fredmiranda.com Login

Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review

  
 
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
I am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.


Do it!

But it still wouldn't tell us anything about the regular FE version (and by extension, the other mirrorless options). Given Thypoch apparently wouldn't send Bastian FE mount review samples does not leave a good impression, irrespective of whether or not there was a communication misunderstanding between the two parties about possible sensor stack specific optimizations.
Nov 13, 2024 at 02:06 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.12 #2Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
Steve Spencer wroteMy guess is that Thypoch wanted more consistency between the 35mm and 50mm given they are part of the same set of cine lenses too. To my eye the 35 lux Asph FLE doesn't look much like the 50 lux Asph, so it seems they may have tried to create a consistent look and they went with the look of the 50 lux Asph as a template. If that is what they did, then the 50 would be a very close replica of the 50 lux Asph, but the 35 although clearly based on the lens design from the 35 lux Asph FLE, appears to have been tweaked more and perhaps those tweaks were to try to make it look more like the 50 (and therefore the 50 lux Asph).
Good thought Steve but not sure I agree. From what we are seeing from Fred, this 50/1.4 is pretty high contrast (aside from flare interference)--maybe not quite as high as the 50 Lux, but pretty similar with a better midzone. The 50 Lux and 35 Lux (you have owned both, but tell me if you disagree) are both quite high contrast WO, especially centrally.

The 35/1.4 Simera is soft WO. My copy, even centrally, shot on a modded sensor or Stock, had pretty diminished contrasts. Resolution was fine.

So, to my mind, we have 3 of 4 lenses with quite high contrast WO, and one outlier. Having said that, your theory might hold and be right with the other aspecs from Thypoch--like flare, bokeh with the rounded many blades, etc.

We see they already dropped the horrible infinite lock. So there is inconsistency there already. I just think they released a not great 35mm, and they are learning as they go, as many newer companies do.

Makes me wonder what the 75mm will shoot like.

And now that I think about it, what Thypoch did reminds me a bit of the ZA 35/1.4 and ZA 50/1.4, with one being much high contrast than the other.
After reviewing more pictures from the Simera 35, I think you are right that it really has fairly low contrast even in the center and in that way it is quite different from the Leica M 35 lux Asph FLE, the Leica 50 lux Asph, and the Simera 50 f/1.4. Thanks for pointing that out. If Thypoch was aiming for a similar look for the 35 f/1.4 and 50 f/1.4 Simera then they really didn't achieve that for contrast, perhaps in bokeh and perhaps in more even performance across the frame, but not in contrast which I find pretty crucial.

I really like what I see in this review of the 50 f/1.4 Simera and as always I find Fred has done an excellent job in giving a feel for that lens in this review. I always liked the 50 lux Asph despite its weaknesses (propensity to flare, mid zone softness at narrower apertures, and sawtooth bokeh balls at times) and I think I would like the Simera optically at least as much.

I never fully took to the 35 lux Asph FLE. It was a great lens for contrast in the center especially, but for me the bokeh was too structured (i.e., harsh) at times and the transition zone often wasn't smooth. I also was bothered more by its midzone weakness on the M10. Still I loved its ergonomics and there is a lot to like about this lens even though I found myself wanting an alternative.

It does not look like the Simera 35 f/1.4 will be that alternative. Hopefully Fred will do a full review of that lens and I will know for sure, but it sure doesn't look like I will be interested.

My favorite 35mm that I have used by a pretty big margin is the Zeiss ZM 35 f/1.4, but it is pretty big on a Leica M camera. I am enjoying shooting manual focussing lenses on my Sony A7r V at the moment, however, and I think I might really like that lens on a Kolari modified Sony (especially if I get my A7r V modified at some point). Right now I am using a CV 40 f/1.2 on my Sony A7r V, which I like but has some annoying weaknesses (mainly more axial CA than I like and weaker close up performance than I like).

I am waiting to see if a 35mm for a Leica M camera comes along that I like better. If it does I may in a few years acquire a Leica M10R or M11, but if it doesn't then I will probably just get my Sony A7r V modified with a thin sensor stack and go with the Zeiss ZM and in the mean time live with my CV 40 f/1.2.
I ordered the lens out of curiosity and because it had an optical lens very similar to the 35 Lux FLE. The bokeh seems to be smother, both in structure and because it's lower contrast from what I could tell, though I did not compare them directly.

One thing about the 35/1.4 Simera, when it's as soft (as in low contrast, resolution is fine), and with the short focus throw from .7 to infinite, cramped focus ring because of the Bolox, it's really easy to misfocus. I have been using EVF to MF fast lenses since the a7 I purchased at launch, and I found this lens exceptionally frustrating. And then add the infinite lock lol.

For me, the 35/1.4 is low contrast with pretty unremarkable color and fairly smooth bokeh. So super boring. The 28/1.4 follows a similar draw. The reason this 50/1.4 interest me is because at least we have strong micro-contrast and punch. As far as M-35mm's, I keep a CV 35/2 ultron as my constant. I like the ZM 35/1.4, 35 Lux FLE as the faster alternatives with a lot of bite. I like the CV 35/1.7 and 35/1.2 vIII, but less so. All have issues--I bounce between them over the years depending on what I want at that moment.

Just a thought, I can't recommend highly enough modding your sensor. I have an a7rII since 2020 and it's been fantastic. But I might look into NKIR over Kolari. Having used both, I much prefer the NKIR, and sebboh, no longer too active, is looking to get another camera modded. He's going with NKIR over another Kolari UT.

What I am very curious about now is how the 21 and 75 will render--closer to the 50 or the 28mm and 35mm's...
I am also really interested in how the 75 f/1.4 will render as well. In the Simera C cine version with the heavier cine housing it comes in at only 450g. I would expect it to come in at about 350g in a regular stills housing, which would make it really interesting from a size and weight perspective for a 75 f/1.4. If it renders like this 50 f/1.4 or close, I would be very interested.

I am less interested in the 21 as I am a big fan of the Voigtlander 21mm and how it renders. If I want a fast 21, then for my tastes a wonderful and small enough one already exists.

Thanks for nudging me toward a modded sensor. I am sure I will do it at some point. On one hand, it would make sense to do it soon and I could start building the kit I really want. On the other hand, I probably should wait until I get a second stock Sony that I wouldn't modify for my AF lenses. My current MF kit that includes the CV 21 f/1.4, 40 f/1.2, 50 f/2 APO, and Loxia 85 f/2.4 all for the stock sensor is quite nice, but there are still several Leica M mount lenses I would really like to use but they suffer on the stock sensor. It will all work out in time. I just need to be patient and content with what I have for now.
Interesting kit. A bit big and too clean for me. I never get along with the 40mm either.

I tend to run a 3 lens of 21/35/75 or a 2 lens kit of 24 or 28mm + 50mm (if nature or shooing a show, toss in an 85mm or 90mm).

My lenses are really small—if and when you mod your sensor, you could shave a lot of weight (relative to the kit you outlined by keeping things at f2 and faster). Then again, our needs and preferences vary

Either way, I think you’ll find modding your sensor allows you to shrink down
...Show more →

I think if I modded my camera, then I would go with an 18/35/75 kit. At 18mm, I think I would like the ZM 18 f/4 if the color cast wasn't too bad on my BSI sensor. Then at 35mm, I know I would like the ZM 35 f/1.4 that I used to have, and at 75mm I am pretty sure I would be happy with the Leica M 75 f/2.4 summarit that I used to have. This 3 lens kit is over a pound lighter than my current kit and I think I would like it more.

I know for architecture, I sometimes like wider than 21mm, but 18mm is almost always wide enough. Currently when I want to shoot architecture I take my Sony/Zeiss 16-35 f/4, but I think I would be happy with just the ZM 18. I do like the CVE 40 f/1.2, and especially so when I crop it about 1.4X and it looks like a 56 f/1.8. Stop it down a bit from there and it makes a great portrait lens, but the axial CA and bokeh at times is still less than ideal. The Loxia 85 f/2.4 is a wonderful lens and I love how it renders, but it's big and bigger than it seems to need to be. I had a Leica M 75 f/2.4 Summarit and it was in many ways very similar and is a lot smaller. I know I would be happy with it as a replacement, but if the Thypoch 75 f/1.4 (that Fred says will be available early next year) turns out to be as nice optically as the 50 f/1.4 and weighs as little as I expect it to weigh, then I might pick that instead. If it performs well on a stock Sony sensor, which is probably pretty likely given it is a 75mm, then I could reduce my kit by half a pound just be replacing the Loxia 85 with it. That might be enough of a size reduction to hold me off modding my sensor for at least a little while.

That said, other than the 16-35 f/4 (which I wouldn't keep if I modded my sensor), the only Sony E mount lenses I would be keeping are longer lenses (85 f/1.4 GM I, Sony/Zeiss 135 f/1.8 ZA, 70-200 f/4 G II Macro, and 200-600 f/5.6-6.3 G). I think all of them may do fine on a modded camera and if that is the case, it might make sense to just get my camera modded.
Nov 13, 2024 at 02:08 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #3Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
I am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.

And at that point, it would be even more safe to assume that if they have not bothered to optimize the newly released 50/1.5 you’re probably not getting any of the other cine lenses optimized. Or the stills versions.


Based on my experience with my modified A7CR UT and E-mount lenses (FE 35/1.8 and FE 55/1.8), I believe the corners will shift "inwards" instead of "outwards." This should positively impact the rendering, making the corners appear even more "out of focus." This effect is the opposite of what we typically see with M-lenses on a stock Sony sensor. It might be different with the Simera, but it's worth testing. Please share your results!
Nov 13, 2024 at 02:49 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
Back to sample shots contributed by FM members


A quick hand held portrait at f/2.0. Easier to do at close range, and I think a more appropriate DOF while still maintaining good separation and Bokeh. It is a bit sharper and less dreamy as well. I do think I am focus a bit in front of the pupil in this portrait. I used the range finder and took only one shot rather that rocking through multiple exposures as i normally would in these circumstances.

Still I am very much liking what I am seeing from this lens so far.




  LEICA M11    Summilux-M 1:1.4/35 ASPH. lens    35mm    f/2.4    1/125s    250 ISO    0.0 EV  

Nov 13, 2024 at 05:52 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #5Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
1bwana1 wrote:
A quick hand held portrait at f/2.0. Easier to do at close range, and I think a more appropriate DOF while still maintaining good separation and Bokeh. It is a bit sharper and less dreamy as well. I do think I am focus a bit in front of the pupil in this portrait. I used the range finder and took only one shot rather that rocking through multiple exposures as i normally would in these circumstances.

Still I am very much liking what I am seeing from this lens so far.


Great portrait! Although the lens performs great wide open, I agree that at f/2 and f/2.8, there's definitely a noticeable increase in crispness, even at the center.
Nov 13, 2024 at 09:22 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
nehemiahphoto wroteI am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.

And at that point, it would be even more safe to assume that if they have not bothered to optimize the newly released 50/1.5 you’re probably not getting any of the other cine lenses optimized. Or the stills versions.
Based on my experience with my modified A7CR UT and E-mount lenses (FE 35/1.8 and FE 55/1.8), I believe the corners will shift "inwards" instead of "outwards." This should positively impact the rendering, making the corners appear even more "out of focus." This effect is the opposite of what we typically see with M-lenses on a stock Sony sensor. It might be different with the Simera, but it's worth testing. Please share your results!


Yes, my experience too with the GM 24 and others. All this is explained well here, with all sorts of other info. This is still the best written article IMO, even though it’s old now:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification/#Performance_with_Native_FE_Lenses
Nov 13, 2024 at 11:13 PM
rsolti13
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
Thanks Fred, ordered from Thypoch with your code. Hopefully it ships soon
Nov 14, 2024 at 06:06 AM
BastianK
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.

And at that point, it would be even more safe to assume that if they have not bothered to optimize the newly released 50/1.5 you’re probably not getting any of the other cine lenses optimized. Or the stills versions.
Based on my experience with my modified A7CR UT and E-mount lenses (FE 35/1.8 and FE 55/1.8), I believe the corners will shift "inwards" instead of "outwards." This should positively impact the rendering, making the corners appear even more "out of focus." This effect is the opposite of what we typically see with M-lenses on a stock Sony sensor. It might be different with the Simera, but it's worth testing. Please share your results!
Yes, my experience too with the GM 24 and others. All this is explained well here, with all sorts of other info. This is still the best written article IMO, even though it’s old now:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification/#Performance_with_Native_FE_Lenses


There has since been a new article with more epmhasis on how different filter stacks affect bokeh rendering:
https://phillipreeve.net/blog/different-filter-stacks-and-what-they-mean-for-us-sony-e-nikon-z-leica-m-kolari-ut/

In the meantime I also received a review sample of the Simera 50mm 1.4.
I haven't fully made up my mind about it yet.
If you are looking for a fast yet close focusing M-mount 50mm this is a really great option.
Contrast is not as good as the Voigtländers though and the mechanical design (while improved over 28 and 35mm) also isn't.
Nov 14, 2024 at 06:11 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.12 #9Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
BastianK wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.

And at that point, it would be even more safe to assume that if they have not bothered to optimize the newly released 50/1.5 you’re probably not getting any of the other cine lenses optimized. Or the stills versions.
Based on my experience with my modified A7CR UT and E-mount lenses (FE 35/1.8 and FE 55/1.8), I believe the corners will shift "inwards" instead of "outwards." This should positively impact the rendering, making the corners appear even more "out of focus." This effect is the opposite of what we typically see with M-lenses on a stock Sony sensor. It might be different with the Simera, but it's worth testing. Please share your results!
Yes, my experience too with the GM 24 and others. All this is explained well here, with all sorts of other info. This is still the best written article IMO, even though it’s old now:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification/#Performance_with_Native_FE_Lenses
There has since been a new article with more epmhasis on how different filter stacks affect bokeh rendering:
https://phillipreeve.net/blog/different-filter-stacks-and-what-they-mean-for-us-sony-e-nikon-z-leica-m-kolari-ut/

In the meantime I also received a review sample of the Simera 50mm 1.4.
I haven't fully made up my mind about it yet.
If you are looking for a fast yet close focusing M-mount 50mm this is a really great option.
Contrast is not as good as the Voigtländers though and the mechanical design (while improved over 28 and 35mm) also isn't.


E or m mount version?

That article you wrote and linked above is excellent—have linked and referenced multiple times.

Funnny on contrast—that’s what I have been harping about this whole thread. At websized unprocessed, I thought the Lux had more bite WO, but looked close.

Then again, nothing like actually shooting lens is a real world environment.

And, agree, I already know the ergo is so-so.
Nov 14, 2024 at 09:26 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #10Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
I will be receiving the Simera 28mm f/1.4 for review soon. I plan to test it using the same methods as with the Simera 50mm, and I will compare its performance to other 28mm lenses.
Nov 14, 2024 at 10:08 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #11Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Funnny on contrast—that’s what I have been harping about this whole thread. At websized unprocessed, I thought the Lux had more bite WO, but looked close.

Then again, nothing like actually shooting lens is a real world environment.

And, agree, I already know the ergo is so-so.


It was challenging to distinguish between the Simera and Leica in the blind tests I posted in this thread. However, when comparing the images side by side at the pixel level, the Leica shows a slight edge in resolution and contrast across the image field, especially at closer distances of 1 to 3 meters.

At infinity, the Leica has an advantage in the center, while the Simera performs better in the mid-field. Therefore, for most images, such as portraits, the Leica will display slightly higher contrast and resolution when shot wide open, but in my opinion, the difference is not very noticeable.
Nov 14, 2024 at 10:20 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
nehemiahphoto wroteFunnny on contrast—that’s what I have been harping about this whole thread. At websized unprocessed, I thought the Lux had more bite WO, but looked close.

Then again, nothing like actually shooting lens is a real world environment.

And, agree, I already know the ergo is so-so.
It was challenging to distinguish between the Simera and Leica in the blind tests I posted in this thread. However, when comparing the images side by side at the pixel level, the Leica shows a slight edge in resolution and contrast across the image field, especially at closer distances of 1 to 3 meters.

At infinity, the Leica has an advantage in the center, while the Simera performs better in the mid-field. Therefore, for most images, such as portraits, the Leica will display slightly higher contrast and resolution when shot wide open, but in my opinion, the difference is
...Show more →

I think I’ll pick up a copy for myself to try Are you getting a 28 e or m mount version?

Did you try shooting both lenses in dimmer, less contrasty light? Higher contrast light helps lower to mid contrast lenses have more bite.
Nov 14, 2024 at 10:42 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #13Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteFunnny on contrast—that’s what I have been harping about this whole thread. At websized unprocessed, I thought the Lux had more bite WO, but looked close.

Then again, nothing like actually shooting lens is a real world environment.

And, agree, I already know the ergo is so-so.
It was challenging to distinguish between the Simera and Leica in the blind tests I posted in this thread. However, when comparing the images side by side at the pixel level, the Leica shows a slight edge in resolution and contrast across the image field, especially at closer distances of 1 to 3 meters.

At infinity, the Leica has an advantage in the center, while the Simera performs better in the mid-field. Therefore, for most images, such as portraits, the Leica will display slightly higher contrast and resolution when shot wide open, but in my opinion, the difference is not very noticeable.
I think I’ll pick up a copy for myself to try Are you getting a 28 e or m mount version?

Did you try shooting both lenses in dimmer, less contrasty light? Higher contrast light helps lower to mid contrast lenses have more bite.


M-mount. I'm really curious to try this one since it's received a lot of praise. I shot in both high and low contrast lighting, and my impressions still hold. It's a modern lens that delivers high contrast and excellent resolution. While it might not quite match the Leica 50/1.4 Lux in the center, the difference is minimal to the point where it's barely noticeable.

This issue isn’t as relevant for mirrorless cameras, but with rangefinder cameras, it’s crucial to get a perfectly aligned copy of the Simera 50. Although Thypoch might pay great attention to alignment, I can’t confirm this since I only tested one copy of the Simera 50, which was perfectly aligned. This is important because the focus throw from 0.7m to infinity is short (shorter than the Leica 50/1.4 ASPH. v1) and when shooting at wide apertures, the depth of field is narrow. Therefore, even a slight misalignment can result in noticeably out-of-focus images.
Nov 14, 2024 at 10:47 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #14Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
BastianK wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.

And at that point, it would be even more safe to assume that if they have not bothered to optimize the newly released 50/1.5 you’re probably not getting any of the other cine lenses optimized. Or the stills versions.
Based on my experience with my modified A7CR UT and E-mount lenses (FE 35/1.8 and FE 55/1.8), I believe the corners will shift "inwards" instead of "outwards." This should positively impact the rendering, making the corners appear even more "out of focus." This effect is the opposite of what we typically see with M-lenses on a stock Sony sensor. It might be different with the Simera, but it's worth testing. Please share your results!
Yes, my experience too with the GM 24 and others. All this is explained well here, with all sorts of other info. This is still the best written article IMO, even though it’s old now:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification/#Performance_with_Native_FE_Lenses
There has since been a new article with more epmhasis on how different filter stacks affect bokeh rendering:
https://phillipreeve.net/blog/different-filter-stacks-and-what-they-mean-for-us-sony-e-nikon-z-leica-m-kolari-ut/

In the meantime I also received a review sample of the Simera 50mm 1.4.
I haven't fully made up my mind about it yet.
If you are looking for a fast yet close focusing M-mount 50mm this is a really great option.
Contrast is not as good as the Voigtländers though and the mechanical design (while improved over 28 and 35mm) also isn't.


Hi Bastian,
Thanks so much for pointing me to the Simera lenses and sharing my contact with the company! I'll admit, I was a bit skeptical about Thypoch at first, but after checking out their latest Simera 50/1.4, I can definitely see why it's getting all the attention.
Nov 14, 2024 at 11:23 AM
BastianK
Offline
Details
p.12 #15Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
BastianK wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.

And at that point, it would be even more safe to assume that if they have not bothered to optimize the newly released 50/1.5 you’re probably not getting any of the other cine lenses optimized. Or the stills versions.
Based on my experience with my modified A7CR UT and E-mount lenses (FE 35/1.8 and FE 55/1.8), I believe the corners will shift "inwards" instead of "outwards." This should positively impact the rendering, making the corners appear even more "out of focus." This effect is the opposite of what we typically see with M-lenses on a stock Sony sensor. It might be different with the Simera, but it's worth testing. Please share your results!
Yes, my experience too with the GM 24 and others. All this is explained well here, with all sorts of other info. This is still the best written article IMO, even though it’s old now:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification/#Performance_with_Native_FE_Lenses
There has since been a new article with more epmhasis on how different filter stacks affect bokeh rendering:
https://phillipreeve.net/blog/different-filter-stacks-and-what-they-mean-for-us-sony-e-nikon-z-leica-m-kolari-ut/

In the meantime I also received a review sample of the Simera 50mm 1.4.
I haven't fully made up my mind about it yet.
If you are looking for a fast yet close focusing M-mount 50mm this is a really great option.
Contrast is not as good as the Voigtländers though and the mechanical design (while improved over 28 and 35mm) also isn't.
E or m mount version?

M

Fred Miranda wrote:
BastianK wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI am tempted to order the Simera-C 50/1.5 and try it on both my modded Sony and native Sony. If it performs worse on stock, I would return to B + H.

And at that point, it would be even more safe to assume that if they have not bothered to optimize the newly released 50/1.5 you’re probably not getting any of the other cine lenses optimized. Or the stills versions.
Based on my experience with my modified A7CR UT and E-mount lenses (FE 35/1.8 and FE 55/1.8), I believe the corners will shift "inwards" instead of "outwards." This should positively impact the rendering, making the corners appear even more "out of focus." This effect is the opposite of what we typically see with M-lenses on a stock Sony sensor. It might be different with the Simera, but it's worth testing. Please share your results!
Yes, my experience too with the GM 24 and others. All this is explained well here, with all sorts of other info. This is still the best written article IMO, even though it’s old now:

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-kolari-ultra-thin-sensor-stack-modification/#Performance_with_Native_FE_Lenses
There has since been a new article with more epmhasis on how different filter stacks affect bokeh rendering:
https://phillipreeve.net/blog/different-filter-stacks-and-what-they-mean-for-us-sony-e-nikon-z-leica-m-kolari-ut/

In the meantime I also received a review sample of the Simera 50mm 1.4.
I haven't fully made up my mind about it yet.
If you are looking for a fast yet close focusing M-mount 50mm this is a really great option.
Contrast is not as good as the Voigtländers though and the mechanical design (while improved over 28 and 35mm) also isn't.
Hi Bastian,
Thanks so much for pointing me to the Simera lenses and sharing my contact with the company! I'll admit, I was a bit skeptical about Thypoch at first, but after checking out their latest Simera 50/1.4, I can definitely see why it's getting all the attention.

Nothing to thank me for.

I kept the 28mm 1.4 Simera as I think it renders the nicest bokeh among the fast 28mm M-mount lenses.
When it comes to 50mm lenses there is just such a huge competition which makes it harder to stand out.
Nov 14, 2024 at 11:55 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.12 #16Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
I have ordered an 50/1.5 Simera-C for e-mount. Would like to see the optical performance of M versus stock* Sony.

And I have a ZA 50/1.4, 50/1 Noct to compare it with.

Edited on Nov 14, 2024 at 03:30 PM · View previous versions
Nov 14, 2024 at 03:09 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #17Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
I have ordered an 50/1.5 Simera-C for e-mount. Would like to see the optical performance of M versus modded Sony.

And I have a ZA 50/1.4, 50/1 Noct to compare it with.


That’s great, Nehemiah!

Please post your findings. Your modded Sony should perform just like the Leica M --- at least mine does!
Nov 14, 2024 at 03:26 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
Thanks Fred! And I mis-typed. I mean performance of the 50/1.5 on Stock versus modded Sony.

This is a “native” e-mount lens. So going to see if Thypoch is offering a lens that performs best within the mount it’s sold under. Or if it’s not essentially a dummy adapter.
Nov 14, 2024 at 03:33 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
Fred Miranda wrote:
I will be receiving the Simera 28mm f/1.4 for review soon. I plan to test it using the same methods as with the Simera 50mm, and I will compare its performance to other 28mm lenses.


Do you still have the 28 Lux to compare it against? This is the only information missing from Bastian's review.

With the current Thypoch discount I'm tempted to get both the 28 and 50 to compare against the Luxes...

nehemiahphoto wrote:
I have ordered an 50/1.5 Simera-C for e-mount. Would like to see the optical performance of M versus stock* Sony.


Awesome! Looking forward to it. Kind of wish Thypoch offered the cine lenses in other mirrorless mounts as well. I'd be inclined to consider it for Canon RF over M... and chipped would be even better for access to Canon's focusing aids, but would probably be hoping for too much.
Nov 14, 2024 at 04:01 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.12 #20Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 ASPH. Review
rscheffler wrote:
Do you still have the 28 Lux to compare it against? This is the only information missing from Bastian's review.


Sorry, but I’ll test it against the Voigtlander 28/1.5 Nokton (my favorite 28mm so far) and also compare it at f/2.8 to the LLL 28/2.8. I no longer own the 28mm Lux.

That said, I've used the 28mm Lux for a long time and compared it to the Nokton. As shown in the Voigtlander 28mm f/1.5 Nokton review, their performance and rendering are very similar.
Nov 14, 2024 at 04:26 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister