p.3 #3FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
Re: the grain thing...
I'm comparing Neopan 1600 and APX 25 on the same image. Neopan appears to resolve more detail than APX, which I think is the opposite of how it ought to be? Also, Neopan appears to be resolving too much detail for the grain size—in a real photo, the grain would destroy some of the detail, but here it's acting as more of a layer on top of the detail.
p.3 #4FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
deadwolfbones wrote:
Re: the grain thing...
I'm comparing Neopan 1600 and APX 25 on the same image. Neopan appears to resolve more detail than APX, which I think is the opposite of how it ought to be? Also, Neopan appears to be resolving too much detail for the grain size—in a real photo, the grain would destroy some of the detail, but here it's acting as more of a layer on top of the detail.
Yep currently looking into grain for v1.2.0 release, likely coming next weekend. Will be a complete overhaul of the grain pipeline
p.3 #5FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
I just wanted to say thank you for this amazing app and all the work you've put into it!
I've spent a ridiculous amount of money on presets, profiles, and all sorts of other tools over the years, but none of them have given me results anywhere near what I'm getting from your app. I'm genuinely impressed.
Right now, the biggest limitation I see is the workflow. Having to open files one at a time can be pretty tedious. It would feel much more natural to browse through an entire folder image by image, or even have access to a folder tree directly within the app.
The other thing is integration with existing software. I imagine building a plugin for Capture One or Lightroom wouldn't be easy, but if someone ever managed to pull that off, it would be absolutely fantastic.
For the time being, I'm using the "Open With..." option in Capture One as a workaround, and it's actually reasonably practical.
In any case, huge respect for what you've created. I'm really excited to see where this goes next and will definitely be following future development closely!
p.3 #6FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
jhonzatko wrote:
I just wanted to say thank you for this amazing app and all the work you've put into it!
I've spent a ridiculous amount of money on presets, profiles, and all sorts of other tools over the years, but none of them have given me results anywhere near what I'm getting from your app. I'm genuinely impressed.
Right now, the biggest limitation I see is the workflow. Having to open files one at a time can be pretty tedious. It would feel much more natural to browse through an entire folder image by image, or even have access to a folder tree directly within the app.
The other thing is integration with existing software. I imagine building a plugin for Capture One or Lightroom wouldn't be easy, but if someone ever managed to pull that off, it would be absolutely fantastic.
For the time being, I'm using the "Open With..." option in Capture One as a workaround, and it's actually reasonably practical.
In any case, huge respect for what you've created. I'm really excited to see where this goes next and will definitely be following future development closely!...Show more →
Thank you for the kind comment (also @deadwolfbones)! Tells me that releasing this app to the public was the right decision
And I feel you on the ridiculous amount spent on presets etc.. I did the same and was never really happy with the results compared to real film, which was a big part of my motivation to build this app.
Re C1/LR - as I said I'm not hugely motivated to build something specifically for these apps. But I do see the workflow issue and that's definitely something I will work on in future releases.
v1.2.0 will focus on grain & sharpness. Longterm to do's right now: Multi-image workflow, Windows version, maybe audit for some of the film stocks that are still ported from spektrafilm. And I might fast-track a side project: using the virtual negative to print part of the app to build an app to convert camera-scanned negatives (I still shoot a lot of real film and imo negative conversion is unnecessarily iffy )
p.3 #7FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
Hell yeah. I'm stoked for this update. I ran some video snippets through the app today and it worked quite well. It was misreading the log profile but once I caught that it was fine. I was surprised by how fast the processing was. I've been testing this all on a M4 MacBook Air 😅.
fjablo wrote: deadwolfbones wroteRe: the grain thing...
I'm comparing Neopan 1600 and APX 25 on the same image. Neopan appears to resolve more detail than APX, which I think is the opposite of how it ought to be? Also, Neopan appears to be resolving too much detail for the grain size—in a real photo, the grain would destroy some of the detail, but here it's acting as more of a layer on top of the detail.Yep currently looking into grain for v1.2.0 release, likely coming next weekend. Will be a complete overhaul of the grain pipeline
p.3 #8FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
This is my first comment here since joining as a member a number of years ago. I had to say that I’m absolutely loving the output from this, especially the portra options. I’ve re-edited countless files from different cameras since the last weekend just to see how they turn out.
Just wanted to say thanks and really looking forward to the updates.
p.3 #9FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
Anyone have an idea of why my previews are rendered all black? I'd love to try this since the results look fantastic, but it doesn't seem to work unfortunately.
The app does process the file and I can even see that vertical images are vertical. Exif looks correct and everything. Also if I export it renders a black image. Very weird.
Edit: Auto exposure also gives different values for different files, so clearly the app opens and processes the files, but I can't see the result for some reason.
You now also the select the film format (35mm vs 120) where you select the film and paper stock. And there is an additional setting to retain camera sharpness fully (it turns off scatter and coupler diffusion effects).
Let me know what you think of the new grain rendering!
p.3 #13FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
As some others have already mentioned, would love to see a windows version on this - you would effectively double the amount of early users (but I guess it's double work as well)
p.3 #14FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
Really liking the new grain profile. In many of my test samples it looks like it's part of the image. The tonality of it is way different. FLX Grain Comparison by Roman France, on Flickr
p.3 #17FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
deadwolfbones wrote:
Also really liking this!
How does shadow vs. highlight affect grain right now @fjablo@ ?
Grain in the shadows should be coarser (sits in the faster emulsion layer), grain in highlights should be finer. Strength of grain is a characteristic of the film overall though, so not affected by this.
If you meant the shadow/highlight sliders, they are more downstream in the pipeline (affecting the print, grain is on the negative) so e.g. lifting shadows would make the grain there more visible, but it would still be coarse.
Oct 29, 2026 at 11:59 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.3 #18FLX Film Lab - physics-based film simulations
DELICIOUS UPDATE Grain is already better than LR now so the need to round trip has been lessened that much more.
I'm really enjoying emulating shooting 120 via my 44x33 files, more so than emulating 35mm via my FF files (mostly because I have plenty of 35mm cameras ).
The new camera vs film sharpness option interestingly renders a softer preview in the app when set to "camera" but the output is sharper when set to "camera", as it should be.