fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Which One?

  
 
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Which One?
The second one looks too fake. Maybe if you toned down that shaft of fake light it would make more sense. The background with the human head in the "real" image is rather distracting.

EBH
Jun 15, 2026 at 10:41 PM
Shasoc
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Which One?
EB-1 wrote:
The second one looks too fake. Maybe if you toned down that shaft of fake light it would make more sense. The background with the human head in the "real" image is rather distracting.

EBH


Thanks. I appreciate your feedback

Socrate
Jun 16, 2026 at 07:47 AM
jimmuller
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Which One?
I feel like I'm sticking my nose in someone else's conversation here but I'll do it anyway. And I often feel like I'm shouting into the wind to a crowd moving the opposite direction. But I'll do it anyway.

The subject of that first photo is neither the background nor whatever is in her hand (regardless of what first caught the photographer's eye) nor even the fact that she is looking at it. It's her face and intense expression. I don't care what is in her hand, never noticed it and never even noticed the sun hitting it until I read one of the comments which brought it up. When I see any pic like that, either a person or a bird or an unusual thing in nature or anything, my eye is drawn to the subject. It's the subject, stupid, not the periphery. I don't even see the background or bokeh or whatever you want to call it, let alone find it distracting as long as the subject is obvious. I see the prime subject. If you want me to see something else, then construct the photo so that my eye is drawn to it, either with focus or light vs. dark, whatever else works.

So the first pic which puts her in a real space looks right and real. I loved that one. I noticed the wall behind her but it didn't distract me. I still don't know what is in her hand. Won't know until I go back and look again. Probably won't care.

JMHO, which orthodoxy doesn't seem to agree with
Jun 25, 2026 at 03:05 PM
grandmas
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Which One?
Surprised this image is still getting comments!

I have been coming to the photo critique forum long enough to realize that the subject and focal points are confusing to many. When you figure out the difference, composition is much easier. The subject usually takes up the majority of the space in an image, and in this case the girl is the subject. The subject does not need to be placed on one side or the other, just put the subject where it will visually balance in the image.

Focal points in an image are the little things that draw the viewers eyes around the rest of the image, and in this case the focal points are the bright light on the girls right hand, her eyes, and the text on the background. They add interest to an image and serve to keep viewers around longer.

The reworked image made by Shasoc removes the interesting background and tries to make the subject the trinket box. The subject and the focal point cannot be changed into something they are not.

It is good that most of the comments could see that the first image made the most interesting image, but I am not sure they understand why.
Jun 25, 2026 at 05:53 PM
Shasoc
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Which One?
grandmas wrote:
Surprised this image is still getting comments!

I have been coming to the photo critique forum long enough to realize that the subject and focal points are confusing to many. When you figure out the difference, composition is much easier. The subject usually takes up the majority of the space in an image, and in this case the girl is the subject. The subject does not need to be placed on one side or the other, just put the subject where it will visually balance in the image.

Focal points in an image are the little things that draw the viewers eyes
...Show more →


Surprised you still haven't got the spirit and the constructive provocation of this post.

Socrate


P.S. On second thought: I am not really surprised.
Jul 02, 2026 at 08:29 AM
FM ForumsPhoto CritiqueJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister