Hate to say this, but get the Scottevest. It's the only game in town. I have tried everything out there for the last 10 years and it's the only product that ticks all the boxes. I have tried nearly all the options that this thread has recommended and they all fall short. I use mine to fly with (where it's very helpful to take extra stuff including lenses with strict airline carryon limits) and more importantly, use it in NYC when I'm walking around in the Spring and Fall. It's too warm for summers here (at least what I have and they have lighter-weight options now) Its fantastic for that job. I can have a small water bottle extra lens (or 2) and batteries, plus phone, wallet, keys etc all in the vest and not look like a pack mule. No bulging or weird shape. It just looks like a regular vest. The biggest con is that for what it is, IT'S STUPID EXPENSIVE. Buy once, cry once....