fredmiranda.com Login

RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)

  
 
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.7 #1RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
aCuria wrote:
Jack Flesher wroteWe seem to be veering OT, but I feel the need to say my piece -- or peace

The reality of differing sensor sizes as respects ISO noise, DoF and diffraction is this, paraphrased from about the best article on it I've ever read -- I believe the source was a DPR article:

The reality is that at the same subject, shutter, aperture diameter and angle of view, you get essentially the same results, independent of sensor size.

Note that aperture DIAMETER varies with format for any given f-stop at the same AoV's for each format, so we're not talking equivalent aperture, but rather the same aperture diameters for a given FoV on said format...

Next point on ISO noise is that down-rezzing higher rez sensors improves net noise as it averages out the noise present on each sq mm of sensor. So if I look at the current best noise FF camera listed at 12mp, if I downrez my 67mp A7R6 file to a net of 12mp, the final noise levels will be extremely close, assuming same ISO, lens and image were used for the initial capture. Veering more OT, there's also some argument that if I apply NR to the full 67mp file before downsizing, I can theoretically obtain a superior result to the base 12mp cams. Others argue this comes at the cost of some finer details potentially disappearing. FWIW...
“ The reality is that at the same subject, shutter, aperture diameter and angle of view, you get essentially the same results, independent of sensor size.”

We are going even more OT but this quote is not entirely correct.

At the same MP count M43 pixels are 1/4 the area of FF, so it hits the nyquist limit first. Adding more MP is useless past the nyquist limit, so M43 will always have 1/4 the useful MP of FF.


Yes. Again, aperture DIAMETER, not actual aperture is the salient point. To be clear, total sensor size does not change the math of the Nyquist limit. In this, yes two different physical sensors with identical 3.8 μm pixel sizes share the exact same theoretical Nyquist limit. So an M43 at 15mp has the same Nyquist as a 60mp FF.

If we overlay the curves of noise, DoF, Nyquist and total resolution against format size on top of each other, the advantages AND disadvantages of each sensor become more obvious. In my case, APSC was pushing up against the ISO wall already, though did gain some added DoF for a given compared to FF while losing limited DoF opportunity -- I wrongly assumed I could live with that tradeoff... Conversely, Medium Format pushes up against diminishing DoF wall a bit too significantly, to the point FF becomes sweeter *for my needs.*

Irony for sure, but in that last comment I could actually make a case for using higher resolution APSC for good light landscape images due to net DoF gains at essentially zero noise or DR cost; and wanting FF for travel and street due to superior lower light performance; but of course now we run into the relative size quotient. No free lunch...
Sep 07, 2026 at 10:56 AM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.7 #2RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
aCuria wrote:
johnvanr wrote
aCuria wrote
johnvanr wrote
aCuria wrote
johnvanr wroteI’ve shot tens of thousands of shots with MFT and the relatively narrower dynamic range has never been an issue. And my MFT gear can warn me when I’m about to blow the highlights, while my Canons can’t.

Granted, I’m not one to seek details in the shadows.

Noise used to be the biggest issue, but that’s gone with the great noise reduction software.

The relative difference in DoF goes both ways. For travel, I’m fine with MFT’s DoF.

I shoot all formats, btw. About to give up APS-c.
That’s an odd way to put it. If dynamic range has truly never been an issue, then you wouldn’t need a warning telling you when you’re about to exceed it in the first place.
That doesn’t make sense. It’s just a highlight warning. Leica’s have them as well, to warn against overexposure.
That’s the contradiction. You’re saying dynamic range has never been an issue, then immediately citing a feature you use to warn you when you’re about to exceed the sensor’s dynamic range. If the limit genuinely never mattered, there would be nothing to warn you about.

Take a simple example: you meter an 18% grey card to establish the correct exposure for the subject. If, at that exposure, the white dress exceeds the sensor’s highlight limit and clips, then the scene requires more dynamic range than the sensor provides at that ISO. You can underexpose to save the dress, but now you’re shifting the problem toward the shadows.

If you have time to slowly compose the shot, sure, you can watch the warning and adjust the exposure until the clipping disappears. But if you’re capturing a spontaneous moment, you may not get that opportunity. The dress may already be irretrievably clipped by the time you see the warning.

A camera with more dynamic range gives you more exposure latitude and reduces the chance of losing either highlights or shadows in the first place.

Alternatively, you can ask all your subjects to get a spray tan and wear dark clothes. That should solve the dynamic-range problem too. /s
Every sensor has a limit to its dynamic range. Several brands offer blinkies to warn when that range is exceeded. I think my 100mp Fuji does as well. That feature has nothing to do with limitations of dynamic range.

And as I said, I never found the dynamic range of my MFT gear limiting to my photographic needs. There are other reasons I don't exclusively use MFT, but that's not it.

There is no need for your sarcasm.
only the “spray” part is sacarsm (you need a real tan not spray, spray looks orange)

I have and do get the kids to wear clothes darker than their skin tone.

Why don’t you share why you don’t use M43 exclusively?


I’ve shared the latter repeatedly on the forums here. I use my GFX100s 99% in panoramic or 1x1 modes, so I crop a lot. Using a 100mp to start with, I still have plenty left in the end.

I use Canon FF because I like to do model shoots with my RF50mm f/1.2 and prefer Canon’s eye AF over OM System’s. I also like using alt lenses at their intended focal lengths, so I use them on my R8 and R5 now that there are good adapters for both. I’m selling my Leica M11, because I don’t need its resolution, even though its dynamic range is awesome. I also use my R5 with the 100mm macro to scan my negatives, for which I prefer 45 mp over 20 mp.

I have Fuji APS-c but I’m selling it soon, because it offers no benefit over MFT for me.
Sep 07, 2026 at 11:05 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.7 #3RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Well, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...
Sep 07, 2026 at 11:23 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.7 #4RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Cliff L. wrote:
Well, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...


Luckily for me I don't have to decide.....I love both systems!!
Sep 07, 2026 at 11:26 AM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.7 #5RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)


Cliff L. wrote:
Well, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...


Welcome to my world. 😀
Sep 07, 2026 at 11:30 AM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.7 #6RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Cliff L. wrote:
Well, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...


I pretty much think between Canon and Sony it’s a wash. IQ will be fine either way, so it comes down to ergonomics and lens choices.

And I doubt OP is going to find anything in FF that he actually wants to carry around when he travels.
Sep 07, 2026 at 11:49 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.7 #7RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
snegron7 wrote:
Cliff L. wroteWell, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...
Welcome to my world. 😀


I read your Tokyo thread again. I thought that the RF 24-105/4 and R6MKII are perfect for travel. Anyway, I only worry about weight in case they need to weigh my carry-on luggage or backpack so I think my RF 24-70/2.8 L IS should be OK with the R6MKII and vertical grip.
Sep 07, 2026 at 12:14 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.7 #8RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
snegron7 wrote:
Cliff L. wroteWell, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...
Welcome to my world. 😀


Allow me to make this patently easy for both of you. The primary decision YOU have to make for YOURSELF is system size and weight limits for travel and street vs say landscape, sports, wildlife, or lifestyle. Once you have that cemented, here's my view after years of shooting travel, street, lifestyle and landscape with a multitude of systems from M43 through medium format digital.

M43. You'll make nice "postcard" style images in good light with this system. It won't do shallow DoF or lower light evening outdoors or travel indoors like old churches and such. And why this became a non-option for me.

APSC. You'll again make wonderful postcard style travel images, and fare a bit better in lower light, but still not really great at really low light or shallow DoF looks or styles if that's what you're after. Size is nice compared to Canon and Nikon top tier FF, but this advantage is reduced significantly when Sony FF enters the discussion.

MF. Wonderful files, wonderful ability to render DoF styles, arguably the best landscape files you could wish for *as long as you're willing to accept the obvious at 100% diffraction that has crept in after f9.* Not so great at higher ISO, superwide glass, super long glass or faster action needs.

FF. The dreamland of options for everything from super wide to super long, to low light, to wide aperture, shallow DoF, to sweeping, extended DoF landscapes, to fast action and wildlife across all focal lengths. For travel can be heavyish and/or largish compared to APSC.

BUT here Sony has some options Canon and Nikon* don't... IF I couldn't take the weight of a Sony A7R5/6 and smaller f4 zooms and f1.8 primes for travel, I would get an A7CR or A7Cii. The last two with a few f4 zooms are essentially the same size and weight as the Fuji XT5/XH2 cams with their f2.8 zooms. And in the case of superwide, the Tamron FF 12-20/2.8 is a bit smaller and lighter than the Fuji 8-16/2.8 zoom; Sony's f4 70-200 OSS ii is about the same size and weight as the Fuji 50-150/2.8 zoom; and finally the Sony 20-70/4 is about the same size as the newer 16-55/2.8 Fuji zoom; so for the most part this becomes a net sum game where the difference is FF vs APSC. And for me, FF wins 8 days a week.
(*To be fair, Nikon has the Z7ii at about the same weight as the Sony A7R6, but the lenses are all significantly larger. In Nikon's corner however is the outstanding 24-105 zoom, so with that lens alone, it could be a worthy competitor to my Sony choice for travel -- assuming one is willing to put aside several camera function shortfalls compared to the Sony A7R6.)

In my case, the Sony A7R6 with battery and media is 198 gm heavier than the A7Cii. While not trivial, I carried both over my shoulder with the same lenses in the bag for a few extended days of shooting. The weight difference was not really all that noticeable, though surprisingly the size difference was more so; not hugely but there, and more importantly in the end for me, not enough for me to want to give up the newer cameras EVF, exquisite files and enhanced battery life. Add in dual card support and redundancy, and it was an easy decision for me to sell off the A7Cii.

There you have it in a nutshell. Yes, I am claiming FF in general for the broadest flexibility. Moreover, I am claiming Sony FF size and performance superiority for travel in the A7Cxx line; and if you can handle the extra bit of size and weight, I will go on record stating the A7R6 may as close to the ideal "all-around" camera body I have ever owned period...

And yeah, I know some of you won't like me being so utterly direct and decisive here, so flame-suit donned

EDIT: I'm going to go one step further for the OP. Sell EVERYTHING you now have except the Sony Tamron zooms. Buy an A7R6 and an A7CR. Use them with your Tammy zooms and decide what if anything you want to expand on OR eliminate and do it. You should have plenty of cash left over to add a couple GM zooms and good primes and you will literally own the best of all worlds to cover YOUR stated desires. You'll have great lens range, a great body for travel, a great body for landscape, sports and wildlife AND a good backup body to the A7R6 in case you need it.

See, I told you this was easy



Edited on Sep 07, 2026 at 01:03 PM · View previous versions
Sep 07, 2026 at 12:34 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.7 #9RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Cliff L. wrote:
Well, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...


I can personally help you out there. Drop over here with your Canon gear.

As for the OP, every member on this site can give him their opinion, but he still won't know what to do, and will still complain about pretty well every brand and model out there.
Sep 07, 2026 at 01:03 PM
TheEmrys
Offline
Details
p.7 #10RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
You love your gear. Use a shoulder strap and call it a day. Neckstraps are way overrated unless it is a fixed focal body and/or a rangefinder.
Sep 07, 2026 at 01:19 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Surfnsun
Offline
Details
p.7 #11RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Can I suggest that you start selling stuff today right here on FredMiranda? This gear doesn't sell overnight and it looks like you're going to have lots of conversations through PM and trips to UPS ahead of you! Good luck with that. don't overthink it.
Sep 07, 2026 at 01:37 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.7 #12RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Jack Flesher wrote:
APSC. You'll again make wonderful postcard style travel images, and fare a bit better in lower light, but still not really great at really low light or shallow DoF looks or styles if that's what you're after. Size is nice compared to Canon and Nikon top tier FF, but this advantage is reduced significantly when Sony FF enters the discussion.


I’m going to disagree (collegially) with Jack on his description of the capabilities of APS-C.

First, though, I’ll agree that FF has capabilities in areas that are a bit more limited by APS-C. Objectively speaking, 40MP is not 66MP. You can get a bit more bokeh at a given aperture. Low light performance of larger sensors is a bit stronger.

So, with no argument from me, FF pushes the performance envelope a bit further than FF. (Just as miniMF pushes it a bit further than FF, etc.)

However…

“… You'll again make wonderful postcard style travel images…”

Well, yes. You can do that with any camera, from your smartphone on up to a Fujifilm GFX system. But I strongly disagree that APS-C is limited to just “postcard style” images.

I’ve sold prints of and licensed a number of APS-C images (in some cases with lesser cameras than the most recent from Fujifilm) and I’m dead serious that I am confident that my XT5 files will print with excellent quality at 20” x 30”. (Larger in some cases. I licensed a slightly cropped APS-C monochrome image of a San Francisco architectural feature to a commercial user at a 44” height — and that was with an earlier Fujifilm camera.)

I regularly do urban night street and travel photography with my Fujifilm system and the results are WAY beyond “postcard” quality.

Now I”m not saying that the APS-C format is ideal for all kinds of photography. I rely on high MP FF gear for almost all of my landscape photography, for example. And while I have done some wildlife photography with my Fujifilm system, it has been less reliable for that than my FF gear.

If I had only a single system, these days it would likely be Sony, and probably based on the A7r6 and the A7CR, with the latter making a reasonably smaller and lighter option if equipped with the right lenses. But with two systems — not for everyone, but works for me — I’m sticking with my Fujifilm APS-C system for travel and street photography given its somewhat smaller size, its manual controls, and Fujifilm’s system of native lenses.

YMMV.


Alpine Lake, Morning

- - -


Meadowlark Song #2

- - -


Mountains, Morning Light

- - -


je suis bleu

- - -


Venice Restaurant, Evening




Edited on Sep 07, 2026 at 04:09 PM · View previous versions
Sep 07, 2026 at 02:05 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.7 #13RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
gdanmitchell wrote:
Jack Flesher wroteAPSC. You'll again make wonderful postcard style travel images, and fare a bit better in lower light, but still not really great at really low light or shallow DoF looks or styles if that's what you're after. Size is nice compared to Canon and Nikon top tier FF, but this advantage is reduced significantly when Sony FF enters the discussion.
I’m going to disagree (collegially) with Jack on his description of the capabilities of APS-C.

First, though, I’ll agree that FF has capabilities in areas that are a bit more limited by APS-C. Objectively speaking, 40MP is not 66MP. You can get a bit more bokeh at a given aperture. Low light performance of larger sensors is a bit stronger.

So, with no argument from me, FF pushes the performance envelope a bit further than FF. (Just as miniMF pushes it a bit further than FF, etc.)

However…

“… You'll again make wonderful postcard style travel images…”

Well, yes. You can do that with
...Show more →

I thought my comment might garner a collegial reply from you. You’re not wrong, but honestly neither am I. I’ll wait to hear further thoughts AFTER you get the A7R6.
Sep 07, 2026 at 02:40 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.7 #14RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
If you're trying to decide between systems, perhaps instead of concentrating on what you like about one system versus another, consider what you can't live without. Sony isn't the only system I use, though I do consider the e-mount primary and it will be the last to go for three reasons; the 70-200/4GII, the 300/2.8GM, and finding and potentially adjusting a whole new set of adapters sounds about as fun as getting a tooth pulled. While the last thing is something I'd like to avoid, the lenses are unique to the mount and useful enough to me to let them drive my camera purchases. I may envy specific lenses in other lines (both the RF 40/1.2 and Z 35/1.4 look like great inexpensive fun), but it's not terribly difficult to be content without them. So what's unique about your systems and how critical are those things to you?
Sep 07, 2026 at 03:23 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.7 #15RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
jojib wrote:
Cliff L. wroteWell, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...
Luckily for me I don't have to decide.....I love both systems!!


I do too, but... I would probably get out and shoot more if I didn't have to debate which kit to take.

Did I mention I also have a small Fuji kit?
Sep 07, 2026 at 05:59 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.7 #16RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Cliff L. wrote:
jojib wrote
Cliff L. wroteWell, one thing is for certain - seven pages in, and this thread has done nothing to help me decide whether to keep my Canon system or my Sony system...
Luckily for me I don't have to decide.....I love both systems!!
I do too, but... I would probably get out and shoot more if I didn't have to debate which kit to take.

Did I mention I also have a small Fuji kit?


And I forgot to mention too---I have the outstanding Fuji X100VI as well :-)
Sep 07, 2026 at 06:14 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.7 #17RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Imagemaster wrote:
I can personally help you out there. Drop over here with your Canon gear.



Just say the word...
Sep 07, 2026 at 06:17 PM
aCuria
Offline
Details
p.7 #18RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
ruthenium wrote:
aCuria wrote
ruthenium wrote
aCuria wrote
johnvanr wrote
snegron7 wroteI haven't printed in years except for the occasional prints I get whenever I test out a film camera that I buy.
So, why do you want large files? Is there something wrong with your OM-5 files from Japan?
I am not OP but dynamic range takes a hit on small sensor cameras.

This means its easy to blow out say a white dress.

For example, if the scene needs 7 stops of DR, you wont clip the dress until above ISO 4000+ on A7C but with OM-5 you will clip the dress above ISO 1600
I find it is easier to think about what you are saying by using photographic equivalence, rather than by referencing the dynamic range (because DR depends on the amount of light, whereas the principles of photographic equivalence explicitly assume the same amount of light in equivalent images).
Thus, the base ISO on my OM-1 II is 200, that is equivalent to ISO 800 on a full-frame camera. ISO 1600 is equivalent to ISO 6400 on FF. Indeed, ISO 1600 is a reasonable upper limit for micro-four-thirds systems. Understandably, the cameras do allow going higher in ISO, and good denoising can create an illusion of "noise doesn't matter" - but this is only an illusion.

Note that the problem with cropped sensor cameras is never(!) at the high ISO - it is ALL at the low ISO. Cropped sensor cameras can never capture the amount of light that a full-frame sensor can capture at the base ISO. For ANY high ISO on a full-frame camera, there's an equivalent ISO on a cropped sensor camera. For example, for ISO 12800 on a full-frame body, the same amount of light (for the same dynamic range) is captured at ISO 3200 by a micro-four-thirds sensor.
In other words, full-frame sensors offer no advantage in the high ISO range. It is a mistake to think that larger sensors can capture more light at high ISO. Their larger capacity for ligth can only be taken advantage of when the light is abundant, that is at or near the base ISO.
For low-light photography, which is where I run into the most dynamic-range limitations, I’ll be shooting the fastest available lenses wide open, typically at f/1.4 or brighter, regardless of system.

Photographic equivalence is only useful when an equivalent lens actually exists. To match a full-frame f/1.4 lens, M43 would require roughly an f/0.7 lens. In most relevant focal lengths, that lens simply doesn’t exist.

So in this particular use case, equivalence is largely irrelevant. I’m not going to stop the full-frame f/1.4 lens down to f/2.8 just to make the comparison equivalent. I’m going to shoot both systems with the fastest lens available, wide open. If one system can use f/1.4 while the other cannot offer the equivalent f/0.7, that practical advantage is precisely the point.
First, the "dynamic range" of a camera, at a given ISO, is a number calculated by dividing the signal (light captured by the sensor) by the noise originating from the camera. Thus, "For low-light photography, which is where I run into the most dynamic-range limitations" is a tautology (you say that for low light photography, you are limited by the amount of light).

This is correct that f/0.7 lenses (equivalent to full-frame f/1.4) don't exist. There is a series of manual-focus Voigtländer lenses (see the uploaded image) that offer equivalent f/1.9, and one is equivalent to full-frame f/1.6. The auto-focus MFT
...Show more →

93_04068 by acurian, on Flickr

2s exposure, handheld, A9iii, 100% crop

We seem to have gone down this line of argument before...

I can shoot handheld 2-second exposures just fine with the A9iii, so the claimed OM1 IBIS advantage may no longer exist.

Canon also claims 8.5 stops IBIS, exact same as OM1-II.

R5II (2024, 8.5 stops)
R1 (2024, 8.5 stops)
R6III (2025, 8.5 stops)


Sep 07, 2026 at 08:10 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.7 #19RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Does Sony really have that much of a weight advantage? Sure the a7 series is small and light but generally the equivalent lenses across systems with the same or similar focal length and aperture specs are very similar in size and weight. Where Sony may have an advantage for casual travel photography is the variety of super zoom options. Which is great if you want a single camera-lens combo and which might be exactly what the OP needs.

But is the Sony 70-200/4 smaller and lighter than the Canon 70-200/4, for example? Or the 28-70/2.8 options? Or in and around 16-28/2.8? While going with these gives up single-lens convenience and versatility, one also gains one to two stops where one can better exploit some aspects of FF, such as shallower DOF work, when desired. Or better light gathering capability vs. slow lenses and/or smaller formats.

I agree though that Canon hasn't really given small and light FF bodies much consideration beyond the RP/R8 bodies, which aren't exactly competing at the higher end, though the R8's guts are solidly mid-range and in some performance metrics outperform the Sony a7 non-R series. An R5II equivalent 'rangefinder' body style would be very interesting with a top left corner EVF.

In hindsight I think the OP would have benefitted from spending one of his shopping days in Japan at Yodobashi simply comparing every system under the sun for his carry requirements. And base his system decision first on which is most comfortable to carry with the lens(es) he most uses, regardless of sensor format. Point being that if a FF system is ultimately too heavy and will be left behind in the hotel during the latter stages of a trip, then it provides no benefit. OP might as well just use a phone in that case. So his decision to use the m43 system when the Canon became too heavy, seems to point to the solution given he's not printing or exhibiting large images and primarily shooting for personal satisfaction.
Sep 07, 2026 at 08:15 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.7 #20RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
aCuria wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
aCuria wrote
johnvanr wrote
aCuria wrote
johnvanr wroteI’ve shot tens of thousands of shots with MFT and the relatively narrower dynamic range has never been an issue. And my MFT gear can warn me when I’m about to blow the highlights, while my Canons can’t.

Granted, I’m not one to seek details in the shadows.

Noise used to be the biggest issue, but that’s gone with the great noise reduction software.

The relative difference in DoF goes both ways. For travel, I’m fine with MFT’s DoF.

I shoot all formats, btw. About to give up APS-c.
That’s an odd way to put it. If dynamic range has truly never been an issue, then you wouldn’t need a warning telling you when you’re about to exceed it in the first place.
That doesn’t make sense. It’s just a highlight warning. Leica’s have them as well, to warn against overexposure.
That’s the contradiction. You’re saying dynamic range has never been an issue, then immediately citing a feature you use to warn you when you’re about to exceed the sensor’s dynamic range. If the limit genuinely never mattered, there would be nothing to warn you about.

Take a simple example: you meter an 18% grey card to establish the correct exposure for the subject. If, at that exposure, the white dress exceeds the sensor’s highlight limit and clips, then the scene requires more dynamic range than the sensor provides at that ISO. You can underexpose to save the dress, but now you’re shifting the problem toward the shadows.

If you have time to slowly compose the shot, sure, you can watch the warning and adjust the exposure until the clipping disappears. But if you’re capturing a spontaneous moment, you may not get that opportunity. The dress may already be irretrievably clipped by the time you see the warning.

A camera with more dynamic range gives you more exposure latitude and reduces the chance of losing either highlights or shadows in the first place.

Alternatively, you can ask all your subjects to get a spray tan and wear dark clothes. That should solve the dynamic-range problem too. /s
I don't think this is right. The key variable for clipping with the camera is how much headroom the camera has when metering at 18% middle grey. I have seen exactly zero evidence that sensors with more dynamic range have more headroom. It is true that having more dynamic range will improve the shadows when highlights are protected, but that doesn't mean the camera will clip highlights less. Clipping highlights is all about exposure and not exposing too far to the right of the histogram.

And let's not forget about the role of the photographer in the process. If you have even a bit of experience and you know you are shooting a white dress (or a similar bight object) and you want to protect the highlights for that target, then you should know that the camera is not setting exposure for that object and you should be using exposure compensation. Clipping the highlights on an object you want to get proper exposure for is really an error of the photographer. You have to know what the camera does (exposes for 18% middle grey) and adjust the camera for the exposure you want. More dynamic range does give you more room in the shadows in this situation, but protecting the highlights you want is on the photographer. Clipped highlights of a feature you want should not be attributed the camera or the dynamic range of the sensor being used. It should be attributed to an error made by the photographer.

Now if you can't keep that dress from being blown out while at the same time getting the shadow details that you want, that cont be attributed to the dynamic range of the sensor, but there are many many times when you can easily avoid clipping highlights and have plenty of shadow detail as well even when shooting bright objects and if you clip the the highlights in those cases it is because the camera was not set properly not because of the camera or the sensor in the camera.
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55513834749_b18486b1de_b.jpgDACB8663 by acurian, on Flickr

This is example from 1D, ISO 3200, Straight out of camera.

DR Equivalent to OM5 ~ ISO 12,800, so if you shoot at ISO 12,800 you would have more or less the same problem

To avoid blowing the highlights here I probably have to dial in like -2 or -3 compensation maybe, but the shadows already look bad.

The problem is ultimately lack of DR at higher ISO. This is the biggest problem with 1D. It can beat modern cameras in other areas, for example the only Sony milc that can match 1/500s flash sync is A9iii, and it
...Show more →

Or rather than using ISO 12,800 on the OM-5 he can use a lens that has a two stop faster aperture, which is often available and have the same depth of field and have 2 stops better DR than the 1D. Yeah you pick up an extra stop of DR with the A7C cameras, but that isn't the same as this three stops worse DR shot that you linked. Nothing even close to that. Yes, the 1D with light that low has really bad DR, but even 2 stops more helps a lot with the shadows.

Note I am not advocating for the OM-5, I was just pointing out that DR is not at all about blowing the highlights like you discussed in the post I quoted. Not blowing the highlights that one cares about, is about getting the exposure right. DR is about the quality of the shadows when you get the exposure right. For some types of shooting that can matter, but even in your example any modern camera, as opposed to the 1D, would do pretty well with the shadows if the exposure is right. Of course good post-processing can help too.
Sep 07, 2026 at 08:40 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister