fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data

  
 
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
dclark wrote:
Since the Z8 buffer size is the same, 21 Frames, for all RAW types, that seems to indicate the Nikon stores unprocessed RAW data in the buffer. Sony seems to compress the data before storing in the buffer for the lossy compressed and stores unprocessed RAW data for lossless compressed and uncompressed. Nikon Z8 lossless compressed is about the same file size Sony A1 uncompressed and they both hit the buffer at ~80 frames. Sony lossless compressed is smaller and hits the buffer at ~105 frames.

It is not documented by Nikon how fast it captures frames once the buffer is
...Show more →

I found using 120FPS on the A9III to be severely limiting. You need to have a very specific goal and strictly follow it. My example is I wanted to try 120FPS with precapture on an osprey entering the water. Just to try and get that perfect moment as the talons just touch the water without even breaking the surface. But old habits die hard and on my first couple attempts I fired during the dive and the buffer was done and when the osprey hit, precapture was probably giving me 5FPS as you show in the data.

I found that 60FPS with precapture was useable as a general setting most of the time. My preferred mode was 30FPS with precapture on all the time. That was a good middle ground to not be running into buffer issues.
May 10, 2024 at 05:01 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
snapsy wrote:
Here are my rough estimates/calcs based on the specs in Nikon manual. Note HE is infinite per Nikon manual so I just entered a large value instead.

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tpS6WxH/0/Dbr94hTD9GFsRKrqdP83ZgCTpNdXxjjpbv4pd4TZB/O/i-tpS6WxH.png

The estimated sustained buffer clearing rate would be the values in rows 7 and 8, or some derivative of it.


Today I did an actual measurement on my Z8 with a Delkin 325GB Black CFE (lossless raw). The "FPS After Burst" is the sustained FPS after the buffer becomes full. The results are very close to what I calculated above from the Z8 manual. Explanation of graphs below.

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-FL3DSr6/0/D7NMskgxnQjTZhJcgfs3QPLc5RVHpdCwGtXR9rh3q/O/i-FL3DSr6.png

May 10, 2024 at 05:46 AM
dclark
Online
Details
p.3 #3Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
snapsy wrote:
dclark wroteIt is not documented by Nikon how fast it captures frames once the buffer is filled, so one would need to make some assumptions to get an estimate. Also there is no data I see for how fast the buffer is cleared once capture stops. It's a small buffer so I assume it should be very quick.
Here are my rough estimates/calcs based on the specs in Nikon manual. Note HE is infinite per Nikon manual so I just entered a large value instead.

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tpS6WxH/0/Dbr94hTD9GFsRKrqdP83ZgCTpNdXxjjpbv4pd4TZB/O/i-tpS6WxH.png

The estimated sustained buffer clearing rate would be the values in rows 7 and 8, or some derivative of it.


As I stated you can make some assumptions to fill in the missing information and make calculations. That is what you have done. You assumed that you can take the buffer size, the frame rate, and the number of frames captured when the buffer fills and compute the sustained frame rate once the buffer is filled. What if I told you the A9III at 120fps has a buffer of 156 frames that fills after 191 frames. What you you conclude the sustained rate would be?

I expect the assumption you have made is probably OK for the Z8.

As I said, if I had a Z8 I would make the measurement, not make the assumption.
May 10, 2024 at 09:13 AM
dclark
Online
Details
p.3 #4Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
snapsy wrote:
snapsy wroteHere are my rough estimates/calcs based on the specs in Nikon manual. Note HE is infinite per Nikon manual so I just entered a large value instead.

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tpS6WxH/0/Dbr94hTD9GFsRKrqdP83ZgCTpNdXxjjpbv4pd4TZB/O/i-tpS6WxH.png

The estimated sustained buffer clearing rate would be the values in rows 7 and 8, or some derivative of it.
Today I did an actual measurement on my Z8 with a Delkin 325GB Black CFE (lossless raw). The "FPS After Burst" is the sustained FPS after the buffer becomes full. The results are very close to what I calculated above from the Z8 manual. Explanation of graphs below.

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-FL3DSr6/0/D7NMskgxnQjTZhJcgfs3QPLc5RVHpdCwGtXR9rh3q/O/i-FL3DSr6.png



Excellent, an actual measurement!!

Hmmm.....what happened at frame ~80

May 10, 2024 at 09:18 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
May 10, 2024 at 09:21 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
dclark wrote:
snapsy wrote
dclark wroteIt is not documented by Nikon how fast it captures frames once the buffer is filled, so one would need to make some assumptions to get an estimate. Also there is no data I see for how fast the buffer is cleared once capture stops. It's a small buffer so I assume it should be very quick.
Here are my rough estimates/calcs based on the specs in Nikon manual. Note HE is infinite per Nikon manual so I just entered a large value instead.

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tpS6WxH/0/Dbr94hTD9GFsRKrqdP83ZgCTpNdXxjjpbv4pd4TZB/O/i-tpS6WxH.png

The estimated sustained buffer clearing rate would be the values in rows 7 and 8, or some derivative of it.
As I stated you can make some assumptions to fill in the missing information and make calculations. That is what you have done. You assumed that you can take the buffer size, the frame rate, and the number of frames captured when the buffer fills and compute the sustained frame rate once the buffer is filled. What if I told you the A9III at 120fps has a buffer of 156 frames that fills after 191 frames. What you you conclude the sustained rate would be?

I expect the assumption you have made is probably OK for the Z8.

As I
...Show more →

I would say consider running the additional tests I hinted at the other day to suss out the A9 III differences you discovered between 120fps and 30fps. The Z8 estimates I made from Nikon's specs were from a single fps rate (20fps).
May 10, 2024 at 09:28 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
dclark wrote:
Hmmm.....what happened at frame ~80


Stall from the buffer-full condition. That's the inflection point from running at the rated 20fps burst to the 15.5fps sustained thereafter. My measurement for was 10 seconds, which is intentionally done to get a stable sustained fps sample after the buffer full condition.
May 10, 2024 at 09:30 AM
dclark
Online
Details
p.3 #8Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
snapsy wrote:
dclark wroteHmmm.....what happened at frame ~80
Stall from the buffer-full condition. That's the inflection point from running at the rated 20fps burst to the 15.5fps sustained thereafter. My measurement for was 10 seconds, which is intentionally done to get a stable sustained fps sample after the buffer full condition.

Yes, I misread your post and thought it was for compressed RAW. It's obviously labeled uncompressed.

May 10, 2024 at 10:13 AM
jhapeman
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
arbitrage wrote:
dclark wroteSince the Z8 buffer size is the same, 21 Frames, for all RAW types, that seems to indicate the Nikon stores unprocessed RAW data in the buffer. Sony seems to compress the data before storing in the buffer for the lossy compressed and stores unprocessed RAW data for lossless compressed and uncompressed. Nikon Z8 lossless compressed is about the same file size Sony A1 uncompressed and they both hit the buffer at ~80 frames. Sony lossless compressed is smaller and hits the buffer at ~105 frames.

It is not documented by Nikon how fast it captures frames once the buffer is filled, so one would need to make some assumptions to get an estimate. Also there is no data I see for how fast the buffer is cleared once capture stops. It's a small buffer so I assume it should be very quick.

If I had a Z8 I would make the measurements (it's easy), although I think it's buffer limits are probably not operationally important to the way I operate a camera. At 20fps the same is true for the A1 or the A9III. At 30fps, which the Z8 cannot do, the Sony A1 is somewhat limiting and the A9III limit is beyond anything I require. I believe the main operational lesson of this data for the A9III is that I would normally use 120fps or 60fps only in boost. There may be a few situations where operating at 120 or 60 fps in conjunction with the pre-capture may be useful. Others may have different methods and will reach other conclusions, but I believe all the information needed for such decisions is presented.

Anyone using any of these cameras does not have much of a basis to blame the camera if you're not getting the shot. IMO, the weak link is the human attached to the finger that is pushing the shutter button.
I found using 120FPS on the A9III to be severely limiting. You need to have a very specific goal and strictly follow it. My example is I wanted to try 120FPS with precapture on an osprey entering the water. Just to try and get that perfect moment as the talons just touch the water without even breaking the surface. But old habits die hard and on my first couple attempts I fired during the dive and the buffer was done and when the osprey hit, precapture was probably giving me 5FPS as you show in the data.

I found that
...Show more →

120fps even with a bigger buffer is a tough use case because of the sheer number of photos you have to slog through. I mostly use my A9III at 30fps with precapture. I used 120fps when I was trying to capture hummingbirds in flight or similar things where the incredibly fast action also calls for an incredibly fast frame rate but you most certainly have to train your brain and finger to work differently in these cases.

For something like your example of the osprey, hitting the shutter right at the moment it is hitting the water is probably ideal if you have a decent-sized recapture turned on.
May 10, 2024 at 10:33 AM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
arbitrage wrote:
dclark wroteSince the Z8 buffer size is the same, 21 Frames, for all RAW types, that seems to indicate the Nikon stores unprocessed RAW data in the buffer. Sony seems to compress the data before storing in the buffer for the lossy compressed and stores unprocessed RAW data for lossless compressed and uncompressed. Nikon Z8 lossless compressed is about the same file size Sony A1 uncompressed and they both hit the buffer at ~80 frames. Sony lossless compressed is smaller and hits the buffer at ~105 frames.

It is not documented by Nikon how fast it captures frames once the buffer is filled, so one would need to make some assumptions to get an estimate. Also there is no data I see for how fast the buffer is cleared once capture stops. It's a small buffer so I assume it should be very quick.

If I had a Z8 I would make the measurements (it's easy), although I think it's buffer limits are probably not operationally important to the way I operate a camera. At 20fps the same is true for the A1 or the A9III. At 30fps, which the Z8 cannot do, the Sony A1 is somewhat limiting and the A9III limit is beyond anything I require. I believe the main operational lesson of this data for the A9III is that I would normally use 120fps or 60fps only in boost. There may be a few situations where operating at 120 or 60 fps in conjunction with the pre-capture may be useful. Others may have different methods and will reach other conclusions, but I believe all the information needed for such decisions is presented.

Anyone using any of these cameras does not have much of a basis to blame the camera if you're not getting the shot. IMO, the weak link is the human attached to the finger that is pushing the shutter button.
I found using 120FPS on the A9III to be severely limiting. You need to have a very specific goal and strictly follow it. My example is I wanted to try 120FPS with precapture on an osprey entering the water. Just to try and get that perfect moment as the talons just touch the water without even breaking the surface. But old habits die hard and on my first couple attempts I fired during the dive and the buffer was done and when the osprey hit, precapture was probably giving me 5FPS as you show in the data.

I found that
...Show more →

I thought of a feature and wanted to see if you think it might be useful in the field. What if the camera gave you the option to discard all the remaining photos in the buffer, as in not write them to the card, allowing you to shoot another 120fps burst without further delay? I'm thinking it could show you the first and last frame of the most recent burst (perhaps as a split-screen, with each side zoomed on the focus point), to let you quickly evaluate whether you likely got the sequence you wanted - if not, let you press a single button to discard all unwritten photos and return the camera to a fully empty buffer. Do you think this is something you would find useful and integrate into your shooting?
May 11, 2024 at 10:26 PM
UKBob
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
Shuttermuse has an interesting article about the best card for an A9iii and he recommends one with the highest sustained write speed ie the ProDigital Gold Type A card with a sustained write speed of 600mb/secBest memory cards for the A9iii -I was wrong
Can I ask what capacity cards would be recommended for an exciting day of wildlife action and how do you configure slots 1 and 2
For the A1 I use 160gb Sony card in Slot 1 with compressed RAW and 80gb in slot 2 for JPEG as back up which gives about 2200 images for each slot However I sort through the images each day and have never run out of space on the 160gb card with my shooting style which is short bursts
May 12, 2024 at 12:19 AM
jhapeman
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
UKBob wrote:
Shuttermuse has an interesting article about the best card for an A9iii and he recommends one with the highest sustained write speed ie the ProDigital Gold Type A card with a sustained write speed of 600mb/secBest memory cards for the A9iii -I was wrong
Can I ask what capacity cards would be recommended for an exciting day of wildlife action and how do you configure slots 1 and 2
For the A1 I use 160gb Sony card in Slot 1 with compressed RAW and 80gb in slot 2 for JPEG as back up which gives about 2200 images for each slot
...Show more →

This is why I have mentioned the Angelbird 1TB cards several times now when this topic comes up. They have a sustained write speed of 650MB/s. They have been discontinued but AngelBird did reply to my email request and indicated that a new version is in the works. I'd guess it will be PCIe 4.0 like the other new cards and hopefully have an even faster sustained write speed.
May 13, 2024 at 10:09 AM
dclark
Online
Details
p.3 #13Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
jhapeman wrote:
UKBob wroteShuttermuse has an interesting article about the best card for an A9iii and he recommends one with the highest sustained write speed ie the ProDigital Gold Type A card with a sustained write speed of 600mb/secBest memory cards for the A9iii -I was wrong
Can I ask what capacity cards would be recommended for an exciting day of wildlife action and how do you configure slots 1 and 2
For the A1 I use 160gb Sony card in Slot 1 with compressed RAW and 80gb in slot 2 for JPEG as back up which gives about 2200 images for each slot However I sort through the images each day and have never run out of space on the 160gb card with my shooting style which is short bursts
This is why I have mentioned the Angelbird 1TB cards several times now when this topic comes up. They have a sustained write speed of 650MB/s. They have been discontinued but AngelBird did reply to my email request and indicated that a new version is in the works. I'd guess it will be PCIe 4.0 like the other new cards and hopefully have an even faster sustained write speed.


Can you measure the performance of the Angelbird 1TB card and post for comparison the same curves as are posted in this thread for the Lexar, Delkin and Sony cards. Those cards showed no difference in performance, even though they differ in their specs. As noted, that is even true for the Lexar Gold and Silver, and the Lexar Gold lists minimum write speed spec that is better than the Angelbird. Also, it has been rumored that the Angelbird was withdrawn because it failed to qualify VPG-200 certification. I don't have much confidence in any of the specs which is why I prefer to make measurements. A set of actual measurements for the Angelbird would be very interesting. I tried to get a card to test but could not buy, rent, or borrow one.
May 13, 2024 at 04:10 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
I'm wondering why no camera manufacturer offers RAID0-like card access? Of course not on the sector level but on the file level. I.e. odd files go on the card 1 and even files go on the card 2. Even if you lose a card - you'd still have half of your files. That would reduce the image dump time in half.
May 13, 2024 at 05:22 PM
dclark
Online
Details
p.3 #15Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
docusync wrote:
I'm wondering why no camera manufacturer offers RAID0-like card access? Of course not on the sector level but on the file level. I.e. odd files go on the card 1 and even files go on the card 2. Even if you lose a card - you'd still have half of your files. That would reduce the image dump time in half.


That would help image write time only if it is limited by card bandwidth, not camera electronic processing. It appears to be limited by camera electronics ability to process files not the card's bandwidth..
May 13, 2024 at 05:27 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
dclark wrote:
docusync wroteI'm wondering why no camera manufacturer offers RAID0-like card access? Of course not on the sector level but on the file level. I.e. odd files go on the card 1 and even files go on the card 2. Even if you lose a card - you'd still have half of your files. That would reduce the image dump time in half.
That would help image write time only if it is limited by card bandwidth, not camera electronic processing. It appears to be limited by camera electronics ability to process files not the card's bandwidth..


I'm not sure, but I thought the files are already processed (in the manufacturer-specific raw format) when they get into the buffer, no? If we're dealing with a slow system bus, then switching to the CFeA 4.0 cards won't make any difference
May 13, 2024 at 05:36 PM
dclark
Online
Details
p.3 #17Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
docusync wrote:
dclark wrote
docusync wroteI'm wondering why no camera manufacturer offers RAID0-like card access? Of course not on the sector level but on the file level. I.e. odd files go on the card 1 and even files go on the card 2. Even if you lose a card - you'd still have half of your files. That would reduce the image dump time in half.
That would help image write time only if it is limited by card bandwidth, not camera electronic processing. It appears to be limited by camera electronics ability to process files not the card's bandwidth..
I'm not sure, but I thought the files are already processed (in the manufacturer-specific raw format) when they get into the buffer, no? If we're dealing with a slow system bus, then switching to the CFeA 4.0 cards won't make any difference


There are a number of things that need to be done to prepare a file for writing onto the memory card, including things like adding metadata, adding jpeg image that is processed according to the users settings, possibly noise reduction, possibly compression, etc. It appears that in the Sony A1 compression is completed before the file is written into the buffer for one type of compression, but not the other (see the linked thread). Regardless, all the processing operations take part of the bandwidth of the processor and may be the limiting factor in the sustained throughput. The data presented here seems to show that the sustained throughput is independent of the card. That would imply, as you stated, that in order to see the benefit of faster cards, the cameras electronics needs to be improved.

May 13, 2024 at 05:54 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
dclark wrote:
docusync wrote
dclark wrote
docusync wroteI'm wondering why no camera manufacturer offers RAID0-like card access? Of course not on the sector level but on the file level. I.e. odd files go on the card 1 and even files go on the card 2. Even if you lose a card - you'd still have half of your files. That would reduce the image dump time in half.
That would help image write time only if it is limited by card bandwidth, not camera electronic processing. It appears to be limited by camera electronics ability to process files not the card's bandwidth..
I'm not sure, but I thought the files are already processed (in the manufacturer-specific raw format) when they get into the buffer, no? If we're dealing with a slow system bus, then switching to the CFeA 4.0 cards won't make any difference
There are a number of things that need to be done to prepare a file for writing onto the memory card, including things like adding metadata, adding jpeg image that is processed according to the users settings, possibly noise reduction, possibly compression, etc. It appears that in the Sony A1 compression is completed before the file is written into the buffer for one type of compression, but not the other (see the linked thread). Regardless, all the processing operations take part of the bandwidth of the processor and may be the limiting factor in the sustained throughput. The data presented
...Show more →

It makes sense, thank you for the explanation!
May 13, 2024 at 06:37 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
docusync wrote:
dclark wrote
docusync wroteI'm wondering why no camera manufacturer offers RAID0-like card access? Of course not on the sector level but on the file level. I.e. odd files go on the card 1 and even files go on the card 2. Even if you lose a card - you'd still have half of your files. That would reduce the image dump time in half.
That would help image write time only if it is limited by card bandwidth, not camera electronic processing. It appears to be limited by camera electronics ability to process files not the card's bandwidth..
I'm not sure, but I thought the files are already processed (in the manufacturer-specific raw format) when they get into the buffer, no? If we're dealing with a slow system bus, then switching to the CFeA 4.0 cards won't make any difference


There is a long image pipeline the raw sensor data has to undergo before it becomes a fully-formed image read for writing. This includes the various flavors of noise reduction (spatial filtering, impulse noise removal), WB scaling, PDAF pixel interpolation, pixel remapping interpolation, etc... and that's just the raw bayered data. Even raws then undergo the full debayered pipeline since they all included embedded jpgs. For a general idea of what this pipeline entails here's the documentation of RawTherapee's pipeline:

https://rawpedia.rawtherapee.com/Toolchain_Pipeline

Think about how long it takes for a computer-based raw processor to render a single raw image and then multiply that by a camera's continuous frame rate and you'll get a sense for how computationally and data intensive the specialized imaging ASICs in cameras are, and why they are often the bottleneck in buffer clearing performance.
May 13, 2024 at 06:45 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Sony A9III CFE-a Memory Card Performance Data
snapsy wrote:
Think about how long it takes for a computer-based raw processor to render a single raw image and then multiply that by a camera's continuous frame rate


I never thought about this from a "general purpose" computer perspective, but you're absolutely right, it must be a seriously powerful server to process 24Mpx 14bit images at 120 fps, especially considering the pipeline mentioned in RawTherapee.
May 13, 2024 at 11:08 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister