p.1 #1Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
Been shooting since before digital existed, and always been using Canon pro DSLRs. 1D, 1DsII, 1Dx and currently have a 1Dx and 1DxII, so recently bought an R3. Been shooting with it for several months and 3 things have me really wondering why mirrorless is popular.
1) The R3 eats through batteries, even with the same battery as the 1Dx, I get 1200-1500- shots on a battery in the 1Dx series vs sometimes under 500 shots on the R3 before the battery is nearly dead.
2) With the DSLRs I have it set up so image previews pop up on the back screen if I want to review quickly. I can keep shooting while viewing through the eye piece and ignore the rear screen, unless I want to quickly peak at the image. With the R3 the preview is in the eye piece, which blocks the viewfinder for the next image. I can't figure out how to set the R3 so the preview pops up for a second or two on the rear screen without having the red screen constantly on. Any tips?
3) The focusing on the 1Dx works better under dark conditions such as a wedding reception. The R3 also hunts more often than the 1Dx. I was expecting the R3 to at least match the focus performance of the older DSLRs.
Are these valid issues or am I missing something with how I have the R3 set up?
p.1 #2Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
I think two of your three issues are related to how your R3 is configured, although the battery-life difference is real.
For the image review issue - go into Image Review and set Viewfinder Display to Disable. That will stop the captured image from interrupting your view through the EVF. You can also set Review Duration to 2 seconds and experiment with AUTO2 screen/viewfinder switching. Just know the R3 cannot operate the rear LCD and EVF simultaneously.
Regarding AF - there are many variables. Are you using Servo AF with subject tracking enabled, are you using adapted EF lenses or RF lenses, sensitivities and tracking speeds, etc.
If you haven't already done so I would suggest setting up two separate AF methods: one using Servo AF with people/eye detection for moving subjects, and another using traditional 1-point AF with subject tracking disabled for low-light situations. You can assign these to different buttons on the back so you don't have to dive into menus.
The R3's AF system is extremely capable when setup correctly and you should see improvements over your DSLR, but it doesn't necessarily behave like the 1D X series out of the box.
Battery life is the one area where your DSLRs have a genuine advantage. The EVF and constantly operating sensor simply consume more power. It gets worse if you chimp a lot, and it sounds like you like to chimp.
Don't give up on the R3 yet, it's a great body and you just need to get your settings dialed in.
p.1 #3Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
Are you not feeling mirrorless, or not feeling Canon mirrorless? I’ve been shooting with the Sony A7R6 with the battery grip and I’m getting the same battery life that you have with the DSLR. I left DSLR and Canon when I stopped shooting the 1DMkiii. Ahh.. nothing really replaces the optical viewfinder, but the stacked sensor Sonys have little or no blackout. I think that the R3 is stacked, so probably not so much blackout but, the A7R6 is the first camera where, to me, the EVF is as bright as an optical viewfinder. I suspect this is mainly a memory lapse. I still shoot with my Contax RTSiii and other Contax film cameras and do appreciate the bright viewfinders, but don’t really love the mirror slap. I turn preview off completely and shoot with the LCD turned around so can’t see that either. Likely, not to the liking of most.
p.1 #4Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
While the R3 is a very good camera, it's also 5 year old technology at this point.
Did you buy it new or used?
The battery consumption does not sound normal. But the context of how you use the camera is also important. I also owned the 1DX and 1DXII. I could shoot sports and get thousands of images on a charge. But I could also do an event with a lot of chimping and some live view use and only get a few hundred. I have not used the R3 for a while, but with the R1, I have gotten up to 15,000 images on a charge. But that's electronic shutter, 40fps with very little image review. In similar conditions with the R5II it's about 2000-3000 on average.
Not everything about mirrorless is better than DSLRs, but some areas where they are better, is significantly better. For example subject recognition, face and eye detection and tracking and the ability to shoot wide open as the subject moves around the edges of the frame with a significantly higher hit rate than DSLRs. I shoot a lot of sports and 30 or 40 fps sequences routinely have nearly perfect focus.
Something to be aware of with virtually all mirrorless cameras is that AF line sensitivity is like the old days back at the start of the AF era. The cameras are vertical line sensitive and not 'cross type' AF points abundant in the 1DX cameras. They're blind to horizontal lines (if shooting horizontal compositions). AF insensitivity is also compounded by low contrast, strong backlight glare and how dark the subject is in the frame. Slower lenses also compound this.
FWIW I do a lot of event coverage and sometimes in quite dark conditions. I'm currently using the R5II and rarely have instances where it's unable to lock focus or it actually hunts.
I think I know what you want to do with question #2 but don't recall that ability on Canon cameras. If in doubt, consult the manual or call Canon's customer support. On my cameras I have programmed the SET button in the center of the rear dial for image playback, so it's very easy to bring up the last image whenever I want to check it.
p.1 #5Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
Mr645 wrote:
Been shooting since before digital existed, and always been using Canon pro DSLRs. 1D, 1DsII, 1Dx and currently have a 1Dx and 1DxII, so recently bought an R3. Been shooting with it for several months and 3 things have me really wondering why mirrorless is popular.
1) The R3 eats through batteries, even with the same battery as the 1Dx, I get 1200-1500- shots on a battery in the 1Dx series vs sometimes under 500 shots on the R3 before the battery is nearly dead.
2) With the DSLRs I have it set up so image previews pop up on the back screen if I want to review quickly. I can keep shooting while viewing through the eye piece and ignore the rear screen, unless I want to quickly peak at the image. With the R3 the preview is in the eye piece, which blocks the viewfinder for the next image. I can't figure out how to set the R3 so the preview pops up for a second or two on the rear screen without having the red screen constantly on. Any tips?
3) The focusing on the 1Dx works better under dark conditions such as a wedding reception. The R3 also hunts more often than the 1Dx. I was expecting the R3 to at least match the focus performance of the older DSLRs.
Are these valid issues or am I missing something with how I have the R3 set up?
I have a half-dozen 1D series DSLRs including the 1Dx. But I am now only using the R series bodies for Canon lenses, some EF with adapters.
1. I'm not sure how you use the camera, but the battery life can be much higther than DSLRs in continous drive mode. If you are heavily chimpering or shooting just a few frames and waiting with EVF on, it may be less. I've had almost 15,000 frames on the R5 II which has twice the pixels and half the battery. I assume you are using the latest battery for the R3.
2. I think you are not setting it up optimally.
3. MILS in general does have some AF limitations like short effective baselength, but I'm almost certain that a more modern camera like the R1 would be better. AFAIK it is the only Canon, Nikon or Sony FF body with a type of cross-point AF sensor (alternating vertical and horizontal PD). It's the difference between 5 year old tech vs. 2 year old tech and a 1 series vs. something else.
p.1 #6Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
I completely respect where you're coming from, but I couldn't disagree more based on my own experience. I used to be skeptical of mirrorless and tried hard to hate the transition, but once I made the switch, I changed my mind completely.
I shoot exclusively birds with the R5 Mark II, and I can honestly say I will never go back to a DSLR.
What sealed the deal for me is how these new bodies breathe new life into older glass. My EF super-telephotos—the 400mm DO II and the 500mm f/4L IS II—have literally come to life with the R5 Mark II. The AF acquisition, tracking tenacity, and sharpness paired with the new sensor are on an entirely different level compared to my old DSLR bodies.
DSLRs had a great run, but for wildlife, the capability of the current mirrorless setup is just night and day.
p.1 #7Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
Former 1ds3, 1dx, 1dxmk2
Then got the R3
Yes, it's quite a change, but for better. Consensus seems to be that you need to some more research about camera settings and then experiment a bit to get it your way. Yes, mls all have worse battery life...but electronic shutter does make a difference and evf consumes more energy than the lcd
Your experience regarding dark conditions is also settings related - mls has an advantage here, if you set it up correctly
In short, you need to do some work and set up the R3 better
p.1 #8Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
I came to the R3, which I’ve had 4 years now, from a 1Ds Mk III.
I have my R3 set up like this:
Viewfinder/rear screen mode is AUTO2. Then one of the layouts I have enabled for the rear screen is SCREEN OFF, and I leave it parked on that. When I take a picture and then take the camera away from my eye, the rear screen stays off unless I press the play button, and then it shows on the rear screen. This approximates the way I used (and still use) my 1Ds Mk III. If I want to use the rear screen on a tripod, I press INFO to cycle away from SCREEN OFF to one of the other two layouts I’ve enabled.
Supposedly the viewfinder is more power hungry than the rear screen. I also spent some time setting up the power saving timeouts. I am getting much, much more than your 500 shots when not shooting bursts. (Bursts are mostly free in terms of power, it’s having the camera on at all that runs the battery down.)
While the R3 has a better sensor than the 1Ds Mk III and can track subjects better, in several ways that matter to me it is not as good a camera as the 1Ds Mk III. In colour accuracy, gamut, dynamic range and power effficiency the viewfinder is very far behind the DSLR’s. When shooting macro, the articulated screen counts for nothing to me as I have the angle finder.
However, I use the R3 more as it is more flexible.
One huge advantage of the R3 is that it gets much less sensor dust than the 1Ds Mk III, because of the feature where it closes a shutter curtain on power off.
p.1 #9Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
Coming from a 5D4 to a R5Ii, there are pros and cons. Battery life is pathetic on the R5ii and much more sensitive to cooler weather.
EVF is a downside also, but it can give you a lot more info.
Deactivate the EVF for reviewing images.
Also AF can be hit or miss sometimes, especially at longer distances and when it can't find the eye.
When it can't lock on the eyes it's worse than on a DSLR, even with spot AF and slower. Especially with long and fast glass, when dof is critical.
Also, it won't make your EF lenses perform better, but when it will detect the eye it will help you in achieving focus and get the framing right in camera.
p.1 #10Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
rscheffler wrote:
While the R3 is a very good camera, it's also 5 year old technology at this point.
Did you buy it new or used? I bought it used at my local store. I had a 1Dx fail and needed a replacement, and with Canon clearly moving away from DSLR I picked up a mint R3 since it used the same batteries and similar layout/size
The battery consumption does not sound normal. But the context of how you use the camera is also important. I also owned the 1DX and 1DXII. I could shoot sports and get thousands of images on a charge. But I could also do an event with a lot of chimping and some live view use and only get a few hundred. I have not used the R3 for a while, but with the R1, I have gotten up to 15,000 images on a charge. But that's electronic shutter, 40fps with very little image review. In similar conditions with the R5II it's about 2000-3000 on average. mostly weddings and social events. I also recently shot a pro wrestling event, but used the 1DxII
Not everything about mirrorless is better than DSLRs, but some areas where they are better, is significantly better. For example subject recognition, face and eye detection and tracking and the ability to shoot wide open as the subject moves around the edges of the frame with a significantly higher hit rate than DSLRs. I shoot a lot of sports and 30 or 40 fps sequences routinely have nearly perfect focus. I use single point AF, back button focus 90% of the time, switch to single point servo sometimes. The ease at moving the focus point around is much better then any Canon DSLR, and being able to cover the entire image is awesome.
Something to be aware of with virtually all mirrorless cameras is that AF line sensitivity is like the old days back at the start of the AF era. The cameras are vertical line sensitive and not 'cross type' AF points abundant in the 1DX cameras. They're blind to horizontal lines (if shooting horizontal compositions). AF insensitivity is also compounded by low contrast, strong backlight glare and how dark the subject is in the frame. Slower lenses also compound this. This makes sense, low light, low contrast scenes the1Dx snaps into focus when the R3 hunted on the same scene.
FWIW I do a lot of event coverage and sometimes in quite dark conditions. I'm currently using the R5II and rarely have instances where it's unable to lock focus or it actually hunts.
I think I know what you want to do with question #2 but don't recall that ability on Canon cameras. If in doubt, consult the manual or call Canon's customer support. On my cameras I have programmed the SET button in the center of the rear dial for image playback, so it's very easy to bring up the last image whenever I want to check it. ...Show more →
p.1 #11Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
melcat wrote:
I came to the R3, which I’ve had 4 years now, from a 1Ds Mk III.
I have my R3 set up like this:
Viewfinder/rear screen mode is AUTO2. Then one of the layouts I have enabled for the rear screen is SCREEN OFF, and I leave it parked on that. When I take a picture and then take the camera away from my eye, the rear screen stays off unless I press the play button, and then it shows on the rear screen. This approximates the way I used (and still use) my 1Ds Mk III. If I want to use the rear screen on a tripod, I press INFO to cycle away from SCREEN OFF to one of the other two layouts I’ve enabled. I like this idea, I'll have to try it. I really got used to looking at incoming images on occasion as they briefly pop on up the rear screen while I can easily ignore them whole shooting.
Supposedly the viewfinder is more power hungry than the rear screen. I also spent some time setting up the power saving timeouts. I am getting much, much more than your 500 shots when not shooting bursts. (Bursts are mostly free in terms of power, it’s having the camera on at all that runs the battery down.)
While the R3 has a better sensor than the 1Ds Mk III and can track subjects better, in several ways that matter to me it is not as good a camera as the 1Ds Mk III. In colour accuracy, gamut, dynamic range and power effficiency the viewfinder is very far behind the DSLR’s. When shooting macro, the articulated screen counts for nothing to me as I have the angle finder. I never owned a 1DsIII but I still have a working 1DsII and that camera has always impressed me with the file quality, especially how smoothly it goes into white, like a bright sky that's blown out. It looks more natural on the 1Ds series of cameras compared to newer models.
However, I use the R3 more as it is more flexible.
One huge advantage of the R3 is that it gets much less sensor dust than the 1Ds Mk III, because of the feature where it closes a shutter curtain on power off....Show more →That reminds me, I need to clean the 1Dx sensor
p.1 #12Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
I want to thank everyone for their responses. And to answer a few questions, I use EF glass exclusively. I have too many lenses to consider upgrading to RF glass, although I may get a few as my EF lenses wear out. I still use the original 70-200F2.8L, before there was IS, I have several other EF lenses that must be 20 years old by now, but they work great.
p.1 #13Going mirrorless and not feeling it. (1DxII to R3)
If it’s any consolation I feel the same
My camera isn’t as posh as yours - not by a long shot ( R8)
I find the whole mirrorless experience utterly soulless.
I take pictures of my son’s football team, have done for the past 10yrs. Normally I use a gripped 5diii with 100-400Lii, but last weekend I decided to try a 1 Div - bought it used 4yrs ago and never once used it except for test shots in the garden.
What can I say… I loved it!!
And furthermore I got feedback from the players.. which I rarely ever get.
Using centre spot AF and AiServo kept me on my toes for the whole 90mins.
No doubt the R8 would have a much higher success rate, but jeez it is such a dull experience in comparison to using DSLR’s.