The Z8 and Z9 separate themselves from the Zf by hardware features such as
- larger grips
- vertical grip (option)
- better heat management
- better memory cards
- GPS in the Z9
- Ethernet port of the Z9
- faster sensor (=> more reliable AF on fast-moving subjects)
- higher-resolution sensor
- in the case of Z9, larger battery
- owing to the better heat management and faster cards, higher quality video modes without cropping
- silent photography
- sensor shield
- greater number of custom function buttons
- support for radio triggering of flash and remote photography via WR-R10 etc.
- full-size HDMI port
There is really no need to artificially boost the the Z8 and Z9 as they're easily among the best value cameras on the high-performance camera market as they are. Nikon is doing very well in that market, but not so well in the more consumer/lower end enthusiast category where most of the camera sales volume is generated. If Nikon can do anything to improve the market standing of their mid-level cameras (with small expense on R&D), they should do it as it would have a large and direct impact on their market share (and lead to subsequent increases in lens and accessory sales). Since the code has already been developed for the Z9 and Z8, if they can easily make the Zf support it they should do that, as well as other future cameras such as the Z6 III and Z7 III. By being competitive on subject-recognition AF in the 1500-2500€ price class and making the cameras as configurable and as pleasant to use as possible (via appropriate firmware choices), Nikon could significantly increase their overall market share (in volume). By crippling lower-end cameras they will not sell any more Z8s or Z9s. People are annoyed at such marketing tactics and vote with their feet (wallets), the one that gives the best value and performance in the 1500-2500€ class cameras probably eventually becomes the market leader. Nikon may have chosen otherwise, to focus on the high end but that places them vulnerable and dependent on their ability to compete for the very best performance over the long run, whereas in the middle sector, I believe the greatest usability wins high points without having to necessarily have the very best performance. The majority of photographers want cameras that are fairly priced and good enough for what they do, and do not get in the way of getting the photos. A relatively small number of photographers really care if their camera happens to be the very best of the best (it's a windy spot). A lot of fredmiranda.com users might fall into the latter camp but then in the normal real-world outside of camera geek forums, it's a different situation and value and ease of use play a big part. I happen to think the Zf is an excellent camera and excellent value for my needs, but it has a few flaws: no cabled remote control, no support of SB-5000 radio triggering, and a few usability quirks that they could easily fix, such as allowing either the self-timer to function without the obnoxiously bright light in the front of the camera, or implement exposure delay mode (which has been a standard feature in DSLRs and earlier mirrorless cameras in this price class and even some lower-priced models).
As for auto capture, good luck finding people who are willing to sacrifice 4500-6200€ cameras (not including the price of the lens) as remotes in the wilderness. It's great that they could do such a useful and in some way cutting-edge feature at all, but there is no way I would leave my expensive camera out there without close supervision (and having to be there and watch that no one takes the camera kind of defeats the purpose of having the auto capture in the first place, as it would alert the animal to human presence). This feature will be really useful when they put it into cheaper cameras. Until then, I'll probably not even try if it works since I can't afford to use it in that way.
In my opinion, features that are purely software and enhance the usability of less expensive cameras would be a huge benefit for Nikon's perception in the eyes of the market and also their sales, much more than niche cameras such as the Z9 that only relatively small number of people can afford. Once the code has been developed for the high end the porting would be minimal cost in most cases, yet it might have a large impact on market share and goodwill.
Vinnie_VdB wrote:
I respectfully disagree. It is not because the processor is shared that buyers of this much lower priced camera take for granted that their camera can get the goodies from more expensive set models. Sure, technically is that all possible, perhaps with relative small resources but marketing wise a lousy move to bring bodies with such a big price gap close to each other.
ilkka_nissila wrote
bernardl wrote
suteetat wrote
It would be nice if Zf gets all the software bell and whistle from Z8.
Z8/Z9 will always distinguish themselves from Zf by virtue of stacked sensor.
However, it would be nice if Zf can detect and find a bird the way Z8/Z9 can.
Zf already have the same CPU so hopefully all the software features can be shared among
all the bodies on the same platform. Since they have to focus on value for the respective typical users of each camera, I would argue that bird photography is a niche usage among Zf user and therefore should be a low priority for Nikon.
The ergonomics of the camera are a poor match for long glass.
I'd personally prefer them to focus on more value added enhancements. Why would they need to focus on value for typical users? The cameras share the same processor and most code would probably work by simply copying and pasting. Granted, bird AF might need some changes because the cameras have different sensors and resolutions, but a lot of the features probably have identical implementations in code. Spreading firmware features across cameras with the same processor has very low effort for relatively high gains in usability. Of course, they might not want to give cheaper cameras all the features of the more expensive models because they want people to buy the more expensive ones, but in practice for a lot of people the cost dictates or at least greatly influences which products they can buy; lot of people who might want a Z9 or Z8 can not justify its cost.
One reason why I have a Zf as a second camera is because it's thinner than most other Z camera bodies (49 mm for Zf vs. 69.5 mm for the Z6 II) and so it takes less space in the bag and is thus a good backup camera when I have limited space for travel. I might ordinarily shoot different subjects with the two cameras (Z8 for birds & landscape & architecture & close-ups; Zf for people, low-light, indoor events) but if one of the cameras fails (that is why one has a backup camera) then the second camera would become primary and it would need to handle all the subjects of the Z8. Thus there is benefit in sharing firmware features across cameras where it is possible, such as the bird subject mode for autofocus.
I don't notice any ergonomic disadvantage to the Zf - for a camera that is so small, it is excellent in my opinion. A larger camera can have a bigger grip which can be helpful but then it also takes more space in the bag and disadvantages the user with the increased weight and bag size required.
For auto capture and other types of remote photography there are also advantages to using a smaller camera; it is easier to mount on a pole for remote photography, and it introduces less financial risk if stolen or broken while doing this (maybe leaving the camera ready to shoot automatically for extended periods of time (on auxiliary USB-C battery). And for remote photography one definitely wants the best code for subject-detection that is available.