for testing and was returned without improvement, my repacement MKIII appears no better.

Whilst the MKIII is capable of capturing pin-sharp images under testing circumstances both of my MKIII's go into a trance during sequence shooting and seriously loose the plot for 3-5 frames (always earlier in sequneces),for no apparent reason - even with pin-point AF accuracy between frames. I have shot several running sequences, using the central AF sensor (no expansion). persons wearing a patterned shirt (no excuse for missing small shirt logo) and the success rate has been poor. Both of my MKIII's routinely miss many full length shots, in a sequence, and yet nail more testing ones when the subject is about to collide with me.

The MKIII's AI servo has been the most inconsistent system that I have used in 15 years of being a professional photographer - I am confident that Canon will iron out the problems. One thing is for sure with the MKIII you have to be far more accurate aiming the AF between consecutive frames as it will punish you if you are sloppy. Understanding how an AF sytem has been designed to work is imperative and the user has to have good discipline and experience to stand any chance of getting the best out of the MKIII, especially with 300mm and 400mm F2.8 lenses at full aperture.

Canon have been testing the AI servo system on formula 1 cars and the advice for moving subjects, such as cars, where the target area is large and there is less likelihood of loosing focus, is to use a +2 setting as the AF system does carry out more calculations than slower settings. I appreciate that some users are already aware of this.

Please respect my wishes and do not download the images or distribute them. Although only test snaps the copyright of the images is reserved.




Edited by Nick G Walker on Oct 06, 2007 at 06:27 PM GMT




Oct 06, 2007 at 06:01 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.1 #3My MK3 servo ramp
Subject is running fast towards camera and this is not a posed portrait 100% crop - RAW - No sharpening - off centre Af sensor - no AF expansion



Edited by Nick G Walker on Oct 06, 2007 at 08:55 PM GMT

Edited by Nick G Walker on Apr 09, 2008 at 10:19 PM GMT




Oct 06, 2007 at 06:03 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.1 #4My MK3 servo ramp
AF placement




Oct 06, 2007 at 06:04 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.1 #5My MK3 servo ramp
light capture sharpening reduced to 60%


Edited by Nick G Walker on Oct 06, 2007 at 08:56 PM GMT




Oct 06, 2007 at 06:19 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.1 #6My MK3 servo ramp
Another example AF sensor on face - once again no Af expansion




Oct 06, 2007 at 06:45 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.1 #7My MK3 servo ramp
100% crop with light> Photokit sharpener> mid res> narrow




Oct 06, 2007 at 06:46 AM
Alan321
Offline
Details
p.1 #8My MK3 servo ramp
gbee, I don't know what you focused on but those shots are soft. I would be unhappy with them. However, given the way models move you might just need a faster shutter speed - I can't tell from those shots that the focus is in front or behind, it's just soft.

Models are the only people I know who place their right foot to their left and their left foot to their right. That plus the way they bob up and down contributes to a greater degree of movement than you get from normal people, so a faster shutter speed is desirable.

Maybe you should have used ISO 1600 or 3200 and cleaned up the images later on. At least you'd have more than 12 that are worth keeping.

- Alan
Oct 06, 2007 at 08:30 AM
gbee
Offline
Details
p.1 #9My MK3 servo ramp
I have more than 12 images worth selecting from, I only needed 12 for two pages.

The shutter speed can be tricky right enough, I'm often at 1/500 @ ƒ2.8 too slow a shutter is a suspicion.

Today though, I have choir groups, I might post later, one with the MK3 and one with the MKIIn ~ the N is better, much sharper.

Alan321 wrote:
Maybe you should have used ISO 1600 or 3200 and cleaned up the images later on. At least you'd have more than 12 that are worth keeping.

- Alan



Edited by gbee on Oct 06, 2007 at 04:02 PM GMT
Oct 06, 2007 at 09:48 AM
gbee
Offline
Details
p.1 #10My MK3 servo ramp
Thanks, I'm suspecting the expansion of the centre point is more off. On advise from another thread I've only activated it yesterday, I think I'll disengage it again. I've static choir groups on the MK3 and the MKIIn and the N is much sharper ~ same lens an all.

Thanks for the reply, I've some sharp shots that I'm happy with but nothing as sharp as yours.

Nick G Walker wrote:
Gbee, They are far too soft.

Oct 06, 2007 at 09:52 AM
Alan321
Offline
Details
p.1 #11My MK3 servo ramp
gbee, the photos I looked at did not seem to have anything in sharp focus, in which case AF expansion is not the problem. Expansion affects selectivity but not actual sharpness.
Oct 06, 2007 at 10:13 AM
bcaslis
Offline
Details
p.1 #12My MK3 servo ramp
They look misfocused to me. Some are focused (pretty sharply) at the bottom of the image. Some are focused on the woman's left hand so the body is way soft. I would use a top AF point with expansion off. They should at least in theory provide much better results. In the limited testing I've done it seems like on a cluttered background like this you need to restrict AI Servo as much as possible. Shooting a plane on the sky I can even use the auto AF. But on a background like I need to restrict it to a single point otherwise it seems to give priorty to the very closest point. That seems to be what is happening on these images.
Oct 06, 2007 at 11:19 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.1 #13My MK3 servo ramp
Gbee,

The second full length image is front focused by a long way - see the floor detail. Do you have another Canon camera body, any model, that you are happy with, to test the MKIII against? Also do you have a lens with a tripod mount on the lens for example 70-200mm F2.8 or super telephoto lens?

If so tripod mount the lens with your known good camera body and AF, one shot, single AF (no Af expansion), on parallel target (planty of detail across the frame - magazine text will do), Very carefully remove the camera. Slide the AF lens selector (on the lens barrel) to manual.

Very carefully attach the MKIII, using the AF back button, central AF sensor (no AF expansion), in one shot, does the MKIII's green Af confirmation light glow - if your first camera body is accurate it should do? If the AF confirmation light does not come on, or flickers, then there is a good chance that the MKIII is out of calibration. Does the image look as sharp as the first camera. Now turn the lens AF selector back to AF and activate the MKIII's AF system, does the AF shift and does the image snap into focus.

Repeat the test but this this time look at the lens barrel focus scale to see which direction the Af moves towards to see if it is front or rear focusing. If I suspect an AF problem I use this test and it has always born out my findings when the technicians adjust the camera and report back. It also helps them pin point the error if you can say with confidence that your camera is front or rear focusing.
Oct 06, 2007 at 12:47 PM
Chris Dees
Offline
Details
p.1 #14My MK3 servo ramp
You can use live view as well, but not too long for the heat of the sensor.
Use AF for focussing on a paper or something like that. Use live view and 10 times magnifying for looking if focus is on. If not you can calibrate your lens depending on front or backfocus and try again.
Oct 06, 2007 at 01:08 PM
gbee
Offline
Details
p.1 #15My MK3 servo ramp
Gentlemen, thank you very much for your input, I'll be putting all tips to good use.

Right now though, I’m suspicious of the expansion of the centre spot, earlier today I had barbershop groups and my MKIIn did a better job. Since then even, I removed the expansion of the centre spot and had a few groups tonight, all on the MK3 and they are more satisfactory, leading me to believe the expansion may be less accurate.

My own tests, not as detailed as described here, suggested my lenses were focussing correctly, they had been to calibration ~ may need it again ~ and while I don’t have direct comparisons in this example, my MKIIn doesn’t cause me any concern.


Oct 06, 2007 at 04:55 PM
nathanlake
Offline
Details
p.1 #16My MK3 servo ramp
Why did noone ask what lens was being used?
Oct 06, 2007 at 05:12 PM
Jeff Winters
Offline
Details
p.1 #17My MK3 servo ramp
I just got to put my new Mark III 535XXX through a good test. I used a 300 2.8 with a 2x extender. It caught birds in flight better than my IIn did and images were sharp even with considerable cropping. I did follow the advice of Les Zugerski and set sensitivity to fast, which differs from how I set my mark IIn. I've also tested the camera with my daughter running towards me. I haven't tested in extreme heat, but as of now I'm completely satisfied.
Jeff
Oct 06, 2007 at 05:33 PM
bcaslis
Offline
Details
p.1 #18My MK3 servo ramp
gbee wrote:
Gentlemen, thank you very much for your input, I'll be putting all tips to good use.

Right now though, I’m suspicious of the expansion of the centre spot, earlier today I had barbershop groups and my MKIIn did a better job. Since then even, I removed the expansion of the centre spot and had a few groups tonight, all on the MK3 and they are more satisfactory, leading me to believe the expansion may be less accurate.

My own tests, not as detailed as described here, suggested my lenses were focussing correctly, they had been to calibration ~ may need it
...Show more →

To clarify, from what I've seen it's not that the expansion is less accurate. It's that it seems to be very heavily weighted towards finding the closest point to the camera rather than the main AF point. That seems somewhat like what it did in the pictures you posted.
Oct 06, 2007 at 07:39 PM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.1 #19My MK3 servo ramp
Not sure if this is stating the obvious, but have you verified that your 70-200 is not mis-focusing in general? And that a lens focus correction setting has not been set inadvertently on the Mark III?

It is not all that uncommon for new AF lenses to mis-focus from the factory and need calibration.
Oct 06, 2007 at 08:00 PM
Alistair Watson
Offline
Details
p.1 #20My MK3 servo ramp
They look soft to me. I am going to Canon Elstree tomorrow morning, anyone want a lift?
Oct 07, 2007 at 04:25 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister