p.7 #1What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
It's a good subject for debate, points to either side.
I feel that sharpness intervenes once it is past a certain level, more-or-less what 20/20 vision gives us.
So over-sharpness in some instances places a distraction over the image as it is viewed, one that stops the viewing and steals focus from the image. Forgive me for saying so, but the LoCA search in reviews is cult behaviour, if you need 100% of 61mp to see it.
There is no question the excess sharpness works great for many subjects, but being of a suspicious mind, it may be no coincidence that the sharpness craze correlated in time with the loss of interest in photographing regular human beings in regular settings - not of the over-lit artificiality of portraits people pay for. Many modern lenses make women look horrible. They dislike it, Fred's wife included. Females in my life too, ones I shoot on the streets.
Lenses from the mainstream are no longer made for people photography, that is why the Canon forum is full of EF chat, and why the vintage lenses are so popular in Hollywood. Why Nikon made the f1/4 series for Z, why people love the 40/1.2 CV and old M lenses, the 58/1.4 from CV and Nikon. Some know what has been lost.
Correct sharpness levels appear to let the lens express other attributes more easily, by 'inviting' the viewer into the image, to merge their vision with the imagery. This is what many refer to when they describe imagery as 'cinematic'. It's a kind of visual flow across, and into the image. You don't see it in APO lenses' images, that's why so few people images are shot with them. So from this angle, sharpness is in the 'be careful what you wish for' category.
And yes, it challenges the tech-first review process so beloved of reviewers to the point they emphasis it over the actual images produced. It's easy to lose touch with your user base when you are in charge of what they have to use. I call this 'cultural herding', you can instil a fashion in the arts easily, witness the Hunter Biden art fiasco. Most modern art, in fact.
Tech can go too far in many fields, and people are uncomfortable with it. Zeiss have admitted this, by the way. I'm far from a voice in the wilderness on this. cheers. PS it's not audio, vision is something far more subtle, less technological. More is not better.
p.7 #3What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
philip_pj wrote:
What happens though, with such lenses, is that the viewer is forced to notice the extreme sharpness as having greater priority and importance than the image itself. The lens's acutance actually usurps the photo as the main attraction. The Sigma Syndrome is very popular.
that...that's not how photography works.
Mark Hamill told a story on Late Night with Seth Meyers where he lamented that his hair was not always wet between shots in a scene in Star Wars where Luke and the gang are trapped in a trash compactor, breaking continuity to which Harrison Ford responds "if the audience is looking at your hair, we are in a lot of trouble"
Basically if people are noticing the sharpness over anything else, your image is shitty to begin with; it's a skill issue.
p.7 #4What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
philip_pj wrote:
Many modern lenses make women look horrible. They dislike it, Fred's wife included. Females in my life too, ones I shoot on the streets.
what in god's name is that statement? why does it have to be just women? probably not your intent, but it rubs the wrong way on so many levels. I'm going to say it again: it's not the lens, it's the photographer. A shitty portrait taken with a Leica 90mm APO SL replaced with any vintage 85mm lens will result in that same shitty portrait, regardless of gender.
p.7 #6What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Sharpness is one variable and we've got 7 pages on the subject, jeez.
FWIW the 40 ART is about the sharpest I've currently got and it's about to be traded in
Acceptable sharpness, distortion, flare handling, rendering, bokeh, AF/MF, AF performance if relevant, weight, handling these are the choices we make
p.7 #7What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
There are nuanced aspects to it. ARRI and Zeiss have been down this road for many years, I think it's fair to say that opinions on the need for the sharpest of lenses are still unresolved, even among the best people at the top of the cine field. These are people shooting investors' money well into eight figures over a matter of weeks. Some of them feel they need it.
In our neck of the optical woods, Leica's chief Peter Karbe is of the same opinion, hence all the super-sharp SL lenses. Not so many enthusiasts seem to desire them over their M lenses, even with the M optics costing up to twice the price they have to pay. I count this as a rare display of common sense and good taste.
"Based on recent market breakdowns and internal sales data shared by Leica Rumors, the approximate percentage split of interchangeable lenses sold leans heavily toward the Leica M system, capturing roughly 77% of the combined interchangeable lens volume, compared to about 23% for Leica SL lenses."
We will hopefully one day be able to see the complexity of images in other ways and with other contributing factors to 'image quality'. A similar quandary exists for bokeh, which was incidentally only popularised in the 1990s by a photo mag editor. Smoother does not equal 'better' bokeh, just as sharper does not equal 'better' image quality!
ALL lens makers know how to produce these ultra sharp lenses, but some have the good sense and taste to make well-rounded lenses instead. They actually de-tune them in design, just like they leave other aberrations such as minimal CA inside their products. Deliberately. cheers.
p.7 #8What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Obviously the requirements for cine are quite different from stills, but the last thing I want is for still images to look like a movie. Video has contaminated cameras far too much already.
There are plenty of lenses that are not so sharp from center to corner. "Ultrasharp lenses" are not too common already at r=15 and many are rather weak at r=18, especially over the whole zoom range.
p.7 #9What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
I don't know a lot about photography overall, but this argument is no different then many others in various hobbies or interests. It's more about using the right too for the job and realizing photography is an art, which means that beauty is 100% in the eye of the beholder.
You shouldn't use a 10lb hammer on finishing nails, nor an F1 racecar for daily driving comfort and fuel efficiency. Most would likely not prefer a softer rendering lens for macro work, nor a razor sharp lens for portraits. But in the hands of the right person, they can make either work.
p.7 #10What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
I find the idea of sharpness being, under most any circumstances, excessive, let alone detrimental to the image, ludicrous. unless, of course, the shooter is aiming for a deliberately soft look, but this is solved by using specialty filters or coatings if the shooter in question knows what they are doing. I'm not talking about the cases where a wrong thing is in sharp focus, of course, like a carpet/tapestry on the wall behind the actual intended subject.
And the answer to the original question: the honor probably goes to the Tamron 85mm f/1.8. But then again most of lenses, even very old ones, are faring much better when put in front of the Z9 sensor. :-) (note that I've never bought any of the lenses known for being flawed in the IQ department, either because of design limitations or deliberate under designing, like Canon EF 50/1.2, Nikon 35/1.4 Z etc.)
p.7 #12What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
EB-1 wrote:
Obviously the requirements for cine are quite different from stills, but the last thing I want is for still images to look like a movie. Video has contaminated cameras far too much already.
There are plenty of lenses that are not so sharp from center to corner. "Ultrasharp lenses" are not too common already at r=15 and many are rather weak at r=18, especially over the whole zoom range.
EBH
Can you explain the difference between a still image that looks like a movie and what you consider an ultimate image from a still camera.
p.7 #13What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
'Movies are composed of a series of individual still images (called frames) shown rapidly in succession to create the illusion of continuous motion.' Many of the better ones were shot by former stills photographers, such as Stanley Kubrick, who famously used Contax-era Zeiss lenses. You see the same in 20c European cinema - every frame looks beautiful.
APO (and near APO) lenses - characterless, sterile lenses featuring wall-to-wall sharpness - are in the middle of a craze period. We see Light Lens Lab as just one firm now making a dedicated range of them. We see full ranges of super-sharp Leica APO lenses for Leica M and SL mounts.
Viltrox just released two APOS at reasonable prices, Cosina currently markets no fewer than ten APOs for M-mount. What do people use them for? Upshots of buildings, street grunge, statues, plants, cars and bikes, bric-a-brac, B&W. Not people, or anything requiring subtlety. Not even many landscapes, because they render flat. I'm a reformed smoker on the issue too.
Sharpness is not a race with rewards going to the winner. Some people can't shake the addiction, so the dealers feed their habit. They will be rehabilitated at some stage. What's happening simultaneously is that a huge number of stills photographers want more from their imagery than the final percentage point of 'sharpness'. In reply to the inquiry:
How strong is the desire for the cinematic look in stills photography?
We receive this response:
'The desire for a cinematic look in stills photography is incredibly strong and currently experiencing an explosion in popularity. Driven by digital fatigue, a longing for emotional authenticity, and the influence of social media platforms, photographers are aggressively moving away from hyper-polished, clinically perfect digital images toward story-driven, evocative frames that mimic the mood of a film still.
The craving for the cinematic aesthetic is less about technical perfection and more about psychological immersion. This aesthetic is heavily dominating popular genres today, particularly in street photography, portraiture, travel, and high-end wedding photography, where clients actively seek out photographers who can make their real lives look like a Hollywood film production.'
Sharpness is not like crack, where you can never get enough of the drug - it's more like a fine wine over dinner. There is a threshold above which the effect becomes unpleasant and unnatural. Unless you are designing for NASA or surveillance outfits.
p.7 #14What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Philip I really cherish your comments and have tried to observe what you describe with words. Unfortunately I still have to see -side by side - in two comparative images depicting the same subject (person or landscape) under identical light to see what you mean. I‘m really trying, and I‘m definitely not being dismissive to your thoughts, but I have just not yet become aware of any rigid comparisons supporting your view, comparisons of the kind Fred presents in other circumstances.
I have specialized in stage photography. Personally I only use Voigländer‘s Apo Lanthars (28-35-50-65mm) for concert photography of musicians and I have NEVER been told that my images were clinical.
In personal use I find the images I get from the Apo Lanthars most malleable in post. Both for showing the intimacy of the performing musicians and for capturing the mood of the event. In addition the Apo Lanthars often allow more cropping than shots made with other lenses, without the image falling appart.
In addition, their exceptionally high correction of longitudinal chromatic aberation (LOCA) is a real bon for avoiding color errors before and behind the plane of focus, or color artefacts within the sparkles on shiny brass instruments even under harsh stage lighting.
Suprisingly, even their bokeh isn‘t that bad, considering their Apo designation. Some former Nikon lenses show much stronger „ring“ enhancements in the disperging disks of point light sources before and behind the plane of focus. Clearly Voigtländer is paying attention to the bokeh even in their Apo Lanthars, despite other lenses being better in this specific regard.
p.7 #15What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Knut. wrote:
Philip I really cherish your comments and have tried to observe what you describe with words. Unfortunately I still have to see -side by side - in two comparative images depicting the same subject (person or landscape) under identical light to see what you mean. I‘m really trying, and I‘m definitely not being dismissive to your thoughts, but I have just not yet become aware of any rigid comparisons supporting your view, comparisons of the kind Fred presents in other circumstances.
I have specialized in stage photography. Personally I only use Voigländer‘s Apo Lanthars (28-35-50-65mm) for concert photography of musicians and I have NEVER been told that my images were clinical.
In personal use I find the images I get from the Apo Lanthars most malleable in post. Both for showing the intimacy of the performing musicians and for capturing the mood of the event. In addition the Apo Lanthars often allow more cropping than shots made with other lenses, without the image falling appart.
In addition, their exceptionally high correction of longitudinal chromatic aberation (LOCA) is a real bon for avoiding color errors before and behind the plane of focus, or color artefacts within the sparkles on shiny brass instruments even under harsh stage lighting.
Suprisingly, even their bokeh isn‘t that bad, considering their Apo designation. Some former Nikon lenses show much stronger „ring“ enhancements in the disperging disks of point light sources before and behind the plane of focus. Clearly Voigtländer is paying attention to the bokeh even in their Apo Lanthars, despite other lenses being better in this specific regard....Show more →
p.7 #16What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
My sharpest lens is the Micro-Nikkor-P.C. 55mm f3.5 factory ai'd - I tried two ai versions, and the f2.8 ais, but the oldest was the sharpest. All four of them were excellent, and sharp. The ai'd one was $40 off ebay.
p.7 #17What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
I was wondering if anyone has used the Zeiss CP.2 or CP.3 Compact Prime lenses, which are available for all major brands and come in focal lengths 15, 18, 21, 28, 35, 50, and 85? I've heard that they are amazingly sharp, even sharper then then the Opus lenses, but they cost more then the Opus. They're both cinema and still lenses, but I've only heard amazing things about the level of sharpness and picture quality. I guess if you're going to have one lens, this might be the one?
p.7 #18What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Without a doubt for Full Frame in the lenses I have owned or tried, the sharpest edge to edge, with the least aberrations edge to edge, and the least chromatic aberrations, is the Leica 35mm APO-SL lens. This is true for both the MTF charts and in actual usage. Probably the best Full Frame lens ever made. Peter Karber is insistent that it is the single best lens Leica has ever made in its long history. This is closely followed by the rest of the APO-SL lenses. Each of which could likely make the same claim if the 35mm didn't exists. Especially true when shot wide open at f/2.0 .They are the reason to own a high mpx SL camera body.