p.2 #1Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
I don’t think there’s any meaningful differences between these combinations. When half prefer the 600 and half prefer the 400 it’s likely a wash, optically, short of any sample variation. I chose the 600 purely because it fits into my preferred lens kit. I have an excellent copy of the 100-400 plus the 300 2.8, so a bare 400 makes no sense, for me. And I occasionally want more than 600 and I’d rather a 1.4x over a 2x.
When I build my lens kits I work backwards from my subject preferences to the gear I needs and for me a 600 makes sense more often than a bare 400. I have also worked out from my Sigma 300-600 that I do tend to be at 600 a lot. And when I don’t the 100-400 is the right lens for me.
I’m sure the 400 is excellent but my need for a longer lens most of the time dictated my choice. Not a 2% difference in IQ that reviewers couldn’t agree on anyway.
p.2 #2Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Daran wrote: aCuria wroteDaran wroteaCuria wroteIn theory on A1ii lenses should not get sharper past f/6.18 (green subject) and f/8.5 (blue subject)"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.There is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.Maybe I've spent too much time online, but I had a surprisingly hard time trying to tell whether your post was meant to be sarcastic.
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoff
However it’s not very useful for photography because the human eye perceives mtf50 as sharpness which is why we use airy disk diameter = 2 pixels which corresponds to 49% contrast reduction
However the part I’m not so sure about is how digital post processing interacts with this, we can increase contrast of the fine details digitally before printing to some extent, so can we use airy disk diameter somewhat greater than 2 to account for digital processing?
p.2 #3Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote: Daran wroteaCuria wroteDaran wroteaCuria wroteIn theory on A1ii lenses should not get sharper past f/6.18 (green subject) and f/8.5 (blue subject)"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.There is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.Maybe I've spent too much time online, but I had a surprisingly hard time trying to tell whether your post was meant to be sarcastic.No sacarsm
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoff
However it’s not very useful for photography because the human eye perceives mtf50 as sharpness which is why we use airy disk diameter = 2 pixels which corresponds to 49% contrast reduction
p.2 #4Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
RustyRus wrote: aCuria wroteDaran wroteaCuria wroteDaran wroteaCuria wroteIn theory on A1ii lenses should not get sharper past f/6.18 (green subject) and f/8.5 (blue subject)"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.There is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.Maybe I've spent too much time online, but I had a surprisingly hard time trying to tell whether your post was meant to be sarcastic.No sacarsm
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoff
However it’s not very useful for photography because the human eye perceives mtf50 as sharpness which is why we use airy disk diameter = 2 pixels which corresponds to 49% contrast reductionDo you need a light 400 or 600mm lens?
The answer to that question is your answer-
Practically yes!
But I want to know theoretically that’s the right answer
p.2 #5Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote: RustyRus wroteaCuria wroteDaran wroteaCuria wroteDaran wrote"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.There is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.Maybe I've spent too much time online, but I had a surprisingly hard time trying to tell whether your post was meant to be sarcastic.No sacarsm
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoff
However it’s not very useful for photography because the human eye perceives mtf50 as sharpness which is why we use airy disk diameter = 2 pixels which corresponds to 49% contrast reductionDo you need a light 400 or 600mm lens?
The answer to that question is your answer-Practically yes!
But I want to know theoretically that’s the right answer
Too much theory. At the end of the day you still have to take pictures with them.
p.2 #7Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote: RustyRus wroteaCuria wroteDaran wroteaCuria wroteDaran wrote"In theory" the diffraction limit is not a hard border, the effect just keeps getting stronger and past the so called "limit" the effect is strong enough to significant limit sharpness. But the softening effect is already visible (e.g. when cropping) before the limit and if you compare a series of apertures, nothing particular happens around the "limit", it just keeps getting softer.There is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.Maybe I've spent too much time online, but I had a surprisingly hard time trying to tell whether your post was meant to be sarcastic.No sacarsm
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoff
However it’s not very useful for photography because the human eye perceives mtf50 as sharpness which is why we use airy disk diameter = 2 pixels which corresponds to 49% contrast reductionDo you need a light 400 or 600mm lens?
The answer to that question is your answer-Practically yes!
But I want to know theoretically that’s the right answer
So you’d pick the wrong focal length for your shooting just because one lens is slightly sharper than the other, in theory? C’mon, man. Pick the lens you need, lace up your hiking boots, and go outside and shoot.
p.2 #9Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
RustyRus wrote: aCuria wroteRustyRus wroteaCuria wroteDaran wroteaCuria wroteThere is a hard border, its when the airy disk covers 4.88 pixels.
When the airy disk covers 2 pixels, diffraction has reduced contrast at the sensor's Nyquist frequency by approximately 49%.Maybe I've spent too much time online, but I had a surprisingly hard time trying to tell whether your post was meant to be sarcastic.No sacarsm
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoff
However it’s not very useful for photography because the human eye perceives mtf50 as sharpness which is why we use airy disk diameter = 2 pixels which corresponds to 49% contrast reductionDo you need a light 400 or 600mm lens?
The answer to that question is your answer-Practically yes!
But I want to know theoretically that’s the right answerSo you’d pick the wrong focal length for your shooting just because one lens is slightly sharper than the other, in theory? C’mon, man. Pick the lens you need, lace up your hiking boots, and go outside and shoot.
600/6.3 doesn’t hit any diffraction limit unless you add TCs. You are right, it’s not a consideration for buying the bare lenses, and is therefore off topic.
p.2 #13Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
rd4tile wrote:
I'm another "the 2X was glued to my 300 f2.8" guy. Seems counter productive to buy the 400 to have the 1.4X glued to it all the time. When shooting around 400mm I prefer the 100-400 f4.5 because I seem to need the zoom. The 600 has spoiled me though, when I grabbed the 100-400 the other day my first thought was how big it is!
I was surprised when I grabbed my 300GM (without any TCs on it) after shooting the 600/6.3 for 2hrs and the thing felt like a heavy brick.
p.2 #16Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
hoodlum90 wrote: arbitrage wroteIt is interesting that he found the 400mm f1.4 accepted the 2xTC better than the 300mm f2.8 for sharpness/contract.
Yeah...seems hard to believe. Looking at the samples in the video (given YT compression) I don't really see the 400/2x being better than the 300/2x. Certainly the 400 and 1.4TC (and the bare 600) are looking a bit better than the 300/2x.
p.2 #17Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote:
No sacarsm
...
The hard cutoff happens when f_N = f_c
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoff
I was afraid you would say that. I also think you really need to look at a real aperture series to see how there are no sudden changes at any aperture. The theory you are referring to is of course correct, but it is not saying what you apparently think it is. There is no hard cutoff.
Note 1: The Spatial_cutoff_frequency you are citing refers to when a very small "object" (a specific high frequency) vanishes due to diffraction. While this does imply that higher frequencies are also "cut", lower frequencies are not. So as increasingly lower frequencies get cut while closing the aperture, the remaining lower frequencies correspondingly produce a less sharp result. Continuously.
Note 2: The airy disk is in fact not a disk, but a continuous hill. The usual definition for the disk diameter is the circle within which it has more than 50% of its peak amplitude, an approximation of the real, continuous shape. In reality the "disk" has no hard diameter, the hill actually extends without any real limit, it just keeps fading toward infinity. Any calculation based on the exact disk diameter is hence merely an approximation as the diameter is only a simplified approximation of the real thing.
p.2 #18Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
hoodlum90 wrote: arbitrage wroteIt is interesting that he found the 400mm f1.4 accepted the 2xTC better than the 300mm f2.8 for sharpness/contract.
The more examples I see, the more I’m impressed with the 400mm. If you use 400-600mm even a 3rd of the time, I’d probably go for the 400
Of course, AF is another story. Adding TC’s always affects AF performance and accuracy. To what degree? Hard to quantify. But from purely optical perspective, the 400mm looks to be a special lens
p.2 #19Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
Daran wrote: aCuria wroteNo sacarsm
...
The hard cutoff happens when f_N = f_c
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoffI was afraid you would say that. I also think you really need to look at a real aperture series to see how there are no sudden changes at any aperture. The theory you are referring to is of course correct, but it is not saying what you apparently think it is. There is no hard cutoff.
Note 1: The Spatial_cutoff_frequency you are citing refers to when a very small "object" (a specific high frequency) vanishes due to diffraction. While this does imply that higher frequencies are also "cut", lower frequencies are not. So as increasingly lower frequencies get cut while closing the aperture, the remaining lower frequencies correspondingly produce a less sharp result. Continuously.
Note 2: The airy disk is in fact not a disk, but a continuous hill. The usual definition for the disk diameter is the circle within which it has more than 50% of its peak amplitude, an approximation of the real, continuous shape. In reality the "disk" has no hard diameter, the hill actually extends without any real limit, it just keeps fading toward infinity. Any calculation based on the exact disk diameter is hence merely an approximation as the diameter is only a simplified approximation of the real thing....Show more →
I made a illustration to depict how i believe it to work.
For each subject, a certain spatial frequency is important for fine detail (for example maybe the width of a hair if its a portrait)
For that particular spatial frequency (and every spatial frequency) there does exist a hard cutoff.
However, as I mentioned earlier, human perceived sharpness depends heavily on contrast. An Airy disk diameter of two pixels corresponds to approximately 50% contrast loss at the sensor's Nyquist frequency, which provides a reasonable practical threshold for when diffraction begins to significantly compromise the finest details the sensor can resolve.
p.2 #20Sony 400mm f/4.5 GM vs 600mm f/6.3 GM — Sharpness, AF and real-world comparisons
aCuria wrote: Daran wroteaCuria wroteNo sacarsm
...
The hard cutoff happens when f_N = f_c
If I did the math right we get d = 4.88 as the hard cutoffI was afraid you would say that. I also think you really need to look at a real aperture series to see how there are no sudden changes at any aperture. The theory you are referring to is of course correct, but it is not saying what you apparently think it is. There is no hard cutoff.
Note 1: The Spatial_cutoff_frequency you are citing refers to when a very small "object" (a specific high frequency) vanishes due to diffraction. While this does imply that higher frequencies are also "cut", lower frequencies are not. So as increasingly lower frequencies get cut while closing the aperture, the remaining lower frequencies correspondingly produce a less sharp result. Continuously.
Note 2: The airy disk is in fact not a disk, but a continuous hill. The usual definition for the disk diameter is the circle within which it has more than 50% of its peak amplitude, an approximation of the real, continuous shape. In reality the "disk" has no hard diameter, the hill actually extends without any real limit, it just keeps fading toward infinity. Any calculation based on the exact disk diameter is hence merely an approximation as the diameter is only a simplified approximation of the real thing.https://starlight-code.com/posts/diffraction-contrast-calculator/
I made a illustration to depict how i believe it to work.
For each subject, a certain spatial frequency is important for fine detail (for example maybe the width of a hair if its a portrait)
For that particular spatial frequency (and every spatial frequency) there does exist a hard cutoff.
However, as I mentioned earlier, human perceived sharpness depends heavily on contrast. An Airy disk diameter of two pixels corresponds to approximately 50% contrast loss at the sensor's Nyquist frequency, which provides a reasonable practical threshold for when diffraction begins to significantly compromise the finest details the sensor can resolve.