fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony vs Leica (Sony mod) vs Lumix sensor stack comparison

  
 
nehemiahphoto
Offline

p.1 #1Sony vs Leica (Sony mod) vs Lumix sensor stack comparison
I haven't done a comp in a while, but curiosity got the better of me and I sent made this this morning. The a7rII Mod (a7rii.m) is NKIR modded thin sensor, giving Leica RF mount performance (or extremely similar). The Sony is a stock A7c (24mp FF). The Lumix is a stock S5iix (24mp FF). The lens is a CV 35/2 Ultron--a modern decently corrected RF lens known to perform much worse on a stock Sony. I really wanted to see how the Lumix sensor stack performed with RF lenses. Is it really better or different for adapting m-mount glass than a Sony? The answer here is nah. If I wanted to shoot m-glass on a modern BSI non-modded sensor, seems that Nikon's are the better option.

I was curious because I picked up a Lumix for some video work, and this @BastianK's recent article on Nikon's Z sensor stack confirmed what I was hoping but had read conflicting reports on for a while--the Z line is a less compromised way of shooting m-lenses without a sensor mod.

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/different-filter-stacks-and-what-they-mean-for-us-sony-e-nikon-z-leica-m-kolari-ut/

Photos taken on tripod, ISO 100, no-ibis, 2-second delay, magnified manual focus on center, LR import with medium contrast tone curve applied, lens corrections of all types turned off (and used dummy adapter). WB cannot be the same, so loosely matched for comparative purposes. A7rii files downsized to 24mp on export to match the other two 24mp bodies. 800x800 pixel crops taken from center, mid-zone and extreme corner.

Head to my flickr at the below link if you are curious to see the higher-res file for pixel peeping:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/68886880@N07/

My summary:

f2 Center: All lenses perform equally well, minus some minute differences from downsizing and lack of AA filter for the A7rii.m

f2 Mid-zone: The a7c needs 5.6 to match the A7rii.m at f2. The s5iix needs between f4 and f5.6 to catch the a7rii.m at f2.

f2 Far Corner: The a7c needs between f5.6 and f8 to match the a7rii.m at f2 (ouch!). The s5iix needs f5.6 to catch the a7rii.m at f2.

TLDR; for this lens at infinity, the a7c has the worst sensor stack induced performance. The s5iix is about a stop ahead, and the a7rii.m is much better than either. I have CV 28/1.5 and Noct 50/1 v2 that show worse performance due to sensor stack on the a7c than my a7rii.m, but I don't think I'll test them. I think it's clear the Panasonic sensor stack is going to cause problems on most lenses at 50mm or below, and not too much different than Sony.

sensor crops final by nehemiahphoto, on Flickr

a7rii by nehemiahphoto, on Flickr

@fredmiranda Fred, can you cross post this to the Sony forum? Sorry, I can't quite find how to change it. Not sure if you can after making the initial post. Thanks
Jun 15, 2024 at 12:50 PM
Malabito
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Sony vs Leica (Sony mod) vs Lumix sensor stack comparison
I had the s1 and my experience is similar, most of my m lenses where quite terrible on the s1.... compared to my sl2s the difference is quite noticeable, on the sl2s lenses worked almost as good as on the m. I wonder how the zf compares to the sl2s.... could be a nice replacement with great autofocus.
Jun 15, 2024 at 02:14 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister