p.11 #1RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
People don't carry spare cameras for fear of camera failure, but to obtain greater flexibility and shot coverage and minimise lens and card swaps. You can mix resolutions, some bodies and some lenses shoot portraits better than others, others do landscapes better, others are small and nimble for cafes/interiors.
So you tailor your gig more accurately. It's the thinking behind near-identical bodies and lens in ranges - habit makes shooting faster. You can form a more intimate relationship with primes carefully designed by a master craftsman rather than a CAD zoom, and you get to know exactly what works for you, in time.
Examples: Street session: a light body with low Mp with a fast 75mm, a medium Mp camera with a 50mm, a coverall high res body with a great 28mm. Jeep work: a specialist 50mm on a high res body, a dreamy portrait lens for villagers. Mountains: a 14mm for tight rivers, a 28mm for more open, a 50mm for more compression. When you pick up a certain lens, your mind thinks with that focal length in mind. You never have to hold a large combo, or spaz at the controls.
Imagine the confidence you develop doing it this way. Six lenses, ~1800 grams, three bodies, 2000 grams. A small carry-on backpack, 30L size. It's a big world. Fortune favours the prepared mind. Luck is the nexus of preparation and opportunity.
p.11 #2RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
philip_pj wrote:
People don't carry spare cameras for fear of camera failure, but to obtain greater flexibility and shot coverage and minimise lens and card swaps. You can mix resolutions, some bodies and some lenses shoot portraits better than others, others do landscapes better, others are small and nimble for cafes/interiors.
So you tailor your gig more accurately. It's the thinking behind near-identical bodies and lens in ranges - habit makes shooting faster. You can form a more intimate relationship with primes carefully designed by a master craftsman rather than a CAD zoom, and you get to know exactly what works for you, in time.
Examples: Street session: a light body with low Mp with a fast 75mm, a medium Mp camera with a 50mm, a coverall high res body with a great 28mm. Jeep work: a specialist 50mm on a high res body, a dreamy portrait lens for villagers. Mountains: a 14mm for tight rivers, a 28mm for more open, a 50mm for more compression. When you pick up a certain lens, your mind thinks with that focal length in mind. You never have to hold a large combo, or spaz at the controls.
Imagine the confidence you develop doing it this way. Six lenses, ~1800 grams, three bodies, 2000 grams. A small carry-on backpack, 30L size. It's a big world. Fortune favours the prepared mind. Luck is the nexus of preparation and opportunity. ...Show more →
Nope. I disagree wholeheartedly with your statement "people don't carry spare cameras fir fear of failure." My first camera failed me in 1984. I was shooting a sporting event and dropped my Nikon FM2. From that moment on I learned to ALWAYS carry a backuo camera. Since then I've severa "primary" cameras fail me ranging from 35mm film cameras, mefium format film cameras, dslr's, and mirrorless cameras. Machines fail. Electronics fail. Not having a backup camera is foolish.
p.11 #3RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
philip_pj wrote:
People don't carry spare cameras for fear of camera failure, but to obtain greater flexibility and shot coverage and minimise lens and card swaps. You can mix resolutions, some bodies and some lenses shoot portraits better than others, others do landscapes better, others are small and nimble for cafes/interiors.
So you tailor your gig more accurately. It's the thinking behind near-identical bodies and lens in ranges - habit makes shooting faster. You can form a more intimate relationship with primes carefully designed by a master craftsman rather than a CAD zoom, and you get to know exactly what works for you, in time.
Examples: Street session: a light body with low Mp with a fast 75mm, a medium Mp camera with a 50mm, a coverall high res body with a great 28mm. Jeep work: a specialist 50mm on a high res body, a dreamy portrait lens for villagers. Mountains: a 14mm for tight rivers, a 28mm for more open, a 50mm for more compression. When you pick up a certain lens, your mind thinks with that focal length in mind. You never have to hold a large combo, or spaz at the controls.
Imagine the confidence you develop doing it this way. Six lenses, ~1800 grams, three bodies, 2000 grams. A small carry-on backpack, 30L size. It's a big world. Fortune favours the prepared mind. Luck is the nexus of preparation and opportunity. ...Show more →
I always bring a spare camera on trips, just in case the others fail. Just got back from a month away. Had my a7riv as spare, which never got used.
p.11 #4RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
I never take a spare camera with me other than my phone. For me photography when I travel is never about documenting the trip. It is about getting a chance to engage in some artistic expression and I love being able to do that when I travel. If my camera broke or wouldn't function I would lose that opportunity, but for me it wouldn't be the end of the world. There are lots of things I like to do when I travel and I would just do more of those things and save photography for the next trip, but that is just me and of course, YMMV.
p.11 #5RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Yeah me too, usually my spare is my iPhone 17 Pro Max. As a matter of fact it is the most important camera that I take for travel as I want to post pictures ASAP to my Facebook and Instagram.
p.11 #6RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
philip_pj wrote:
People don't carry spare cameras for fear of camera failure, but to obtain greater flexibility and shot coverage and minimise lens and card swaps.
Back when I was living in Calgary and making a good secondary income from stock photography, I took a 10-day trip out to the west coast of Vancouver Island. On the very first day, after a 15+ hour drive, I stopped at a trailhead in the park before getting to my hotel, and had my medium-format camera crash to the pavement off the top of my tripod. That was the last trip I ever took without a spare camera.
p.11 #7RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
To raise a related issue, some people think it's a choice - for non-pros - between enjoying the trip or doing their photography. Either/Or. I've always felt the photography enlivens the experience, breathes importance and emotion into it. You work harder at seeing, you feel more involved in the scene, not kind of floating through the location.
Thought I'd mention that, to kind of encourage people to get more from it, those that are not already doing it that way. cheers.
p.11 #8RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
philip_pj wrote:
To raise a related issue, some people think it's a choice - for non-pros - between enjoying the trip or doing their photography. Either/Or. I've always felt the photography enlivens the experience, breathes importance and emotion into it. You work harder at seeing, you feel more involved in the scene, not kind of floating through the location.
Thought I'd mention that, to kind of encourage people to get more from it, those that are not already doing it that way. cheers.
100%! There's a certain spontaneity that you can capture while visiting a place for the first time! When I go to a new, exotic (to me at least) place for the first time, I like to bring decent equipment to capture as much detail as possible. However, if it's my second or thrird time visiting, then I'll take a minimum amount of gear like my micro four thirds outfit.
p.11 #9RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
A long time ago I threw two cameras and a bunch of lenses in my bag. I have only ever used shoulder bags and cursed myself the entire trip. That hasn't happened again.
For many years now I carry one camera and two or three lenses on extended trips. These are not pure photography trips, but more like vacations where photography is half of the fun. So far I have not experienced a catastrophic camera failure, but if the worst happens I can always try to buy a new camera locally. Of course that depends on where I am. If it is not possible, the sun will still rise the next day.
p.11 #10RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Toothwalker wrote:
A long time ago I threw two cameras and a bunch of lenses in my bag. I have only ever used shoulder bags and cursed myself the entire trip. That hasn't happened again.
For many years now I carry one camera and two or three lenses on extended trips. These are not pure photography trips, but more like vacations where photography is half of the fun. So far I have not experienced a catastrophic camera failure, but if the worst happens I can always try to buy a new camera locally. Of course that depends on where I am. If it is not possible, the sun will still rise the next day.
You can only buy a new camera if you travel solely in megacities, in wealthy countries.
Bringing a small sony camera, for example, takes up very little space in the travel bag. For the DAY, you leave the extra camera behind. It only gets taken out if needed. Why would you carry around a backup body every single day?
p.11 #11RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Steve Spencer wrote:
I never take a spare camera with me other than my phone. For me photography when I travel is never about documenting the trip. It is about getting a chance to engage in some artistic expression and I love being able to do that when I travel. If my camera broke or wouldn't function I would lose that opportunity, but for me it wouldn't be the end of the world. There are lots of things I like to do when I travel and I would just do more of those things and save photography for the next trip, but that is just me and of course, YMMV....Show more →
Part of the fun for me is to take out cameras as I feel. And an extra sony camera takes up pretty much no space in the overall packing for a trip, so throwing it in doesn't prevent bringing anything else. There are days I don't bring out cameras, but it is something that certainly brings joy to me, and so redundancy just makes sense. A phone gives me no joy to use personally, and despite being younger than most here, I have no interest in social media. A phone gives me nothing useable.
p.11 #12RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
shadow9d9 wrote: Steve Spencer wroteI never take a spare camera with me other than my phone. For me photography when I travel is never about documenting the trip. It is about getting a chance to engage in some artistic expression and I love being able to do that when I travel. If my camera broke or wouldn't function I would lose that opportunity, but for me it wouldn't be the end of the world. There are lots of things I like to do when I travel and I would just do more of those things and save photography for the next trip, but that is just me and of course, YMMV.Part of the fun for me is to take out cameras as I feel. And an extra sony camera takes up pretty much no space in the overall packing for a trip, so throwing it in doesn't prevent bringing anything else. There are days I don't bring out cameras, but it is something that certainly brings joy to me, and so redundancy just makes sense. A phone gives me no joy to use personally, and despite being younger than most here, I have no interest in social media. A phone gives me nothing useable.
Like you a phone brings me no joy and I rarely use mine to shoot photos. I occasionally use it to document something but I don't consider it photography when I use my phone. For me an extra camera, however, is a step too far. I only bring about 2000g of photo gear when I travel so a backup camera I find adds too much weight and too much space. It would prevent me from bringing something else, but of course YMMV.
p.11 #14RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
snegron7 wrote:
My reason for my crossroad dilemma is that I really don't love my A7iv (uncomfortable ergonomics and the fact that I have to shoot 100% manual for every single situation because it doesn't work as efficiently in Aperture Priority + Auto ISO as my R6II does). However, it yields better images in terms of detail capture than my R6II, and the AF tracking is way better than on my R6II.
IMO ergonomics trumps image quality. Most of the lenses and bodies anymore are good enough for the vast majority of people's needs. Whereas, ergonomics tells us whether we want to actually take the cameras out.
I sold my Canon RP and got a 5Diii. The RP has a lot of specs that are vastly superior to the 5D, but the 5D feels so much better in hand. So much so, that I'm willing to eschew it all for what feels better.
p.11 #15RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
shadow9d9 wrote:
You can only buy a new camera if you travel solely in megacities, in wealthy countries.
Bringing a small sony camera, for example, takes up very little space in the travel bag. For the DAY, you leave the extra camera behind. It only gets taken out if needed. Why would you carry around a backup body every single day?
No, I would not carry around a backup body every single day. Sometimes I leave a lens in the hotel and when I am on a road trip in Norway I can put as much equipment in my car as I like. But ... I have only one camera at the moment and I will not buy a second one just in case. Besides, some of the extended trips are just with hand luggage where every item counts.
p.11 #16RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
I might have missed it in all these posts, but I would strongly consider a Q3 for travel/landscape/wide angle work. It is WR, has outstanding image quality and has a wonderful user interface (and phone app). They typically go for $5k on the used market.
p.11 #17RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
snegron7 wrote:
Disclaimer: Please do not read or respond to this post if you are easily annoyed/offended by questions about gear, or if you live by the mantra "just get out there and shoot", or "cameras/lenses are just tools". This Canon/Sony forum is about discussing gear and is not a platform for grumpy, rude, condescending trolls to criticize or belittle anyone who dares to ask questions about gear. Also, this is not about GAS. It's a legitimate question about gear.
So, here's my question/dilemma:
I'm at a crossroads regarding gear at this time. I currently have the following:
- Sony A7c
- Sony A7iv
- Tamron 17-28mm f2.8
- Tamron 20-40mm f2.8
- Tamron 28-200mm f2.8-5.6
- OM System OM-5
- OM System 45-150mm f4 Pro
- Olympus 30mm f3.5 Macro
- Olympus 60mm f2.8 Macro
- Pan/Leica 9mm f1.7
- Panasonic 12-35mm f2.8 G2
- Panasonic 17mm f2.5 G
- Way too many film cameras (35mm and 120) to list including bodies and lenses from Nikon, Canon, Pentax, Minolta, Konica, Mamiya.
My "crossroad" issue is if I should invest in either GM glass for my two Sonys, or L glass for my one Canon (I rarely use my 7dmk2 anymore). The lenses I'd like to get are the "trinity" lenses; 16-35mm f2.8 (or 15 to 35mm f2.8 if we're talking Canon), 24-70mm f2.8, and 70-200mm f2.8. My reason for my crossroad dilemma is that I really don't love my A7iv (uncomfortable ergonomics and the fact that I have to shoot 100% manual for every single situation because it doesn't work as efficiently in Aperture Priority + Auto ISO as my R6II does). However, it yields better images in terms of detail capture than my R6II, and the AF tracking is way better than on my R6II. As for my R6II, it weighs a bit too much for travel, and the L lenses will make it even heavier. I carried it attatched to my RF 24-105mm f4.0L while in Japan for two weeks, and I regretted it after the first few hours of walking with it.
If I had the money, I would probably ditch everything and go with a Leica rangefinder plus 3 lenses. But I don't have Leica money.
As you've probably guessed by now, I enjoy travel photography, but I also like to shoot wildlife when possible. I'm not a fan of heavy equipment, but I prefer FF over smaller sensors. Getting a new R8II to use with my tiny RF primes might not be a bad idea, but weather sealing is important to me. The tiny RF primes are not weather sealed, so that's a bit of an issue for me.
While I like the idea of investing in the "trinity" zooms for either Sony FE or Canon RF, I'm not opposed to doing a 3 prime lens option with either 3 fast Canon L primes or 3 fast Sony GM primes. But, it all boils down to which camera I tolerate the most since I don't absolutely love any one of them. I would hate to throw L or GM money into a system that would end up just irritating me further down the line. As for ditching everything and going with Nikon, that's not going to happen. I used to be a big Nikon fan for decades until they ditched the F mount and I was stuck with several dozen obsolete AF-D lenses. I reward companies that have zero customer loyalty with not buying their products ever again. Fujifilm might be an option, but APS-C as my main outfit is not appealing to me. Maybe their medium format cameras might be an option, but I don't know enough about them.
Respectful, non-dismissive, non-condescending, well thought out suggestions from actual members (not marketing influencers) are welcome. Thanks!
Edit: I forgot to add; my reason for wanting faster L or GM lenses is because I need durable, weather sealed lenses with good optical performance to use under all types of adverse conditions. ...Show more →
I'd liquidate gear that statistically you haven't used.
If I were in your position I'd sell off anything bought or released prior to Nov 2016.
I'd replace them with the latest and greatest.
RF bodies, lenses and accessories exceed their EF mount equivalents. If I get more keepers in spite of my greying hair then the better.
Instead of Sony though I'd go medium format with GFX and retain EF lenses that are compatible with it or go all in with GF lenses.
Buying gear is part of the fun of photography. If anyone has a problem with GAS then focus on your pocket & not the pocket of other responsible buyers.
p.11 #18RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Having lived in multiple camera ecosystems like you if I were going to simplify my kit and still be proud of it I would buy the R5 II and either go with the Canon trinity or if I were going to go with primes select three from the VCM f1.4 line up. The VCM's are very good for the money and quite a bit lighter than their 1.2 counterparts. If you go with the trinity I would pick up the first RF 70-200 f2.8 because it is quite a bit lighter and more compact than the Z. I have a lot of gear but for the most part a good kit with three primes or the trinity covers 90-95% of the ground that most would want to cover. I like the R5 II over the R6 series and prefer it over my R1. It's a super body with lots of room for crops.
p.11 #19RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
snegron7 wrote: philip_pj wroteTo raise a related issue, some people think it's a choice - for non-pros - between enjoying the trip or doing their photography. Either/Or. I've always felt the photography enlivens the experience, breathes importance and emotion into it. You work harder at seeing, you feel more involved in the scene, not kind of floating through the location.
Thought I'd mention that, to kind of encourage people to get more from it, those that are not already doing it that way. cheers. 100%! There's a certain spontaneity that you can capture while visiting a place for the first time! When I go to a new, exotic (to me at least) place for the first time, I like to bring decent equipment to capture as much detail as possible. However, if it's my second or thrird time visiting, then I'll take a minimum amount of gear like my micro four thirds outfit.
Quoted you mainly just to grab your attention and ask the simple question of if you've made a final decision?
As re your comment here, I would argue that even the fifth time visiting a place, I seem to find new and different things to photograph. Heck, my own style has changed enough that I want my newest goto kit with me, even though my basic kit has been pretty consistent all along based on gear available at the time. When I traveled with film cameras, I had some version of normal, wide and tele. Depending on the year, usually an intermediate zoom as my main goto, a wider lens of some sort, initially primes but as wide zooms got better I transitioned, and then also something in the low to mid tele range. As technology has moved, so has my gear, to the point I still today am continually balancing size, weight and performance against costs of the changes. For me it's a process and I doubt there will ever be an end game. Right now it's Sony, but next year it could be Nikon or Canon. Or even Hasselblad or Fuji medium format (however this is unlikely). But for me, it's not likely ever be M43 or APSC again. If I happen to get to a point where physical limitations prevent me from carrying a higher-end FF kit, I'll probably then just succumb to being a cell-phone photographer...
p.11 #20RF-L or FE-GM (No Trolls, Gatekeepers, or Dismissive Responses)
Jack Flesher wrote: snegron7 wrotephilip_pj wroteTo raise a related issue, some people think it's a choice - for non-pros - between enjoying the trip or doing their photography. Either/Or. I've always felt the photography enlivens the experience, breathes importance and emotion into it. You work harder at seeing, you feel more involved in the scene, not kind of floating through the location.
Thought I'd mention that, to kind of encourage people to get more from it, those that are not already doing it that way. cheers. 100%! There's a certain spontaneity that you can capture while visiting a place for the first time! When I go to a new, exotic (to me at least) place for the first time, I like to bring decent equipment to capture as much detail as possible. However, if it's my second or thrird time visiting, then I'll take a minimum amount of gear like my micro four thirds outfit.Quoted you mainly just to grab your attention and ask the simple question of if you've made a final decision?
As re your comment here, I would argue that even the fifth time visiting a place, I seem to find new and different things to photograph. Heck, my own style has changed enough that I want my newest goto kit with me, even though my basic kit has been pretty consistent all along based on gear available at the time. When I traveled with film cameras, I had some version of normal, wide and tele. Depending on the year, usually an intermediate zoom as my main goto, a wider lens of some sort, initially primes but as wide zooms got better I transitioned, and then also something in the low to mid tele range. As technology has moved, so has my gear, to the point I still today am continually balancing size, weight and performance against costs of the changes. For me it's a process and I doubt there will ever be an end game. Right now it's Sony, but next year it could be Nikon or Canon. Or even Hasselblad or Fuji medium format (however this is unlikely). But for me, it's not likely ever be M43 or APSC again. If I happen to get to a point where physical limitations prevent me from carrying a higher-end FF kit, I'll probably then just succumb to being a cell-phone photographer... ...Show more →
I ended up buying 3 primes (so far) for my Sony's:
- Sony 35mm f1.4 GM
- Sony 50mm f1.8
- Sony 85mm f1.8
I'm still debating on whether to get a Sony 24mm f1.4 GM plus a Sony 14mm f1.8 GM, or a Sony 24-70mm f2.8 GM II. I would still lack a longer lens than my 85mm. Also, my reason for buying the less expensive Sony 50mm f1.8 was because I hardly shoot at that focal length. I would use it for the rare occasion I'd need to shoot a portrait, which I hardly ever do. Same with the 85mm f1.8. I've owned the Sony 85mm f1.8 in the past, and it was very sharp. I use it for the occasional crop shots of cityscapes. Honestly, a 24-105mm f4.0 would probably work best for me with my Sony gear, but I've heard mixed reviews of that lens. Maybe if Sony updates it I might consider it.
While I really, really love my R6II with my RF 24-105mm f4.0L, it is heavy around my neck. I thought about getting the RF 24-70mm f2.8L, but that lens is even bigger and heavier than my RF 24-105mm f4.0L. RF-L primes are also bigger and heavier than I'd like. Also, I would need a spare body as a backup for my R6II. It would most likely be either another R6II (newer R6III seems to not perform as well as the older R6II per online complaints), or an R5II to be used as primary with my current R6II as backup. That still doesn't solve the problem of heavy lenses though.
As for point and shoots, I've been doing a ton of research for an upcoming graduation ceremony that doesn't allow interchangeable lens cameras or point and shoots with lenses over 3 inches long, or camcorders. Top option was the Sony RX100 vii. I purchased it new a couple of weeks ago, and I was extremely disappointed. It doesn't perform well in low light, focusing is hit or miss (mostly miss), detail capture with lens zoomed to the longest setting is a blotchy mess, and dust particles make their way very easily into the inside lens elements. Overall a $300 point and shoot at a $1,500 price tag. I returned it. Still looking for an alternative for that event, but I think I'm going to just go with a cellphone.