catacore wrote:
Reviving an one year old thread, I was wondering, from a user's perspective, how would one compare this Nokton against the Laowa Argus 28/1.2. I am quite torn between these two fast lenses, at this moment, and any input would be much appreciated!
The Nokton would have many practical pluses (smaller, lighter, EXIF data), but still.....
p.14 #2Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
catacore wrote:
Reviving an one year old thread, I was wondering, from a user's perspective, how would one compare this Nokton against the Laowa Argus 28/1.2. I am quite torn between these two fast lenses, at this moment, and any input would be much appreciated!
The Nokton would have many practical pluses (smaller, lighter, EXIF data), but still.....
I now have these 4 in E-mount: Laowa Argus 28/1.2, CV Nokton 28/1.5, CV APO-Lanthar 28/2, Kistar 28/3.2, and 7Artisans 28/1.4 FE-Plus in M-mount (but optimized for Sony sensor stack). Only the CV pair have electronic contacts.
As you know, I prefer smaller cameras (hence I use A7CII as my main camera) + smaller / lighter lenses. Laowa was the first one of those that I acquired back when it was released in 2023 and at that time there were basically no other options for a native 28mm manual prime lens for E-mount though the 7Artisans FE-Plus was already available (I only got one of those 2nd hand last year on a good deal, and I think new ones of the FE-Plus version are no longer being produced currently).
For me Laowa is a bit too big and heavy and not a perfect match for A7C series cameras due to that. Minimum focus distance at 0.5m is a bit limiting. It's also not the best in terms of flare resistance and contrast when shooting against the sun or bright lights. I think CV build and feel of handling are also more refined. With Laowa I'm also having harder time to figure out where optimal focusing distance is when shooting stopped down and trying to get best corner-to-corner sharpness. With CV lenses I can trust that optimal focusing distance in those cases is at or very close to the mid-point of infinity symbol (after confirming results initially) but with Laowa it's not the case and it's a bit harder to determine as the range with seemingly equal results is wider and I often end up with different picks for focus distance at different times when trying to get best corner-to-corner sharpness at long distance shots.
My personal preferred options from these lenses are now the CV pair (currently the APO-Lanthar is new and I've been shooting with it more) + Kistar 28/3.2 for very characterful rendering. I don't see particular appeal points for Laowa over those. It's faster at f1.2 but I think for bokeh shots on a 28mm lens one would like to be able to focus closer and it would be more useful. CV pair can focus to 0.28m natively and Kistar can focus to 0.2m. There could be a use case for f1.2 for portraits but personally I hardly shoot portraits at all.
catacore wroteReviving an one year old thread, I was wondering, from a user's perspective, how would one compare this Nokton against the Laowa Argus 28/1.2. I am quite torn between these two fast lenses, at this moment, and any input would be much appreciated!
The Nokton would have many practical pluses (smaller, lighter, EXIF data), but still.....
Thanks! I forgot to mention that I have read Bastian's review multiple times... I was more after a "user's experience" about these lenses.
p.14 #4Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Juha Kannisto wrote: catacore wroteReviving an one year old thread, I was wondering, from a user's perspective, how would one compare this Nokton against the Laowa Argus 28/1.2. I am quite torn between these two fast lenses, at this moment, and any input would be much appreciated!
The Nokton would have many practical pluses (smaller, lighter, EXIF data), but still.....I now have these 4 in E-mount: Laowa Argus 28/1.2, CV Nokton 28/1.5, CV APO-Lanthar 28/2, Kistar 28/3.2, and 7Artisans 28/1.4 FE-Plus in M-mount (but optimized for Sony sensor stack). Only the CV pair have electronic contacts.
As you know, I prefer smaller cameras (hence I use A7CII as my main camera) + smaller / lighter lenses. Laowa was the first one of those that I acquired back when it was released in 2023 and at that time there were basically no other options for a native 28mm manual prime lens for E-mount though the 7Artisans FE-Plus was already available (I only got one of those 2nd hand last year on a good deal, and I think new ones of the FE-Plus version are no longer being produced currently).
For me Laowa is a bit too big and heavy and not a perfect match for A7C series cameras due to that. Minimum focus distance at 0.5m is a bit limiting. It's also not the best in terms of flare resistance and contrast when shooting against the sun or bright lights. I think CV build and feel of handling are also more refined. With Laowa I'm also having harder time to figure out where optimal focusing distance is when shooting stopped down and trying to get best corner-to-corner sharpness. With CV lenses I can trust that optimal focusing distance in those cases is at or very close to the mid-point of infinity symbol (after confirming results initially) but with Laowa it's not the case and it's a bit harder to determine as the range with seemingly equal results is wider and I often end up with different picks for focus distance at different times when trying to get best corner-to-corner sharpness at long distance shots.
My personal preferred options from these lenses are now the CV pair (currently the APO-Lanthar is new and I've been shooting with it more) + Kistar 28/3.2 for very characterful rendering. I don't see particular appeal points for Laowa over those. It's faster at f1.2 but I think for bokeh shots on a 28mm lens one would like to be able to focus closer and it would be more useful. CV pair can focus to 0.28m natively and Kistar can focus to 0.2m. There could be a use case for f1.2 for portraits but personally I hardly shoot portraits at all....Show more →
Thanks, Juha, for your detailed writing. I am using an A7CR, so very similar concerns about size/weight. I guess Laowa's appeal is due to its exotic combination of wide angle and fast aperture, but I am still wondering how this combinatoin would translate in actual "real life" shooting.
It is more about finding a wide angle lens for my Sony, after shooting for one year only Leica M. The only E mount lenses I have now are Tamy 28-200 and Zeiss 55/1.8,so looking for a WA prime (manual focusing prefered).
Loxia 25 is in the cards, as well, but that is a totally different proposition, I guess.
But the Laowa Argus (exotic) line has always intrigued me. Still not sure I will have a use for it....