I must admit I only used the original monochrom at length, during my time at Leica.
It doesn't have 3*14 bit, there is no interpolation to give you the benefit of averaging noise. Furthermore, all 3 channels would be identical if you converted it to a colour file. All the DR gains are from quantum efficiency vs the same sensor with a CFA. Please read Jim Kasson's blog to learn more about the myth of bit depth for DR in editing. It's real, but only really visible when you're comparing 14-bit and above to 11-bit and below.
flash wrote:
thrice wrote
It really doesn't.
In fact after interpolation you have each pixel represented by 3*14 bits coming from a Bayer sensor. You throw away *some* of that data converting to monochrome but arguably have more DR from bit-depth for post processing than you would with the monochrom.
The monochrom benefits from having much lower noise which gives you a more usable DR but that benefit is due to the lack of CFA and higher quantum efficiency, not due to 14 bits.
flash wrote
thrice wrote
The 14 bits for tones makes me chuckle. No phones have 14 bit displays, no commercial PC monitors have 14 bit displays (LUT != Display bit depth) and no printers can reproduce 16384 shades of grey scale. How are you showing all them tones to people?
The sharpness, DR and finer noise argument is the only practical difference. It matters a whole bunch in post processing.
Gordon The Monochrome sensors also produce. a 3 x 14 bit file. But the data is all real. There's no interpolation like a Bayer array.
Have you used a Monochrome for any period of time?
Gordon