fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024So much for global shutter !!

  
 
duncangr
Offline

p.1 #1So much for global shutter !!
Wow A9iii gets better every day - doesn’t even need firmware updates. 

And this with mechanical shutter at 12fps. What happens with electronic shutter - better, worse, stay the same ?


https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_R1-Sony_A9iii.jpg

Oh and strangely those triangles have disappeared now and ben replaced with circles - apparently the level of on camera processing is not sufficient to warrant the triangles being shown so the threshold level was adjusted to be just above the R1 level


Ah well at least I get global shutter, 120fps and a better pre-capture implementation.

What am I missing I thought the R1 was supposed to be a low light high DR camera?
Dec 22, 2024 at 11:37 PM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.1 #2So much for global shutter !!
What?
Dec 23, 2024 at 02:31 AM
Jonas B
Online
Details
p.1 #3So much for global shutter !!
duncangr wrote:
Wow A9iii gets better every day - [...]
What am I missing I thought the R1 was supposed to be a low light high DR camera?


It seems as you have saved an earlier diagram and compared it to a current diagram at photonstophotos. Why?

EDIT: My mistake, at first I wrote diagram at DxO.

Edited on Dec 23, 2024 at 04:25 AM · View previous versions
Dec 23, 2024 at 02:43 AM
duncangr
Offline
Details
p.1 #4So much for global shutter !!
Jonas B wrote:
duncangr wroteWow A9iii gets better every day - [...]
What am I missing I thought the R1 was supposed to be a low light high DR camera?
It seems as you have saved an earlier diagram and compared it to a current diagram at DxO? Why?


What better way to illustrate the mysterious change of threshold between then and now ?

Never mind that that's how it came - from the horse mouth so to speak.

Forgot to mention that base ISO of 200 though!

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/tests/Canon_R1/Canon_r1.png
Dec 23, 2024 at 04:21 AM
Jonas B
Online
Details
p.1 #5So much for global shutter !!
duncangr wrote:
What better way to illustrate the mysterious change of threshold between then and now ?
[...]

Who cares?Opening the thread I was hoping for something interesting about a global shutter, not a mysterious change of a curve showing what DR a Canon is capable of (or not).
I like your bird images though!
Dec 23, 2024 at 04:34 AM
duncangr
Offline
Details
p.1 #6So much for global shutter !!
Jonas B wrote:
duncangr wroteWhat better way to illustrate the mysterious change of threshold between then and now ?
[...]
Who cares?Opening the thread I was hoping for something interesting about a global shutter, not a mysterious change of a curve showing what DR a Canon is capable of (or not).
I like your bird images though!


Thanks re the birds.

The main point was the DR comparison with the non-global shutter R1 where it's pretty much a wash - I was under the impression the R1 was supposed to be substantially better. Apologies if that doesn't interest you.

The mysterious change was just a little aside.
Dec 23, 2024 at 05:00 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.1 #7So much for global shutter !!
Jonas B wrote:
duncangr wroteWhat better way to illustrate the mysterious change of threshold between then and now ?
[...]
Who cares?Opening the thread I was hoping for something interesting about a global shutter, not a mysterious change of a curve showing what DR a Canon is capable of (or not).
I like your bird images though!


I think the general point is that for both Canon and Sony moving to a camera with ultra high frames per second (120 in Sony's case and 40 in Canon's case) comes at a cost in base ISO performance, at least at this point in time. These are both cameras designed for fast action, IMO, and they make a similar trade off to improve fps while reducing base ISO capability. In addition, for a flagship camera both have notably lower megapixels than other cameras from each brand with 24 MP.

They obviously differ in that the Sony has higher fps and the global shutter, whereas the Canon has the bigger built in grip body and I am sure Canon would claim better AF with the cross type sensors in the R1. I haven't used either camera and have no idea how each actually performs for action and that isn't my type of shooting at all, but I do think it is worth noting the similar compromises that both Sony and Canon made to get an ultra high fps camera.
Dec 23, 2024 at 07:49 AM
Jonas B
Online
Details
p.1 #8So much for global shutter !!
Steve Spencer wrote:
[...] but I do think it is worth noting the similar compromises that both Sony and Canon made to get an ultra high fps camera.


OK. All that is good. Seeing a wonky DR curve for a Canon camera was not what I expected from reading the topic title. I understand some care. At the same time it's a kind of information which is totally not helpful. What am I supposed to do with it?

If one need a global shutter the A9iii is the only choice. It doesn't matter how somebody metering DR changed a curve for another camera one way or another. That's all.

If one is interested in game wars or for some reason switch system all the time or just want to know everything there is about camera gear so OK. My kind of apologize to all of the latter kind!
Dec 23, 2024 at 09:50 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.1 #9So much for global shutter !!
Steve Spencer wrote:
Jonas B wrote
duncangr wroteWhat better way to illustrate the mysterious change of threshold between then and now ?
[...]
Who cares?Opening the thread I was hoping for something interesting about a global shutter, not a mysterious change of a curve showing what DR a Canon is capable of (or not).
I like your bird images though!
I think the general point is that for both Canon and Sony moving to a camera with ultra high frames per second (120 in Sony's case and 40 in Canon's case) comes at a cost in base ISO performance, at least at this point in time. These are both cameras designed for fast action, IMO, and they make a similar trade off to improve fps while reducing base ISO capability. In addition, for a flagship camera both have notably lower megapixels than other cameras from each brand with 24 MP.

They obviously differ in that the Sony has higher fps
...Show more →

I agree with your points on the highly specialized nature of both cameras.
While the photographic dynamic range (PDR) is important, I believe that it is not very important.
I have Sony A1 and (added this year) two micro-four-thirds cameras: OM-1 II and Panasonic G9 II.
Relevant to this thread, interestingly, my G9 II at base ISO has PDR 10.17 (both with the mechanical and electronic shutter), comparable to the PDR 10 of A9 III at base ISO.
At high ISO (3200 and above), the PDR of A9III is better, but only marginally, by 0.6. For example at ISO3200 the values are 7.04 against 6.44 log(2)EV. In practice, I tested G9 II at ISO 3200 and I see that an image deliberately underexposed by 3 stops can be fully recovered in post, and the result looks virtually indistinguishable from the properly exposed image at ISO 3200 (https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1878263/).
I wouldn't worry too much about the PDR of modern cameras. Even small-sensor cameras like the MFT G9 II have more than enough dynamic range, for most practical needs.
Some sacrifices (e.g. a loss of PDR by 1 log(2) EV) are justifiable when the overall camera performance is improved. I don't expect this should have much of an effect on the low-light performance. In low-light, that is at ISO 6400 and higher, all images are noisy, regardless of the sensor size full-frame or MFT. Thus, the success of getting useable photos at high ISO depends more on the efficiency of denoising in post than on the light-gathering ability of a camera.
Dec 23, 2024 at 10:51 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister