p.1 #1Question: Sony 600mm f/6.3 GM + Megadap ETZ21 Pro+ on Z?
Curious if anyone is running this combo yet. How does AF and everything else hold up? The Sony weight, price, and MFD are tempting, but I'm staying on my Z8. Would love to hear your thoughts.
p.1 #2Question: Sony 600mm f/6.3 GM + Megadap ETZ21 Pro+ on Z?
I have Z8, Megadap pro and Sony 400/4.5. It works great for static or slow moving subjects. Useless for BIF. I don't think the megadap is fast enough to communicate between each frame. Even the EVF feed is messed up. So hard to follow the bird. I'd say it's better to get Nikon 600 or a Sony body to get full advantage of the lens
p.1 #3Question: Sony 600mm f/6.3 GM + Megadap ETZ21 Pro+ on Z?
Jemini wrote:
I have Z8, Megadap pro and Sony 400/4.5. It works great for static or slow moving subjects. Useless for BIF. I don't think the megadap is fast enough to communicate between each frame. Even the EVF feed is messed up. So hard to follow the bird. I'd say it's better to get Nikon 600 or a Sony body to get full advantage of the lens
Oh wow! Thank you Jemini. I literally had the lens in my cart already. Is it the only Sony lens you adapt? Could it be because the Megadap firmware doesn't cover the 400 and 600 yet?
p.1 #4Question: Sony 600mm f/6.3 GM + Megadap ETZ21 Pro+ on Z?
I fully agree with the previous commenter.
The Z 600mm f/6.3 PF VR S is clearly the better choice for use on a Nikon Z8.
Alternatively, you could get a compatible Sony body.
I don’t think that makes sense for this category of lens.
Reverse engineering with smart adapters like the Megdap Pro simply reaches its limits here, especially when compared to native Z-mount lenses that utilize native protocols.
While this might not be a major issue for many types of photography/focal length ranges, it certainly matters for a category where maximum AF performance, tracking capability, and IBIS/VR performance are critical, BiF, Sports, fast action.
You also lose certain features—such as the in body focus limiter feature and, as far as I know, RSF/RSFH functionality—and you forgo the benefits of IBIS/VR-synced stabilization, which is noticeably superior to Sony’s OSS., even when comparing native Nikon to native Sony.
p.1 #5Question: Sony 600mm f/6.3 GM + Megadap ETZ21 Pro+ on Z?
JB-603 wrote: Jemini wroteI have Z8, Megadap pro and Sony 400/4.5. It works great for static or slow moving subjects. Useless for BIF. I don't think the megadap is fast enough to communicate between each frame. Even the EVF feed is messed up. So hard to follow the bird. I'd say it's better to get Nikon 600 or a Sony body to get full advantage of the lensOh wow! Thank you Jemini. I literally had the lens in my cart already. Is it the only Sony lens you adapt? Could it be because the Megadap firmware doesn't cover the 400 and 600 yet?
It could be firmware.
But I had similar experience with 300/2.8 too. So not sure. For normal slow moving subjects the adapter is ok. When we need the best AF, I don't think it's a great idea.
p.1 #6Question: Sony 600mm f/6.3 GM + Megadap ETZ21 Pro+ on Z?
Vento wrote:
I fully agree with the previous commenter.
The Z 600mm f/6.3 PF VR S is clearly the better choice for use on a Nikon Z8.
Alternatively, you could get a compatible Sony body.
I don’t think that makes sense for this category of lens.
Reverse engineering with smart adapters like the Megdap Pro simply reaches its limits here, especially when compared to native Z-mount lenses that utilize native protocols.
While this might not be a major issue for many types of photography/focal length ranges, it certainly matters for a category where maximum AF performance, tracking capability, and IBIS/VR performance are critical, BiF, Sports, fast action.
You also lose certain features—such as the in body focus limiter feature and, as far as I know, RSF/RSFH functionality—and you forgo the benefits of IBIS/VR-synced stabilization, which is noticeably superior to Sony’s OSS., even when comparing native Nikon to native Sony.
Oh yes, the VR is another subject I forgot to mention. I agree with you. I had to turn off the OSS on Sony lens to have decent VR to work. Once the lens OSS turned off, I think it's just IBIS is working and that's ok for shorter focal lengths. Not that great for longer lenses. Sony's OSS is behind Nikon's VR anyway (Jan Wegener mention this in every lens reviews). This is one major reason I'm not leaving Nikon yet.
Below image was taken hand held at 1/5 seconds using 400/4.5 on Z8.
NIKON Z 8NIKKOR Z 400mm f/4.5 VR S lens400mmf/4.51/5s12800 ISO0.0 EV
p.1 #7Question: Sony 600mm f/6.3 GM + Megadap ETZ21 Pro+ on Z?
While I don't have any Sony's telephoto primes, I do have the ETZ21 Pro+ and have used it pretty extensively with other FE lenses (up to the 100–400mm). Like others have reported in this thread, the adapter exhibits enough AF lag that it can make tracking fast action problematic; I certainly wouldn't classify it as useless, more frustrating and/or disappointing. For almost any other scenario it works great and you are unlikely to notice any AF lag. I recently installed the latest firmware for the adapter, however haven't had a chance to see if it helped AF in challenging situations... I don't expect any major improvements.
The ETZ21 Pro+ does not allow lens VR and IBIS to work together. I find that in-lens VR generally works better than IBIS for telephoto lenses, but that's never as good as Nikon's lenses with VR that work in tandem. The most effective option could also depend on the specific lens being adapted. Lenses such as the Sony 100–400mm (the older version) have relatively ineffective in-lens VR when adapted.
If you need the highest lens performance nothing will be better than Nikon's better glass.