DWOfPaul wrote:
The Z8 is a great camera, and at its current price, it is an awesome value. It also works great with Nikon DSLR lenses and feels extremely similar to using Nikon DSLR's and Nikon DSLR files when editing.
Currently in the US (new):
Nikon Z8: $3,200
Canon R5II: $4,000
Sony a1II: $6,800
Here in Canada:
Nikon Z8 C$4399
Canon R5 II C$5899
Sony A1 II. C$8299
The Z8 is certainly the best bargain of the bunch at these prices. I find the R5 II matches or exceeds the performance of the Z8 in most ways except lens choice and video recording options (which may or may not mean much to many users), and if the OP is looking for Z8 performance in a smaller, lighter package, this would be it. The A1 II is a bit better than either of them in most respects (except AF compared to the R5 II), but you really have to need some of those bleeding edge features to justify the cost differences between the three models.
I prefer the rear LCD screen of the Z8 - it is better for both stills and video unless you want to take selfies. I thought the Sony articulating screen design was good until I tried using it in confined spaces for macro work, where it proved to be a struggle orienting it when changing from horizontal to vertical compositions. The rear LCD on the Canon cameras is easily the worst design, and since this is something I use very often, it's a real source of friction when using a Canon.
I also prefer the size of the Z8, but certainly not the weight. The grip is just the right size for my medium-small hands, so no need to attach a battery grip for comfortable and stable handling like I find necessary with all of the Sony bodies. The grip of the R5 II is very close behind the Z8, but a battery grip is nice for handling long lenses.
One thing I don't like about the Sony cameras is their use of Type A CFExpress cards. They are very difficult to remove from my A1 II card slots as grabbing them requires very tiny fingers, and I can't image trying to do it in winter with gloves on. I wish the Z8 and R5 II had dual CFExpress slots - the SD card isn't much use these cameras other than as a "space saver spare" for emergency use.
Sony has some very compelling long lenses available now, so both it and Nikon are pretty much tied for wildlife work; Sony has a big edge in wide focal length glass, especially fast wide primes. I wish Canon would take heed and expand their lens range to be more competitive; as I'm currently contemplating going back to Nikon partly for this reason, I'm hoping the introduction of Sony's new 400mm and 600mm primes might tempt some Nikon owners to switch and put some more long Nikon Z glass into the used market ...
Realistically, all of these cameras are so good, there is no "wrong" choice as long as the system you choose has the lenses you want. It primarily comes down to the ergonomics - do you actually enjoy using the camera - and for many people, the price.