p.1 #1Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Hello fellow FM members. I guess I'm a bit excited and wanted to share and also ask the members. What have you enjoyed moving to this body? Was it worth for you. Top 3 things you like?
Just some quick observations
its slightly heavier, but the larger grip is 100% worth it
smallright is required for that pinky extension grip
EVF seems a lot better than a7RIV
Tilt screen not a huge thing for me personally
same sensor (nothing to see here)
I feel like the biggest actually new feature is the AI which does seem better overall.
What things am I missing that you have enjoyed? (that maybe I can explore) or overall feedback.
CFE A instead of a B seems like a super "miss" by Sony. The cards cost more than 2TB NVME drives.
Do you think Sony will give us anymore firmware updates to this body?
p.1 #4Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
I moved from an A7RIII to an A7RV and I think the bigger grip and overall bulkier body help a lot. I shoot for work and often handhold for many hours. I feel smaller bodies make my hands tired faster, so Sony making these cameras more towards the tried-and-true DSLR size helps with strenuous work-type uses.
I photograph mainly people and portraits, so I was happy to ditch the landscape tilt screen on my A7RIII and older cameras. A7RV's multi-tilt screen is a bit fidgety, but it's much better than shooting blind because the screen can't tilt the right way.
The new menu is good too. AFAIK, the A7RIV uses the old horizontal scrolling menu, and I think the new menu makes more sense... that's because Sony is kind of mimicking the proven DSLR menus (like Nikon's).
My work partner shooting with my A7RV + 50 1.2 GM:
p.1 #5Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Honestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced.
p.1 #6Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
For me the top things were:
1. larger, higher resolution EVF that can be zoomed to provide view of the entire image with glasses.
2. White balance AI and sensor, white balance is basically correct now.
3. Improved color science, mainly a result of the WB, but I find JPG usable now.
4. Improved IBIS.
5. Fast CPU that does not require the files to be written before changing settings.
6. Fast writing of files.
7 Improved focus.
Thing I don't like:
1. increased size and weight
2. Menus more complex.
p.1 #7Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
I do enjoy the larger grip, however I do miss how much lighter the A7RIV felt (if that makes any sense).
The menu system was another reason I moved. I'm having to learn where things are, but overall I think its an improvement. (the processor makes it much faster)
I guess I'm 2 years late for this upgrade, however I'm not a pro, and just upgrade has prices decrease and my budget allows for "fun" upgrades.
Appreciate the discussion and everyone's perspective.
p.1 #8Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Totally agree. I moved to Sony becausr it was small. Every generation they make it bigger and it is never enough for people.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Honestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced....Show more →
p.1 #9Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Lukacs wrote:
How is the eye recognision compare? I wish my RIV can find eye easier sometimes.
Yeah same here I just finished up shooting the LLBWS Championship parade and I had to turn off the eyeAF as it was just abismal. Anything longer than 6-8 feet was unreliable. I don’t usually shoot events with this camera, but thought maybe I could use the extra resolutions for cropping since it was a huge crowd and wasn’t sure how close I’d get. My ancient A9 is a lot better, and in retrospect I shoulda used that body instead.
p.1 #10Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Honestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced....Show more →
I am completely with you on this one. The larger size is a key reason that I have stayed away from the A7RV. I so much prefer the smaller bodies. My trajectory into Sony from Canon was the NEX-7, the a6000, the A7RII, the A7RIII and the A9 The RIII and A9 were about as big as I wanted them to get.
Using a larger body tends to make for a different kind of photography and a different attitude toward picture taking--more intrusive, obvious, less contemplative and quietly thoughtful. At least that is the case for me. The bigger bodies make the weight and size of the camera intrude on my awareness more. Obvisously this can be overcome, but I do prefer the experience of shooting with a smaller, easier-to-hand body.
I do like the size of the A7Cxx bodies a lot, but after telling myself I didn't care for a long time, I realize that I do care about the EVF and the LCD. I would like those to be better even if it means the cameras get a smidge larger. But I will live with the current EVF and LCD. The most annoying thing is that it makes it a bit harder to check focus critically--need to magnify all the time.
It is also good that Sony is making high quality small lenses. I am a fan of the 40G and 50G; and the 16-25 & 25-50 zooms are high quality and excellent rendering in a very small and light form factor. They are perfect on the A7Cxx cameras.
In the search for even smaller and more discrete, I am playing with the idea of putting an aps-c 16-70/4.0 lens on an A7CR for walking around in foreign cities. It would be a very small setup with an effective 24-105 FOV.
p.1 #11Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Strange. I felt the exact opposite in the analogue days. The bigger and therefore bulkier the camera was, the more contemplative, quiet and thoughtful the photographic process was. OK, that can't be transferred 1:1 to slightly different sized 35mm bodies, but I wanted to mention it.
p.1 #12Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Honestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced....Show more →
I too really loved the A7r II body, which has been one of my main camera until recently when I upgraded to the a7r V. I like the A7r V substantially more despite its bigger size. The main thing I like about the A7r V is the EVF. It is just lovely and worth the extra size and weight for me. I also really like the back LCD, again they are really worth the size and weight, and they add more weight than one might expect because screen with that size and resolution and clarity are power hungry so the battery had to get bigger to get reasonable battery life--it was already pretty bad with the A7r II with the smaller lower resolution EVF and LCD. Then there is the computational capabilities, which include the massively better AF, and that has to take a bit more battery life too, and all three of those things (better EVF, better LCD, and better computational ability/AF) are to me very much worth the extra size and weight increases.
That said, part of the reason they are worth it to me is I have pretty huge hands. I am 6' 3" tall and I can't really find gloves big enough for my hands--extra large are noticeably small. So a bigger body has different tradeoffs for me. Yeah I like the smaller size for carrying the camera, but for holding the camera I appreciate a bit bigger body as my hands are less scrunched. The real problem that I have with Sony bodies, however is that there is so little space between the grip and the lens. My fingers are often squished in that space. It is the 127mm dimension on the A7r II and still only 131mm even on the A7r V that I find too small. I much prefer the 139mm on the Leica M10 I used to own and it of course has no grip and a smaller diameter mount, so it felt like lots of room for my hands. My Nikon Z7 isn't much better at 134mm and a larger diameter mount. By the way, I think one of the reasons that the grip has gotten bigger isn't really trying to make it more ergonomic, which I don't think the bigger grip actually does, it is rather to allow for the bigger battery, which as described above I do think is needed for what I like most, but if I could have that bigger battery with no grip at all I would be much happier, and even if they can't do that, which I don't think they can, if they would just make that 131mm dimension more like 140mm and turned the battery to make the grip not stick out as much, I would be much happier with more room for the huge mitt that is my right hand.
Also keep in mind a big part of the reason the A7C series can be so small is largely because they went back to the same resolution EVF as the A7r II. It is nice to have the choice, but even though I like small cameras I have a clear preference for a bigger better EVF over a smaller camera. When I replaced my A7r II, it was an easy choice for me to get the A7r V over an A7CR. I value the excellent EVF in the A7r V way too much now that I have used it to go back to the low resolution A7CR EVF. Of course other people can and should weigh these tradeoffs differently, but there is a natural tradeoff between a bigger high resolution EVF size and size of the camera especially if you maintain decent battery life and I will go with a better EVF over smaller size given how I weigh that tradeoff.
So, in my view Sony's A7R series has gotten bigger, but it isn't primarily driven by bloat. It is driven by improvements to the EVF, LCD, and computational capabilities of the camera, all of which drive a bigger battery as well and for me those improvements are worth the bigger size of the camera. Fortunately, in the Sony world if those improvements are not worth the increasing size to you, the A7C is there for you with its lower resolution EVF, smaller battery, and smaller size. Nobody else provides that choice, so like the Joe Walsh song, "I can't complain, but sometimes I still do."
p.1 #13Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
The A7C (all versions) uses the same battery as the A7RV. All A7 and A7R models (etc) since the A9i, A7iii and A7Riii use the larger Z battery. It hasn't been the reason for steadily increasing body sizes for a long time now.
p.1 #14Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
GHarris wrote:
The A7C (all versions) uses the same battery as the A7RV. All A7 and A7R models (etc) since the A9i, A7iii and A7Riii use the larger Z battery. It hasn't been the reason for steadily increasing body sizes for a long time now.
Yes, the body size increases are not related to battery size. I think they have more driven by the preferences of professional photographers who shoot for long periods with a camera in their hands and by Sony's expansion into large tele prime and zoom lenses, for which a large, gripped body is desirable.
Sony does clearly recognize that there is a strong preference among many of their customers for small and light camera bodies and gear. Thus the A7Cxx bodies and lenses like the 40G, 50G, and the 16-25, and 25-50 zooms.
p.1 #15Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
GHarris wrote:
The A7C (all versions) uses the same battery as the A7RV. All A7 and A7R models (etc) since the A9i, A7iii and A7Riii use the larger Z battery. It hasn't been the reason for steadily increasing body sizes for a long time now.
I am sorry, but this is a very simplistic way to look at the relation between camera capabilities and battery life, IMO. Look at Fred's listing of the specs. The big jump in grip size from 60mm to 74mm is between the A7r II and A7r III exactly when the bigger battery was introduced. We also saw a big increase in weight with that battery from 625g to 657g. With the A7r IV and the same battery there is only a tiny increase in grip size from 74mm to 78mm and in weight from 657g to 665g. Then there is a big jump from the A7r IV to the A7r V, but we got a much higher resolution EVF and a different and in my view much more capable LCD, and more computational abilities with that increase in size and we got that without much of a hit at all in battery life. Battery efficiency improved, but with those power hungry new capabilities the battery could not be made smaller to offset the size required by those new capabilities, so the camera grew in size again.
Now if you strip out those capabilities (or at least most of them with a lower resolution EVF, simpler LCD, and get some other efficiencies like a simpler shutter) you can keep the camera small and actually improve the battery life like Sony did with the A7C series, and get a small camera. But just because the same battery is used does not mean there is no relation between power use of the camera when it adds capabilities and size partly driven by the size and capability of the battery. The current Sony batteries are great, so they did not need to change them, but as batteries improve efficiency it should be possible to reduce their size, but not if you add capabilities that require more power.
p.1 #16Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteHonestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced.I too really loved the A7r II body, which has been one of my main camera until recently when I upgraded to the a7r V. I like the A7r V substantially more despite its bigger size. The main thing I like about the A7r V is the EVF. It is just lovely and worth the extra size and weight for me. I also really like the back LCD, again they are really worth the size and weight, and they add more weight than one might expect because screen with that size and resolution and clarity are power hungry so the battery had to get bigger to get reasonable battery life--it was already pretty bad with the A7r II with the smaller lower resolution EVF and LCD. Then there is the computational capabilities, which include the massively better AF, and that has to take a bit more battery life too, and all three of those things (better EVF, better LCD, and better computational ability/AF) are to me very much worth the extra size and weight increases.
That said, part of the reason they are worth it to me is I have pretty huge hands. I am 6' 3" tall and I can't really find gloves big enough for my hands--extra large are noticeably small. So a bigger body has different tradeoffs for me. Yeah I like the smaller size for carrying the camera, but for holding the camera I appreciate a bit bigger body as my hands are less scrunched. The real problem that I have with Sony bodies, however is that there is so little space between the grip and the lens. My fingers are often squished in that space. It is the 127mm dimension on the A7r II and still only 131mm even on the A7r V that I find too small. I much prefer the 139mm on the Leica M10 I used to own and it of course has no grip and a smaller diameter mount, so it felt like lots of room for my hands. My Nikon Z7 isn't much better at 134mm and a larger diameter mount. By the way, I think one of the reasons that the grip has gotten bigger isn't really trying to make it more ergonomic, which I don't think the bigger grip actually does, it is rather to allow for the bigger battery, which as described above I do think is needed for what I like most, but if I could have that bigger battery with no grip at all I would be much happier, and even if they can't do that, which I don't think they can, if they would just make that 131mm dimension more like 140mm and turned the battery to make the grip not stick out as much, I would be much happier with more room for the huge mitt that is my right hand.
Also keep in mind a big part of the reason the A7C series can be so small is largely because they went back to the same resolution EVF as the A7r II. It is nice to have the choice, but even though I like small cameras I have a clear preference for a bigger better EVF over a smaller camera. When I replaced my A7r II, it was an easy choice for me to get the A7r V over an A7CR. I value the excellent EVF in the A7r V way too much now that I have used it to go back to the low resolution A7CR EVF. Of course other people can and should weigh these tradeoffs differently, but there is a natural tradeoff between a bigger high resolution EVF size and size of the camera especially if you maintain decent battery life and I will go with a better EVF over smaller size given how I weigh that tradeoff.
So, in my view Sony's A7R series has gotten bigger, but it isn't primarily driven by bloat. It is driven by improvements to the EVF, LCD, and computational capabilities of the camera, all of which drive a bigger battery as well and for me those improvements are worth the bigger size of the camera. Fortunately, in the Sony world if those improvements are not worth the increasing size to you, the A7C is there for you with its lower resolution EVF, smaller battery, and smaller size. Nobody else provides that choice, so like the Joe Walsh song, "I can't complain, but sometimes I still do."...Show more →
From the outside looking in, it seems for some unknown reasons, it took Sony til 2024 with the A9III body design to slightly increase the awkward/infamous too narrow e-mount gap between grip and mount. More than once I thought if Sony would have increased that gap even by a smidge on earlier models, maybe Sony didn't need to increase the overall size of their cameras year after year. As you pointed out other brands seemed to have figured this out years ago.
Personally, I would love to own and use the new A9III body design, but currently it only comes with a 24MP sensor and IMO questionable ISO performance, so not for me ATT.
Otherwise there has always been plenty of small camera kit choices available in the market for years. As you wrote, just seems a matter of which comprises were are willing to accept for small and compact.
p.1 #17Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Steve Spencer wrote: Fred Miranda wroteHonestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced.I too really loved the A7r II body, which has been one of my main camera until recently when I upgraded to the a7r V. I like the A7r V substantially more despite its bigger size. The main thing I like about the A7r V is the EVF. It is just lovely and worth the extra size and weight for me. I also really like the back LCD, again they are really worth the size and weight, and they add more weight than one might expect because screen with that size and resolution and clarity are power hungry so the battery had to get bigger to get reasonable battery life--it was already pretty bad with the A7r II with the smaller lower resolution EVF and LCD. Then there is the computational capabilities, which include the massively better AF, and that has to take a bit more battery life too, and all three of those things (better EVF, better LCD, and better computational ability/AF) are to me very much worth the extra size and weight increases.
That said, part of the reason they are worth it to me is I have pretty huge hands. I am 6' 3" tall and I can't really find gloves big enough for my hands--extra large are noticeably small. So a bigger body has different tradeoffs for me. Yeah I like the smaller size for carrying the camera, but for holding the camera I appreciate a bit bigger body as my hands are less scrunched. The real problem that I have with Sony bodies, however is that there is so little space between the grip and the lens. My fingers are often squished in that space. It is the 127mm dimension on the A7r II and still only 131mm even on the A7r V that I find too small. I much prefer the 139mm on the Leica M10 I used to own and it of course has no grip and a smaller diameter mount, so it felt like lots of room for my hands. My Nikon Z7 isn't much better at 134mm and a larger diameter mount. By the way, I think one of the reasons that the grip has gotten bigger isn't really trying to make it more ergonomic, which I don't think the bigger grip actually does, it is rather to allow for the bigger battery, which as described above I do think is needed for what I like most, but if I could have that bigger battery with no grip at all I would be much happier, and even if they can't do that, which I don't think they can, if they would just make that 131mm dimension more like 140mm and turned the battery to make the grip not stick out as much, I would be much happier with more room for the huge mitt that is my right hand.
Also keep in mind a big part of the reason the A7C series can be so small is largely because they went back to the same resolution EVF as the A7r II. It is nice to have the choice, but even though I like small cameras I have a clear preference for a bigger better EVF over a smaller camera. When I replaced my A7r II, it was an easy choice for me to get the A7r V over an A7CR. I value the excellent EVF in the A7r V way too much now that I have used it to go back to the low resolution A7CR EVF. Of course other people can and should weigh these tradeoffs differently, but there is a natural tradeoff between a bigger high resolution EVF size and size of the camera especially if you maintain decent battery life and I will go with a better EVF over smaller size given how I weigh that tradeoff.
So, in my view Sony's A7R series has gotten bigger, but it isn't primarily driven by bloat. It is driven by improvements to the EVF, LCD, and computational capabilities of the camera, all of which drive a bigger battery as well and for me those improvements are worth the bigger size of the camera. Fortunately, in the Sony world if those improvements are not worth the increasing size to you, the A7C is there for you with its lower resolution EVF, smaller battery, and smaller size. Nobody else provides that choice, so like the Joe Walsh song, "I can't complain, but sometimes I still do."...Show more →
---------------------------------------------
chiron wrote: GHarris wroteThe A7C (all versions) uses the same battery as the A7RV. All A7 and A7R models (etc) since the A9i, A7iii and A7Riii use the larger Z battery. It hasn't been the reason for steadily increasing body sizes for a long time now.Yes, the body size increases are not related to battery size. I think they have more driven by the preferences of professional photographers who shoot for long periods with a camera in their hands and by Sony's expansion into large tele prime and zoom lenses, for which a large, gripped body is desirable.
Sony does clearly recognize that there is a strong preference among many of their customers for small and light camera bodies and gear. Thus the A7Cxx bodies and lenses like the 40G, 50G, and the 16-25, and 25-50 zooms.
The increase in Sony camera body size isn't just about battery size. It's more about what professional photographers need for long shoots and Sony's move into bigger telephoto lenses, which work better with a larger, gripped body.
Sony knows a lot of us prefer small and light gear, especially in Japan, and you can see that in the A7C series and lenses like the 40G, 50G primes and recent compact zooms.
The incremental increase in size and weight with each new generation is also because many people switching from Canon and Nikon didn't like Sony's ergonomics. Plus, pros using heavy zoom lenses for long periods found smaller bodies uncomfortable. This change has been mostly well-received, but personally, I like smaller and lighter cameras. That's why I was excited about the A7C, though the EVF was a bit disappointing. The new A7CII and A7CR have much better EVF magnification (from 0.59x to 0.70x), so I may give the A7CR a try now.
The A7C series uses the same battery as the A7R V, so battery size isn't the main reason for the bigger bodies. However, a while back, when Sony updated the A7R II to III and IV, they just didn't have the tech to make everything fit as neatly as they do now with the "C" series.
Once the body is ergonomically optimal, it’s hard for Sony to backtrack with a smaller, less ergonomic version, and I think that’s a major reason they decided to start the C line..
That said, the A7RV is still lighter and smaller than the competition!
p.1 #18Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Need to remember the need for Vertical grips and the fact that some sport shooters with long glass are without monopods as well. So balance is a big deal .I have zero issues with the size of the bodies I don't have large hands so they fit me pretty well
p.1 #19Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteHonestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced.I too really loved the A7r II body, which has been one of my main camera until recently when I upgraded to the a7r V. I like the A7r V substantially more despite its bigger size. The main thing I like about the A7r V is the EVF. It is just lovely and worth the extra size and weight for me. I also really like the back LCD, again they are really worth the size and weight, and they add more weight than one might expect because screen with that size and resolution and clarity are power hungry so the battery had to get bigger to get reasonable battery life--it was already pretty bad with the A7r II with the smaller lower resolution EVF and LCD. Then there is the computational capabilities, which include the massively better AF, and that has to take a bit more battery life too, and all three of those things (better EVF, better LCD, and better computational ability/AF) are to me very much worth the extra size and weight increases.
That said, part of the reason they are worth it to me is I have pretty huge hands. I am 6' 3" tall and I can't really find gloves big enough for my hands--extra large are noticeably small. So a bigger body has different tradeoffs for me. Yeah I like the smaller size for carrying the camera, but for holding the camera I appreciate a bit bigger body as my hands are less scrunched. The real problem that I have with Sony bodies, however is that there is so little space between the grip and the lens. My fingers are often squished in that space. It is the 127mm dimension on the A7r II and still only 131mm even on the A7r V that I find too small. I much prefer the 139mm on the Leica M10 I used to own and it of course has no grip and a smaller diameter mount, so it felt like lots of room for my hands. My Nikon Z7 isn't much better at 134mm and a larger diameter mount. By the way, I think one of the reasons that the grip has gotten bigger isn't really trying to make it more ergonomic, which I don't think the bigger grip actually does, it is rather to allow for the bigger battery, which as described above I do think is needed for what I like most, but if I could have that bigger battery with no grip at all I would be much happier, and even if they can't do that, which I don't think they can, if they would just make that 131mm dimension more like 140mm and turned the battery to make the grip not stick out as much, I would be much happier with more room for the huge mitt that is my right hand.
Also keep in mind a big part of the reason the A7C series can be so small is largely because they went back to the same resolution EVF as the A7r II. It is nice to have the choice, but even though I like small cameras I have a clear preference for a bigger better EVF over a smaller camera. When I replaced my A7r II, it was an easy choice for me to get the A7r V over an A7CR. I value the excellent EVF in the A7r V way too much now that I have used it to go back to the low resolution A7CR EVF. Of course other people can and should weigh these tradeoffs differently, but there is a natural tradeoff between a bigger high resolution EVF size and size of the camera especially if you maintain decent battery life and I will go with a better EVF over smaller size given how I weigh that tradeoff.
So, in my view Sony's A7R series has gotten bigger, but it isn't primarily driven by bloat. It is driven by improvements to the EVF, LCD, and computational capabilities of the camera, all of which drive a bigger battery as well and for me those improvements are worth the bigger size of the camera. Fortunately, in the Sony world if those improvements are not worth the increasing size to you, the A7C is there for you with its lower resolution EVF, smaller battery, and smaller size. Nobody else provides that choice, so like the Joe Walsh song, "I can't complain, but sometimes I still do."---------------------------------------------
chiron wroteGHarris wroteThe A7C (all versions) uses the same battery as the A7RV. All A7 and A7R models (etc) since the A9i, A7iii and A7Riii use the larger Z battery. It hasn't been the reason for steadily increasing body sizes for a long time now.Yes, the body size increases are not related to battery size. I think they have more driven by the preferences of professional photographers who shoot for long periods with a camera in their hands and by Sony's expansion into large tele prime and zoom lenses, for which a large, gripped body is desirable.
Sony does clearly recognize that there is a strong preference among many of their customers for small and light camera bodies and gear. Thus the A7Cxx bodies and lenses like the 40G, 50G, and the 16-25, and 25-50 zooms.The increase in Sony camera body size isn't just about battery size. It's more about what professional photographers need for long shoots and Sony's move into bigger telephoto lenses, which work better with a larger, gripped body.
Sony knows a lot of us prefer small and light gear, especially in Japan, and you can see that in the A7C series and lenses like the 40G, 50G primes and recent compact zooms.
The incremental increase in size and weight with each new generation is also because many people switching from Canon and Nikon didn't like Sony's ergonomics. Plus, pros using heavy zoom lenses for long periods found smaller bodies uncomfortable. This change has been mostly well-received, but personally, I like smaller and lighter cameras. That's why I was excited about the A7C, though the EVF was a bit disappointing. The new A7CII and A7CR have much better EVF magnification (from 0.59x to 0.70x), so I may give the A7CR a try now.
The A7C series uses the same battery as the A7R V, so battery size isn't the main reason for the bigger bodies. However, a while back, when Sony updated the A7R II to III and IV, they just didn't have the tech to make everything fit as neatly as they do now with the "C" series.
Once the body is ergonomically optimal, it’s hard for Sony to backtrack with a smaller, less ergonomic version, and I think that’s a major reason they decided to start the C line..
That said, the A7RV is still lighter and smaller than the competition!...Show more →
Nobody said (and I certainly didn't) say the increase in body size was just about battery size; there are certainly other factors involved. I think it is wrong, however, to say it has nothing to do with battery size either. One of the big jumps in the A7R series was between the A7r II and the A7r III and at least part of that jump in size both in how big the grip was and in how heavy they made the camera is because they used a bigger battery.
There was little jump in size between the A7R III and A7r IV as those two models are quite close in size. There was a moderate jump in size between the A7R IV and the A7R V but at least part of that increase in size is due to the larger EVF and the new LCD screen. I am sure other factors like reports on ergonomics from users and potential switchers influenced things as well, but when I look at the size changes it seems to me a lot can be explained by the physical changes to a larger battery with the A7R III and the higher resolution EVF and flippy LCD with the A7R V and for me those physical changes are worth the larger size.
p.1 #20Body change A7RIV to A7RV.....(just looking for cool features or input)
Fred Miranda wrote: Steve Spencer wroteFred Miranda wroteHonestly, the call for bigger grips with each new generation makes me dislike newer Sony bodies.
You can see the progression in grip size and weight in this image. The best compromise for size and weight is the A7R II because the A7R was just too crude and quirky. However, I was one of the first to buy one after moving from Canon, and I actually learned to love its quirks because it was so compact and had an amazing sensor for its time.
The A7R II and III greatly improved the camera, but even with the A7R III, the width increased from 60mm to 74mm due to the larger grip, and it has continued getting bigger, reaching 82mm with the A7R V. The weight also increased significantly from the A7R to the newer models, which I dislike.
Of course, professional Sony shooters drove these changes, and I’m glad they now offer the “C” line, going back to compact bodies, although the viewfinder quality is greatly reduced.I too really loved the A7r II body, which has been one of my main camera until recently when I upgraded to the a7r V. I like the A7r V substantially more despite its bigger size. The main thing I like about the A7r V is the EVF. It is just lovely and worth the extra size and weight for me. I also really like the back LCD, again they are really worth the size and weight, and they add more weight than one might expect because screen with that size and resolution and clarity are power hungry so the battery had to get bigger to get reasonable battery life--it was already pretty bad with the A7r II with the smaller lower resolution EVF and LCD. Then there is the computational capabilities, which include the massively better AF, and that has to take a bit more battery life too, and all three of those things (better EVF, better LCD, and better computational ability/AF) are to me very much worth the extra size and weight increases.
That said, part of the reason they are worth it to me is I have pretty huge hands. I am 6' 3" tall and I can't really find gloves big enough for my hands--extra large are noticeably small. So a bigger body has different tradeoffs for me. Yeah I like the smaller size for carrying the camera, but for holding the camera I appreciate a bit bigger body as my hands are less scrunched. The real problem that I have with Sony bodies, however is that there is so little space between the grip and the lens. My fingers are often squished in that space. It is the 127mm dimension on the A7r II and still only 131mm even on the A7r V that I find too small. I much prefer the 139mm on the Leica M10 I used to own and it of course has no grip and a smaller diameter mount, so it felt like lots of room for my hands. My Nikon Z7 isn't much better at 134mm and a larger diameter mount. By the way, I think one of the reasons that the grip has gotten bigger isn't really trying to make it more ergonomic, which I don't think the bigger grip actually does, it is rather to allow for the bigger battery, which as described above I do think is needed for what I like most, but if I could have that bigger battery with no grip at all I would be much happier, and even if they can't do that, which I don't think they can, if they would just make that 131mm dimension more like 140mm and turned the battery to make the grip not stick out as much, I would be much happier with more room for the huge mitt that is my right hand.
Also keep in mind a big part of the reason the A7C series can be so small is largely because they went back to the same resolution EVF as the A7r II. It is nice to have the choice, but even though I like small cameras I have a clear preference for a bigger better EVF over a smaller camera. When I replaced my A7r II, it was an easy choice for me to get the A7r V over an A7CR. I value the excellent EVF in the A7r V way too much now that I have used it to go back to the low resolution A7CR EVF. Of course other people can and should weigh these tradeoffs differently, but there is a natural tradeoff between a bigger high resolution EVF size and size of the camera especially if you maintain decent battery life and I will go with a better EVF over smaller size given how I weigh that tradeoff.
So, in my view Sony's A7R series has gotten bigger, but it isn't primarily driven by bloat. It is driven by improvements to the EVF, LCD, and computational capabilities of the camera, all of which drive a bigger battery as well and for me those improvements are worth the bigger size of the camera. Fortunately, in the Sony world if those improvements are not worth the increasing size to you, the A7C is there for you with its lower resolution EVF, smaller battery, and smaller size. Nobody else provides that choice, so like the Joe Walsh song, "I can't complain, but sometimes I still do."---------------------------------------------
chiron wroteGHarris wroteThe A7C (all versions) uses the same battery as the A7RV. All A7 and A7R models (etc) since the A9i, A7iii and A7Riii use the larger Z battery. It hasn't been the reason for steadily increasing body sizes for a long time now.Yes, the body size increases are not related to battery size. I think they have more driven by the preferences of professional photographers who shoot for long periods with a camera in their hands and by Sony's expansion into large tele prime and zoom lenses, for which a large, gripped body is desirable.
Sony does clearly recognize that there is a strong preference among many of their customers for small and light camera bodies and gear. Thus the A7Cxx bodies and lenses like the 40G, 50G, and the 16-25, and 25-50 zooms.The increase in Sony camera body size isn't just about battery size. It's more about what professional photographers need for long shoots and Sony's move into bigger telephoto lenses, which work better with a larger, gripped body.
Sony knows a lot of us prefer small and light gear, especially in Japan, and you can see that in the A7C series and lenses like the 40G, 50G primes and recent compact zooms.
The incremental increase in size and weight with each new generation is also because many people switching from Canon and Nikon didn't like Sony's ergonomics. Plus, pros using heavy zoom lenses for long periods found smaller bodies uncomfortable. This change has been mostly well-received, but personally, I like smaller and lighter cameras. That's why I was excited about the A7C, though the EVF was a bit disappointing. The new A7CII and A7CR have much better EVF magnification (from 0.59x to 0.70x), so I may give the A7CR a try now.
The A7C series uses the same battery as the A7R V, so battery size isn't the main reason for the bigger bodies. However, a while back, when Sony updated the A7R II to III and IV, they just didn't have the tech to make everything fit as neatly as they do now with the "C" series.
Once the body is ergonomically optimal, it’s hard for Sony to backtrack with a smaller, less ergonomic version, and I think that’s a major reason they decided to start the C line..
That said, the A7RV is still lighter and smaller than the competition!...Show more →
Pros make up an increasingly dwindling portion of photography. And long lenses with small bodies being uncomfortable never made any sense. You carry by the lens and only hold the body to direct/stabilize.