p.3 #1Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Cosina always optimizes their lens for the filter stack and they spoke plenty about this lens being optimized for Sony on the product introduction video too. So there's no worry that it would have filter-stack thickness related issues.
Butterfingers wrote:
I wasn't aware that there was already an M mount version of this. And I see from Bastian's review that it suffers from the issues that come with the thicker filter stack of the Sony cameras, softer corners, does anyone know if the FE version of this lens will be optically identical to the M mount version or if it will be optimized for the thicker Sony filter stack?
p.3 #3Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
They are obviously trying to put some product distance between the source lens and the mirrorless versions that flow on from that earlier release. Adding to the distinct look is that diameter and length are up 8/9mm each from the VM.
It will be interesting to see if the optimization had any effect on the M-mount lens's CA, particularly with the very close MFD of 0.28m (down from 0.5m). EVFs make short work of such close focus, and short MFDs make great sense with a fast 28mm. You get the hood, which is nice too.
p.3 #5Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
nehemiahphoto wrote:
If they tweak one thing, I hope it’s coma correction or midzone sharpness wide open at portrait distance.
The E mount and VM lens diagrams look identical - no added ED glass elements or changed element shapes - so Cosina just adjusted the element spacing. I don't think that's enough to improve E results above VM results.
Unless - Cosina just used the VM diagram for convenience and the actual E lens formula is different? But what the chances of that?
p.3 #6Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
mudlake wrote: Makten wrotemudlake wroteHow do you 28mm lovers like to use your lens? Travel? Landscape? Portrait? All of the above?
I would love to get this perfectly beautiful 28mm but can’t quite determine how I would use it. I have four Voigtlanders that I love: 10/5.6, 21/1.4, 35/1.2 SE, and 50/1.2 SE. I almost always have the 50mm on the camera on trips and when I feel the need for wider, the 35mm steps up. When needing WIDE the 21/1.4 gets some use and is perfectly croppable to 28/1.9 on the A7R5.
So to those who love 28, any advice on how I might use this new little gem? Help me justify a purchase! 🙂Why are you buying something that you don't even know what to use for? 😂. I’m not. Read my post again. Carefully.
"I would love to get this..."
OK, why would you love to get a lens that you don't know what you would use for?
p.3 #7Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
NJPhotographer wrote: Knut. wroteNJPhotographer wroteI wish it were autofocus.Voigtländer is the manual focus lens brand of Cosina.
- Autofocus and Voigtländer, this is a contradiction in itself.
(Manual focus is not for everyone but if you look for manual focus lenses, Voigtländer is the way to go.)
28mm in autofocus:
- You might consider the original Sony 28/2.0 SEL FE which is not that bad.
- An alternatve is the Viltrox 28//1.8 - Viltrox produces increasingly performant lenses lately.
- Sigma 28/1.4 Art is the way to go if you want utmost performance.
Voigtländer 28/1.5 is the path for pure manual focus aficionados.Even so, I wish it were autofocus. Manual focus is not for me. I've considered and bought all of those:
- I have the Sony 28/2. Nicely small. Good (not great) optics & autofocus, but no aperture ring.
- I have the Viltrox 28/1.8. Good optics & autofocus, but aperture ring is clickless only.
- I had the Sigma 28/1.4. Excellent lens, but way too large & heavy (DSLR design).
StoneCrop wroteOr get an M mount version and the techart LM-EA9 auto focus adapter? I've never tried that but I know others on this forum have done so with some successThat's a solution, but it's $399 and is not as good as built-in autofocus.
I completely agree that it would be nice to have a better, but nevertheless lightweight 28mm with autofocus.
But as it is, Voigtländer is a manual focuus brand, it is thus rather moot to ask for an AF lens from them. They have absolutely no technological expertise with linear motors, high quality plastic casings and all else that is neccessary for such a feat. If they ever do produce an AF lens, it will not be cutting edge and people will complain again (They know that and they serve the market segment they are strong in). And they produce absolutely charming mechanical lanses out of brass and aluminium! (just not AF).
It is really up to Sony to offer a 28mm G or GM autofocus lens, obviously you would be keenly interested, I guess several other people as well. Who knows, maybe it will come some day. Or Sigma will offer a lightweight iSeries lens at 28mm. I guess these are the two companies to approach with such a request.
People who go Voigtländer usually want manual focus for specific reasons. It is nice to have different companies covering different market segments.
p.3 #8Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
OscarF wrote:
The E mount and VM lens diagrams look identical - no added ED glass elements or changed element shapes - so Cosina just adjusted the element spacing. I don't think that's enough to improve E results above VM results.
Unless - Cosina just used the VM diagram for convenience and the actual E lens formula is different? But what the chances of that?
I see no reason why Cosina should display in the company website a different lens diagram than the actual one. I bet they just adjusted the element spacing, and/or the distance of the rear element from the bayonet mount. Therefore, the performance of the E-mount version should be at most equal to that of VM-mount lens.
p.3 #9Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
28mm used to be the bread and butter wide angle from 1960 to 1980. Wider than 28mm lenses used to be fancy and demand a premium price.
When the higher perperformant AF lenses came out manufacturers went straight to 24/25mm in the expectation, that they could achieve a higher margin. 28mm was felt to be too common, despite it being a very nice focal length in itself. This has become the more apparent as there are only a few 28mm lenses produced today.
I‘m very happy with this 28mm since it pairs much better with 50mm than a 35mm lens. It also does not distort the heads of people at the edge of the frame as much as wider angles do. If neccessary it can be complimented with a light weight 15mm.
p.3 #10Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Knut. wrote:
... there are only a few 28mm lenses produced today.
Probably because today we have so many good to excellent 24-xx f/4 & f/2.8 zooms. Or 28-xx f/2 zooms (large and expensive though).
P.S: in the film era I used the Nikkor 25-50/4; I used that lens for landscapes mostly. Then I swapped it for a AI-S 28/2.8. The only advantage of the prime lens was better flare/ghosting behaviour when shooting landscapes with the sun in the frame. I regret I sold the 25-50/4. Sharp, versatile, no distortion: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/929565/2374#16706702
p.3 #11Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Ripolini wrote: Knut. wrote... there are only a few 28mm lenses produced today.Probably because today we have so many good to excellent 24-xx f/4 & f/2.8 zooms. Or 28-xx f/2 zooms (large and expensive though).
P.S: in the film era I used the Nikkor 25-50/4; I used that lens for landscapes mostly. Then I swapped it for a AI-S 28/2.8. The only advantage of the prime lens was better flare/ghosting behaviour when shooting landscapes with the sun in the frame. I regret I sold the 25-50/4. Sharp, versatile, no distortion: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/929565/2374#16706702
Yes, zooms have come a long way, especially if you look at the latest offerings of Sigma and Sony.
- Fixed focal lenses still have advantages in distortion (at times) and
- performance at f1.2 to 2.0 (some exceptional lenses)
But mostly they are a voluntary restriction:
- To slow you down,
- force you to make more deliberate framing decisions
- training yourself to see with a certain view
Manual focus, for example with Voigtländer lenses, can ad positively this process: You have to force yourself to define exactly where the plne of focus should fall (including the f-stop you chose) This, can be very creative.
p.3 #12Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Yes @Knut., I know what MF lenses are for. Actually I own two Z CV Apo-Lanthars, 3 Zeiss ZF/ZF.2 lenses and a 40+ y.o. Nikkor 50/1.4
However I bet that the market demands more 24-xx zooms than (fast) MF prime lenses. About Voigtlander lenses, I think that they were primarily conceived as cheaper alternatives for Leica M users. This allowed/forced Cosina to design compact prime lenses, similar in size to their Leica M counterparts.
Now, in addition to licensing and commercial issues, the increased sensor thickness of Sony, Nikon and Canon's MILCs poses problems with off-axis performance (i.e. borders' sharpness); these technical issues are more pronounced for fast (rangefinder) lenses having the exit pupil closer to the sensor. In these cases, the lens design must be either tweaked or changed (CV 50/2 Apo-Lanthar is an example of different designs for M- and E/Z-mount).
So, at present we have six VM wideangles with 18mm < FL < 35mm (21/1.4, 21/3.5, 21/4, 28/1.5, 28/2, 28/2.8), two (just) E-mount wideangles (21/1.4 and the soon-to-be-released 28/1.5; the 21/3.5 has been discontinued), and no Z-mount CV lens with FL in between 15 and 35 mm. I am not an expert of Sony lenses, but I know that relatively fast Z wideangles are larger, heavier and with quite complex optical schemes (12-14 glass elements in 10-11 groups!). I guess this is necessary to not have large differences between the angles of incidence of light rays on the sensor at the centre (90°) and off-axis.
My question is: are the larger sensor stack thicknesses, employed in MILCs of major companies, compatible with compactness and large relative apertures of wideangles? could the use of higher quality glass and/or more complex manufacturing/grinding processes help solving the technical issues at reasonable prices?
Let's wait for comprehensive reviews of the E 28/1.5 (or Thypoch Simera 28/1.4) to know the answer.
p.3 #13Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Makten wrote: mudlake wroteMakten wrotemudlake wroteHow do you 28mm lovers like to use your lens? Travel? Landscape? Portrait? All of the above?
I would love to get this perfectly beautiful 28mm but can’t quite determine how I would use it. I have four Voigtlanders that I love: 10/5.6, 21/1.4, 35/1.2 SE, and 50/1.2 SE. I almost always have the 50mm on the camera on trips and when I feel the need for wider, the 35mm steps up. When needing WIDE the 21/1.4 gets some use and is perfectly croppable to 28/1.9 on the A7R5.
So to those who love 28, any advice on how I might use this new little gem? Help me justify a purchase! 🙂Why are you buying something that you don't even know what to use for? 😂. I’m not. Read my post again. Carefully."I would love to get this..."
OK, why would you love to get a lens that you don't know what you would use for?
You're like a dog on a bone, aren't you?
If you've never desired something simply because of its beauty and form and *possible* usefulness, I don't have much more to say to you. Did you ever try something new in a restaurant just because you thought it might be nice for a change?
I won't be responding to you anymore. Thanks for your intense interest in why I *might* want to purchase a lens I haven't used before.
p.3 #14Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Filter diameter is different if you compare the two. That may be an indication of different diameter to the individual elements themselves… or maybe not!
p.3 #15Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
mudlake wrote: Makten wrotemudlake wroteMakten wrotemudlake wroteHow do you 28mm lovers like to use your lens? Travel? Landscape? Portrait? All of the above?
I would love to get this perfectly beautiful 28mm but can’t quite determine how I would use it. I have four Voigtlanders that I love: 10/5.6, 21/1.4, 35/1.2 SE, and 50/1.2 SE. I almost always have the 50mm on the camera on trips and when I feel the need for wider, the 35mm steps up. When needing WIDE the 21/1.4 gets some use and is perfectly croppable to 28/1.9 on the A7R5.
So to those who love 28, any advice on how I might use this new little gem? Help me justify a purchase! 🙂Why are you buying something that you don't even know what to use for? 😂. I’m not. Read my post again. Carefully."I would love to get this..."
OK, why would you love to get a lens that you don't know what you would use for?You're like a dog on a bone, aren't you?
If you've never desired something simply because of its beauty and form and *possible* usefulness, I don't have much more to say to you. Did you ever try something new in a restaurant just because you thought it might be nice for a change?
I won't be responding to you anymore. Thanks for your intense interest in why I *might* want to purchase a lens I haven't used before.
No, I don't think I've ever desired something if it wasn't obviously useful. Like a meal on a restaurant will make you not hungry.
Whatever. I just find it very strange to even consider buying stuff you don't sort of _know_ that you will have a use for.
p.3 #16Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
'I think that they were primarily conceived as cheaper alternatives for Leica M users.'
It may look that way to present day photographers, but they have a storied past littered with some great achievements. How about a 29mm f0.8 Super Nokton for m43 users? Or a 60mm f0.95?
p.3 #17Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Makten wrote: mudlake wroteMakten wrotemudlake wroteMakten wrotemudlake wroteHow do you 28mm lovers like to use your lens? Travel? Landscape? Portrait? All of the above?
I would love to get this perfectly beautiful 28mm but can’t quite determine how I would use it. I have four Voigtlanders that I love: 10/5.6, 21/1.4, 35/1.2 SE, and 50/1.2 SE. I almost always have the 50mm on the camera on trips and when I feel the need for wider, the 35mm steps up. When needing WIDE the 21/1.4 gets some use and is perfectly croppable to 28/1.9 on the A7R5.
So to those who love 28, any advice on how I might use this new little gem? Help me justify a purchase! 🙂Why are you buying something that you don't even know what to use for? 😂. I’m not. Read my post again. Carefully."I would love to get this..."
OK, why would you love to get a lens that you don't know what you would use for?You're like a dog on a bone, aren't you?
If you've never desired something simply because of its beauty and form and *possible* usefulness, I don't have much more to say to you. Did you ever try something new in a restaurant just because you thought it might be nice for a change?
I won't be responding to you anymore. Thanks for your intense interest in why I *might* want to purchase a lens I haven't used before.No, I don't think I've ever desired something if it wasn't obviously useful. Like a meal on a restaurant will make you not hungry.
Whatever. I just find it very strange to even consider buying stuff you don't sort of _know_ that you will have a use for.
Well it seems like he has a use for the lens. He likes the look of it…for some that is enough use I guess.
p.3 #18Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
OscarF wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteIf they tweak one thing, I hope it’s coma correction or midzone sharpness wide open at portrait distance.The E mount and VM lens diagrams look identical - no added ED glass elements or changed element shapes - so Cosina just adjusted the element spacing. I don't think that's enough to improve E results above VM results.
Unless - Cosina just used the VM diagram for convenience and the actual E lens formula is different? But what the chances of that?
Not sure--but I do know, the optical formulae of lenses that are ported from m-mount to e, like the CV's that are in FE mount, tend to have smoother bokeh and a slightly different more diffuse draw. Fred found that, and I found that as well with the only FE CV I owned in both mounts (40/1.2). I also know the 80 Lux and 75 Lux have identical formula, but they present differently, even though the only "difference" is physical spacing as R mount was for SLR versus M.
I know spacing is important, and even very minor tweaks can change imaging performance. I am not knowledgable enough about optics to understand why/how from looking at a diagram.
Edit: Upon further reflection, in conjunction with spacing, I wonder if the larger diameter of the elements for E versus M as well as the size of the rear element are also a factor in the rendering qualities, even though the optical formulas the same.
p.3 #19Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
philip_pj wrote:
'I think that they were primarily conceived as cheaper alternatives for Leica M users.'
It may look that way to present day photographers, but they have a storied past littered with some great achievements. How about a 29mm f0.8 Super Nokton for m43 users? Or a 60mm f0.95?
It's actually a pity that they decided to make huge lenses for MFT. It defeats the whole purpose of the system IMO.Would have made a lot more sense to design as small lenses as possible, just like they do for Leica M.
p.3 #20Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Not sure--but I do know, the optical formulae of lenses that are ported from m-mount to e, like the CV's that are in FE mount, tend to have smoother bokeh and a slightly different more diffuse draw. Fred found that, and I found that as well with the only FE CV I owned in both mounts (40/1.2). I also know the 80 Lux and 75 Lux have identical formula, but they present differently, even though the only "difference" is physical spacing as R mount was for SLR versus M.
I know spacing is important, and even very minor tweaks can change imaging performance. I am not knowledgable enough about optics to understand why/how from looking at a diagram.
Edit: Upon further reflection, in conjunction with spacing, I wonder if the larger diameter of the elements for E versus M as well as the size of the rear element are also a factor in the rendering qualities, even though the optical formulas the same....Show more →
So you're saying with the two CV 40mm f/1.2 lenses you have in both E and M mounts - the E mount version has larger diameter glass elements than the M mount version? If the lens design truly stays the same but all the glass elements are made larger diameter for the E mount, then the element thickness would also have to increase - and that would increase the focal length of the lens and also increase the size of the projected image circle...wouldn't it?
The filter size difference between the M and E 28mm f/1.5 lenses is only 3mm - 46mm vs 49mm. When you look at the photos of the two lenses - their front elements appear to be the same size when compared to the different sized filter rings (the engraved 'beauty ring' is wider on the E mount version of the lens).