You know, it really is strange but having the original box and warranty card definitely increases the sale value both here and on eBay. I agree that it's ridiculous, and I don't pay extra for such things, but both photographic gear and other items unrelated to photography have always sold better when I've had the original box.
One time (several years ago) I auctioned a Sony laserdisc player on eBay. For the first four days I watched as nobody bid on my auction. (It was a seven day auction.) On the fourth day I got a message from somebody asking if I still had the original box, and if so, what condition was the box in? I was a bit surprised by somebody inquiring about the condition of the box. Anyway I went looking for the box and found it in my attic. When I updated the listing on the fifth day to indicate I would pack it in the excellent-condition original box, suddenly it started attracting bids. I would have been happy to get $110 plus shipping for it. In the last hour of the auction a bidding war erupted between two people, who drove the price up well past $200. Then in the last 10 seconds of the auction two bid snipers swooped in and drove the price up to $330 plus shipping. I was astonished.
The winning bidder was the guy who had inquired about the box. He told me he never would have gone above $200 if I didn't have the box. He said it was a sign of somebody who took care of their stuff that I still had the box in excellent condition.
So crazy or not, it's a good idea to hang onto the original boxes.