nsbca wrote:
slin100 wrote
It's quite simple, actually. To retain the same FoV at the same subject distance, use a focal length 1.6x shorter. To, additionally, retain the same DOF, open up 1 1/3 stops.
No complicated formulas. I'd wager it's no more complicated than the sunny 16 rule of thumb. Show me how it works.
I have a EOS-20D with a 1.6 crop sensor.
I.m shooting with a 85mm lens set at f/8
I am 100 ft from my subject.
I switch over to my 1Ds body.
What focal length and f/stop setting do I need to retain both Fov and DOF while still keeping the distance to subject a constant?
135mm at f/5?
1.6x->FF: Use a focal length 1.6x longer. Open up 1 1/3 stops. So, 135mm at f/13.
So what if I want to keep the 85mm on the camera and still retain the same DOF and FoV? I guess I have to move. But where?
f/5 at 160ft?
This is not unlike switching from a 135mm to a 85mm lens on a FF. You would have to move closer, to 100/1.6 or 62.5 ft to retain the FOV of the subject. Of course, perspective will change. Furthermore, you're now working a lot closer to the hyperfocal distance, so it going to be a little harder to retain the same DOF. In this case, you would use approximately f/9.5.
Now I want to swap the lens from my 20D to my 1D Mark II. Uhhoh! I think we get back to carrying that formula book around with us again.
All of this is a lot of calculation that should not be necessary to an intuitive photographer
As I have shown, it's not that bad with two formats. I'll note, however, that 1.6/1.3 is 1.23, so it's not unlike dealing with a 1D2 and a 1Ds. Frankly, I think the number of people who own all three formats is not that common. If DOF is that important, doing these calculations is necessary. Heck, some people still carry DOF charts with them. Nothing is stopping you from carrying an extra set. At some point it will become second nature.
As you remarked a couple of times, you cope by outputing smaller prints for smaller formats. That works for you, but I'll wager that the majority of people don't work this way. They print at a few popular sizes (4x6 and 8x10) regardless of the format of their camera.