fredmiranda.com Login

100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?

  
 
CPWarner
Offline
Details
p.2 #1100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
robert614 wrote:
Your prelimary results are more or less what I was expecting. Although I was quietly hoping the results with TC’s would be better. While the bare 100-400mm F4.5 seems to be an exceptional lens. It’s probably not the best idea if you plan to use it with TC’s the majority of the time



I should state that the differences I stated were really picking at minor differences I could see at pretty extreme magnifications of an image. I would also say that my 400-800 is very good and that the 100-400mm f4.5 with 1.4x is also very good. The only combo I would not choose to use would be the 100-400 with the 2x.
Oct 01, 2026 at 07:50 AM
Andyuk109
Offline
Details
p.2 #2100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
Yep, it is an appealing combo. Maybe not perfect but feels like a very good balance of quality, weight and flexibility

A harder call if you already have the 300 and/or a good copy of the 400-800 admittedly

CPWarner wrote:
Andyuk109 wroteWith the new 600/6.3 will sell the 300-600 and run with the 100-400 and 600 along with the 1.4tc as required.
I am hearing a number of people looking to have that setup, 100-400 f4.5 with the 600 f6.3. Not sure if I will go there yet. I really like my 400-800mm and will likely keep that for now.

Oct 01, 2026 at 08:30 AM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.2 #3100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
CPWarner wrote:
DWOfPaul wrote@CPWarner@@@@ Thanks for sharing your first hand experience. That sounds in line with what I have heard that the 100-400mm f4.5 + TC 1.4 can make a very good replacement for the 200-600mm f6.3 but that the 400-800mm f8 is still better than the 100-400mm f4 + TC 2x. I just have a hard time seeing myself carrying both lenses around. At 9.5 pounds, it has me back to wishing Sony would allow third party lenses to use TCs and have unlimited FPS so I could get a Sigma 300-600mm f4. I would be giving up the short end, but at least I would be gaining 500mm f4 and 600mm f4 for carrying that much weight around.
That Sigma 300-600 is nearly 9 pounds (8.75 lbs) itself.


Yes, but its one lens to jugle / keep on a tripod. The 100-400mm is about 4lbs and the 400-800mm is about 5.5lbs. So unless I bring two tripods with me I will always have atleast a 4 lb lens in one arm / on my sholder. Maybe it would work well with a double camera holster, but I have personally never tried one.

The 100-400mm f4.5 + 600mm f6.3 does sound like it would make a very nice combo at about 6lbs total.
Oct 01, 2026 at 12:29 PM
Andyuk109
Offline
Details
p.2 #4100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
Not a bad shout on the dual camera rig but I could never make it work with the 300-600. Tried a pgytech dual rig and a BlackRapid one and neither worked well

Just too unbalanced and allowed the lens to swing too much. The only way I can carry mine is on a cross-body shoulder strap with 1 hand on the neck of the lens or tripod foot to keep it still

If it helps, a quick pic of the 300-600 vs 100-400 with hoods reversed as you would carry them

Oct 01, 2026 at 01:57 PM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.2 #5100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
@Andyuk109@ that's quite the size difference!

I think the 300-600mm is basically a single lens commitment. Maybe you could comfortably carry something like a Tamron 50-400mm f6.3 with it, especially if the Tamron was in a backpack.

The largest lens I have walked around with is my Nikon 300mm f2.8 VR II + TC 2x. The lens and TC alone come in at around 7lbs. If I am walking, I hand hold it. If I am using a tripod too, I usually carry it over my shoulder. I use my 24-70mm f2.8 and 70-200mm f2.8 lenses less often now, but there were many times I was out with the 300mm and had them in my backpack, which was a good 5+ lbs.

While I have not weighed my setups, I would say I usually try to keep it to around 15lbs or less with no tripod and 20lbs or less with a tripod, for the full setup, all lenses, cameras, batteries, etc. Now, if it's one of those lucky locations and I can take photos near my car, I won't even think about weight
Oct 01, 2026 at 04:51 PM
franklindelanoj
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #6100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
I’ve been using the 100-400 f/4.5 and I’ve been pretty impressed with it so far. For airshows, I think the versatility is probably its biggest advantage. Being able to start at 100mm and still have 400mm without changing lenses is really useful when the aircraft get closer.

With the 1.4x, I’ve found the image quality and AF to remain very good. Obviously you lose some light and there is a little more reach to manage, but I don’t find the combination disappointing at all.

Compared with the 300 GM + 2x, I’d say the 100-400 + 1.4x feels more like a practical all-around setup, while the 300 + 2x still has the edge when you specifically want maximum reach and image quality. For an airshow where distances can change constantly, though, I really like having the flexibility of the 100-400.

I also think it makes more sense as a single-lens solution than carrying two bodies if you’re trying to keep the setup relatively light. That said, if you already own the 300 GM, the 300 + 600 setup gives you a pretty compelling lightweight two-body option.

For me, the 100-400 has definitely lived up to the hype. It’s one of those lenses that becomes more useful the more you shoot with it, rather than something that is only impressive on paper.
Oct 01, 2026 at 04:54 PM
robert614
Offline
Details
p.2 #7100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
franklindelanoj wrote:
I’ve been using the 100-400 f/4.5 and I’ve been pretty impressed with it so far. For airshows, I think the versatility is probably its biggest advantage. Being able to start at 100mm and still have 400mm without changing lenses is really useful when the aircraft get closer.

With the 1.4x, I’ve found the image quality and AF to remain very good. Obviously you lose some light and there is a little more reach to manage, but I don’t find the combination disappointing at all.

Compared with the 300 GM + 2x, I’d say the 100-400 + 1.4x feels more like a practical
...Show more →

Thanks for sharing your thoughts and first hand experience!

Using the 100-400 f4.5 + 1.4x as a one lens setup for airshows was what I was leaning towards initially. You said sharpness may be slightly behind the 300mm + 2x. How about AF accuracy?
Oct 01, 2026 at 06:28 PM
Andyuk109
Offline
Details
p.2 #8100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
DWOfPaul wrote:
@Andyuk109@@ that's quite the size difference!

I think the 300-600mm is basically a single lens commitment. Maybe you could comfortably carry something like a Tamron 50-400mm f6.3 with it, especially if the Tamron was in a backpack.

The largest lens I have walked around with is my Nikon 300mm f2.8 VR II + TC 2x. The lens and TC alone come in at around 7lbs. If I am walking, I hand hold it. If I am using a tripod too, I usually carry it over my shoulder. I use my 24-70mm f2.8 and 70-200mm f2.8 lenses less often now, but there
...Show more →

Yep, pretty much. Most long lens bags will hold it, but not much else and you aren't going to be using any fast access bags or holsters whilst carrying it

With a really big bag (I use a vanguard alta sky 69) you can carry it and another big prime and a few smaller lens but only really as transport from point to point

On the other hand the 100-400 fits in the thinktank 150 holster, the 600 looks like it will fit in the lens changer which still leaves space for a few other pouches on the belt system and saves the need for any sort of backpack
Oct 02, 2026 at 11:22 AM
robert614
Offline
Details
p.2 #9100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
Andyuk109 wrote:
DWOfPaul wrote@Andyuk109@@@@ that's quite the size difference!

I think the 300-600mm is basically a single lens commitment. Maybe you could comfortably carry something like a Tamron 50-400mm f6.3 with it, especially if the Tamron was in a backpack.

The largest lens I have walked around with is my Nikon 300mm f2.8 VR II + TC 2x. The lens and TC alone come in at around 7lbs. If I am walking, I hand hold it. If I am using a tripod too, I usually carry it over my shoulder. I use my 24-70mm f2.8 and 70-200mm f2.8 lenses less often now, but there were many times I was out with the 300mm and had them in my backpack, which was a good 5+ lbs.

While I have not weighed my setups, I would say I usually try to keep it to around 15lbs or less with no tripod and 20lbs or less with a tripod, for the full setup, all lenses, cameras, batteries, etc. Now, if it's one of those lucky locations and I can take photos near my car, I won't even think about weight
Yep, pretty much. Most long lens bags will hold it, but not much else and you aren't going to be using any fast access bags or holsters whilst carrying it

With a really big bag (I use a vanguard alta sky 69) you can carry it and another big prime and a few smaller lens but only really as transport from point to point

On the other hand the 100-400 fits in the thinktank 150 holster, the 600 looks like it will fit in the lens changer which still leaves space for a few other pouches on the belt system and
...Show more →

I use a Vanguard backpack for my Sigma 300-600 too! Except I use the smaller Alta Sky 62

It can fit the 300-600f4 mounted to a body on on side. And my 70-200 f2.8 II mounted to a body and my Zemlin Hood for the Sigma on the other side
Oct 02, 2026 at 03:50 PM
flash
Offline
Details
p.2 #10100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
My 100-4.5 is noticeably better than my older variable aperture copy. Even at 4.5 at 400 it’s better than 5.6 and at the same aperture the gap widens. So the new lens is a keeper. Sure the old one is smaller but every time I go to pack it, I end up taking the newer one. That, to me is a sign. I also have a good copy of the Sigma 60-600 in L mount that’s at least as good as the older 100-400.

As for what to match it with, well that’s going to get complicated. I’m not shooting air shows where handheld panning might be faster. My thing is wildlife and I can use a support in a safari vehicle. The Sigma 300-600’s speed matters in really low light. I don’t think the 600 6.3 will work (I do have an order in) for that stuff. But I might drop the 300-600 in favour of my 600 f4, which is a kilo lighter and works with the 1.4x. Or the 400-800 which is slower but negates the need for TC changes in the field, which can be dusty. I kind of really want a 400-800 f5.6 GM….

Gordon
Oct 02, 2026 at 04:12 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

CPWarner
Offline
Details
p.2 #11100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
flash wrote:
I kind of really want a 400-800 f5.6 GM….

Gordon


If we are dreaming, how about a 300-800 f6.3 GM to keep the weight down and expand the range just a bit.
Oct 03, 2026 at 07:16 AM
Douglas L
Offline
Details
p.2 #12100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
CPWarner wrote:
flash wroteI kind of really want a 400-800 f5.6 GM….

Gordon
If we are dreaming, how about a 300-800 f6.3 GM to keep the weight down and expand the range just a bit.


I wonder what the size and weight of such a lens would be? The Nikon 800mm f6.3 PF is relatively light but it's not a zoom. I would be happy if Sony just makes an 800mm f6.3 that's even lighter and smaller than the Nikon. The 600 f6.3 sounds great but I would prefer an 800 f6.3. I can never get too much reach for birding.
Oct 03, 2026 at 07:55 AM
jlambros
Offline
Details
p.2 #13100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
This is really a great thread, especially for us airshow shooters. Even with these latest lens releases, it still seems that there is no "perfect" solution. It's always a compromise. We probably have more choices, as others have noted, since a large aperture isn't really needed and bokeh is usually not an issue. I think that sharpness and reach is what we value more.

For me, the image quality of my 300 plus TC's is outstanding. The problem is, my more flexible 200-600 seems to just sit unused. And, I still can't get to 800 very well.

My buddy shoots Nikon with their 180-400 f4 and built-in TC1.4 on a Z9 with an adapter. That is one heavy ass setup (lens 7.7lbs) but it produces great results. Flipping a switch select TC is sweet as it's quick and doesn't allow dust intrusion. Additionally, he uses the 800PF. This is kinda ideal, maybe?

When will Sony consider these for us (built-in TC and/or a light 800) ?!!!

---
Jeff
Oct 04, 2026 at 01:13 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #14100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
jlambros wrote:
This is really a great thread, especially for us airshow shooters. Even with these latest lens releases, it still seems that there is no "perfect" solution. It's always a compromise.


That is a key understanding that applies more generally to essentially all decisions about photographic equipment — every purchase involves compromises of some sort, and there is no perfect choice.

That reality is not a bad thing, and it actually helps with decision-making a lot once you understand it. Rather than searching in vain for “perfect,” you learn to analyze your own needs and balance the pluses and minuses to find the best compromise for you.
Oct 04, 2026 at 08:59 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #15100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
gdanmitchell wrote:
jlambros wroteThis is really a great thread, especially for us airshow shooters. Even with these latest lens releases, it still seems that there is no "perfect" solution. It's always a compromise.
That is a key understanding that applies more generally to essentially all decisions about photographic equipment — every purchase involves compromises of some sort, and there is no perfect choice.

That reality is not a bad thing, and it actually helps with decision-making a lot once you understand it. Rather than searching in vain for “perfect,” you learn to analyze your own needs and balance the pluses and minuses to find the best compromise for you.


Great points here. “The balance of pluses and minuses” = a lot of possible solutions for “x is best for me,” depending on who the me is.

It wasn’t that long ago in photography that lenses now considered “marginal performers” would have been lauded as “best evers.”

We can make it lighter weight, we can make it better optically, we can make it cheaper, pick any two… But today in some cases we’re getting all three.
Oct 04, 2026 at 09:07 AM
davidsee
Offline
Details
p.2 #16100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
I just shot a college football game with my 100-400. I am 69 years old and after a lifetime of shooting, I am a working pro, my body hurts. I had the 70-200 on another body on my shoulder, but relaized I wasnt shooting it, at the end of the first half I put it away and just ran with the 100-400 it worked great I missed nothing, the game started at 5:30 plenty of daylight I had a 1.4 on it better then the 200-600 quality wise. the second half I used the crop mode a bit. I strongly advise go as light as you can.
Oct 04, 2026 at 10:08 AM
mslino
Offline
Details
p.2 #17100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
robert614 wrote:
Hey guys,

I’ve been considering picking one up. Mainly as an airshow lens. I’ve been using the 400-800mm recently, but 400mm at the wide end is often too long for many venues. Necessitating a second body with my Original 100-400mm GM

I was considering either the new 100-400 f4.5 + 1.4x as a single lens solution. Or a 300mm GM (which I already have) and a 600mm f6.3 GM on a second body as a lightweight 2 body option. I have owned the 200-600 in the past. While that is always an option, it’s more of a been there, done that
...Show more →

Hi There!

Take a look at this video Jan Wegener released today. He covered all aspects of recent and older Sony lenses for wildlife, which in some cases covers Air Show issues.

https://youtu.be/Kzoi8m8eEGc?si=W4abwRcVHS478L2A
Oct 04, 2026 at 12:02 PM
mslino
Offline
Details
p.2 #18100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
Hi everyone!

For anyone who does air shows, I think the Sony 200-600mm is a no-brainer; it's heavy, but it gives you, I'd say, 90% of the reach you need for shooting air shows. I had a bad copy of this lens, and it was frustrating. I sold it and bought the Sony 400-800mm, and now I'm using it with my 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6.
I'm very interested in buying the new 600mm f/6.3 to use with a 1.4x extender if I need more reach and to carry less weight than the 400-800mm.
Oct 04, 2026 at 12:27 PM
howard
Offline
Details
p.2 #19100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
mslino wrote:
Hi everyone!

For anyone who does air shows, I think the Sony 200-600mm is a no-brainer; it's heavy, but it gives you, I'd say, 90% of the reach you need for shooting air shows. I had a bad copy of this lens, and it was frustrating. I sold it and bought the Sony 400-800mm, and now I'm using it with my 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6.
I'm very interested in buying the new 600mm f/6.3 to use with a 1.4x extender if I need more reach and to carry less weight than the 400-800mm.


I don’t understand what you’re saying — you had a very bad and frustrating experience with the 200-600 but you say it’s a no-brainer.

Howard
Oct 04, 2026 at 12:53 PM
mslino
Offline
Details
p.2 #20100-400mm f4.5 owners: what’s the verdict?
howard wrote:
mslino wroteHi everyone!

For anyone who does air shows, I think the Sony 200-600mm is a no-brainer; it's heavy, but it gives you, I'd say, 90% of the reach you need for shooting air shows. I had a bad copy of this lens, and it was frustrating. I sold it and bought the Sony 400-800mm, and now I'm using it with my 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6.
I'm very interested in buying the new 600mm f/6.3 to use with a 1.4x extender if I need more reach and to carry less weight than the 400-800mm.
I don’t understand what you’re saying — you had a very bad and frustrating experience with the 200-600 but you say it’s a no-brainer.

Howard


My copy of the 200-600mm was too bad - not sharp at all - but the lens range is a no-brainer for air shows if you have a sharp copy. I rented one after selling my copy, and it was bad too. That's what I mean!
Oct 04, 2026 at 01:36 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister