swldstn wrote: itai195 wroteMikeEvangelist wroteAlan Parker wroteAnyone have any insights on this? The lens seems to get very little chatter online I like it very much. Overall sharpness, character of OOF areas, and handling are all great. In my view it shoots more like a prime than a zoom.I wish Sony made a 16mm prime already. I am interested in this lens. Mostly as the next best thing to a 16mm prime since I already have other lenses covering 20mm+. I have contemplated dropping a wide zoom from my kit altogether, but I would miss having that 16mm at times.Probably my lack of skill but below 20/21 mm I struggle with which focal then to shoot with. So to me the 16-35mm or 16-25 are more of a crutch to me. So I do now have three wide zooms, the 16-35/2.8 GMII, 12-24/4 G, and a Sigma 16-28/2.8 DG DN Contemporary. I plan to keep the GM II since I do use that with my A7RV. But everything else is up in the air but will mostly get used on the A7CR so size does matter for when I travel.
The 16-35 GM II is a wonderful lens, probably the one I’d keep if I didn’t already have a 24-70 or 20-70. I just want something a bit wider to supplement those. The 20G is fantastic but when I tried just going that way I definitely missed having a 16mm sometimes. I currently have a 16-35 PZ and the image quality meets my needs but I don’t love the ergonomics. We are certainly spoiled with options these days.
Just received the lens in the mail. Overall first impressions are super impressive! What a beautiful compact package! The Voigtlander is certainly going
I know this lens is basically the same size as the 24-50, but i like it more, something about it, have it for a few weeks, and it’s real nice. Alan Parker wrote:
Just received the lens in the mail. Overall first impressions are super impressive! What a beautiful compact package! The Voigtlander is certainly going
I am curious to learn more about this lens. I need a lens to cover wider than 24mm and not quite want to spend over 2 grands knowing I don’t use the focal length that often.
Younjulius wrote:
I am curious to learn more about this lens. I need a lens to cover wider than 24mm and not quite want to spend over 2 grands knowing I don’t use the focal length that often.
It will be between 16-25mm g vs 16-35mm gm i.
I'm personally really enjoying the lens so far. It's really light and compact which I appreciate. It's not extending much during the zooming either. The sharpness seems insane, even at f/2.8. It's really very impressive compared to my CV15 or Canon 17-40.
The only small pet peeves I have so far is that the zoom direction is reversed of what you might expect. The engineered plastic also seems slightly lower quality than what you find on GM lenses. Other than that no real complaints from me.
Some samples.
To my eye the lens looks really sharp and the bokeh is really well done; no weird shapes or anything. I do seem some LoCa here and there but also nothing unusual. Close-up performance was the biggest surprise honestly.
I received the Sony 16-25mm f/2.8 G lens today. Form factor (build, low weight, and small size) is impressive, making it a great travel tool but also a high IQ lens for the a7RV. I haven't been out and about with it for landscape/exterior architecture shots yet, but I've been pleased with rendering, bokeh, and close-up composition using Mike's lens profile (Thanks, Mike!).
Sony ILCE-7RM5 FE 16-25mm F2.8 G ƒ/2.8 20.0 mm 1/125s ISO640 (used a littel noise reduction and Adobe Camera Raw settings to taste)
Newenglandrocks wrote:
So I understand the business decisions involved here. If I was leading Sony lens product management, I would green light these over medium fast telephotos, too. But it would be nice to see them throw us a bone between the 200-600G and the 300GM. Just pick some random Nikon Z prime telephoto lens that is more than $2K and less than $6K, copy the focal length, max aperture, paint it white and add a 10% market-leader premium. Or give us an f/5-f/5.6 200-600GM.
I realize there is a smaller market for these "mid market" telephotos, but I sure would like to see one and suspect Sony could sell a meaningful amount of them. But probably not remotely as much dollar volume as the 16-25, 24-50, 20-70 and 70-200G zoom family. 🤷🏻♂️...Show more →
I’ve got $ set aside for just such a lens. A slightly faster 200-600 would be ideal or perhaps an 800PF…
I’ve mentioned before that I bought the 24-50mm f2.8 G to use on my A7CR and A7CII. My original plan was to also buy the new 16-25mm f2.8 G to keep the kit small for travel. In the mean time I decided to explore how other wide angle zooms I had felt on these compact bodies. The three that I have already are
1. Sony FE 12-24mm f4 G @ 565 grams taken in trade for a Nikkor Z S lend
2. Sigma 16-28mm f2.8 DG DN Contemporary @ 450 grams bought for my A7C
3. Sony FE 16-35mm f2.8 GM II @ 547 grams bought when my son permanently borrowed my V1 version for his A7SIII.
The new Sony 16-25mm f2.8 is only 409 grams
I had tried a Sony FE PZ 16-35/4 G that a friend was selling when he got out of Sony but didn’t keep that since I didn’t own any compact Sony bodies at the time.
The Sigma is the only one missing the aperture ring, other switches and customizing buttons of the Sony G/GM lenses that I enjoy using. I thought the 12-24mm was smaller than the ne GM II but I was wrong it’s actually bigger and about 18 grams heavier. So I decided to try out the 16-35/2.8 GM II on the A7CR and it actually doesn’t feel that heavy or front heavy which really surprised me. I’ve been using the GM II on my A7RV and it’s a great quality. That is with the A7CR’s grip attached.
So I’m going to stay pat for the time being and save the $1200 to see if I can find a good price on the 16-25/2.8 G or a very slightly used one. I planned to sell the z sigma and I think I will still do that since, while it’s a nice lens, I have too many.
Also I’m told that for landscape I only really don’t need a f2.8 and can get away with an f/4 so I might reconsider that path because it will be light.
I’m debating selling my 20g to get this lens. Just a bit more versatile on focal range but also 1.8-2.8 for indoor isn’t a deal breaker, I’m not allergic to all noise. I feel like it would be better for indoor gatherings where wide is needed and I don’t do Astro. The only thing outstanding for me is that the 20g is a very very good lens and I think one of the few modern Sony lenses with character, but maybe that’s in my head.
h00ligan wrote:
I’m debating selling my 20g to get this lens. Just a bit more versatile on focal range but also 1.8-2.8 for indoor isn’t a deal breaker, I’m not allergic to all noise. I feel like it would be better for indoor gatherings where wide is needed and I don’t do Astro. The only thing outstanding for me is that the 20g is a very very good lens and I think one of the few modern Sony lenses with character, but maybe that’s in my head.
Anyone made this switch?
I haven’t made the switch but since I do have the 20/1.8 G I’ve considered using it with the 24-50/2.8 G to get wider and not have another f/2.8 or f/4 zoom in the wide range. Not as flexible but the 20/1.8 G is is typically as wide as I go a lot of the time. Too many options and too many decisions.
I have the 20 f/1.8 G and recently picked up the new Sigma 24-70 DG DN II. I have thought about switching out the 20 G for the Sony 16-25 G, but I rarely shoot ultra wide.
The 20 G also compliments my 35 GM nicely, so probably hold tight as my photography wallet is broke since I also recently traded out my 200-600 with the Sigma 500 f/5.6 DG DN. My local camera store said I was their customer of the month!
swldstn wrote:
I’ve mentioned before that I bought the 24-50mm f2.8 G to use on my A7CR and A7CII. My original plan was to also buy the new 16-25mm f2.8 G to keep the kit small for travel. In the mean time I decided to explore how other wide angle zooms I had felt on these compact bodies. The three that I have already are
1. Sony FE 12-24mm f4 G @ 565 grams taken in trade for a Nikkor Z S lend
2. Sigma 16-28mm f2.8 DG DN Contemporary @ 450 grams bought for my A7C
3. Sony FE 16-35mm f2.8 GM II @ 547 grams bought when my son permanently borrowed my V1 version for his A7SIII.
The new Sony 16-25mm f2.8 is only 409 grams
I had tried a Sony FE PZ 16-35/4 G that a friend was selling when he got out of Sony but didn’t keep that since I didn’t own any compact Sony bodies at the time.
The Sigma is the only one missing the aperture ring, other switches and customizing buttons of the Sony G/GM lenses that I enjoy using. I thought the 12-24mm was smaller than the ne GM II but I was wrong it’s actually bigger and about 18 grams heavier. So I decided to try out the 16-35/2.8 GM II on the A7CR and it actually doesn’t feel that heavy or front heavy which really surprised me. I’ve been using the GM II on my A7RV and it’s a great quality. That is with the A7CR’s grip attached.
So I’m going to stay pat for the time being and save the $1200 to see if I can find a good price on the 16-25/2.8 G or a very slightly used one. I planned to sell the z sigma and I think I will still do that since, while it’s a nice lens, I have too many.
Also I’m told that for landscape I only really don’t need a f2.8 and can get away with an f/4 so I might reconsider that path because it will be light.
So I'm actually looking at the Sigma 14-24 and Sony 16-35 GM (OG not the II). How would you compare the two? Really stuck in trying to find something wider than my 35mm GM. Also considering the Sigma 28-45 f1.8 right now.
File this under "you didn't ask me", but I have both the Sigma 14-24 and 28-45. They are larger and heavier than any combination of 16-25 / 24-50, 16-35. I find the 14-24 to be excellent. My initial impression of the 28-45 is similar. I tend to prefer primes, but I believe these two lenses give my best primes a run for their money. I have never used the 16-25, 24-50, or either the 16-35 or 16-35 II. So my comments about performance aren't comparing them to those lenses, they are based on the other lenses I have in that range (which are mostly primes.)
But the 14-24 / 28-45 combo is definitely heavier and will take up more room in your bag. They will also put more weight on your arms if you are shooting with them off tripod. And with the 14-24, if you want to use filters, it's much trickier than the 16-25 / 24-50 / 16-35 which take screw in filters.
You also are FPS locked on the Sigma lenses, which probably wouldn't be a big deal for the 14-24, but might be for the 28-45.
Also, the 28-45 is a newer generation Art lens. They were both designed ground up for mirrorless, but the 14-24 lacks an aperture ring, which also means it has less switches (aperture lock, clickless aperture, etc) and it lacks the one extra custom button that would be used in portrait orientation, that is found on the 28-45.
TDP has a pretty nice tool to compare lenses, realize it's just one copy of a lens....so I wouldn't solely judge the performance of a lens on this comparison. This is just the performance of the single lens that was tested.
mjeffv2 wrote: swldstn wroteI’ve mentioned before that I bought the 24-50mm f2.8 G to use on my A7CR and A7CII. My original plan was to also buy the new 16-25mm f2.8 G to keep the kit small for travel. In the mean time I decided to explore how other wide angle zooms I had felt on these compact bodies. The three that I have already are
1. Sony FE 12-24mm f4 G @ 565 grams taken in trade for a Nikkor Z S lend
2. Sigma 16-28mm f2.8 DG DN Contemporary @ 450 grams bought for my A7C
3. Sony FE 16-35mm f2.8 GM II @ 547 grams bought when my son permanently borrowed my V1 version for his A7SIII.
The new Sony 16-25mm f2.8 is only 409 grams
I had tried a Sony FE PZ 16-35/4 G that a friend was selling when he got out of Sony but didn’t keep that since I didn’t own any compact Sony bodies at the time.
The Sigma is the only one missing the aperture ring, other switches and customizing buttons of the Sony G/GM lenses that I enjoy using. I thought the 12-24mm was smaller than the ne GM II but I was wrong it’s actually bigger and about 18 grams heavier. So I decided to try out the 16-35/2.8 GM II on the A7CR and it actually doesn’t feel that heavy or front heavy which really surprised me. I’ve been using the GM II on my A7RV and it’s a great quality. That is with the A7CR’s grip attached.
So I’m going to stay pat for the time being and save the $1200 to see if I can find a good price on the 16-25/2.8 G or a very slightly used one. I planned to sell the z sigma and I think I will still do that since, while it’s a nice lens, I have too many.
Also I’m told that for landscape I only really don’t need a f2.8 and can get away with an f/4 so I might reconsider that path because it will be light.
What do others think I should do?So I'm actually looking at the Sigma 14-24 and Sony 16-35 GM (OG not the II). How would you compare the two? Really stuck in trying to find something wider than my 35mm GM. Also considering the Sigma 28-45 f1.8 right now.
mjeffv2 wrote: swldstn wroteI’ve mentioned before that I bought the 24-50mm f2.8 G to use on my A7CR and A7CII. My original plan was to also buy the new 16-25mm f2.8 G to keep the kit small for travel. In the mean time I decided to explore how other wide angle zooms I had felt on these compact bodies. The three that I have already are
1. Sony FE 12-24mm f4 G @ 565 grams taken in trade for a Nikkor Z S lend
2. Sigma 16-28mm f2.8 DG DN Contemporary @ 450 grams bought for my A7C
3. Sony FE 16-35mm f2.8 GM II @ 547 grams bought when my son permanently borrowed my V1 version for his A7SIII.
The new Sony 16-25mm f2.8 is only 409 grams
I had tried a Sony FE PZ 16-35/4 G that a friend was selling when he got out of Sony but didn’t keep that since I didn’t own any compact Sony bodies at the time.
The Sigma is the only one missing the aperture ring, other switches and customizing buttons of the Sony G/GM lenses that I enjoy using. I thought the 12-24mm was smaller than the ne GM II but I was wrong it’s actually bigger and about 18 grams heavier. So I decided to try out the 16-35/2.8 GM II on the A7CR and it actually doesn’t feel that heavy or front heavy which really surprised me. I’ve been using the GM II on my A7RV and it’s a great quality. That is with the A7CR’s grip attached.
So I’m going to stay pat for the time being and save the $1200 to see if I can find a good price on the 16-25/2.8 G or a very slightly used one. I planned to sell the z sigma and I think I will still do that since, while it’s a nice lens, I have too many.
Also I’m told that for landscape I only really don’t need a f2.8 and can get away with an f/4 so I might reconsider that path because it will be light.
What do others think I should do?So I'm actually looking at the Sigma 14-24 and Sony 16-35 GM (OG not the II). How would you compare the two? Really stuck in trying to find something wider than my 35mm GM. Also considering the Sigma 28-45 f1.8 right now.
Well Ted Devine’s feedback is very good. I have owned both the lenses you are comparing. I sold the Sigma 14-24 when I bought the Sony 16-35/2.8 GM version 1. Size of the Sigma was an issue but really more focal range. My use for the 16-35/2.8 was not landscape so I actually ended up not wanting to go that wide. I was using it to shoot events with groups mostly. In reality I still own the version one GM and now the version two GM II. My oldest son “ borrowed” my GM version for his A7SIII but we now live on different coast so i replaced it with the GM II.
Well I just bite the bullet and ordered one. Coming to me tomorrow in NY
So Im at 16-25/24-50 and Sony 85mm 1.8 plus the A7CR and after that I rent everything. Actually have a A7RV and 70-200 coming Friday from lensrentals