old-gregg wrote:
EB-1 wrote
The trend towards smaller, lighter, and slower aperture lenses, many with with severe distortion and CA is sickening. I have the same attitude. For example, the smaller and slower Sony 24mm f/2.8G is the right lens for me because I value weight above all else, and I don't need fast aperture for wide angle. But its barrel distortion was so enormous, that I got the GM instead.
At the same time, when I am looking at software-corrected output from the G... and I see nothing wrong. The lens+software together produce great results, and yet I can't bring myself to own a lens like that. The contradiction is killing me.
Both optical and digital distortion correction will reduce image sharpness, although they do so for different reasons. Optical correction involves compromises in the optical design, while digital correction requires geometric warping and resampling of the image, which can reduce fine detail toward the edges.
A lens design is simultaneously trying to control spherical aberration, coma, astigmatism, chromatic aberration, field curvature, distortion and so on.
These don't behave independently so optimizing a design for very low distortion requires compromises elsewhere.
If the lens design accepts more distortion in order to achieve higher resolution, and then let software correct the distortion. It can still mean a net resolution gain.