p.2 #2New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
Sonnar-7 wrote: BastianK wroteReview sample arrived today, if you have any specific questions I will try to answer them.I do wonder about the rendering, can we have an hint as if it is classic or modern?
Definitely modern.
Looks pretty sharp across frame at f/2.0 and bokeh is more of the smooth type.
p.2 #3New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
BastianK wrote: Sonnar-7 wroteBastianK wroteReview sample arrived today, if you have any specific questions I will try to answer them.I do wonder about the rendering, can we have an hint as if it is classic or modern?Definitely modern.
Looks pretty sharp across frame at f/2.0 and bokeh is more of the smooth type.
p.2 #4New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
sander9t wrote:
A very interesting "replica", at least in terms of exterior style. Two things to note though: it is made out of aluminum instead of brass like the original TTH, and it uses one ED and one HRI elements. While the 6/4 design is kept from the original, the rendering could be different. Would love to see some samples.
BTW the Reid III camera with the original TTH 2-inch collapsible is such a beautiful setup.
I am pretty sure that this lens will also comes with a brass version at a slightly higher price. In China, the aluminium version price is about $550, while the brass version should be higher by about $80. Should be similar pricing strategy like the Voigtlander version I and version II.
p.2 #5New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
There will be a brass version and the weight differences are 120g for aluminium (I measured this myself) and 216g for brass (I was told by the manufacturer).
p.2 #7New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
sander9t wrote: BastianK wroteDefinitely modern.
Looks pretty sharp across frame at f/2.0 and bokeh is more of the smooth type.That was what I suspected before. Too bad that they only replicate the exterior design not the rendering!
I am not entirely sure if there is a right or wrong here.
I also see some people prefering a vintage exterior look with modern optics.
Either way, my review will go live tomorrow at 8 pm GMT+8 with the official announcement and then you can all have a look at its rendering characteristics.
p.2 #9New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
Desmolicious wrote: BastianK wroteReview sample arrived today, if you have any specific questions I will try to answer them.How's the vignetting? Given the 36mm filter size.
Okay actually, similar to other 50mm 2.0 M-mount lenses I have used.
p.2 #10New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
BastianK wrote: Desmolicious wroteBastianK wroteReview sample arrived today, if you have any specific questions I will try to answer them.How's the vignetting? Given the 36mm filter size.Okay actually, similar to other 50mm 2.0 M-mount lenses I have used.
Very interesting! With that filter size I would have thought it would be much worse.
Short summary:
Vintage casing, modern optics, solid mechanics (impression after 2 weeks of usage), really nice aperture diaphragm
Because of its collapsible nature the rear element is also pretty far from the sensor, meaning it also works well on other digital mirrorless cameras like Sony E and Nikon Z.
p.2 #14New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
oscartb wrote:
Any confirmation whether the aperture is clicked or declicked? Seeing mixed reports in the coverage out there so far.
As written no clicks.
p.2 #15New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
Desmolicious wrote: BastianK wroteDesmolicious wroteBastianK wroteReview sample arrived today, if you have any specific questions I will try to answer them.How's the vignetting? Given the 36mm filter size.Okay actually, similar to other 50mm 2.0 M-mount lenses I have used.Very interesting! With that filter size I would have thought it would be much worse.
A36 filter, according to what I've read. Same as the original 5cm Elmar, 5cm Summar...
p.2 #16New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
BastianK wrote: oscartb wroteAny confirmation whether the aperture is clicked or declicked? Seeing mixed reports in the coverage out there so far.As written no clicks.
Thanks for confirming Bastian!
Unfortunate choice, I think the declicked aperture plus the infinity lock is too many ergonomic challenges for me. A shame, as I was hoping this would be a faster option than my Elmar-M, especially after the disappointing news on the upcoming uncollapsible-collapsible lens from Voigtlander. If they ever release a version with a normal focusing tab and clicked aperture Thypoch will have my money.
p.2 #17New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
Not quite my jam, I would have wished for a different rendering but it still is an interesting lens. In its « modernity »(I don’t quite like the term) it is a nice one, the bokeh has a little structure to it.
Thanks for the test Bastian! I was so curious about that lens.
p.2 #18New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
From their simera 35 and 28, and this eureka 50, I'm seeing that they're doing something very subtle but excellent, in my opinion. The images render so smooth in tonality with just the right amount of texture in bokeh, something I often see in some of the best Leica glasses wide open.
Sadly, no aperture click, hope they'll put it back in final production version!
p.2 #19New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
Can't argue against that . I was just expressing my own preference as the main reasons I am drawn to the original TTH 50/2 lens are (1) elegant exterior design and (2) quite balanced yet distinctive vintage rendering (not as wild as Angenieux or Dallmeyer but more lively than Summicrons). The TTH steadily increased in price in the last few years and is out of my budget. So I was very excited to see a replica from Thypoch but disappointed to learn the rendering is way different from the original.
Anyway a very nice writeup - always appreciate your effort in testing all sorts of lenses for us!
BastianK wrote:
I am not entirely sure if there is a right or wrong here.
I also see some people prefering a vintage exterior look with modern optics.
Either way, my review will go live tomorrow at 8 pm GMT+8 with the official announcement and then you can all have a look at its rendering characteristics.
p.2 #20New Thypoch Eureka 50mm f/2 collapsible for M mount
Thanks for the discussion. Now we see the pricing on B&H:
$579 for aluminum
$859 for brass
cypressblend wrote:
I am pretty sure that this lens will also comes with a brass version at a slightly higher price. In China, the aluminium version price is about $550, while the brass version should be higher by about $80. Should be similar pricing strategy like the Voigtlander version I and version II.