p.1 #1Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
I've been researching the Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM and 600mm f/6.3 GM, particularly how the 400mm + 1.4x TC compares against the native 600mm.
After reading the discussions here and watching several reviews, I'm finding quite a few conflicting conclusions. I thought it might be useful to summarize what I've found and get more opinions from people who have actually used both.
1. Sharpness and image quality
The results seem surprisingly mixed:
Dustin Abbott: Found the 400mm + 1.4x TC marginally sharper than the bare 600mm.
The-Digital-Picture: Their test-chart comparisons seem to favor the 400mm + 1.4x TC slightly in center sharpness. The 600/6.3 has better corrected CA and is sharper outside of the frame center.
Overall, there doesn't seem to be a clear consensus. I'm also wondering how much these differences matter when comparing actual detail resolved on a distant subject rather than pixel-level sharpness.
2. Autofocus performance
This is probably the area I'm most interested in, particularly for birds in flight and lower-light conditions.
Alex Phan: Reported excellent AF with the 600mm in good daylight, but considerable hunting with birds against shaded vegetation. He also found his 300mm f/2.8 + 2x TC acquired focus faster in those conditions: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1958596/
Fred Miranda owners: Several have reported excellent autofocus with the 400mm + 1.4x TC, although others have noticed some reduction in AF acquisition or tracking performance when using teleconverters: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1958518/
The question is whether the native 600mm has a meaningful AF advantage over the 400mm + 1.4x TC when both are effectively f/6.3.
Has anyone compared acquisition speed and tracking keeper rates directly, especially with erratic birds or busy backgrounds?
3. Teleconverter performance
The 400mm appears to work exceptionally well with the 1.4x TC, producing 560mm f/6.3 with very little apparent loss of sharpness.
The 2x TC results seem more divided. Some owners report excellent 800mm f/9 performance, while others find the AF penalty significant enough that cropping from 560mm is preferable.
The 600mm also supports a 1.4x TC for 840mm f/9, but owner reports on that combination seem mixed.
In theory on A1ii lenses should not get sharper past f/6.18 (green subject) and f/8.5 (blue subject)
I'd be interested in whether anyone has compared the 400mm + 2x TC against the 600mm + 1.4x TC for both sharpness and AF reliability.
4. Ergonomics and handling
This is another interesting area because the bare lenses weigh almost exactly the same, but adding a TC changes the balance.
MohChee reported taking both combinations on an approximately 15-mile hike with his spouse. Both preferred carrying the bare 600mm, finding that the additional 150–200g and weight distribution of the 400mm + TC were more noticeable than expected.
The 400mm obviously offers the advantage of removing the TC for a brighter, shorter lens, whereas the native 600mm provides more reach without adding any accessories.
5. Value and versatility
The 400mm is more flexible, especially when the subject is close enough to fill the frame at 400mm.
On the other hand, the 600/6.3 seems to be more ergonomic and is lighter compared to the 400/4.5 + TC.
I'd really appreciate more firsthand comparisons from people who have used both lenses, particularly:
Does the 400mm + 1.4x TC genuinely resolve more detail than the bare 600mm, or is the difference mostly limited to test charts?
Is there a noticeable AF acquisition or tracking advantage with the native 600mm?
How well do the 400mm + 2x and 600mm + 1.4x combinations perform in real wildlife photography?
Does the additional weight and different balance of the 400mm + TC make a meaningful difference during prolonged handheld shooting?
For those who have tried both, which would you ultimately keep?
He goes on to say the 600’s advantage at 840mm, vs 400+2X, is actually greater, but still close.
I don’t own the 400, so can’t personally add much here. Except as to your question about how the 600 does with TC’s — for me the 600 does spectacularly well with TC’s on the a1ii, despite concerns about theoretical diffraction limits. My 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.
p.1 #3Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Another thread going on about the actual focal lengths. 560mm is surprisingly close to 600mm.
IMHO, iq difference is negligible or non existent. I don't know if anyone can actually measure AF difference. In theory bare lens should have an advantage. I have only 400. I don't feel it's 'heavy' once TC added. So it's in our mind. If you compare side by side you may feel it
In short you can't go wrong either way. For me 400 was better deal because I'm getting 90% (if not more) of performance for much better price and flexibility of two lenses.
p.1 #4Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
kopebuyer wrote:
My 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.
I've seen multiple people say the same thing, I guess I'm in the minority because when I tested my 300+2x TC the 600 6.3 was noticeably better. So much so that I sold the 300 and 2x TC and now shooting just with the 600 6.3 as my only lens.
p.1 #5Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
pdog109 wrote: kopebuyer wroteMy 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.I've seen multiple people say the same thing, I guess I'm in the minority because when I tested my 300+2x TC the 600 6.3 was noticeably better. So much so that I sold the 300 and 2x TC and now shooting just with the 600 6.3 as my only lens.
p.1 #6Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote: pdog109 wrotekopebuyer wroteMy 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.I've seen multiple people say the same thing, I guess I'm in the minority because when I tested my 300+2x TC the 600 6.3 was noticeably better. So much so that I sold the 300 and 2x TC and now shooting just with the 600 6.3 as my only lens.Was the 2x permanently attached to your 300?
p.1 #7Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
pdog109 wrote: aCuria wrotepdog109 wrotekopebuyer wroteMy 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.I've seen multiple people say the same thing, I guess I'm in the minority because when I tested my 300+2x TC the 600 6.3 was noticeably better. So much so that I sold the 300 and 2x TC and now shooting just with the 600 6.3 as my only lens.Was the 2x permanently attached to your 300?Yup pretty much.
p.1 #8Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
In the olden days Roger Cicala could have put 10 of each on the optical bench and given us some insight into variation.
He would probably not have got around to it yet, but would have already pulled some apart.
p.1 #9Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
There is a Sony Store near by my place and they have ALL lenses in store for customers to try out. I did a quick test of 300/2.8, 400/4.5, 600/6.3 plus both teleconverters with A1 II a few days ago, unfortunately they're inside a shopping mall so there was no moving subject to test AF. My impression was,
IQ: All 3 lenses are excellent, I will say 328>445>663 for bare lenses, but the differences are very minor. Adding 1.4x affects a little, but all are still very good. Adding 2x affects more, though still acceptable to me. 445+1.4x vs 663 bare lens are very close, I think it's meaningless to judge the difference.
AF: All 3 lenses are very fast for initial acquisition and focusing near/far for either bare lens or w/1.4x. Adding 2x I could feel the slowing down, but since I was testing non-moving subjects only, the AF performance was still very good.
For me, the focal range I need is between 400-600mm, and I prefer larger aperture (I was planning to buy 328 quite a while), so obviously I will choose 445+1.4x.
p.1 #10Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote:
In theory on A1ii lenses should not get sharper past f/6.18 (green subject) and f/8.5 (blue subject)
"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.
p.1 #11Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
pdog109 wrote: kopebuyer wroteMy 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.I've seen multiple people say the same thing, I guess I'm in the minority because when I tested my 300+2x TC the 600 6.3 was noticeably better. So much so that I sold the 300 and 2x TC and now shooting just with the 600 6.3 as my only lens.
That is interesting. I found them so close I could only see a sharpness difference at 200% and it was just barely in favour of the 600.
For AF, I was never quite sure which was the winner. They were also very close. I just didn't have challenging enough subjects to give it a real stress test. I needed my April swallows to really know for sure.
But since you were using the 300 with the 2x on it all the time then the 600 is a better choice.
p.1 #12Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Is it somehow possible to combine / merge the thread I made with this one, if you think it adds something? I don’t think it’s useful to have 2 similar threads I think we were creating it at the same time, but you were faster haha!
p.1 #13Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
arbitrage wrote: pdog109 wrotekopebuyer wroteMy 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.I've seen multiple people say the same thing, I guess I'm in the minority because when I tested my 300+2x TC the 600 6.3 was noticeably better. So much so that I sold the 300 and 2x TC and now shooting just with the 600 6.3 as my only lens.That is interesting. I found them so close I could only see a sharpness difference at 200% and it was just barely in favour of the 600.
On the-digital-picture it seems that they are very close in the center (maybe a notch towards the 300+2x), but off center the 600f6.3 looks much better (the TC causes quite a bit of CA). So any judgment from images would be quite dependent on where in the frame the subject was.
p.1 #14Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
I have the 400 as well as the 1.4 teleconverter. Initial impressions are very positive especially considering that it was purchased to replace the older 100-400 4.5-5.6. Compared to that lens at 400, the prime is dramatically longer in focal. Also, it is clearly sharper and more contrasty. My question relates to teleconverter use verses cropping. I am not primarily a birder. So for me, I will shoot at 400 often. When I do need more reach is it clear that on a higher resolution body that the 1.4 teleconverter is better than simply cropping?
p.1 #15Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Daran wrote: arbitrage wrotepdog109 wrotekopebuyer wroteMy 600 also slightly beats my 300+2X at 600mm… but they are so close it’s effectively a draw.I've seen multiple people say the same thing, I guess I'm in the minority because when I tested my 300+2x TC the 600 6.3 was noticeably better. So much so that I sold the 300 and 2x TC and now shooting just with the 600 6.3 as my only lens.That is interesting. I found them so close I could only see a sharpness difference at 200% and it was just barely in favour of the 600.On the-digital-picture it seems that they are very close in the center (maybe a notch towards the 300+2x), but off center the 600f6.3 looks much better (the TC causes quite a bit of CA). So any judgment from images would be quite dependent on where in the frame the subject was.
Yeah, that is true. I was only comparing the centre area.
p.1 #16Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Bjlangford wrote:
I have the 400 as well as the 1.4 teleconverter. Initial impressions are very positive especially considering that it was purchased to replace the older 100-400 4.5-5.6. Compared to that lens at 400, the prime is dramatically longer in focal. Also, it is clearly sharper and more contrasty. My question relates to teleconverter use verses cropping. I am not primarily a birder. So for me, I will shoot at 400 often. When I do need more reach is it clear that on a higher resolution body that the 1.4 teleconverter is better than simply cropping?
"When I do need more reach is it clear that on a higher resolution body that the 1.4 teleconverter is better than simply cropping?"
My experience with A1II say so
"Compared to that lens at 400, the prime is dramatically longer in focal" Not surprised at all. I didn't have them side by side. But when I had 100-400 I felt it was well short of 400. I said it in multiple threads, the 70-350 was really close to 100-400 at MFD. I know MFD is not the best way to test lenses. Also two copies of 100-400 I tried I was not impressed by sharpness either. I know many people here have sharp copies of this lens.
p.1 #17Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
I'm another "the 2X was glued to my 300 f2.8" guy. Seems counter productive to buy the 400 to have the 1.4X glued to it all the time. When shooting around 400mm I prefer the 100-400 f4.5 because I seem to need the zoom. The 600 has spoiled me though, when I grabbed the 100-400 the other day my first thought was how big it is!
p.1 #18Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Daran wrote: aCuria wroteIn theory on A1ii lenses should not get sharper past f/6.18 (green subject) and f/8.5 (blue subject)"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.
There is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.
p.1 #20Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote: Daran wroteaCuria wroteIn theory on A1ii lenses should not get sharper past f/6.18 (green subject) and f/8.5 (blue subject)"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.There is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.
Maybe I've spent too much time online, but I had a surprisingly hard time trying to tell whether your post was meant to be sarcastic.