gdanmitchell wrote:
I wonder if this is going to turn out to be a flaw with the initial batch that gets addressed going forward?
scott f wrote
ps09 wrote
Thanks for the info guys. I found the 4-8 to be acceptable in the right conditions, but found the handling of it so close to the 600 f4 that I sold it at a $600 loss to a friend that doesn't have a 600f4. I figured that saving 1.3# wasn't worth being at f8 from 600mm on. For some reason I find the 600f4 easier to handhold than the 4-8. I kinda dig my fingers inside the hood of the 600 and I can be quite steady. For me, I figured if I was going to be on a monopod I'd rather have the 600.
I had a great usage case for the 100-400 plus 1.4 on Monday. I was in the kayak photographing loons when an intruder loon landed on the lake. I was maybe 75' from the male while it was feeding the loonlet. I was using the 600 instead of the 300 because I was on and off with the 1.4, trying to keep my distance and get depth of field. I had more light than I needed. Mom and the baby came right at me (I think for protection) and the male went wild. Full dives and penguin walk. Splashing like crazy. I had too much lens at 600mm and 350-400 would have been perfect. My images ended up great, except for the 50% that I clipped wings due to being too close. Luckily for me I've photographed this behavior many times. It would have been devastating if this had been my first time photographing this behavior so close.
If I had the 100-400 on a second body Monday, I would have switched as soon as I saw the intruder flying overhead. Thinking back, I should have had the 300 on a second body, but space is at a premium when kayaking, so the 1-4 could be attractive with 2 tcs in the dry bag.
So, to me, the new 1-4 would have to be on par with the 300gm with 1.4, and reasonably acceptable with the 2x for me to consider it. The new 1-4 + 300 and a pocket full of tcs seems like a great YNP two-camera combo.
What's the deal with the zoom creep? That's probably the biggest "piss me off" thing I've heard about the new lens and could keep me from buying it. I assume it creeps to 100mm? Yes,, it creeps to 100 pretty quickly, but taking the zoom control off smooth solves it.
I've seen another report of a lens that doesn't creep but it was from preorder, day 1 release. So there is some tolerance going on with the zoom "tightness".
Will be interesting to see if the ones that don't creep start to creep after more use.