fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198

  
 
pierrep69
Offline
Details
p.8 #1Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
So far, I like my 16-25f2.8G.

Compared to my previous 16-35GMII, it's a bit worse at 16mm in the corners (where the GMII shines IMO), but better at 20 and 25mm, which is where I mostly shoot landscapes where corners really matter.

I'd say it's about on par with the PZ I have owned before. I'm more than satisfied with my 16-25 + 35 GM combo (I must say, that GM is a joy to use and super impressive, I love it).

The 16-35 GM II was overall the best 16-35 at f5.6, but frustratingly close to the PZ at similar aperture (again, better at 16mm, slightly worse at 20 and 24mm, slightly better at 35mm), and not that great at f2.8, while bigger and much more expensive (I've had the 16-25 and the 35 GM for the same amount of money as for the 16-35 GMII), which defeated a bit the purpose of the lens IMO.
Aug 10, 2024 at 11:07 AM
swldstn
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
pierrep69 wrote:
So far, I like my 16-25f2.8G.

Compared to my previous 16-35GMII, it's a bit worse at 16mm in the corners (where the GMII shines IMO), but better at 20 and 25mm, which is where I mostly shoot landscapes where corners really matter.

I'd say it's about on par with the PZ I have owned before. I'm more than satisfied with my 16-25 + 35 GM combo (I must say, that GM is a joy to use and super impressive, I love it).

The 16-35 GM II was overall the best 16-35 at f5.6, but frustratingly close to the PZ at similar aperture
...Show more →

My thinking is it all depends on the focal range you want to cover, the single lens weight you want to stay below, and the bag weight you want to keep below. Here are three possible solutions.

1. At 547 grams the 16-35mm f/2.8 GM II is the lightest overall weight bag weight to cover that range but not the lightest on your camera.

2. The 406 grams + 440 grams = 846 grams of 16-25/2.8 G + 24-50mm f/2.8 G combination is heavier in the bag and requires you to switch lenses but each lens is lighter.

3. The 16-25mm f/2.8 G + 35mm f/1.4 GM combination is 406 grams + 524 grams = 930 grams but gives you a fast prime but you still need to change lenses to cover the range.

I left out the f/4 solutions here and others like using the older 35mm f/2.8 ZA which is really light but you lose G and GM build features. I think though you get the idea. It all depends on your goals on how you want to slice the pie. I found this interesting because I can actually use all three approaches based on the lenses I currently own. Heck I could even choose the 16-35/2.8 GM II + 50mm f/1.4 GM at 547 grams + 516 grams = 1063 grams.

What’s your preference or recommendation?
Aug 10, 2024 at 12:34 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.8 #3Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
swldstn wrote:
What zoom range do you think they can achieve?


I don't know what they can achieve, but what I think would be nice is something along the lines of the old Nikon 75-150mm f3.5 Series E lens - light, compact, relatively fast, and sharp. That lens had a 52mm filter thread, so Sony could make a modern equivalent with f2.8 and use a 67mm filter size.
Aug 10, 2024 at 01:19 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
molson wrote:
swldstn wroteWhat zoom range do you think they can achieve?
I don't know what they can achieve, but what I think would be nice is something along the lines of the old Nikon 75-150mm f3.5 Series E lens - light, compact, relatively fast, and sharp. That lens had a 52mm filter thread, so Sony could make a modern equivalent with f2.8 and use a 67mm filter size.


I don't think they could cover nearly that range and have it be of about the same size and vey high quality as the 16-25 and 25-50 2.8 zooms. Those zooms emphasize quality, size, and handling with a 2.8 max ap by giving up range.

If Sony were to make such a zoom, I think it would more likely be a 50-80/2.8 with a 67mm filter thread and a $1200 price. I don't know how much demand there might be for such a lens. People pooh-poohed the first two when they first appeared as too limited in range until they saw the advantages of the size and the optical quality.

A light and small 50-80/2.8 with excellent rendering might work well as a portrait lens, covering environmental portraits through head-and-shoulders and full face, as well as for a third travel lens in the new trio.
Aug 10, 2024 at 03:35 PM
Younjulius
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
chiron wrote:
molson wrote
swldstn wroteWhat zoom range do you think they can achieve?
I don't know what they can achieve, but what I think would be nice is something along the lines of the old Nikon 75-150mm f3.5 Series E lens - light, compact, relatively fast, and sharp. That lens had a 52mm filter thread, so Sony could make a modern equivalent with f2.8 and use a 67mm filter size.
I don't think they could cover nearly that range and have it be of about the same size and vey high quality as the 16-25 and 25-50 2.8 zooms. Those zooms emphasize quality, size, and handling with a 2.8 max ap by giving up range.

If Sony were to make such a zoom, I think it would more likely be a 50-80/2.8 with a 67mm filter thread and a $1200 price. I don't know how much demand there might be for such a lens. People pooh-poohed the first two when they first appeared as too limited in range until they saw
...Show more →

I don’t think 50-80mm is in need to cover as much as 16-50mm range. I would rather have a bit longer range to be useful like 70-105mm or even 90-150mm with the same filter size.
Aug 10, 2024 at 04:38 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.8 #6Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
chiron wrote:
I don't think they could cover nearly that range and have it be of about the same size and vey high quality as the 16-25 and 25-50 2.8 zooms. Those zooms emphasize quality, size, and handling with a 2.8 max ap by giving up range.



I'm pretty sure that with modern lens design and manufacturing technologies, Sony ought to be able to match what Nikon did 50 years ago, when lenses were built using stone knives and bearskins...
Aug 10, 2024 at 04:40 PM
swldstn
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
chiron wrote:
molson wrote
swldstn wroteWhat zoom range do you think they can achieve?
I don't know what they can achieve, but what I think would be nice is something along the lines of the old Nikon 75-150mm f3.5 Series E lens - light, compact, relatively fast, and sharp. That lens had a 52mm filter thread, so Sony could make a modern equivalent with f2.8 and use a 67mm filter size.
I don't think they could cover nearly that range and have it be of about the same size and vey high quality as the 16-25 and 25-50 2.8 zooms. Those zooms emphasize quality, size, and handling with a 2.8 max ap by giving up range.

If Sony were to make such a zoom, I think it would more likely be a 50-80/2.8 with a 67mm filter thread androgen a $1200 price. I don't know how much demand there might be for such a lens. People pooh-poohed the first two when they first appeared as too limited in range until they saw
...Show more →

Looking at the two shorter G lenses and other zooms I think the engineers at Sony might be able to achieve a ratio of 1.5x to 2.0x so that would make it either a 50-80mm as you say or as much as a 50-100mm or you could leave a little space and do a 70-105mm or even a 75-150mm maybe.
Aug 10, 2024 at 05:03 PM
MikeEvangelist
Online
Details
p.8 #8Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
molson wrote:
I don't know what they can achieve, but what I think would be nice is something along the lines of the old Nikon 75-150mm f3.5 Series E lens - light, compact, relatively fast, and sharp. That lens had a 52mm filter thread, so Sony could make a modern equivalent with f2.8 and use a 67mm filter size.


I'd be happy with something like a 70-120mm ƒ3.5 in a similar (presumably longer) form factor as the 24-50mm.
Aug 10, 2024 at 07:40 PM
lsquare
Offline
Details
p.8 #9Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198


swldstn wrote:
chiron wrote
molson wrote
swldstn wroteWhat zoom range do you think they can achieve?
I don't know what they can achieve, but what I think would be nice is something along the lines of the old Nikon 75-150mm f3.5 Series E lens - light, compact, relatively fast, and sharp. That lens had a 52mm filter thread, so Sony could make a modern equivalent with f2.8 and use a 67mm filter size.
I don't think they could cover nearly that range and have it be of about the same size and vey high quality as the 16-25 and 25-50 2.8 zooms. Those zooms emphasize quality, size, and handling with a 2.8 max ap by giving up range.

If Sony were to make such a zoom, I think it would more likely be a 50-80/2.8 with a 67mm filter thread androgen a $1200 price. I don't know how much demand there might be for such a lens. People pooh-poohed the first two when they first appeared as too limited in range until they saw the advantages of the size and the optical quality.

A light and small 50-80/2.8 with excellent rendering might work well as a portrait lens, covering environmental portraits through head-and-shoulders and full face, as well as for a third travel lens in the new trio.
Looking at the two shorter G lenses and other zooms I think the engineers at Sony might be able to achieve a ratio of 1.5x to 2.0x so that would make it either a 50-80mm as you say or as much as a 50-100mm or you could leave a little space and do a 70-105mm or even a 75-150mm maybe.


I don't think a 50-80mm f/2.8 lens will sell. I think 50-100mm, 70-105mm, or even a 75-150mm will have a market.
Aug 11, 2024 at 08:13 AM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
lsquare wrote:
swldstn wrote
chiron wrote
molson wrote
swldstn wroteWhat zoom range do you think they can achieve?
I don't know what they can achieve, but what I think would be nice is something along the lines of the old Nikon 75-150mm f3.5 Series E lens - light, compact, relatively fast, and sharp. That lens had a 52mm filter thread, so Sony could make a modern equivalent with f2.8 and use a 67mm filter size.
I don't think they could cover nearly that range and have it be of about the same size and vey high quality as the 16-25 and 25-50 2.8 zooms. Those zooms emphasize quality, size, and handling with a 2.8 max ap by giving up range.

If Sony were to make such a zoom, I think it would more likely be a 50-80/2.8 with a 67mm filter thread androgen a $1200 price. I don't know how much demand there might be for such a lens. People pooh-poohed the first two when they first appeared as too limited in range until they saw the advantages of the size and the optical quality.

A light and small 50-80/2.8 with excellent rendering might work well as a portrait lens, covering environmental portraits through head-and-shoulders and full face, as well as for a third travel lens in the new trio.
Looking at the two shorter G lenses and other zooms I think the engineers at Sony might be able to achieve a ratio of 1.5x to 2.0x so that would make it either a 50-80mm as you say or as much as a 50-100mm or you could leave a little space and do a 70-105mm or even a 75-150mm maybe.
I don't think a 50-80mm f/2.8 lens will sell. I think 50-100mm, 70-105mm, or even a 75-150mm will have a market.



Let's say they make it a 50-85/2.8 in the same form factor and of the same optical and rendering qualities of the 16-25 G and the 25-50 G.

That would cover four very desirable prime lenses: 50mm, 65mm, 75mm, and 85mm. And all you would be giving up is about one stop.

I think that is about the same selling proposition as the first two lenses. The three together would make a great travel kit, and for many people like me who don't shoot tele or extra wide, it might be all the lenses they would ever need.
Aug 11, 2024 at 09:31 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
Not sure it would sell as I think a lot of folks that want a 75/85 want a 1.4 or even a 1.2 as it's straight at that portrait or 3/4 body shot. I know I would prefer it a 50mm -85mm I would pass on but hell does not hurt to have it in the market.
Aug 11, 2024 at 09:39 AM
pierrep69
Offline
Details
p.8 #12Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
Some "very biased" comparisons I did lately, with old photos taken with my previous 16-35f4 Zeiss at 24 and Zeiss Batis at 25mm (which obviously is 23mm).

16-25f2.8 @f5.6: Link

16-35f4 @f5.6: Link

Zeiss Batis 25f2 @f5.6: Link

Remarks: the differences wouldn't break or make an image, to be honest, but the 16-25 is a hair sharper than the Zeiss Batis, which is enough for me. Especially as the 16-25 is even better at 20mm, and I'd say pretty good at 16mm.
Aug 12, 2024 at 03:09 AM
pierrep69
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
If money is no objection, the 16-35 GM II is the best IMO, overall.


  1. At 16mm, it is impressively good, even at f2.8 (almost no need to close down for sharpness).
  2. At 20 and 24mm, though, it is less impressive in the corners, but still pretty good.
  3. At 35mm, you need to close down to get good sharpness for landscapes (but no issue, since you would need to close down to have most of the frame in focus any way)
  4. At f2.8, the minimum focus distance is impressive, and you can get some pretty awesome photos while traveling.


Now, the thing is: is the $1000 price difference worth it? In my case, I don't think so. I prefer to invest that money in a prime I like a lot (the 35f1.4GM) which will bring me more joy, and then calm down my anxiety that some day, someone will tell me that my 16-25G is less sharp at 16mm in a landscape than it could have been with another lens.

But I'd seriously, still, recommend the GMII. Beware, though, there are some copy variations with it. That's also a reason why I don't want to try it again, as much as I believe it's a solid lens when you have a good version. I'm not betting $2700 to have a slightly decentered lens (first copy had the issue at f2.8, but was super sharp at f5.6, second copy really sucked at 20mm, but like, really, while being super great at 16mm).
Aug 12, 2024 at 03:45 AM
swldstn
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
pierrep69 wrote:
If money is no objection, the 16-35 GM II is the best IMO, overall.


  1. At 16mm, it is impressively good, even at f2.8 (almost no need to close down for sharpness).
  2. At 20 and 24mm, though, it is less impressive in the corners, but still pretty good.
  3. At 35mm, you need to close down to get good sharpness for landscapes (but no issue, since you would need to close down to have most of the frame in focus any way)
  4. At f2.8, the minimum focus distance is impressive, and you can get some pretty awesome photos while traveling.


Now, the thing is: is the $1000
...Show more →

So does this mean you bought the 16-25mm f/2.8 G or decided not to? I did buy a mint used copy since the goal of my travel bag is to give me flexibility and it’s a good match for my compact C bodies. Will see how it works out. Take care.
Aug 12, 2024 at 11:16 AM
pierrep69
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
I took the 16-25 It is smaller and nicer to handle, but I think the GMII was better at 16mm.

I haven't played enough with the 16-25 to know if I'm going to be satisfied with it, but so far, it looks good.
Aug 12, 2024 at 12:40 PM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
I'm kinda late to this thread, but I have two questions regarding the 16-25:
1) Do we have any feel yet how good or bad copy variation is with this lens? The sample seems small, but it looks like most people here have good or decent copies.
2) Has anybody done a comparison with the Sigma 14-24 by any chance? I understand that 14mm and 16mm are quite different, but I've been pondering trading my rarely used Sigma and getting this lens instead mainly for ease of filter use.
Aug 16, 2024 at 08:22 AM
mojoh
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
A review of this lens by Marc Alhadeff, if u are keen on reading..

https://sonyalpha.blog/2024/04/29/sony-fe-16-25mm-f2-8-g/
Aug 22, 2024 at 05:20 PM
graytrekker
Offline
Details
p.8 #18Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
Has anyone tried this (or the sister 24-50) for astro yet?
Aug 27, 2024 at 09:05 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
I am struck by how good the rendering seems to be in the various sample images I have seen, both from this lens and from its sibling. That is more important to me than sharpness.

But I would like to hear more comparisons of the Tamron 20-40/2.8 to either the Sony 16-25/2.8 or the 25-50/2.8.

The Sony lens appears to make images that are very nicely rendered and optically fine. But the Tamron would suit my usual range well enough so that I might only need that one lens. The question is whether the 20-40 renders as beautifully and with strong optical quality.
Aug 27, 2024 at 10:11 PM
Peire
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Sony FE 16-25mm f/2.8 G Lens $1198
I've finally found a reason to buy the Sony G 16-25/2.8. It will accompany my Sony GM2 24-70/2.8 and Sony GM2 70-200/2.8 Mk2, and serve as a lightweight replacement for the Sony GM 16-35/2.8 when the super-wide-angle Sony GM 12-24/2.8 isn't absolutely necessary. And now I've got it.
Sep 19, 2024 at 12:39 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister