fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread

  
 
Yaniv
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Nelu wrote:
Are you serious now?
A sparrow on a fence?
I could have taken that shot with any camera, digital or not.
What's the big deal about it?


Good for you, you can save your money then.

Aug 01, 2024 at 12:05 PM
Rudy Pohl
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Nelu wrote:
Are you serious now?
A sparrow on a fence?
I could have taken that shot with any camera, digital or not.
What's the big deal about it?


Might be a big deal at a dog show where there are lots of people and dogs mixed together. Probably horse shows too, and of course the annual Rabbit Breeders Championships.
Aug 01, 2024 at 12:06 PM
Jeff Nolten
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Is the R52 mechanical shutter as quiet as the R5's?
Aug 01, 2024 at 12:38 PM
Yaniv
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Jeff Nolten wrote:
Is the R52 mechanical shutter as quiet as the R5's?


Yes
Aug 01, 2024 at 12:55 PM
goalerjones
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Nelu wrote:
Are you serious now?
A sparrow on a fence?
I could have taken that shot with any camera, digital or not.
What's the big deal about it?


I deal with the tracking issue all the time with horses and their riders. Having an auto feature will make that easier for sure, meaning I won't have to use the AF On button to manually over ride the auto tracking if it gets it wrong, in theory. We will have to wait and see with actual hands on production camera feedback.

Aug 01, 2024 at 02:08 PM
ronno
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Where are people buying the cameras now?
Aug 01, 2024 at 07:45 PM
icantbebigwill
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Were you shooting bursts? If so, what was the hit rate?
Aug 02, 2024 at 06:59 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
icantbebigwill wrote:
Were you shooting bursts? If so, what was the hit rate?


100%
He reported the below on the other thread.

docusync wrote:
lighthound wrote
docusync wrote
lighthound wrote
docusync wroteI also got mine R5 II today,
Well come on man! There are desperate GAS inflicted folks out here that want to hear some real user insights.
What are your first impressions so far? Any unforeseen concerns? Any nice surprises? How's the AF system compared to R5?
I'll take it today for a back to school event but it won't be anything challenging for the AF system. I'll probably ask my kiddo to jump and run a few times

No surprises, but I'm always trying to turn it on by switching the stills/video switch that is now in place of the power switch. The new power switch is a tri-state, and sometimes I switch it to the "locked" position and then wonder why my controls are not working. It's ok, I just need some time to get used to these new switches.

One minor annoyance is the joystick's shape. It's more round, and not flat like the old one. I could push the old one by touching the edge. Now I have to position my thumb more carefully over the center of the joystick.

Everything else is very familiar.

I had to disable the Eye-controlled AF feature because it's slow and not accurate, even after multiple calibrations. I'm not sure if it's really improved like they said compared to the R3. Both my wife and I had it disabled on the R3 for the same reason, but I'm sure it may work for some folks focusing on large subjects.

Overall, it's a nice camera. I reached out to Lifeguard Design to get a protective skin but they currently don't have one. Will report back when I have some pictures
Well, I guess you could make sure your settings are ready as you walk into the school and maybe grab a pigeon or something flying by some trees or flag pole.

I've never tried the R3 Eye control but being that I wear glasses and peak over the top of them when shooting, I suspect it wouldn't work for me anyhow. It's definitely something I'm interested in trying but without experiencing it, it's hard to say if I'd like it or not for my type of shooting. I suppose it would be nice, while shooting a group of elk or something, to not be forced to recompose or bump the joystick over to get the AEAF onto a different critter.

Are you going to test out that cool new feature tomorrow where you log an image of say your kiddo so that it always finds him/her and locks onto them? I would think your back to school event would be a great application for such a thing.
I'm very curious to see if this feature could be used on critters such as elk, where the R5 struggles to find their eyeball in low light. I know it's mainly for people but it'd be interesting to see if it would half-ass work on critters.
Anyways, I asked each kid to run towards me, and at 30 fps every single frame was in critical focus, at f/1.2.
The lens is the RF 85/1.2DS which is definitely not the fastest lens on the market. Also 85mm doesn't offer much working distance like a supertele, so the kids approached quickly. I normally perform this test on all my cameras. I never was able to get even half of the frames in acceptable focus with the original R5. The A1 was much better, and the A9III was almost perfect but it could lose critical focus during a rapid approach,
...Show more →

Aug 02, 2024 at 07:23 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Forget about the 200-500, Canon needs to release the 600/4DO they teased us with in 2015.
Aug 02, 2024 at 08:29 AM
icantbebigwill
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Wow impressive. Thanks!


lighthound wrote:
icantbebigwill wroteWere you shooting bursts? If so, what was the hit rate?
100%
He reported the below on the other thread.

docusync wrote
lighthound wrote
docusync wrote
lighthound wrote
docusync wroteI also got mine R5 II today,
Well come on man! There are desperate GAS inflicted folks out here that want to hear some real user insights.
What are your first impressions so far? Any unforeseen concerns? Any nice surprises? How's the AF system compared to R5?
I'll take it today for a back to school event but it won't be anything challenging for the AF system. I'll probably ask my kiddo to jump and run a few times

No surprises, but I'm always trying to turn it on by switching the stills/video switch that is now in place of the power switch. The new power switch is a tri-state, and sometimes I switch it to the "locked" position and then wonder why my controls are not working. It's ok, I just need some time to get used to these new switches.

One minor annoyance is the joystick's shape. It's more round, and not flat like the old one. I could push the old one by touching the edge. Now I have to position my thumb more carefully over the center of the joystick.

Everything else is very familiar.

I had to disable the Eye-controlled AF feature because it's slow and not accurate, even after multiple calibrations. I'm not sure if it's really improved like they said compared to the R3. Both my wife and I had it disabled on the R3 for the same reason, but I'm sure it may work for some folks focusing on large subjects.

Overall, it's a nice camera. I reached out to Lifeguard Design to get a protective skin but they currently don't have one. Will report back when I have some pictures
Well, I guess you could make sure your settings are ready as you walk into the school and maybe grab a pigeon or something flying by some trees or flag pole.

I've never tried the R3 Eye control but being that I wear glasses and peak over the top of them when shooting, I suspect it wouldn't work for me anyhow. It's definitely something I'm interested in trying but without experiencing it, it's hard to say if I'd like it or not for my type of shooting. I suppose it would be nice, while shooting a group of elk or something, to not be forced to recompose or bump the joystick over to get the AEAF onto a different critter.

Are you going to test out that cool new feature tomorrow where you log an image of say your kiddo so that it always finds him/her and locks onto them? I would think your back to school event would be a great application for such a thing.
I'm very curious to see if this feature could be used on critters such as elk, where the R5 struggles to find their eyeball in low light. I know it's mainly for people but it'd be interesting to see if it would half-ass work on critters.
Anyways, I asked each kid to run towards me, and at 30 fps every single frame was in critical focus, at f/1.2.
The lens is the RF 85/1.2DS which is definitely not the fastest lens on the market. Also 85mm doesn't offer much working distance like a supertele, so the kids approached quickly. I normally perform this test on all my cameras. I never was able to get even half of the frames in acceptable focus with the original R5. The A1 was much better, and the A9III was almost perfect but it could lose critical focus during a rapid approach, when the person is close. I could never imagine that a 100% success rate is possible, and now I'm scared to think what the R1 can do.
I'm likely going to swap the R5II for an R1 whenever it becomes available, and will keep the A9III for action portraiture with strobes.

Now after Canon made such mind blowing cameras they seriously need to release the "promised" 200-500. Yeah, I know nobody promised anything, but still...

P.S. Another neat new feature is the ISO "shortcut". It allows you to have a few "favorite" ISOs (like the second gain ISO) one line above the full ISO list for a quick access/selection.


Aug 02, 2024 at 08:45 AM
Nelu
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
goalerjones wrote:
Nelu wroteAre you serious now?
A sparrow on a fence?
I could have taken that shot with any camera, digital or not.
What's the big deal about it?
I deal with the tracking issue all the time with horses and their riders. Having an auto feature will make that easier for sure, meaning I won't have to use the AF On button to manually over ride the auto tracking if it gets it wrong, in theory. We will have to wait and see with actual hands on production camera feedback.


I'm not familiar how this auto feature works.
Let's say you have a rider on a horse. The rider is your intended subject but the horse is also a valid subject.
How can the camera possibly know which one to pick?

Aug 02, 2024 at 09:07 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
icantbebigwill wrote:
Wow impressive. Thanks!

lighthound wrote
icantbebigwill wroteWere you shooting bursts? If so, what was the hit rate?
100%
He reported the below on the other thread.

docusync wrote
lighthound wrote
docusync wrote
lighthound wroteWell come on man! There are desperate GAS inflicted folks out here that want to hear some real user insights.
What are your first impressions so far? Any unforeseen concerns? Any nice surprises? How's the AF system compared to R5?
I'll take it today for a back to school event but it won't be anything challenging for the AF system. I'll probably ask my kiddo to jump and run a few times

No surprises, but I'm always trying to turn it on by switching the stills/video switch that is now in place of the power switch. The new power switch is a tri-state, and sometimes I switch it to the "locked" position and then wonder why my controls are not working. It's ok, I just need some time to get used to these new switches.

One minor annoyance is the joystick's shape. It's more round, and not flat like the old one. I could push the old one by touching the edge. Now I have to position my thumb more carefully over the center of the joystick.

Everything else is very familiar.

I had to disable the Eye-controlled AF feature because it's slow and not accurate, even after multiple calibrations. I'm not sure if it's really improved like they said compared to the R3. Both my wife and I had it disabled on the R3 for the same reason, but I'm sure it may work for some folks focusing on large subjects.

Overall, it's a nice camera. I reached out to Lifeguard Design to get a protective skin but they currently don't have one. Will report back when I have some pictures
Well, I guess you could make sure your settings are ready as you walk into the school and maybe grab a pigeon or something flying by some trees or flag pole.

I've never tried the R3 Eye control but being that I wear glasses and peak over the top of them when shooting, I suspect it wouldn't work for me anyhow. It's definitely something I'm interested in trying but without experiencing it, it's hard to say if I'd like it or not for my type of shooting. I suppose it would be nice, while shooting a group of elk or something, to not be forced to recompose or bump the joystick over to get the AEAF onto a different critter.

Are you going to test out that cool new feature tomorrow where you log an image of say your kiddo so that it always finds him/her and locks onto them? I would think your back to school event would be a great application for such a thing.
I'm very curious to see if this feature could be used on critters such as elk, where the R5 struggles to find their eyeball in low light. I know it's mainly for people but it'd be interesting to see if it would half-ass work on critters.
Anyways, I asked each kid to run towards me, and at 30 fps every single frame was in critical focus, at f/1.2.
The lens is the RF 85/1.2DS which is definitely not the fastest lens on the market. Also 85mm doesn't offer much working distance like a supertele, so the kids approached quickly. I normally perform this test on all my cameras. I never was able to get even half of the frames in acceptable focus with the original R5. The A1 was much better, and the A9III was almost perfect but it could lose critical focus during a rapid approach, when the person is close. I could never imagine that a 100% success rate is possible, and now I'm scared to think what the R1 can do.
I'm likely going to swap the R5II for an R1 whenever it becomes available, and will keep the A9III for action portraiture with strobes.

Now after Canon made such mind blowing cameras they seriously need to release the "promised" 200-500. Yeah, I know nobody promised anything, but still...

P.S. Another neat new feature is the ISO "shortcut". It allows you to have a few "favorite" ISOs (like the second gain ISO) one line above the full ISO list for a quick access/selection.


Yes it is! And as he had mentioned, just imagine what the R1 with it's cross-type AF system must be like. Those folks at the Olympics have got to be in high heaven using these new rigs.

After seeing how the R1's AF worked in some early reviewers video, I can see where the long ago "leak" about the R1 was that is was "Insane" came from.
Because it is.
And the fact that they put the same AF algorithm in the R5II is fantastic news, even though it didn't get the cross-type sensor.
Aug 02, 2024 at 09:53 AM
biggles2002
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread


Nelu wrote:
goalerjones wrote
Nelu wroteAre you serious now?
A sparrow on a fence?
I could have taken that shot with any camera, digital or not.
What's the big deal about it?
I deal with the tracking issue all the time with horses and their riders. Having an auto feature will make that easier for sure, meaning I won't have to use the AF On button to manually over ride the auto tracking if it gets it wrong, in theory. We will have to wait and see with actual hands on production camera feedback.
I'm not familiar how this auto feature works.
Let's say you have a rider on a horse. The rider is your intended subject but the horse is also a valid subject.
How can the camera possibly know which one to pick?


A choice what to prioritize in auto would be nice
Aug 02, 2024 at 10:45 AM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Nelu wrote:
goalerjones wrote
Nelu wroteAre you serious now?
A sparrow on a fence?
I could have taken that shot with any camera, digital or not.
What's the big deal about it?
I deal with the tracking issue all the time with horses and their riders. Having an auto feature will make that easier for sure, meaning I won't have to use the AF On button to manually over ride the auto tracking if it gets it wrong, in theory. We will have to wait and see with actual hands on production camera feedback.
I'm not familiar how this auto feature works.
Let's say you have a rider on a horse. The rider is your intended subject but the horse is also a valid subject.
How can the camera possibly know which one to pick?


Yeah, I'm not sure how that would work. I shoot horse shows professionally with R6 Mark IIs. For showjumping, I have the camera set to People, not Auto, and I use single AF point + expansion to help the camera acquire initial focus on the rider's face / helmet. Tracking generally does the rest.

I think Auto may be useful for a general, walk-around situation, but I would not use it for sporting events, or whenever you are following a specific subject.



Aug 02, 2024 at 10:46 AM
Dave_E
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Jeff I’m with you, Still like to use my old EF 400 f4 DO II to this day even though I love my RF 400 f 2.8, It is so compact and extremely sharp. I would love to have an RF 600 f 4 DO lens.

Dave
Aug 02, 2024 at 10:51 AM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
arbitrage wrote:
Forget about the 200-500, Canon needs to release the 600/4DO they teased us with in 2015.


Looking at this post https://www.canonwatch.com/canon-patent-400-600mm-f2-8-4-300-600mm-f2-8-4-5-and-70-300mm-f4/
we may actually get both, but in one package Something like a 300-600 2.8-4.5 refractive.
"A zoom lens that is small in size and has a large aperture while still providing high optical performance."
Aug 02, 2024 at 10:51 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
Is video bird/animal AF vastly improved over the original R5? Is video stabilization improved? Is ISO performance and dynamic range improved? Can electronic shutter be used while bracketing exposures?

Yaniv wrote:
I'll start :




Aug 03, 2024 at 12:09 AM
koenkooi
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread


AlphaPhotography wrote:
Is video bird/animal AF vastly improved over the original R5? Is video stabilization improved? Is ISO performance and dynamic range improved? Can electronic shutter be used while bracketing exposures?

Yaniv wroteI'll start :


Both Canon and the early reviewers say that the wide-angle IBIS wobble when filming is gone. That would be a huge improvement for me when filming my kids.
Aug 03, 2024 at 01:46 AM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Canon R5 Mark II Image Thread
stanj wrote:
artsupreme wroteI would suggest doing some testing to see if you can tell the difference. I don't know anyone who shoots RAW anymore except for maybe one guy who shoots some landscape every few months because he has very little files to cull/store. But for everyone else who's shooting on a regular basis it's cRAW. Give it a try and compare.
I shoot always raw on the R3 because I can tell the difference in the shadows. I shoot raw on the R5 for night photos (long exposures, or very high ISO) because there I can see the difference, too. Everything else cRaw for sure.


I tried craw once. I had looked at lots of analysis and concluded that if the subject is properly exposed and ISO is high (>800) there is not much difference and the files are smaller and you get 50% more in a burst. My tentative conclusion was that craw was okay (as compared to 12bit electronic raw) for wildlife (higher iso) but not optimal for on the tripod work (iso 100/14bit).

But after shooting craw for wildlife, I forgot to switch to raw when I switched to landscape at night.

I turned off craw permanently after that - I did not buy 14bit raw to not take advantage of it. And 80 burst I can make it work with care. And drives are cheap compared to cameras.

The new R5ii craw mode is going to be even harder to justify for me, because r5ii electronic is 14bit (unlike the the r5 12 bit), so its likely a bigger downgrade to go craw.



Edited on Aug 04, 2024 at 10:18 AM · View previous versions
Aug 03, 2024 at 10:14 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister