philip_pj wrote:
For a lot of doc work, you want to ensure good definition of material, meaning you must shoot at mid apertures and use higher ISO settings than is ideal.
Thypoch were more conservative than Cosina in their 28mm, their one has an MFD of 40cms; the two Voigtlander 28s (APO-Lanthar and Nokton) both provide 0.28cms.
The direct competitor, the 28/1.5 Nokton, lacks FLE however. Near focus is very important in cine-oriented lenses, and this Simera is indeed solid, and it brings the slightly boisterous bokeh into play. I tend to shoot it at around f2 to get adequate DOF in near-focus shots, while still retaining the 'arty' character of the lens. Here are a couple of examples, helped along by the 14 blade iris (and more light)....Show more →
The Voigtlander 28/1.5 is a better performing lens at a shorter MFD than the Simera 28/1.4 with its MFD. An FLE does not guarantee a better performance at MFD
“This Voigtländer VM 28mm 1.5 Nokton shows a surprisingly good performance at its minimum focus distance, especially when we compare its performance to the Thypoch Simera 28mm 1.4 with its floating elements design. Despite featuring a simpler unit focus design this Voigtländer corrects spherical aberration (glow) better, which leads to higher contrast and resolution. It does show stronger color aberrations though.”
The 35/1.4 Simera is even worse as than the 28/1.4 Simera—you need to stop down for decent performance. The CV 35/1.5 does better without an FLE:
“despite the lack of a floating elements design this Voigtländer 35mm 1.5 does pretty well at its minimum focus distance of 0.5”
The 35/1.4 Simera: “ his Thypoch Simera 35mm 1.4 features a floating elements design, so despite its comparably short minimum focus distances we should expect good performance at wider apertures here.
Fact is, it is still a bit soft at its maximum aperture and stopping down 1-2 stops increases contrast and resolution noticeably.”
But interestingly, the CV 50/1.5 or 50/1.2 doesn’t have an FLE and they do worse than the Simera 50/1.4. Same with the 75/1.4 Simera versus the Voight 75:1.5.
philip_pj wrote:
For a lot of doc work, you want to ensure good definition of material, meaning you must shoot at mid apertures and use higher ISO settings than is ideal.
Thypoch were more conservative than Cosina in their 28mm, their one has an MFD of 40cms; the two Voigtlander 28s (APO-Lanthar and Nokton) both provide 0.28cms.
The direct competitor, the 28/1.5 Nokton, lacks FLE however. Near focus is very important in cine-oriented lenses, and this Simera is indeed solid, and it brings the slightly boisterous bokeh into play. I tend to shoot it at around f2 to get adequate DOF in near-focus shots, while still retaining the 'arty' character of the lens. Here are a couple of examples, helped along by the 14 blade iris (and more light)....Show more →
The Voigtlander 28/1.5 is a better performing lens at MFD than the Simera 28/1.4 with its MFD. Both at 0.5 the Voigt does better. An FLE does not guarantee a better performance at MFD. From actual controlled testing and review at phillipreeve.net:
“This Voigtländer VM 28mm 1.5 Nokton shows a surprisingly good performance at its minimum focus distance, especially when we compare its performance to the Thypoch Simera 28mm 1.4 with its floating elements design. Despite featuring a simpler unit focus design this Voigtländer corrects spherical aberration (glow) better, which leads to higher contrast and resolution. It does show stronger color aberrations though.”
The 35/1.4 Simera is even worse as than the 28/1.4 Simera—you need to stop down for decent performance:
“This Thypoch Simera 35mm 1.4 features a floating elements design, so despite its comparably short minimum focus distances we should expect good performance at wider apertures here.
Fact is, it is still a bit soft at its maximum aperture and stopping down 1-2 stops increases contrast and resolution noticeably.”
The CV 35/1.5 does better without an FLE:
“despite the lack of a floating elements design this Voigtländer 35mm 1.5 does pretty well at its minimum focus distance of 0.5”
But interestingly, the CV 50/1.5 or 50/1.2 doesn’t have an FLE and they do worse than the Simera 50/1.4. Same with the 75/1.4 Simera versus the Voight 75/1.5.
Thank for the kind words. I handpicked these lenses for the kind of work I do. I did two rounds, one with the 28/1.4 which did the heavy lifting, and the second with the Viltrox 14/4. Both went very well to my eyes, but the Simeras have a classy look to them.
Colours seem to fall into place easily, most retouching was for tonal control from window light. The Simeras are also kind under lighting of this kind, a real bonus in low light. This was just pre-monsoon, soft light admittedly - a big soft box in the sky! I don't know how the Portuguese handled the climate, they stayed in Goa/Kerala from 1498 until 1961.
For a lot of those who post a substantial number of images taken with edge-of-field lenses like the Simeras, the question arises as to where to post them. Having given this some thought, I think it's best to have separate categories for (i) image-centric content, and (ii) lens-centric content. For me, at least.
It will work better overall. Enthusiasts who already have some degree of interest in these lenses will visit the dedicated thread to find lens discussion, and the general membership will become more acquainted with what the lenses can achieve, if images are posted in the FE image thread. Of course some image will warrant being in both places.
I shoot a lot of depth-dependent imagery, where the sense of depth in the image is vital to its success. These lenses, and in particular the 28mm and 35mm, excel at this requirement. (Luckily, these are the two focal lengths made in E-mount, before the company decided to prevent E-mount users from having native mount options for the 21mm, 50mm and 75mm Simera lenses.)
A major benefit of a slower focus fade and greater retention of background content is that you can get away with a wider f-stop quite often; while still having the ability to blur the background using a closer camera-subject distance where possible.
I shoot a lot of material indoors - in museums, mansions, churches, monasteries, cafes and more besides. So my ability to have the luxury of simply stopping down and firing away is pretty much prevented. The ISO-S/s-Aperture juggle is ever-present for this kind of work.
The lens has many attributes that assist - color discrimination, warmth, fade character, fast aperture viability, size/weight, among others. As cine-oriented lenses, these characteristics are key.
The one I want to highlight here is detail retention in bokeh. This issue is becoming prominent in the cine world, such that slower fade from focus and detail inside bokeh are now features of some high end lens ranges.
Below, see the extra valuable information to be see in the Simera 28/1.4 as compared to a Sigma lens of the same configuration. It's very obvious both in distance images and in close up images. The Sigma values its own out-of-focus material more than your image content. That's the upshot.
Here are a couple of images that show the attention Thypoch put into its fade character and out-of-focus detail depiction. It's a very enjoyable way to shoot certain subjects, even if (unlike me) you have to option to secure more DOF via better light. Both images feature a strong nearby focal plane (the ashtrays) yet give the viewer a pleasant entree into the background content.
I really like 'arty' images nowadays, so here is one which also shows the close focus bokeh (and color) of the 28mm. This lens is still surprising me, even as I now have full confidence in its bokeh.