fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2006 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2006Interesting interview

  
 
Pixel Perfect
Offline

p.1 #1Interesting interview
Someone on dpreview translated interview with Engineer from 400D team. One point is that he implies Canon is not going to offer inbody IS, but instead will expand it's in lens IS to many more lenses. He calims in body is not good as you don't see stabilization through the viewfinder.

Here is link:

http://photojpn.org/bbs/viewtopic.php?t=772

The author has requested do not copy and paste his article.
Sep 21, 2006 at 11:28 PM
Uusilehto
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Interesting interview
Thanks for posting that.
Answered a few interesting questions. Mainly the part about the dust reduction software backwards compatibility isssue.
Sep 22, 2006 at 12:05 AM
pookipichu
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Interesting interview
Hmmm even though you don't see stabilization through the viewfinder, I find in body stabilization just makes more sense in the majority of cases. There are no wide angle primes with IS, there are no normal primes with IS, there are no mid-teles with IS.

Especially since Canon charges an extra $500-$900 to put IS in a lens, it makes more sense for the consumer and professional photographer to have the OPTION of in body IS. In body anti-shake can be turned off, but it obviously can't be turned on if it's not there. Anti-shake in body is relatively cost effective to implement as demonstrated by Minolta, Sony and Pentax. It's a lame excuse and insult to intelligence for them to play the "in lens is better" card. Especially now with new AS technologies that are more effective than before. If Pentax can do AS and dust removal in a weather sealed body for $900, so can Canon. Enough said.
Sep 22, 2006 at 12:15 AM
EOS20
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Interesting interview
Intresting artical.


I think the main reason why Canon won't add in body IS is not just becuse they belive that lens IS is better, But becuse they know that they can charge us more to buy IS lenses! Not really much point in adding more IS lenses to the lineup if they are going to charge us a huge markup prices over the non-IS equivalent. What Canon needs to do is make IS lenses more affordable!

I would like in body IS as a option, As Lasse mentioned, You could always turn it off when using IS lenses, and you can use the in body IS when shooting with primes and mid range zooms that dont/wont have IS.

Sep 22, 2006 at 12:35 AM
Marco
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Interesting interview
EOS20 wrote:
I think the main reason why Canon won't add in body IS is not just becuse they belive that lens IS is better, But becuse they know that they can charge us more to buy IS lenses!


Completely agreed.
Moreover adding IS in lenses implies a new optical design and generally a lower optical performance due to the added glass.
Sep 22, 2006 at 02:10 AM
limitdown
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Interesting interview
Let's assume that Lens IS is better than Body IS.
I would still want inbody IS (even just 1-2 extra stops of holdability) versus no stabilization at all. That way, I could have some extra hand holdability on my 50 1.4. And If I want better IS then I'll just pop on my 17-85 IS. And when I save up enough for an 85 1.2 MK2, then it would turn into an 85 1.2L MK2 IS.

But inbody IS will not make money for canon. Look at the price difference btwn a 70-200 2.8 vs the IS version (45% higher ($500) at B&H). Whereas inbody IS in the Sony camera probably didn't even cost much. The inbody IS completely cannibalized the potential sales from any IS lenses in the future. If I owned a Sony cam, there is no way I would pay $500 more for an optical IS lens (even if it offered 3 extra stops of holdability) if I already had inbody IS, which gives 2 extra stops of holdability.

Canon's decision is purely driven by the almighty dollar (or yen, or renminbi...)
Sep 22, 2006 at 02:11 AM
Gochugogi
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Interesting interview
Canon's decision is purely driven by the almighty dollar (or yen, or renminbi...)

The choice of lens vs body based IS isn't that simple or clear cut. Canon originally released lens based IS in the 1995 for film bodies and has continued that legacy and full compatibility into the digital era. It would be nearly impossible to apply IS to a roll of film, hence lens based IS. They were once prasied for said innovation. Now they are cursed and accused of greed and excess profit.

One nice thing about lens based IS is it backwards compatible with all EOS bodies. That's not possible with sensor based IS. And I suspect the larger the sensor, the more difficult it becomes to effect sensor based IS.
Sep 22, 2006 at 02:48 AM
limitdown
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Interesting interview
Gochugogi wrote:
Earlier quoteCanon's decision is purely driven by the almighty dollar (or yen, or renminbi...)
The choice of lens vs body based IS isn't that simple or clear cut. Canon originally released lens based IS in the 1995 for film bodies and has continued that legacy and full compatibility into the digital era. It would be nearly impossible to apply IS to a roll of film, hence lens based IS. They were once prasied for said innovation. Now they are cursed and accused of greed and excess profit.

One nice thing about lens based IS is it backwards compatible with all EOS bodies. That's not possible with sensor based IS. And I suspect the larger the
...Show more →

Don't get me wrong, I love lens IS and that's why I bought the 17-85 IS (which btw, is not backward compatible with film since it's EF-S). And I would not call for Canon do away with lens IS. In-body IS would complement NOT replace. So they should continue to make, for example, 70-200 2.8 IS and non-IS and let us choose.

If 2nd tier manufacturers can do in-body IS, then Canon should be able to do that as well (at least for APS-size sensors, for now....).

I wish Canon would make BOTH lens and in-body IS so that I can choose which one I want to use and when. But I suspect they have not adopted in-body IS for economic reasons.

Yes, I praise Canon for their lens IS innovation so I do NOT curse them for that. But I do curse them for not adopting in-body IS....

...just my 2 communal renminbi...
Sep 22, 2006 at 03:21 AM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Interesting interview
I will say when it comes to supertelephotos I'll always want lens based IS. I see a role for both systems. In body is a fantastic idea that enables a whole slew of older lenses and lenses it's juts impractical to put an IS system in to deliver good handheld results in low light.

I also disagree that Canon's price gouging on IS. I'm the first to say the prices of the newly released IS lenses is high, but this has always been the case initially and these prices will come down.
Sep 22, 2006 at 03:34 AM
EOS20
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Interesting interview
I think it would only be possible to have in body IS on a APS-C sized sensor anyway, Right?

IS lenses will still have there place on APS-H and Full framed cameras so Canon won't loose all there IS lens sales since there will be alot of users who will be making the move into full frame over the next few years as the price of FF cameras becomes even more affordable.

Having IS in APS-C cameras IMO would be a good option for Canon as your average consumer who likes all the mods and cons will still look towards Canon rather then Sony, Pentax with there in-built IS. Also Those who want to continue shooting with APS-C cameras will be able to have IS on all there lenses not just on the ones that Canon offers with IS. Sports/wildlife photographers would benifit from having a APS-C camera for the extra reach from the crop sensors for example. Also alot of pepole would be able to buy one of these APS-C IS bodies as a backup to there fullframed body.

A Pro grade APS-C body with in built IS would be nice to see!
Sep 22, 2006 at 03:34 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Interesting interview
limitdown wrote:
[...] And I would not call for Canon do away with lens IS. In-body IS would complement NOT replace. So they should continue to make, for example, 70-200 2.8 IS and non-IS and let us choose.

[...]


And what exactly, do you think, would happen to all those IS lenses if Canon does introduce in-body IS? Sales of IS lenses will plummit and result in price increases or possibly even discontinuation of those models.

I don't think a complemetary system can be viable, it's one or the other. Keeping both will only increase the price contrast and drive the majority of the consumers to the more affordable side. That will be body-based, since that's a one-time investment instead of a per-lens investment.
Sep 22, 2006 at 04:00 AM
DaveMart
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
limitdown wrote[...] And I would not call for Canon do away with lens IS. In-body IS would complement NOT replace. So they should continue to make, for example, 70-200 2.8 IS and non-IS and let us choose.

[...]
And what exactly, do you think, would happen to all those IS lenses if Canon does introduce in-body IS? Sales of IS lenses will plummit and result in price increases or possibly even discontinuation of those models.

I don't think a complemetary system can be viable, it's one or the other. Keeping both will only increase the price contrast and drive the majority of the consumers to the more affordable side. That will be body-based, since that's a one-time investment instead of a per-lens investment.

I don't think they would conflict to that extent.
In-body IS would take over for focal lengths under 200mm for users of 1.6 crop.
IOW, it would hit the cheaper IS galss, but not the dearer.
IS in body for 1.6 but not for 1.3 and FF would seem a reasonable compromise.
So there would still be a market for even IS glass at shorter focal lengths for the users of 1.3 and FF.
The market for longer stabilised galss should not be much affected.
It's difficult to do in-body IS for FF anyway.
Regards,
DaveMart
Sep 22, 2006 at 04:37 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Interesting interview
DaveMart wrote:
[...]

The market for longer stabilised galss should not be much affected.
It's difficult to do in-body IS for FF anyway.


Is it?

One degree of barrel/lens movement translates to the same amount of shift at the sensor plane (given a fixed focal length of course) regardless of sensor size, because the mount/sensor distance is the same for FF, APS-H and APS-C. A FF sensor does NOT need to shift more.

In-body FF IS would need more powerful actuators, about 2.5 times as powerful, because a FF sensor will weigh about 2.5 times as much as a APS-C sensor.

(I simplify here: sensor weight increases with (1.6)² = 2.56 assuming equal thickness, and the support frame will have longer, but not thicker, sides so it will become 1.6x heavier. The total increase should be under 2.5x)

But other than up-scaling of powerdraw and volume taken up by the actuators, there is no difference. The gyro-sensors will not be any different, nor the electronics that drive the actuators.
Sep 22, 2006 at 05:00 AM
DaveMart
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
DaveMart wrote[...]

The market for longer stabilised galss should not be much affected.
It's difficult to do in-body IS for FF anyway.
Is it?

One degree of barrel/lens movement translates to the same amount of shift at the sensor plane (given a fixed focal length of course) regardless of sensor size, because the mount/sensor distance is the same for FF, APS-H and APS-C. A FF sensor does NOT need to shift more.

In-body FF IS would need more powerful actuators, about 2.5 times as powerful, because a FF sensor will weigh about 2.5 times as much as a APS-C sensor.

(I simplify here: sensor weight increases with (1.6)² = 2.56 assuming equal thickness, and the support frame will have longer, but
...Show more →
Perhaps I should have said that some allege that it would be more difficult to do in-body IS at FF - I am certainly not qualified to assess the merits or otherwise of this claim.
However, it would provide the perfect excuse for Canon not to introduce it at FF, since they are not keen on it anyway, if they are forced by the market to introduce it for 1.6.
Presumably the more affluent FF market would be more prepared to pay a premium for being able to have the viewfinder image stabilised, and more likely to buy the longer glass where the benefits of in-body IS has attracted more questions anyway.
The real pressure is on at entry level, and if Canon do not move at this level many may be attracted to the Pentax and Sony alternatives.
Regards,
DaveMart
Sep 22, 2006 at 05:21 AM
jabog6
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Interesting interview
limitdown wrote:
But inbody IS will not make money for canon. Look at the price difference btwn a 70-200 2.8 vs the IS version (45% higher ($500) at B&H). Whereas inbody IS in the Sony camera probably didn't even cost much. The inbody IS completely cannibalized the potential sales from any IS lenses in the future. If I owned a Sony cam, there is no way I would pay $500 more for an optical IS lens (even if it offered 3 extra stops of holdability) if I already had inbody IS, which gives 2 extra stops of holdability.

Canon's decision is purely driven
...Show more →

I agree with everything limitdown wrote. However, maybe lens-IS is more profitable for Canon right now, but it the long run it might cost them. I, for one, can't afford to get the IS version of every lens, and would certainly appreciate having body-IS for low-light shots of non-moving objects. If I was thinking of replacing my 20D (which I am not... yet), I would take a long hard look at contenders from other brands, and body-IS would be one of the key features I'd be looking for.

So, Canon might profit in the short run, but in the long run, this strategy might lose them some customers.

My .02.
Sep 22, 2006 at 05:28 AM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.1 #16Interesting interview
Framing accuracy would suck with IS in body, no?

EB
Sep 22, 2006 at 05:30 AM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Interesting interview
Canon and Nikon know they have a major problem on their hands. Obviously, lens based IS was develop for film cameras where stabilizing the lens was the only option. Both manufcturers are tied to systems that are 10 years old which in the modern world translates into antiquity. One look at Sony's ads in NG tells the story. The one feature they stress is stablization.

Now pretend that you are first time DSLR purchaser. Salesman says that camera A has built-in IS but you can get the very same feature with camera B by spending $500 more each time you buy a lens. Both look about the same, both are 10MP and both come from major manufacturers. Anybody else see Canon's market share in this critical segment sliding downward? Lens IS is "better" claims Canon. Maybe it is, but statements like that won't do a thing to stem the bleeding.

Forget about the 2 v. 3 stops arguement. Canon's first gen IS only had 2 and for all we know the next Sonys may have 4. Also the arguement that you can't provide IS on FF is just silly. Of course they can. May not be easy but if you can do it on a 1.6x IS on a FF sensor is certainly doable.

Canon will add in-camera IS or lose significant market share. It is that simple. They may conclude that their profits from the segment are high enough to stay the course and be willing to take the share loss but that's a very dangerous marketing decision, especially if Nikon throws its hat into the ring. Nikon has had a lot of trouble recovering from making similar head in the sand decisions in the late 1980's and by adding in body IS and touting the ability to use 35 years worth of lenses they could recover a lot of the ground that they lost. (For you youngsters, Nikon once had a much more dominate market position than Canon has today and just blew it away by falling to innovate.)
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:06 AM
gfiksel
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
DaveMart wrote[...]

The market for longer stabilised galss should not be much affected.
It's difficult to do in-body IS for FF anyway.
Is it?

One degree of barrel/lens movement translates to the same amount of shift at the sensor plane (given a fixed focal length of course) regardless of sensor size, because the mount/sensor distance is the same for FF, APS-H and APS-C. A FF sensor does NOT need to shift more.

In-body FF IS would need more powerful actuators, about 2.5 times as powerful, because a FF sensor will weigh about 2.5 times as much as a APS-C sensor.

(I simplify here: sensor weight increases with (1.6)² = 2.56 assuming equal thickness, and the support frame will have longer, but
...Show more →

Even better, on a FF camera the same amount of shake in mm is 1.6 times smaller relative to the sensor size, so it will be less noticeable at the same output print size.
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:09 AM
timbop
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Interesting interview
jabog6 wrote:
limitdown wroteBut inbody IS will not make money for canon. Look at the price difference btwn a 70-200 2.8 vs the IS version (45% higher ($500) at B&H). Whereas inbody IS in the Sony camera probably didn't even cost much. The inbody IS completely cannibalized the potential sales from any IS lenses in the future. If I owned a Sony cam, there is no way I would pay $500 more for an optical IS lens (even if it offered 3 extra stops of holdability) if I already had inbody IS, which gives 2 extra stops of holdability.

Canon's decision is purely driven by the almighty dollar (or yen, or renminbi...)
I agree with everything limitdown wrote. However, maybe lens-IS is more profitable for Canon right now, but it the long run it might cost them. I, for one, can't afford to get the IS version of every lens, and would certainly appreciate having body-IS for low-light shots of non-moving objects. If I was thinking of replacing my 20D (which I am not... yet), I would take a long hard look at contenders from other brands, and body-IS would be one of the key features I'd be looking for.

So, Canon might profit in the short run, but in the long run,
...Show more →

yep, that is true. I think that they are in a bit of a catch-22 situation with IS as well as upping to 10MP. A better performing (lower noise higher DR) 8MP would have been more value IMHO than a 10MP with the same performance, but market pressures forced their hand. I personally think that especially for longer FL's, the in-lens design is probably superior - it can be optimized for FL. For canon it means more profits. BUT, the entry-level competition is putting IS in-body, which means that they may have to do something to stay competetive. I would guess that the "average" entry-level consumer will probably have 2 lenses, a wide-normal zoom and telezoom. The 70-300IS is great, and the price is not too far over the cheap 75-300's. They likely are not going to spend the cash for a 17-55IS, but the 17-85 is still available and a reasonably priced compared to 3rd party glass in that FL. My guess is that this is canon's thought, but it may not work out for them. For an XTi buyer, an IS kit will cost them $2000. A corresponding kit for the alpha with non-IS lenses will probably cost at least $1500 to $1700. If consumers think it through, then Canon is OK - especially when they realize how much better the 70-300 is compared to the consumer 75-300's.

But, a lot depends on the salesman - and in-body IS will probably be easier to sell.
At some point they may have to put IS in the body (which they already do in their P&S's), regardless of which is better technically or profit-wise. Canon's golden age in the entry to mid range may be ending - despite better technology/products.
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:16 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Interesting interview
gfiksel wrote:
[...]

Even better, on a FF camera the same amount of shake in mm is 1.6 times smaller relative to the sensor size, so it will be less noticeable at the same output print size.


Correct, but I chose to leave that out because higher pixel densities will demand higher IS accuracy. If the EOS 1Ds Mk III (whenever it is really here) does get the 22 mpixel FF sensor it will have about the same pixel density as the current 8 mpixel 20/30D.
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:20 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister