robert_in_ca wrote:
armd wrote
arbitrage wrote
I had a great day with the R5II and 100-500 yesterday. I'm not going to bother going into details of my thoughts comparing it to the A1 as I see my original comparison was censored and deleted so obviously this forum doesn't support free speech and people don't value my thoughts (at least whomever reported that post).
Have fun out there guys, enjoy your gear of choice. You will get the shots you want with any of the top gear these days. Just need to learn the system you choose in depth and make it work in your hands. Probably best to chase the lens lineup you want over the cameras.
Ironically if you do want to read my original comparison you can go view Mike's post that quoted it and said I have no business on this thread. What a joke. You will get the shots you want with any of the top gear these days. Just need to learn the system you choose in depth and make it work in your hands. Probably best to chase the lens lineup you want over the cameras.
If only. The AF system of the Nikon is still behind that of Canon and Sony and anyone who claims otherwise hasn't used all three. While I love my PF lenses for their size, price, weight, and performance, the truth is the Z8's(Z9) AF system is just not up to par. Unfortunately, the Z series lenses can't work on either the RF or E mount, otherwise I would have the ultimate blended system. My only hope is that Nikon wakes up and produces a body with AF in the class of Canon/Sony or Canon starts producing RF, PF like lenses (highly doubtful). Having shot all three system (all top of the line bodies and glass) I agree that Canon and Sony AF is better than Nikon. I've noticed if the subject isn’t taking up most of the sensor there's a lack of clarity around the eyes and overall with the Nikon. If the subject is taking up most of the sensor then it's a wash between the systems. Nikon's strength is its long lens selection (which is excellent) and its weakness is its AF and subject recognition algorithms.
It's more than that and I've described the issues in multiple threads. On the positive side, I've found the Nikon cockpit recognition in the "airplanes" subject detection to be the best in the business. It recognizes warbirds from mustangs to F-35's to helio's without fail and it's better than Canon/Sony. I haven't shot enough motorsports to comment conclusively in that domain. For people, it does a fine job recognizing the eyes in SD, though it has a tendency to focus on the lash, eyebrow, cheek, nose, more so than either Sony/Canon. For sports it is reasonably comparable provided one masters the nuances of the AF system though with the new ball detect that Canon offers, it is likely behind. With respect to mammals, it doesn't tend to eye detect as far away as the other brands though it's about as accurate and all of these systems fail on some ungulates, elephants, hippos, alligators, etc. So, in this application the three systems are fairly comparable.
Nikon's AF appears to be tied to the EVF feed so proper exposure is critical to achieve best results. For perched birds, I find both Sony/Canon to do a better job of detecting and tracking the bird against busier backgrounds. Frequently, I have to change AF modes or do a handoff to follow the subject (typically a custom 1x1 followed by AA, etc.). For BIF against the sky, all three systems are nearly comparable though again Sony/Canon can detect the subject and in particular the eyes at a longer distance.
The greater distinctions for BIF occur when water is involved. It's very dependent on lighting, backgrounds, and other intangibles though some generalizations can be made. I find the Canon and Sony bodies detect and track better in nearly all phases when the subject is a bird striking through the water such as eagles, osprey, etc. For whatever reason, I've found the Nikon AF wanders off the subject for several frames before, during, and immediately after the strike with a great deal of regularity. It doesn't appear to be focusing on another more contrasty subject, rather it seems as though the predictive calculations are off. This occurs in spite of different AF modes and settings such as changing the AF to erratic. With respect to diving birds, where the subject hits the water and then emerges a short time later (think Pelicans, Kingfishers), they're reasonably similar. Again, depending on the lighting, of the three systems, the Canon seems to get fooled the least by bird reflections and generally stays firmly on the subject's eye. Both Nikon and Sony are a bit less fastidious this way though I suspect that this could be an easy firmware update.
Now, the disclaimer, namely these are a few of my observations after several years' experience with all three systems and it isn't meant to be an endorsement/indictment of any particular brand. Your experience may differ depending on the lenses, lighting, subject, experience, or a myriad of factors. No system is perfect and they all have strengths and weaknesses from price, ergonomics, size, weight, and other intangibles. In the final analysis, the user is the arbiter of what is best for him/herself.