I've been enjoying these Thypoch Simera lenses. I'll probably rent a few Summilux lenses down the line, but for the price, these things are pretty damn good. Shot this one on the 50 at a shutter speed a little too slow for an IBIS-less M11. Untitled Philly I by Roman France, on Flickr
'for the price'. It's a common refrain, isn't it. (BTW, have you seen how many views this thread has accrued?). When I start seeing posts about the little things that peeve users as threads slow down, I start posting images - the things that matter! To me, anyway, and to maybe assist the buying decisions of others.. cheers.
What a great thread and knowledgeable community! I'm leaning towards the Simera-C 50mm version just for the longer focus throw. However, I can't find any information on whether there's an aperture click and de-click mechanism on the Simera-C lenses. Can someone with the lens confirm if an aperture click is possible? The click selector on the standard Simera would seem to have to be moved from the aperture ring since the aperture is geared on the Simera-C. I wouldn't be surprised if there isn't a way to click the aperture ring, but just wanted to know for certain.
• Simera (Photo Line): Designed for rangefinder and mirrorless stills. They feature an aperture ring marked with "Sun" and "Moon" symbols and a physical lever allowing you to click (for distinct tactile f-stop feedback) or declick (for smooth, silent adjustments).
• Simera-C (Cinema Line): Specifically adapted for filmmaking. The iris movement is completely clickless and smooth from wide-open (T1.5 or T1.9 depending on the focal length) down to T16, allowing for fluid exposure adjustments during a shot.
The C series 50/1.4 is 353g and 369g (M and E-mounts) and the stills Simera 50/1.4 is 281g and 309g (M and Z-mounts), for comparison. The T-stop marks are well-spaced (in 1/3 stops) as a benefit of the longer 210 degree throw of the C lenses.
Many Leica M users love the clicky-clack of aperture ring detents for reasons I've never been able to fathom, they sound cheap to me. Once you adjust to a smooth aperture and the ring rotation needed for what you shoot, it feels natural.
In fact, the stills Simeras have a very subdued detent feel and report, attracting even more criticism for this deliberate design implementation, to go along with the compressed small aperture text spacing, also deliberate and rather common..such is life. cheers.
Thanks Phillip, I'm aware of the purpose of the two different lineups, but just couldn't find a factual confirmation that the Simera-C didn't have click stops available. The lack of information neither confirms nor denies.
I missed that the T-stops have consistent 1/3 stop spacing, that would be nice.
I've never used a clickless aperture ring so that will be a new experience. Just another factor to consider.
This is funny. Prior to posting here, I had asked both Thypoch support via email, and their Chat, whether the Simera-C had a click/de-click feature.
First I got an email answer back from their Chat saying the Simera-C DOES have a click/de-click lever.
Then I got an email from a sales engineer saying the Simera-C DOES NOT have a click/de-click lever. !
I trust the sales engineer more than the Chat, and thanked them for their reply and that they should check their Chat bot.
I guess the good news is that they responded in roughly a day or so, within 36 hours, basically next day given the time zone difference.
In following up on the sensor stack thickness discussion earlier in the thread, I found some links that show physical measurements and thought I'd provide them for reference.
Sensor Stack Thickness: When Does It Matter? by Roger Cicala, June 9, 2014
Apologies if this link was posted earlier, I tried searching and couldn't find it.
The third message down, shown as #2, gives measurements.
Assuming Roger's measurements are accurate, and the M9 sensor stack is 0.8 mm and the Nikon Z measurement stated from the Leica Forum thread is accurate at 1.1 mm, the Z is 37.5% thicker! The Sony sensor is over double the thickness.
I got a Thypoch Simera-C and returned it for a Simera the next day. Some observations for anyone wondering about the differences between the two:
1. The Simera-C has the index marks for the focus ring and aperture on the side of the barrel instead of at the top, 3 O'clock from behind the camera. If I had known this, I wouldn't have bought it, just pure ignorance on my part. Doh! I've never used a cine lens before. I'm sure it's usable but the ergonomics just seemed awkward for still photography.
2. The Leica mount Simera-C comes with lens adjustment shims. This seems like a great feature to help people tune the lens to their camera.
3. The aperture and focus rings are in the "conventional" arrangement with the focus ring in front and the aperture ring in the rear versus the Simera with the focus ring in the back and the aperture ring in the front.
4. The Simera-C has a de-clicked aperture ring while the Simera has a click/de-click switch.
5. The Simera-C didn't seem large to me but it's distinctly larger than the Simera. The Simera-C is "autofocus" size versus the Simera at "rangefinder" size.
6. The Simera-C seems to be more robustly built than the Simera, just appears sturdier. However, in no way do I mean to imply the Simera is cheaply built, it seems fine.
7. The Simera-C uses larger filters, you can see this in the specs, but just wanted to point it out.
I have the Simera 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 in Sony mount. Both are terrific. I would like them to make the 50mm in Sony mount but so far no luck. However, the Viltrox 50/2 Air is so good I may not need a 50 Simera. Anyone out there with both the 50 Simera and Viltrox 50/2 care to comment on image quality between the two?
I imagine it would also be easier to sell a Simera-C lens as they are something of a fixture in the indie/hybrid arena. None of it would put me off for mirrorless use where focus has good EVF feedback, and many often use in-between aperture settings (like f1.7 or f2.4), where the clicks just get in the way, if the detents are too aggressive. Wide open is the reference and rapid habit formation does the rest, for aperture changes. Many simply use WO. Filters are 62mm or 67mm - easy and cheap-ish.
I am trying to resist the 100/1.8-C and expect to win here, but only if Mandler does the right thing by us and remakes / retunes the Summilux 75/1.4. It will be (there is confidence for you!) a very different lens from the Simera 75mm so would be usable in a different session. The 100mm C lens will be a longer 75/1.4 and would steal work from it. cheers.