fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2005 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2005Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8

  
 
OlafSiebert
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
... ok... I admit, but instead of a zoom I have to camera's on my neck...

may be a zoom could be handier...
May 23, 2005 at 07:36 AM
daemeon
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
This is the main reason, I kept my 80-200L. Like the prime, it dispatches the 70-200L IS and its fairly noticable.
May 23, 2005 at 08:21 AM
daemeon
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
rockit wrote:
OlafSiebert wroteIf I ever switch to a digitalsystem, primes it will be. Especially during weddings, you can easily step in and out...
teh weddings you photograph must be of an entirely different nature then the vast majority of weddings ive been to.

like i said earlier, i think the versitility of a zoom is far more important then the small (and greatly inconsequential) increase in sharpness you would get with a prime.

that zoom can be the difference between getting a shot and missing it. i will take getting the shot at a slightly softer level over missing the shot but knowing that it would have been sharper if i had gotten it, every time.

its like i learned with noise, ill
...Show more →

Been there, done that. Agree wholeheartedly.
May 23, 2005 at 08:22 AM
digitalspike
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
IraGraham wrote:
Interesting comments, do you really think you can bring in detail that was never recorded in the first place. Are you saying that for a soft lens that never recorded for example a letter in the original image, you are able to pull it out in PS. I am not so sure of that. If it is not recorded it is not there, PS or not. I will be curious what others think. Thanks for your thoughts.


I agree, and usign the USM alone introduces other problems as well. It might be okay if you are willing to settle and live with those imperfections but using a prime gives you 1 less step to perform.

Now take the time to look at 200-500 photos and try to detrmine which ones need to be USM in photoshop.

Prime please!
May 23, 2005 at 12:01 PM
yeaton
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
Does that house have a security system


Great tests! Thanks for posting the results! I'm just starting to fall in love with primes.

Matt
May 23, 2005 at 07:57 PM
kawter2
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
ok now I am a bit nervious... I had planned on picking up the 70-200 2.8IS this weekend,,,,


Primarily it will be used for weddings, sugestions?
May 23, 2005 at 09:47 PM
sleepwalker33
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
IF you can live with a terribly unsharp lens then the 70-200 lens is right for you. Otherwise your best bet is to shoot 50mm 1.8 the shots will always be sharper and in the end thats all that clients care about sharp pictures.
May 23, 2005 at 10:21 PM
papageno
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
It would be interesting-I think-to take this a step farther and repeat the tests with a tripod. Why? To see if any of these lenses cause problems because they are hand held. Does the lens balance poorly, to its detriment? Is weight a factor--and, if so, how so?
Also, should a flash be mounted, to better simulate field conditions?
May 23, 2005 at 10:37 PM
Tim Wild
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
sleepwalker33 wrote:
IF you can live with a terribly unsharp lens then the 70-200 lens is right for you.


That's a controversial statement, would you mind sharing why you're trashing this often-praised lens? I got the lens recently and haven't used it much yet, everything i've gotten from it seems nice and sharp.
May 23, 2005 at 11:22 PM
Steve Tinetti
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
If I were that Brinks sign shot with the zoom, I would demand my money back!! Tell you what; since we are showing "real world" tests here, how about we shoot these lenses side by side at a wedding? I have shot the 70-200 IS lens in "real world" weddings and portraits and I tell you what; it would be hard to beat for what it offers in versatility and quality. Thousands of happy owners of this lens cannot be wrong.

I will grant you this: If I set my zoom to 135, turned off the IS, hoped my shutter speed didn't drop below 1/125th, human zoomed myself to frame the shot, then did the same thing with the 135mm 2.0 and my bride held a Brinks sign in front of her face for each shot, I could probably point out a sharpness difference in a 200-300%+ crop. In fact, I might go a step further and grant the 135 "blows away" the zoom. Note to self, stay away from Brinks signs...

Anyone, and I mean anyone, who reads this thread and is now reluctant to buy the 70-200 2.8 IS lens is grossly missing the point, unless you shoot Brinks signs for a living.

Thanks to the original poster for showing us the difference in these lenses. Both are great lenses and both would be used in very different circumstances, IMO. As for using this "real world test" as a purchasing factor, however, don't let your research end here. As I said, thousands of happy owners can't be wrong.

Steve
May 23, 2005 at 11:40 PM
kawter2
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
sleepwalker33 wrote:
IF you can live with a terribly unsharp lens then the 70-200 lens is right for you. Otherwise your best bet is to shoot 50mm 1.8 the shots will always be sharper and in the end thats all that clients care about sharp pictures.



WT* you are comparing a 70-200 to a 50mm.... thanks for the insight!! Was that supposed to be a insult?

Mod break. This is a great way to start a flame war. Be careful here; no name calling please. If you want a reply, show respect and ask for one. If you're really pissed, send a pm.
Steve

Edited by Steve Tinetti on May 23, 2005 at 11:00 PM GMT (Reason: name calling)
May 23, 2005 at 11:43 PM
kawter2
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
Steve Tinetti wrote:
Anyone, and I mean anyone, who reads this thread and is now reluctant to buy the 70-200 2.8 IS lens is grossly missing the point, unless you shoot Brinks signs for a living.

Steve



That is what i thought, but this lens gets such a polariztion of opinions, either they love it or hate it.. usually i think it is people that cant $$ it maybee, but I dunno
May 23, 2005 at 11:45 PM
Steve Tinetti
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8

That is what i thought, but this lens gets such a polariztion of opinions, either they love it or hate it.. usually i think it is people that cant $$ it maybee, but I dunno


For all this lens offers, including great sharpness, it is our number one wedding lens. It is flat out terrific, IMO and I would recommend it any day.
Steve
May 24, 2005 at 12:04 AM
sols
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
sleepwalker33 wrote:
IF you can live with a terribly unsharp lens then the 70-200 lens is right for you. Otherwise your best bet is to shoot 50mm 1.8 the shots will always be sharper and in the end thats all that clients care about sharp pictures.


l think this poster is being heavily sarcastic.
May 24, 2005 at 12:10 AM
sols
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
Steve Tinetti wrote:
If I were that Brinks sign shot with the zoom, I would demand my money back!! Tell you what; since we are showing "real world" tests here, how about we shoot these lenses side by side at a wedding? I have shot the 70-200 IS lens in "real world" weddings and portraits and I tell you what; it would be hard to beat for what it offers in versatility and quality. Thousands of happy owners of this lens cannot be wrong.

I will grant you this: If I set my zoom to 135, turned off the IS, hoped my shutter
...Show more →

Well put, Steve. You've put it all into perspective. Thanks.
May 24, 2005 at 12:11 AM
OlafSiebert
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
I don't know if you know Annabel Williams, but she used to use a Canon 70-300 /4.5-5.6 lens. Well, let's be honest, that lens sucks! (As well as all other lenses in those range from any brand)...

... however, Annabel managed to be one of the famous WP's not due to sharpness, but due to caught emotions! That's what her clients wanted.

Although I do prefer primes (simply cause my camera system doesn't has useful zooms) I also do believe that a Canon or Nikon zoomlens / 2.8 is worth its money.

What I doubt, is - if you shoot with a 300d or f70 or whatever, this 200mm will be around 300mm, will you use this? Are you that far away from your B&G
May 24, 2005 at 12:22 AM
IraGraham
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
I am amazed at the peoples bad attitude in this forum. This is not a test to make the 70-200 2.8 IS look bad. It is only to demonstrate how it faired against a top notch prime the 135mm 2.0. I laugh at the sarcasm about a bride holding a Brinks sign, lighten up, it is not that serious. By the way I did have IS on when I took the shot with the 70-200mm 2.8 IS. I to love the 70-200 2.8 IS lens. I use it all of the time at weddings. I do however like to know the strengths and weaknesses of my lenses. I use it to take advantage of the best in each lens. I thought other photographers would care about this information instead of slamming it. I often pull out the 135 2.0 when doing 3/4 length bridal shots at the alter. Or other times when not using a zoom would not hurt my chances of getting the shot. I also use my 50 1.8 when doing some group shots instead of using a zoom. There are other times when zooms rule. I am a firm believer that a great photographer can do a great job with a $150 Pentax K1000, it is not about the equipment, it is about what you capture more then anything else. I am sorry to offend those who love their 70-200 2.8 IS, remember.......................I love mine also!!!!!
May 24, 2005 at 06:11 AM
rockit
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
were these done handheld or on a tripod?
May 24, 2005 at 06:38 AM
IraGraham
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
Hand held. On 70-200 IS w/IS on.
May 24, 2005 at 06:42 AM
OlafSiebert
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Ira's Real World Lens Tests 135 2.0 Vs 70-200IS 2.8
@ IraGraham: people are not bad attituded, they just cannot stand critism anymore... and now there comes somebody who tells them they bought a 'wrong' lens ... :-)
May 24, 2005 at 06:45 AM
FM ForumsPeople, Portraits & WeddingsJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister