fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2007 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2007Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?

  
 
Valerie S
Offline

p.1 #1Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
I thought that cross point AF sensors were high precision cross point sensors, but apparently there is a difference between the two. Can anyone describe what the difference is?


Thanks
Aug 19, 2007 at 10:27 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
I think Canon the high-precision (single center) AF sensor is equally sensitive in both the vertical and horizontal planes, whereas previously it was not (or maybe it's now to f/2.8, when before it was less?). Something like that...
Aug 19, 2007 at 10:30 AM
Valerie S
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Jeff wrote:
I think Canon the high-precision (single center) AF sensor is equally sensitive in both the vertical and horizontal planes, whereas previously it was not (or maybe it's now to f/2.8, when before it was less?). Something like that...


To me, "cross point" implies vertical and horizontal. I'm wondering what the "real world" difference is between the two. Is it that the high precision is good to f5.6 lenses whereas the others are only good for f2.8 (or faster) lenses?
Aug 19, 2007 at 10:40 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Coming from a MkIII user, you don't really want a 'real-world' report on what I think about this new implementation of AF technology, do you?
Aug 19, 2007 at 10:51 AM
Alan321
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
In the good old days of the 45-point AF system introduced with the EOS 3, and in the subsequent 1D-whatevers, a cross type AF sensor was the only high precision AF sensor. That applied in the likes of the 20D too, but then things started to change I think with the 5D and Canon introduced the concept of standard-precision cross-type AF sensors (which I would have expected had to offer more precision than linear sensors) and high-precision cross-type sensors.

Cross-type can detect focus patterns in both "horizontal" and "vertical" directions whereas linear sensors can do it only in one direction or the other.

The high-precision sensors can detect to an accuracy three times more precise (middle third of DOF at max aperture) than the standard-precision sensors, but I believe that extra precision applies in one direction only. Technically it works in the middle third of depth of focus but as near as I can tell it corresponds to (but is not equal to) the middle third of depth of field. Canon's explanation in their Lens Work book is a bit ambiguous.

The older (pre 1D3) 1-series cross-type sensors reverted to linear mode when the aperture was too dark, whereas the new ones (5D, 1D3) retain cross-type functionality but with standard precision.

The extra precision comes from a combination of additional pixels per AF sensor and longer AF sensors that can detect more subtle contrast patterns and lock onto them more precisely.

Because of the way it is implemented, high precision is usually limited to maximum apertures of f/2.8 or brighter or, in the 1-series bodies only, as dark as f/4 for the central sensor only.

- Alan
Aug 19, 2007 at 11:16 AM
Valerie S
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Thanks Alan.
Aug 19, 2007 at 11:28 AM
Gochugogi
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
The 1989 EOS 1 was the first EOS with a cross AF sensor, i.e., sensitivity to both vertical and horizontal axis. However it required a F2.8 or faster optic to retain both vertical and horizontal sensitivity. With slower lenses it degraded to single axis sensitivity. The 1991 EOS 10S introduced multiple sensors (3) and a standard-precision cross-type AF sensor with both vertical and horizontal sensitivity to F5.6.

The next real breakthrough was the 1998 EOS 3 with the 45-sensor AF array. It sported a cluster of 7 high-precision sensors cross sensors in the center area, 6 of which required F2.8 for both vertical and horizontal sensitivity and high-precision status. With slow lenses they degraded to single axis sensitivity. However the center cross retained both vertical and horizontal sensitivity with F4 albeit at normal precision as I recall. Slower than F4 it degraded to single axis sensitivity only but was able to focus down to F8. This was the basic system used in the 1V and 1D series until the advent of the 1D MKIII.
Aug 19, 2007 at 01:24 PM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.1 #8Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Canon AF exemplifies high precision with low accuracy.

EB
Aug 19, 2007 at 01:41 PM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
EB-1 wrote:
Canon AF exemplifies high precision with low accuracy.

EB



That is precisely what I was thinking when reading the above...

At the moment, this is all so much technological jaw-flapping until my 1D MkIII works as advertised. Once it works, I'll buy into the techno-hype...
Aug 19, 2007 at 01:49 PM
Gochugogi
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Canon AF exemplifies high precision with low accuracy.

I guess it all depends on your shooting style. Even Canon's lowend bodies rarely miss for me, albeit you must be fairly proactive to make the most of the system. On the other hand, my MF was never very good unless done in slow mo.
Aug 19, 2007 at 03:56 PM
RDKirk
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Alan is pretty close to correct. On the DRebels, the 20D/30D, and the 5D, the rectangular focusing marks each represent a single-axis pixel array (parallel to the long dimension of the rectangle). The arrays are sensitive to subject contrast details running perpendicular to the arrays--and are totally blind to contrast details running parallel to the arrays.

These arrays are "normal precision," which means the camera calculates the distance the lens must move to within the Depth of Focus (not depth of field) for the maximum aperture of the lens.

There are two arrays for each point. The arrays are on the same line and separated by a small distance ("base length"), viewing the subject with a small parallax difference.

The depth of focus is the range at the sensor within which a point produces an out of focus blur of less than the circle of confusion (0.035mm for Canon). Depth of focus varies only by aperture, not by focal length or focused distance. An f2.8 200mm lens at 10 feet has exactly the same depth of focus as an f2.8 20mm lens at 50 feet.

A cross-type sensor has pixel arrays running both vertically and horizontally, and the camera computes distance using data from both. The cross-type sensor is also "normal precision."

"High precision" focusing involves using a more complex focusing algorithm (Read: Takes more time to calculate). The camera switches to high precision mode when you mount a lens that reports its maximum aperture as f2.8 or greater. At high precision mode, the camera calculates the correct movement of the lens to within 1/3 of the depth of focus.

In addition to switching to a more complex algorithm, the camera also turns on additional pixel arrays for the focus points that are "high precision" focus points. These pixel arrays have, moreover, a longer "base length" for greater parallax. In the DRebels, 20D/30D, and 5D, the additional pixels are all aligned horizontally, meaning that the precision increase is for subject linear details running vertically.

Computing data from two sets of arrays with a more complex algorithm takes a bit more horsepower--or a bit more time. In addition, computing data at lower light levels also requires more horsepower--or more time. I suspect that's why Canon limits the high precision mode to the faster lenses...and in the same way, the faster lenses need more precision at maximum aperture.

The DRebels, 20D/30D, and 5D each have a single computer computing both metering and focusing. It could be that focusing would be noticeably sluggish at most light levels if they allowed autofocusing and high precision autofocusing with slower lenses.

The 1D-series cameras have a dedicated computer for focusing, which is why they can afford to push high precision with slower lenses (and normal precision with even slower lenses).

There used to be a map diagram of the pixel arrays of the 20D on the Canon-Japan site. It's probably still there.
Aug 19, 2007 at 05:38 PM
Valerie S
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
As I'm waiting on a exchange for my Mk III, I started wondering if the 40D specs would make it out to be as fast and accurate in low light AF situations. Your saying that the 1D series have a separate computer to handle the slower algorithm sop that in effect, it should be as fast or faster, correct?

My last Mk III was great except in it's low light AF performance in which my 30D was vastly superior, which is why I sent it back. I see that the 40D spewcs are -.5 to 18 EV whereas the Mk III is -1 to 18 EV.
Aug 19, 2007 at 06:04 PM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
RDKirk wrote:
Alan is pretty close to correct. On the DRebels, the 20D/30D, and the 5D, the rectangular focusing marks each represent a single-axis pixel array (parallel to the long dimension of the rectangle). The arrays are sensitive to subject contrast details running perpendicular to the arrays--and are totally blind to contrast details running parallel to the arrays.


I may be a little off here, but I believe that with a single-axis pixel array focus point, perpendicular detail contrast presents the most accurate target, but the sensor will also work with contrasty detail appearing at an angle. It's only when that angle approaches parallel that the single-axis focus point has difficulty.

Would that be a correct assessment in your opinion?
Aug 19, 2007 at 06:29 PM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
OSev wrote:
My last Mk III was great except in it's low light AF performance in which my 30D was vastly superior, which is why I sent it back. I see that the 40D spewcs are -.5 to 18 EV whereas the Mk III is -1 to 18 EV.


Oddly, my 5D, which has the same sensitivity specs as the 30D, was even better in low-light AF performance than my 30D was. Both exceed the low-light AF performance of the 1D II that I used to have. Then again, neither could handle high-speed operations in more reasonable light like the 1D2 could!
Aug 19, 2007 at 06:32 PM
Valerie S
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Tom_W wrote:
Oddly, my 5D, which has the same sensitivity specs as the 30D, was even better in low-light AF performance than my 30D was. Both exceed the low-light AF performance of the 1D II that I used to have. Then again, neither could handle high-speed operations in more reasonable light like the 1D2 could!


I shoot a lot of music in clubs and ISO 3200 and high performance low light AF is my reason for buying a MK III. I've heard from numerous people that the Mk II was worse in these conditions than a 5D.
Aug 19, 2007 at 07:19 PM
apdieb
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Tom_W wrote:
Oddly, my 5D, which has the same sensitivity specs as the 30D, was even better in low-light AF performance than my 30D was. Both exceed the low-light AF performance of the 1D II that I used to have. Then again, neither could handle high-speed operations in more reasonable light like the 1D2 could!


EXACTLY my findings. I believe the 5D AF sensors are a bit larger and thus able to detect contrast easier (at least that is what I read from Chuck Westfall somewhere)..


Edited by apdieb on Aug 20, 2007 at 01:53 AM GMT
Aug 20, 2007 at 01:52 AM
apdieb
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
OSev wrote:
I shoot a lot of music in clubs and ISO 3200 and high performance low light AF is my reason for buying a MK III. I've heard from numerous people that the Mk II was worse in these conditions than a 5D.


Without a doubt. Been there, done that.
Aug 20, 2007 at 01:52 AM
simonit
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
The other difference Canon are claiming on the 40d is 'Additionally the center point is now twice as sensitive as any other point with lenses of F2.8 or faster and has cross-type sensors set at forty-five degrees.'

Have no idea what difference it makes having them in the diagonal plane and what it means in the real world!!
Aug 20, 2007 at 02:41 AM
LotsToLearn
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Will this greater sensitivity also allow for AF at f/8 with the center point like on 1 series bodies (eg. using a 2x TC on an f/4)?

I know IQ is degraded, just wondering if it's possible.

Aug 20, 2007 at 09:21 AM
Alan321
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Cross point AF vs. High Precision x point AF?
Jeff wrote:
EB-1 wroteCanon AF exemplifies high precision with low accuracy.

EB
That is precisely what I was thinking when reading the above...

At the moment, this is all so much technological jaw-flapping until my 1D MkIII works as advertised. Once it works, I'll buy into the techno-hype...


Wow, that sure was a raw nerve he touched there

With that unresolved AF problem in mind you'd be nuts to rush out for a 1Ds3. I'll put up with my little 1Ds2 for a while. Jeff, I really feel for you - it's usually me who gets all the lemons. Even my 1D2 was a dud until it was serviced by Canon.

- Alan
Aug 20, 2007 at 10:05 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister