My gut is that sample variation has improved for all the major manufacturers. Once we hit 30MP+ sensors, people started paying much more attention to sample variation. But I haven't really seen anything concrete comparing brands. If anything, it semas like if a lens from a big brand has high sample variation at this point, it's model specific not brand specific.
Dunno whether sample variation actually has decreased - it most probably has.
But it is still way to high.
With all my acquired zoom lenses in recent years (except the Tamron 50-400 where I got lucky) I had to try at least one other copy, often 2, until the amount of decentering or tilt was acceptable.
I bet the camera companies know that most people don't pixel peep so that their calculation is simple: Dealing with some returns is much cheaper than a very meticulous centering control, and thus having a rather high sample variation is a central method to keep lens prices reasonable.
Most high grade zooms are around $3000 if not more so I'd assume people are fairly critical. Mid or lower grade zooms are probably more variable and have fewer mechanical adjustments internally. IME fixed length lenses are more reliable for maintaining alignment.
Overall, I am fairly forgiving of distortion as long as the images look good after correction. Some lenses definitely push into unacceptable territory, though, and it usually shows in the final images.
Unfortunately, no one has figured out how to map Sony distortion profiles to Nikon yet, so distortion does play a factor in some of my lens selections, as severe lens distortion can mess up framing, and especially mess up video. For example I would be happy with the Sigma 20-200mm f6.3 on a Sony camera, but won't buy it to adapt to a Nikon Z camera.
DWOfPaul wrote:
...
Bokeh - Has gotten smoother
...
Vignetting - Has gotten much worse overall. We seem to be accepting a bout a stop more now with digital corrections
....
I'm not sure about the Bokeh. Awareness by users and manufacturers has certainly increased, relative to say 20 years ago. Recently I've come to think that the quality of bokeh (specifically softness of bokeh behind the plane of focus, ie so as not to distract) plays second fiddle to 'sharpness' as this seems to be the case with the latest generation of lenses (ie Sony 85 GMII and Sigma 35mm f/1.2 DG II being the most notable recent examples). I might be wrong here, and hope so. The Sony 50/1.2GM has superb soft bokeh, the Sony 35/1.4 is similar (but not as soft), the 55/1.8 ZA is certainly excellent compared with older lenses. Yes, modern lens bokeh is often a priority, and it should be, where it probably wasn't in the past. I wonder if that's because the complex lens designs of cine lenses are inspirations for still lenses, which are (virtually) never simple lens designs any more.
Vignetting is definitely a problem, you can only recover so much from the dark corners of a file. A have an 40+ year old Konica Hexanon 24/2.8(V2) which vignettes enough to make it difficult to recover corners at times, shame because it's superb otherwise. Modern lenses are starting to push the limits of what's acceptable, imho.
Interestingly but not widely known, is that vintage lenses (so called) containing plenty of lead, as in 25-55% by weight, and collectively they presently make up 10-30% of lenses used in Hollywood - depending on the source.
Cinematographers and DPs are doing everything they can to hold on to these lenses from several makers, prominently Zeiss and Canon, hence the prices they go for despite being fifty years old.
They have fantastic depth to the images, with wonderful bokeh. Zeiss Super Speeds - only six lenses - in good shape go for $100,000 a set. No one in regular stills photography seems to care about optics, but I'm happy to inform readers. It's an interest of mine, part of an obsession for optics in our lenses.
The modern trend in stills bokeh is to have a lot of widely distributed background blur with little differentiation inside the bokeh field - its all heavy blur and reviewers are still happy to say that is the 'best bokeh (!). Subjects appear as cutouts superimposed over the blur field. There is no context at all, ultra blurry shapes inhabit the background.
People don't like it in the cine world and nor do audiences, because it is so artificial and combined with super sharp subjects it looks clinical and unreal as in 'not real'. Ironically, a major offender today is Zeiss itself, but they are now changing their errant ways, with new ranges like Aatma.
The best part for people like me is that the Super Speeds appeared at the same time as the main CY lenses. I have six of those, 21mm-28mm-35-70mm-100-300mm-50mm-100mm. They share coatings, glass compositions and even designs with the legendary Super Speeds, which were Stanley Kubrick's 'go to' lenses in Raging Bull, The Shining, Full Metal Jacket and Eyes Wide Shut. They are lush and rich - perfect for cinema and bloody good for stills too.
If you have ever seen one of these movies, the sheer optical quality jumps out at you, or it should. They contain (widely considered) to be very high impact imagery. With everyone at the top of their game, many rate Zeiss ahead of everyone else.
By the way, the Super Speeds share the same simple designs (they came out in 1975) as the Contaxes and only the Distagons have 10 and 11 elements. The 50mm shown in the video below below is a 7/6 design. Leica's SL APO-Summicron 50mm f2 is a 12 elements in 10 groups design, for comparison. The Nikon 50/1.8 S is a 12 elements in nine groups. So that is the formula for the modern cutout look, for the super sharp lenses stills people crave and even make judgements on how much 'sharpness' lenses have - the more the better! Only the Leica M world is different, even then many want the high sharpness look.
The bokeh quality on Zeiss Super Speed lenses is considered characterful, expressive, and distinctively vintage rather than classically "smooth" or "clinical".
You might spend six minutes on this video, if vintage bokeh quality is in doubt, in some way, to your mind:
..
philip_pj wrote:
Interestingly but not widely known, is that vintage lenses (so called) containing plenty of lead (...)
They have fantastic depth to the images, with wonderful bokeh.
(...)
The modern trend in stills bokeh is to have a lot of widely distributed background blur with little differentiation inside the bokeh field - its all heavy blur and reviewers are still happy to say that is the 'best bokeh (!). Subjects appear as cutouts superimposed over the blur field. There is no context at all, ultra blurry shapes inhabit the background.
(...)
How often do you actually intend to keep spreading your tall tales here? Don't you get bored of it at some point?
Statements as utterly idiotic as "the bokeh of modern lenses blurs everything" really get on my nerves.
You shape the bokeh to your own liking by deliberately and purposefully selecting an aperture that suits the subject and the subject distance.
A lens doesn't have just *one* specific bokeh.
These really are the absolute basics that even a beginner can be expected to be familiar with.