fredmiranda.com Login

G9II vs OM1II

  
 
ruthenium
Offline

p.1 #1G9II vs OM1II
I am not sure if there might be interest in this comparison.
I compared the colors of the two cameras, and whether the colors change when underexposed by 3 stops, then recovered in post.
A few words about the methodology.
-the lens used was Panaleica 10-25mm F1.7 at 25mm.
- all raw files were obtained in full manual, using the mechanical shutter on OM-1 II. On G9II, the shutter was set to EFC at ISO 100, and to electronic at ISO 3200 (the EFC shutter on G9II is limited to ISO 1600).
- at F2, the raw images were correctly exposed in-camera
- then, the aperture was closed to F5.6 while keeping the SS and ISO unchanged. Hence the corresponding raw images were underexposed by three stops.
- the raw files obtained at the base ISO and F2 were opened in DxO PL8, where calibrated DCP color profiles were created from the images from each camera.
-these color profiles were applied on all raw images (OM1II profile on the OM1II images and G9II profile on the G9II images); the exposure was lifted by exactly 3 stops for the underexposed images.
-only the lens distortion was corrected and de-noising was applied: DxO DeepPRIME for the images at base ISO, and DxO DeepPRIME XD2s for the images at ISO3200. No other correction has been used.

The results are uploaded below. I don't see a major difference between the two. The only thing I noticed was that whereas the results for G9II were well-reproducible, there was some occasional inconsistency between the images taken with OM1II. Some of the underexposed images showed a green-ish cast. I did not use these for the comparison below.

The last thing, I also compared the colors of the Vivid profile on G9II (in the out-of-camera jpg, at ISO 100 and F2) with the colors obtained in DxO PL8 after applying the custom DCP profile. This comparison is in the last (third) upload given below. The Vivid is the top image.






from OM-1 II







from G9II







G9II: out-of-camera jpg compared with one obtained in DxO PL8

Oct 27, 2024 at 01:47 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.1 #2G9II vs OM1II
Here is another comparison of the colors of G9II and OM-1 II at their base ISO and at ISO 3200, properly exposed at F4 then underexposed by three stops at F11, followed by recovery in post.
The lens was Oly 300mm F4. Electronic shutters of G9II and OM-1 II were used to acquire the raw images.
I used the custom G9II and OM1 II color profiles obtained as described in the previous post. DeepPRIME XD2s denoising was applied and sharpening was set to +0.5 in DxO PL8. The contrast was not corrected in any way, directly or indirectly. Vignetting correction was not used.
The first upload shows a full-sized image from OM-1 II at F4 and ISO 200.
The second upload is the corresponding underexposed image at F11 and ISO 200.
Uploads 3 and 4 are comparisons of the crops taken from the full-sized images at the base ISO and at ISO 3200, properly exposed (on top) and the underexposed-then-recovered in post (at the bottom).
There are some subtle differences in colors, but both sensors in G9II and OM1 II have enough dynamic range to allow satisfactory recovery of underexposed by three stops images at the base ISO as well as at the relatively high ISO 3200.




  OM-1MarkII     OLYMPUS M.300mm F4.0 lens    300mm    f/4.0    1/60s    200 ISO    0.0 EV  






  OM-1MarkII     OLYMPUS M.300mm F4.0 lens    300mm    f/11.0    1/60s    200 ISO    0.0 EV  







G9II vs OM1 II at the base ISO







G9II vs OM1 II at ISO3200

Oct 28, 2024 at 09:32 PM
Dr_Fishy
Offline
Details
p.1 #3G9II vs OM1II
Thanks for sharing...I am debating picking up an OM1 or G9ii with the BH deal going on right now. Leaning towards OM1 for mainly stills, the body is a bit smaller and I am already very familiar with using olympus bodies.
Oct 30, 2024 at 09:49 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.1 #4G9II vs OM1II
The most useful review that I have seen (and read three times, as it is long and very detailed) is from Lothar Katz:
https://thisbeautifulplanet.de/panasonic-g9ii-vs-omds-om-1-compared-for-bird-shooting
If you haven't seen this review - have a look, and hopefully it may help you to decide. My own, still limited experience with G9II, is practically the same as that of Lothar.
Oct 30, 2024 at 11:00 AM
Robin Smith
Offline
Details
p.1 #5G9II vs OM1II
An issue with looking at color comparisons is what your viewing monitor is like, and how well it can display any differences. I have to confess I can see little difference between them, but I think that is similar to the OPs thoughts.

One thing I do notice about the OM1 (mk 1)(and the EM1 Mk2) compared to Sony is that I spend a lot more time getting the white balance correct, or at least how I like it. I find that the OM makes the images very warm by default in RAW, and I very frequently have to tweak it cooler, something I only very rarely do with Sony files. It seems that once there is any warm sunlight in the scene the OM goes overboard and needs restraining. On the other hand I do like its ability to handle reds well.

I spend much more time post processing m43 files than FF and fixing WB is one of those things contributing to this time. I'm not complaining as I am a big fan of m43.
Oct 31, 2024 at 09:46 AM
Tom Reynolds
Offline
Details
p.1 #6G9II vs OM1II
Interesting report BUT the report is based on an OM-1 mk 1 firmware version 1.4 not 1.7. Further, the OM-1mk 2 has increased the buffer and the AF subject ID focusing.

I still have an OM-1 mk 1 which is updated to firmware 1.7 but I essentially never use it because the mk 2 has several, small but important upgrades for bird photography.

Tom
Oct 31, 2024 at 04:26 PM


FM ForumsMicro Four Thirds ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister