I feel like I'm sticking my nose in someone else's conversation here but I'll do it anyway. And I often feel like I'm shouting into the wind to a crowd moving the opposite direction. But I'll do it anyway.
The subject of that first photo is neither the background nor whatever is in her hand (regardless of what first caught the photographer's eye) nor even the fact that she is looking at it. It's her face and intense expression. I don't care what is in her hand, never noticed it and never even noticed the sun hitting it until I read one of the comments which brought it up. When I see any pic like that, either a person or a bird or an unusual thing in nature or anything, my eye is drawn to the subject. It's the subject, stupid, not the periphery. I don't even see the background or bokeh or whatever you want to call it, let alone find it distracting as long as the subject is obvious. I see the prime subject. If you want me to see something else, then construct the photo so that my eye is drawn to it, either with focus or light vs. dark, whatever else works.
So the first pic which puts her in a real space looks right and real. I loved that one. I noticed the wall behind her but it didn't distract me. I still don't know what is in her hand. Won't know until I go back and look again. Probably won't care.
JMHO, which orthodoxy doesn't seem to agree with